We first learned about the mystery of Wild Horse Canyon while we were still at Sugar Creek, three days before starting for our summer vacation in the Rockies.
It was half past one, Friday afternoon. In a few minutes, just as soon as Little Jim got there, we would open our gang meeting, decide a few important things, then go in swimming. It would be our last happy-go-lucky swim until we got back, because while we were out West, we’d have to use hotel or motel pools where there’d be a lot of other people. Mountain streams would be too cold to swim in and really enjoy it.
We were all lying in the shade of the Snatzerpazooka tree, about twenty feet from the sandy beach of our swimming hole. Snatzerpazooka himself, the scarecrow we’d hung up early that summer to keep the crows from gobbling up the new shoots of corn in Dragonfly’s father’s cornfield, was swaying in the lazy afternoon breeze. Dragonfly’s new Stetson cowboy hat was hanging on his left wooden shoulder.
Circus, our acrobat, was up in the tree. In fact, he was sitting on an overhanging branch close to the tree’s trunk, using the trunk for a backrest.
Little Jim kept on not coming, and we kept on feeling impatient, waiting for him. In a way, Little Jim was the most important member of the gang. That is, it was extra-important that he be there at this meeting. It was his folks—his township trustee father and his very musical mother—who were taking us with them on the out-West vacation. They were going to spend two weeks at a famous music festival in the mountains, and we were all getting to go along. I could hardly wait till next Monday.
Little Jim, the cutest member of the gang and maybe the most cheerful, was one of the best boys there ever was, I thought, as right that second I saw him coming along the path that leads from the spring to the Snatzerpazooka tree.
“Here he comes!” I exclaimed to the rest of us. “Hurry up!” I yelled down the narrow, weed-bordered winding path to him and expected to hear him call back cheerfully, “I’m coming!” as he nearly always does whenever anybody yells to him like that.
He came puffing up to where we were, but there wasn’t any usual cute little grin on his cute little mouse-shaped face. Instead, his lips were set, and he was either sad or mad about something. I couldn’t tell which.
“’S’matter?” Poetry asked him. “How come you’re so late?”
Little Jim’s worried, teary-voiced answer cut like a knife into my heart when he said, “It’s Crescendo! Something’s happened to her. We can’t find her anywhere. She didn’t sleep in her box last night or the night before, and she didn’t come home this morning. She’s been gone two whole days!”
We all knew what he meant when he said “Crescendo.” He meant the very cute calico cat that had been Little Jim’s pet ever since he was only five.
Little Jim was sad all right; he was also mad. He took a swipe at a tall mullein stalk with the striped walking stick he always had with him. He broke the mullein stalk, and its yellow-flowered head bent over and hung upside down.
“We wanted to give her to the animal shelter to feed and look after till we got back—and now she’s gone!”
While Little Jim was getting his breath and telling us about Crescendo’s being lost, strayed, or stolen, Dragonfly cut in to exclaim, “Who cares about a calico cat? Let’s get started swimming!”
Big Jim growled back at him, “We’re having an important meeting! Besides—don’t you remember?—we have to examine the creek bottom first!”
“Why?” Dragonfly whined, pretending he didn’t already know, and sneezed. In fact, he sneezed three times in rapid-fire succession—which meant we weren’t starting on our mountain vacation any too soon for him. Hay fever season was already here.
“Because,” Circus called down from his tree seat, “the heavy rains we’ve been having lately may have washed a lot of junk into the swimming hole, that’s why. A waterlogged old stump, sharp rocks, or broken bottles or tin cans we might get hurt on. Or maybe the water washed out a few dangerous holes.”
I knew what he was talking about. Every year after the spring floods and also after every big summer rain had sent a rush of water swirling down the creek, we tested the bottom to be sure our swimming hole was still a safe place to swim. Sometimes it wasn’t until we’d taken out quite a lot of junk that had been washed in.
Anyway, while we were waiting to test the creek bottom—and also trying to cheer up Little Jim, who was really worried about his calico pet, which was one of the prettiest cats I ever saw—we decided to look over some of the out-West advertising Big Jim had brought with him. It was some he had gotten in the mail that very morning from the town near which we were going to camp for two whole weeks, high in the Rockies. We would go into town every day to a big tent in a meadow there to hear the wonderful music of some of the world’s greatest musicians.
Big Jim hadn’t any sooner opened the Aspen Avalanche than Dragonfly let out a happy exclamation, saying, “Look! There’s a cowboy wearing a hat just like mine!”
What he was looking at and exclaiming about was a full-page advertisement for a rodeo that was going to be held in Aspen. Right in the middle of the page, sitting on a very pretty horse, was a man in a Western outfit, and on the man’s head was a swept-brim hat, which, I noticed, was just like Dragonfly’s. For half a second, I envied the spindle-legged little guy that his folks had let him have a big broad-brimmed Stetson while mine hadn’t let me.
Then I saw the name of the cowboy and let out an exclamation myself. “Hey!” I cut loose with. “It’s Cranberry Jones!”
Boy oh boy, oh boy oh boy! my mind exclaimed. Cranberry Jones, whose voice I’d heard on the radio and had seen different pictures of riding his famous palomino horse, was going to be one of the stars at the Aspen rodeo, and we would get to see him ourselves!
Dragonfly sprang to his cowboy-booted feet, swept his swept-brim hat from Snatzerpazooka’s left shoulder, shoved it into our circle, and exclaimed, “See! His hat’s just like mine!”
Poetry grunted, shrugged, and in his duck-like, squawky voice answered, “Yours is like his, you mean.”
Dragonfly pouted back, “What’s the difference? Just so they’re alike!”
I looked at his chimpanzee-like face and at the hat he had just put on and liked him in spite of him.
Big Jim broke up our nonsensical argument then by saying, “Look, you guys! Want a mystery to solve while we’re out there?”
Just the word “mystery” brought my mind to excited life. Big Jim had turned back to the front page, where there was a column of news items with a heading that said: “Rolling Stones from the Avalanche.”
Below the heading were interesting stories of things that had happened long ago. Each had a different date. One was “Thirty Years Ago This Week.” Another was “Twenty Years Ago.” Another, “Ten Years Ago.” And down near the bottom were a few lines about an old man named Joe Campbell, Cranberry Jones’s stableman, who had died of a heart attack last New Year’s morning. Joe’s body was found in a snowdrift just outside the stable door only a few yards from where one of Cranberry’s palominos was standing, saddled and showing evidence of having been ridden.
“Joe’s habit of taking very early morning rides ‘for my health,’ as he always expressed it, had been the cause of his death. The weather had been just too cold for an old man to venture out.” That was the way the story ended.
But the mystery that Big Jim had just pointed out had happened the night before on New Year’s Eve and had a heading that said:
BLONDE DISAPPEARS AFTER MIDNIGHT
DRINKING SPREE IN WILD HORSE TAVERN
Circus right that second came scrambling down the tree, shaking the branch Snatzerpazooka was hanging on and knocking some of the sawdust out of his stuffed head—Snatzerpazooka’s stuffed head, I mean. Some of it fell into my eyes so that for a second I couldn’t see what I was seeing.
Besides, some of the print in the story was blurred and several lines were worn. Even some of the words were missing. It was a spooky story about a young lady who had come to the Winter Ski Festival. The story said, “She took a few lessons on the Little Nell Beginner’s Slope, then was away to the more dangerous runs: The Cork Screw, Ruthie’s Run, and even the treacherous FIS. Yesterday, after the morning mail …”
Big Jim, who was reading aloud to us, stopped. “Her name’s worn off,” he said, squinting at the paper, holding it close to his eyes and trying to make out the missing word.
“Let me see,” Poetry said. “I’ve got twenty-twenty vision without glasses.” He studied the story, then in his usual mischievous tone, remarked, “Like it says, she’s missing”—which wasn’t very funny.
Big Jim read on. “Yesterday after the morning mail … seemed despondent and spent most of the day alone. She was seen late at night at the Wild Horse Tavern bar. About midnight she left the bar and was last seen fighting her way through the blizzard toward her motel four blocks away. She did not arrive at the Snow-slide and at press time still had not been found.”
Big Jim finished reading the news article to us. It was like reading the first chapter of an exciting mystery story in a magazine and seeing at the bottom of the page the words “To Be Continued.”
“Look!” Circus exclaimed. “There’s an editor’s note!”
And there was. It began, “The mystery is still unsolved. The story has been pointed up this week by the owners of the Snow-slide, The Cranberry Jones Enterprises. Jones himself has offered a $500 reward for any information …”
That was as much of the editor’s note as there was. The rest was worn away, maybe by the paper’s being much handled in the mail.
Well, it wasn’t any ordinary mystery story, and it wouldn’t be continued in next week’s Avalanche. If there was ever any new chapter, somebody would have to find the disappearing woman.
Already my mind was out there in the mountains in last winter’s blinding blizzard, trying to imagine who the woman was and what had happened to her. I was wishing that when we got there we would stumble onto a clue of some kind that would help us solve the mystery.
“I know what I’ll do with the five hundred dollars, if I get it,” Dragonfly piped up. “I’ll get me a palomino just like Cranberry Jones’s. I’ll—”
“If we solve the mystery,” Poetry countered, “we’ll divide it six ways between us, and your share’ll be eighty-three dollars and thirty-three and one-third cents.”
Little Jim chimed in then. “I wonder what was in her letter that made the woman so sad.”
Poetry came back with another idea, which was, “When we get out there, I’ll bet we’ll find the missing body ourselves.”
Big Jim, who had been lying on his stomach, rolled over, straightened to a sitting position, and with a puzzled expression on his face, asked, “Who said anything about a body? It just said the woman disappeared in a blizzard at midnight, New Year’s Eve.”
Poetry scowled. “But she had to have a body to disappear in, didn’t she? Here, let me see the paper.”
Big Jim handed him the Avalanche, and after Poetry had read awhile, he yawned and said to us, “Well, gang, we’ll have to solve the mystery ourselves. A woman just doesn’t go up in smoke or disappear into thin air!”
Big Jim must have felt a little irked at our barrel-shaped friend because he answered him, “Who said anything about thin air! She disappeared in air that was full of swirling snow!”
Poetry grinned back, looked at his wrist-watch and quacked, “High altitude air is always thin.” Then he added, “Time to go in swimming”—which it was.
Going in didn’t seem as important as it had, though, because all our minds were probably out in the Rockies with a mystery running around in them. In less than a week we’d be out there for real, having a wonderful vacation. One of the first things I was going to do, I thought and said so, was to walk past the Wild Horse Tavern where the golden-haired woman had been drinking the night she disappeared. After we had our tent pitched away back in the mountains somewhere along Maroon Creek or maybe on the Roaring Fork, we’d all put our heads together and see if we could help solve the mystery. Maybe we could solve it, and maybe we couldn’t.