Jim North could not tell exactly what was happening, but in the pit of his stomach he knew the fate of convoy PQ-17 had taken a calamitous turn. All around him, the thirty merchant ships in the convoy were veering off in different directions through the icy Arctic waters, abandoning the tight defensive formation that had kept the German bombers and U-boats at bay since the convoy left Iceland a week before. Every ship’s signal lanterns blinked messages nonstop. On the bridge of North’s vessel, the freighter Troubadour, the Norwegian captain and the first officer held a terse discussion in their native tongue, punctuated by vile curses. North understood only the curses, but there was no mistaking the tone of their voices. A fresh crisis had overtaken convoy PQ-17 on its misbegotten voyage to Arctic Russia.
It was the Fourth of July 1942, a little past 9:30 p.m., although the time of day meant nothing to the men on the ships because the Arctic sun never set in July. The convoy was less than 800 miles from the North Pole. Earlier in the day, the American vessels forming the core of the convoy had celebrated Independence Day by hoisting brand-new U.S. flags into the fog and scudding clouds. Soon afterward, the Allied warships protecting the convoy had fought off an attack by twenty-three German dive-bombers. Three ships had been sunk but the mariners considered the battle a victory, an encouraging sign that they might yet reach the Soviet Union alive. Some of the men were still congratulating one another when the new crisis—whatever it was—engulfed them.
North was still trying to figure out what the Norwegians were saying when he was startled by the blare of another ship’s claxon. A small British escort vessel approached the Troubadour, and a British officer shouted through a bullhorn, repeating an extraordinary message that had been sent to all the ships by signal flags. Convoy PQ-17 was breaking up. The powerful warships protecting it were already racing away. The Troubadour and the other merchant ships—all of them hopelessly slow and packed with TNT and other explosive cargo—were supposed to find their own way, alone and unprotected, across hundreds of miles of the remote Barents Sea to Russia.
The convoy already was surrounded by U-boats, which had shadowed it for hundreds of miles, probing for gaps in its defenses. Now there would be no defenses. The twenty-four-hour Arctic daylight offered no respite from the German bombers, more of which were certainly on the way. Worst of all, perhaps, convoy PQ-17 faced a possible attack by the German battleship Tirpitz, the world’s most formidable warship. The Tirpitz had guns that could hurl devastating shells for a distance of twenty-two miles—from beyond the horizon. It could sink lesser ships like the Troubadour before they even saw it coming. Men on some Allied ships called the Tirpitz the “Big Bad Wolf.”
“Sorry to leave you like this,” the commander of a departing British destroyer shouted across the water to a friend on one of the merchant ships he was leaving behind. “Looks like a bloody business. Good luck.”
The scattering ships would need a great deal of luck, not only against the Germans but against the Arctic itself. The convoy’s route skirted the edge of the polar ice field extending down from the North Pole. The water was full of icebergs and floes with razor-sharp edges. Though it was midsummer, the ocean was still cold enough to kill a person in minutes, and the air temperature often dipped below zero degrees Fahrenheit. Clouds and fog could persist for days, leaving navigators unable to fix their ships’ positions by the sun. The nearness of the Magnetic North Pole rendered vessels’ magnetic compasses useless.
At twenty, Jim North was the youngest and greenest deckhand on the Troubadour. He had never been to sea before and knew little about the Soviet Union except that “it was a big country fighting the Germans like we were.” After the convoy had repelled the German dive-bombers, North had felt cocky, indestructible. Now, as he watched the convoy dissolve, he wrote, “I was scared shitless.”
THOUSANDS OF MILES AWAY in Washington, D.C., London, and Moscow, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, British prime minister Winston Churchill, and Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin were testing the limits of their fraught alliance against Adolf Hitler. The Soviet Union was fighting for its survival against Nazi Germany in a war of medieval savagery that already had claimed millions of lives—far more than America and Britain together would lose in the entire course of World War II. America and Britain were merely watching the slaughter from the sidelines. Stalin was furious. But Roosevelt and Churchill did not think their troops were ready yet to compete with German troops on the battlefield. For the time being, the only help they were willing to give Stalin was to send convoys of war supplies across the ocean to the reeling Red Army. Whether that was enough help to keep Stalin on the Allied side was in doubt. But Roosevelt and Churchill were determined to keep the convoys sailing.
Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin were usually too busy to pay much attention to individual convoys. But they would all have cause to remember convoy PQ-17.
Amid the chaos on the Troubadour’s bridge, the Norwegian captain, George Salvesen, quickly regained his unruffled demeanor. He had a plan. Salvesen did not think the lumbering Troubadour could survive an 800-mile run across open water with the Nazis already upon it. Instead, he would take the ship north, into the polar ice field, and hide there until the German attacks subsided. The captain ordered North to steer northwest into the ice—the opposite direction of most of the other fleeing vessels. The ice field was a treacherous place for a ship. The captain hoped it was the last place the logical Germans would think to look.
North did as he was ordered. The Troubadour had to dodge floes as it approached the ice barrier, a low wall of brilliant white stretching all the way across the northern horizon. A cold, gray fog swirled around the ship. A startled polar bear scrambled away from the Troubadour across a pressure ridge, where two floes had slammed together with crushing force. The Troubadour was about to become a Ghost Ship. The bridge had fallen into an uneasy silence. The captain called out “Steady as she goes,” trying to sound reassuring. But North was far from reassured when he glanced at the compass to note the ship’s bearing. The needle of the useless compass was spinning around and around.