CHAPTER 6: R IS FOR RETIREMENT AND AGING: WHEN YOU STOP LEARNING, YOUR BRAIN STARTS DYING

We don’t stop playing because we grow old.
We grow old because we stop playing.

GEORGE BERNARD SHAW

Brain Love Story icon

BETTY

Betty was 94 when she first came to see me. I had seen three generations of people in her family for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): her son, grandson, and great-granddaughter. When I asked her why she wanted to be evaluated, she said that she wanted to be able to finish reading the paper in the morning, something she had never been able to do. When Betty came back for her first follow-up visit after a month on our program, she told me she had read her first book! It was a joyous appointment. Several months later, she wondered aloud how her life would have been different if she had addressed her attention and impulse-control issues earlier in her life, yet she was grateful her children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren would not have to suffer as she had.

Too often, elderly (let’s say those over 70) people are dismissed with brain health/mental health issues —such as ADD/ADHD, depression, anxiety or memory issues —because they are older; but research has found that no matter what your age, your brain can be better if you put it in a healing environment. Brain imaging work at the Amen Clinics has also clearly shown the gravity of age. As your skin starts to sag and wrinkle and show other signs of aging, the same type of process occurs in the brain. Following are three typical scans at 35, 55, and 85.

TYPICAL AGING BRAIN SPECT SCANS

Surface SPECT scan showing uniform blood flow.

35 years old

Surface SPECT scan showing areas of very low blood flow.

55 years old

Surface SPECT scan showing larger areas of very low blood flow.

85 years old

Yet your brain doesn’t have to deteriorate with age if you remain diligent about your health for as long as you want to have a clear and happy mind! Here is a scan of my grandmother Margaret when she was a 92-year-old, and she was cognitively sharp until the day she died at age 98. One of her secrets of brain health was that she knitted her whole adult life, which is an exercise that works out the cerebellum.

Betty with a younger woman smiling at the camera

Grandmother

Surface SPECT scan showing mostly uniform blood flow.

Scan at 92

In a study the Amen Clinics and others published in the Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease in 2018 on 62,454 SPECT scans, we presented the overall pattern of brain aging and factors that accelerated it.[205] For example, we showed that children have very active brains that tend to settle down in activity around their mid-20s. From the mid-20s, brain activity then tends to stay relatively stable until the 60s, when it begins to decline, often due to poor vascular health and the other BRIGHT MINDS risk factors. But this doesn’t have to happen —there’s nothing inevitable about it. We have scanned many elderly patients and found really healthy scans, mostly because they were serious about taking care of themselves. Look at a typical aging pattern for the posterior cingulate gyrus, an area critical to memory and mood, in the graph below.

ACTIVITY IN THE AGING POSTERIOR CINGULATE GYRUS

(One of the first areas that dies in Alzheimer’s disease)

Graph of the mean of baseline posterior cingulate gyrus plotted against age from 0 to 92. The readings start at 2.0, rise to almost 2.5 in the first 5 years, then decline fairly smoothly till the 60s, where they decline with sharp jumps up and down till they reach 0.0 at age 92.
Cutaway side-view diagram of a brain with a region labeled along with a list of its associated functions. The middle toward the rear is labeled Posterior Cingulate Gyrus: Visual memory, one of the first areas to die in Alzheimer's disease.

These were the factors that accelerated aging the most in our study in order of importance: schizophrenia, marijuana abuse, bipolar disorder, and ADD/ADHD, along with alcohol abuse, and smoking. Other studies show that high iron levels in your blood[206] and red meat consumption[207] are also associated with premature aging.

The world’s population is on average becoming older, and age is the biggest risk factor for Alzheimer’s disease and other forms of dementia.[208] According to the World Health Organization, between 2015 and 2050 the percentage of people over 60 years will nearly double, from 12 percent to 22 percent.[209] This is really challenging for individuals as well as governments because as many as 10 percent of all people 65 years of age and older have serious memory problems, and up to 50 percent of all people 85 and older will be diagnosed with dementia. That means that if you are fortunate enough to live to 85, you have a one in two chance of losing your mind. Plus, the really bad news is that our research and the scientific findings of others have shown that Alzheimer’s disease and other forms of dementia actually start in the brain decades before people have any symptoms. For too many people, the golden years are anything but golden. The older you get, the more serious you need to be about the health of your brain.

Other brain health/mental health issues also worsen with age. The older you get, the more likely you are to struggle with your memory, social isolation, hearing problems, and overall cognitive function. As the brain deteriorates with age, it leads to a greater risk of mood problems, anxiety, irritability, temper flare-ups, and irrational behavior. Combine the lowered brain activity with detrimental changes to the four circles —biological, psychological, social, and spiritual —and it can accelerate brain health/mental health issues. Let’s look at how the four circles can contribute to brain health/mental health issues in the aging brain:

Poster titled 'Drivers of Brain Aging.' In the largest known brain imaging study, scientists from Amen Clinics, Google, Johns Hopkins, UCLA, and UC San Francisco evaluated 62,454 brain SPECT scans of individuals aged nine months to 105 years to investigate factors that accelerate brain aging. 128 brain regions studied to predict the chronological age of a patient. The poster includes a table titled 'Accelerated Aging Prediction': Schizophrenia: 4 years. Cannabis Abuse: 2.8 years. Bipolar Disorder: 1.6 years. ADHD: 1.4 years. Alcohol Abuse: 0.6 years. The poster displays SPECT scans at ages 20, 50, and 80 that show progressively more holes in activity. Daniel G. Amen, MD, founder of Amen Clinics, says, 'We can new link clinical diagnoses and addictions to premature aging of the brain. Better treatment of these disorders can slow or even halt brain aging. The cannabis abuse result was especially important, as our culture is starting to view marijuana as a harmless substance. These findings invite us to rethink its effects on the brain.'
circle icon B
circle icon P
circle icon S
circle icon SP

I saw some of these changes happening to one of my uncles. As he aged, his behavior became downright embarrassing whenever we went to dinner together. He had always been a bit impulsive, but later in life he was rude to servers and often made inappropriate comments. I could see his brain deteriorating before my eyes. Also, when depression strikes in the elderly, it may well be one of the first signs of dementia. Ultimately, when you stop learning, your brain starts dying.


BRIGHT MINDS Tip icon

When you stop learning, your brain starts dying.

 


YOU DON’T HAVE TO BE OLDER TO HAVE THESE ISSUES

Anyone who is in a job that does not require ongoing learning is at a higher risk of memory problems and brain health/mental health issues. Numerous studies show that people who struggled in school, who learned to hate learning, or who dropped out of school early also have a higher incidence of cognitive problems and mental health challenges.

If you want to create a mental illness, never fully support children with ADD/ADHD or learning disabilities. Every day of their lives that they feel they are failing or that someone is disappointed in them ratchets up chronic stress, which shrinks the hippocampus, a critically important brain structure involved in memory, mood, and learning. My nieces were at great risk for this because of their home situation before their mother got help for her brain. Likewise, if you want to create a mental illness, start your children in school too early. Research shows that younger children in school are more likely to be diagnosed with ADD/ADHD and treated with stimulant medication.[213]

Research also shows that purpose and social contribution across the lifespan have a surprising pattern: They tend to peak when people are young (late adolescence/young adulthood), then begin to wane during middle age and decline sharply through late adulthood.[214] When purpose is absent or low, it increases the risk of mental illnesses, particularly depression, and decreases self-acceptance.[215]

Likewise, you are more likely to develop a mental illness if you have an “old mind-set,” where you find yourself saying things such as:

Retirement/Aging Risk Factors
(and the Four Circles They Represent)

circle icon B
  1. 1. Increasing age, especially over 65.
circle icon B circle icon P
  1. 2. Having a job that does not require new learning.
circle icon S
  1. 3. Loneliness or social isolation. Humans are social animals: Social connectivity is hardwired into our brains, and when we are lonely and/or disconnected from others, it can have negative consequences for us cognitively, emotionally, and physically.[216] More than one in eight people report having no close friends.[217] The loneliest among us experience cognitive decline 20 percent faster than people who are connected to others, and loneliness has been associated with depression, social anxiety, addictions, even hoarding.[218] Loneliness peaks at several periods in life: during the late 20s, mid-50s, and late 80s.[219] Loneliness does not mean being alone or not having friends. It is subjective distress, meaning the discrepancy between the social relationships you have and the ones you want. The physical damage associated with being lonely was found to be equivalent to 15 cigarettes a day.
circle icon SP
  1. 4. Retired without new learning endeavors or passion or purpose.
circle icon B
  1. 5. Too much or too little iron (blood test) —ferritin measures iron stores in the blood. Get yours checked. Levels between 50 and 100 nanograms/mL are ideal. Levels below 50 ng/mL can cause problems, such as anxiety, fatigue, restless legs, and ADD/ADHD. A 2015 study among psychiatric patients found that more than 25 percent of them were also suffering from anemia, with the condition being most common in people with psychotic disorders, anxiety, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and bipolar disorder.[220] High levels (over 250 ng/mL) are associated with iron overload and increase the risk of inflammation, heart disease and neurodegenerative diseases, such as Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s disease.[221]
circle icon B
  1. 6. Decline of neurotransmitters (brain chemicals), such as serotonin, dopamine, gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), and acetylcholine. As we age, we lose brain cells that produce these important chemicals that help our neurons communicate effectively. Low serotonin activity increases risk of depression;[222] low dopamine increases risk of Parkinson’s disease and loss of motivation and pleasure;[223] low GABA increases the risk of anxiety;[224] and low acetylcholine can affect learning and memory.[225]

Take a look at how the evil and benevolent rulers would ensure that aging and retirement helped or perpetuated mental illness.

RETIREMENT/AGING

THE EVIL RULER WOULD . . .

  1. 1. Recommend everyone retire early, stop learning new things, and watch all the television they want, especially the news that focuses on violence, natural disasters, and partisan politics that breeds anger and stress.
  2. 2. Let people watch as many scary movies as they want or play violent video games, both of which wear out the pleasure centers.
  3. 3. Encourage people to spend their days in meaningless activities in isolation and demand that people spend hours on social media every day, which increases the risk of depression and obesity.
  4. 4. Start children in school too young.

THE BENEVOLENT RULER WOULD . . .

  1. 1. Encourage lifelong learning, purpose, and knitting.
  2. 2. Discourage children from starting school too young.
  3. 3. Promote cross-training in the workplace.
  4. 4. Limit television, social media, and scary movies to keep the pleasure centers healthy.
  5. 5. Encourage regular blood donation for those who have high iron blood levels.
  6. 6. Educate people about the benefits of intermittent fasting.
  7. 7. Provide treatment for ADD/ADHD and learning disabilities, so people would enjoy learning.
  8. 8. Mandate brain health education at schools and businesses, which would highlight the positive effects of lifelong learning.

Despite the dire news about aging and your brain, you don’t have to give in to decline. Yes, you will age, but you can slow the process while keeping your brain sharp, focused, and clear. Imagine entering the latter part of your life with just as much mental capacity and energy as you have now, if not more. It’s possible.

PRESCRIPTIONS FOR REDUCING YOUR RETIREMENT/AGING RISK FACTORS
(AND THE FOUR CIRCLES THEY REPRESENT)

circle icon P circle icon SP
  1. 1. Care! The older you get, the more serious you need to be. I turned 65 this year, and I’m planning to have one of the healthiest brains when I reach my 90s. I often ask myself, “Do you want an old brain or a young one?” to stay motivated when I don’t feel like working out or eating well. I recently saw a world-famous boxing champ who was struggling with his memory. After looking at his brain, I used the metaphor that he was in the “fight of his life.” He was going to have to break up with Colonel Sanders, one of his great loves, if he was going to keep his memory healthy. He told me he would train diligently because “you ain’t got nothing without your memory.”
circle icon B circle icon P circle icon S circle icon SP
  1. 2. Avoid anything that accelerates aging —such as no new learning, being in a job that does not require ongoing learning, high iron levels, smoking anything, alcohol or marijuana abuse, standard American diet, loneliness, and a lack of purpose.
circle icon SP
  1. 3. Know your why for being healthy. Do you believe you need to be healthy because God has a calling for you? Is it independence? I love my four children, but honestly, I never want to have to live with them. I never want to be a burden, and I do not want them telling me what to eat or what to wear or worrying about taking my driver’s license from me. If that is true for you, then you need to be serious about your health.
circle icon B circle icon P
  1. 4. Exercise your brain with new learning. Engage in lifelong learning to keep your brain strong. Take a cue from actress Dame Judi Dench, who continues to act even though she is now in her eighties. She told the Telegraph in 2015 that retired is the rudest word in the dictionary. “I don’t think age matters at all. What matters is your determination not to give up and not to stop learning new things.”[226]

    The best mental exercises involve acquiring new knowledge and doing things you haven’t done before. Even if your daily activities are complex, such as teaching coding, interpreting brain scans, or engineering a new bridge, they won’t challenge your brain as much as new learning. Whenever the brain repeats an activity over and over, it uses less and less energy each time to accomplish it. New learning, such as a new hobby or game, establishes new connections, which maintains and improves other brain areas that you use less often.

    The parts of your brain that you use will grow, and the parts of your brain that you do not use will atrophy, or shrink. This provides guidance on how to exercise the brain. If you were to only play Scrabble or do the Sunday crossword puzzle, you wouldn’t get the full benefits you want. That’s like going to work out and only doing right bicep curls and then leaving. See the graphic below for more ideas.

BRAIN HEALTH WORKOUTS BY REGION

Diagram of a brain with regions labeled. Each region has associated activities listed. Prefrontal cortext: Language games, such as Scrabble, Boggle, and Words With Friends; crossword puzzles; speech and debate classes in college; strategy games, such as chess, Rail Baron, Axis and Allies, and Blokus. Temporal lobe: Memory games; memorization of poetry and prose (increases hippocampal size). Basal ganglia: Balancing, synchronizing arm and leg movements, and manipulating props like ropes and balls. Parietal lobe: Math games like sodoku; juggling (occipital lobes and cerebellum); golf, even for novices; map reading without a GPS device. Cerebellum: Coordination games like table tennis (also involves PFC), dancing (learn new dance steps), yoga, tai chi, and basketball.
circle icon B
  1. 5. Balance your iron levels. Causes of too much iron include regular alcohol consumption, cooking in iron pans, foods fortified with iron, well water high in iron, or vitamin or mineral supplements with extra iron. Some people are genetically predisposed to absorb too much iron from food. Donating blood can help you lower iron levels. Green tea, rosemary[227], and curcumin may also help.[228]

    If you are low in iron, supplement with iron but never take iron in combination with other vitamins because it can make them toxic, and always take the iron supplement a couple of hours away from other supplements.

circle icon B
  1. 6. Fast intermittently. Fasting helps your brain stay healthy because it cleans out the buildup of toxic proteins that damage neurons, reducing inflammation and slowing down aging. A simple way to do a nightly 12- to 16-hour fast is to eat dinner at 7 p.m., for example, and not eat again until 7 a.m. (or 11 a.m. for a longer fast). Even longer fasts of 24 hours can also be helpful.
circle icon S
  1. 7. Get connected. To reduce the risk of loneliness and isolation, invest time with your family, church, or other groups. Sign up for a class or meet new people, anything to stay connected and build relationships. Research shows that caring for others increases your life expectancy.[229] Grandparents who care for their grandchildren, for example, live longer, on average, than grandparents who do not. In one study, older people who volunteered over two years actually increased the size of their hippocampus (involved in mood and memory).[230]
circle icon B
  1. 8. Take nutraceuticals that are most useful to slow aging.
    • N-acetylcysteine (NAC). NAC has shown promising results in people with bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, OCD, and addictions.[231] It can also decrease inflammation[232] and may help delay brain atrophy in Alzheimer’s disease.[233]

      Dose suggestion: The typical adult dose is 600–2,400 mg a day; more than 1,800 mg/day can upset your stomach. I usually start patients at 600 mg twice a day.

    • Huperzine A. This remarkable compound, studied in China for nearly 20 years, improves the cognitive impairment that is often seen in people with depression[234] or schizophrenia,[235] as well as with several types of dementia.[236] It can have adverse side effects such as gastrointestinal issues, headaches, dizziness, and increased urination, as well as side effects with certain medications. Caution: Huperzine A should only be used with a doctor’s supervision.

      Dose suggestion: The typical adult dose is 50–100 micrograms (mcg) twice a day.

    • Saffron. Recent clinical trials have found that it helps for depression,[237] bipolar disorder, and anxiety. As a potent antioxidant[238] and nerve protector,[239] saffron enhances memory,[240] protects the hippocampus, boosts blood flow[241] and acetylcholine,[242] and fights toxic buildup of the proteins thought to cause dementia.[243]

      Dose suggestion: The typical dose of saffron in trial is 30 mg a day of standardized concentrates. The dose of the patented preparation of saffron called Satiereal is 176.5 mg a day, and its potency is comparable to that of 30 mg per day of other saffron concentrates.

    • Sage. In the 17th century, herbalist Nicholas Culpeper wrote that the herb sage could “heal” the memory while “warming and quickening the senses.” Centuries later, research shows the brain-enhancing effects of sage extracts[244] including potential relief from depression.[245]

      Dose suggestion: The typical dose is 300–600 mg of dried sage leaf in capsules or essential oil in doses of 25–50 microliters (mcL). Caution: Those who have high blood pressure or seizure disorders should only use it under the direction of their physicians.

    • Phosphatidylserine (PS). Clinical trials show that PS improves attention, learning, memory and verbal skills in aging people with cognitive decline, and it is the best documented nutraceutical for memory. Even people with Alzheimer’s have been found to benefit from taking PS. PS may also be effective in controlling stress, as it has been found to reduce cortisol levels,[246] and may reduce symptoms of ADD/ADHD in children.[247] You can get PS from egg yolks, muscle meats, and organ meats.

      Dose suggestion: The typical adult dose is 100–300 mg a day.

BRIGHT MINDS: RETIREMENT/AGING

STEPS TO CREATE MENTAL ILLNESS . . . AND MAKE MY NIECES, ALIZÉ AND AMELIE, SUFFER

  1. 1. Don’t care about your aging brain.
  2. 2. Engage in habits that accelerate brain aging.
    • Don’t treat ADD/ADHD or learning disabilities so children learn to hate learning.
    • Have a job that requires no new learning.
    • Retire early without a new hobby, passion, or purpose in life.
    • Don’t think about why you want to have a healthy brain.
    • Live alone and isolate yourself from friends and family.
    • Don’t check your iron level or treat abnormal levels.
    • Focus on all your aches and pains and other reasons why your life isn’t as good as it used to be.
    • Adopt an “old mind-set.”
    • Watch a lot of TV, especially news that focuses on violence, natural disasters, and partisan politics that breeds anger.
    • Spend hours on social media, which increases the risk of depression and obesity.
  3. 3. Avoid the strategies that slow the brain aging process.

STEPS TO END MENTAL ILLNESS . . . AND KEEP MY NIECES, ALIZÉ AND AMELIE, HEALTHY

  1. 1. Care about your brain at all ages.
  2. 2. Avoid anything that prematurely ages your brain.
  3. 3. Engage regularly in healthy habits that slow the aging process.
    • Focus on learning new things to keep your mind active, and engage in a variety of exercises that work different brain regions.
    • Cross-train at work to learn new skills.
    • At retirement age, continue working or volunteering, or find a new passion.
    • Know why you want to keep your brain healthy as you age.
    • Consider intermittent fasting to help clear the brain of toxic proteins that damage neurons.
    • Stay connected to family and friends, and engage in church or other group activities to form bonds with others.
    • Check your iron level and treat it if it is abnormal.
    • Maintain a youthful outlook on life.
    • Avoid watching too much distressing TV news.
    • Limit the amount of time you spend on social media.
    • Get treatment for ADD/ADHD or other learning disabilities so you will enjoy learning.
    • Consider nutraceuticals to optimize your brain health.

Pick One BRIGHT MINDS Retirement/Aging Tiny Habit to Start Today


Tiny Habits icon
  1. I’ll limit charred meats.
  2. I’ll ask my doctor to check my ferritin (iron) levels.
  3. If my iron is too high, I’ll donate blood.
  4. I’ll try a daily fast for 12–16 hours.
  5. In my diet, I’ll include potent antioxidants such as blueberries, other berries, green tea, and cloves.
  6. To obtain the basic nutrients my brain needs to generate energy and use it to power its functions, I’ll take a multiple vitamin-mineral supplement and concentrated fish oil.
  7. I’ll add acetylcholine-rich foods, such as shrimp.
  8. I’ll stay connected to others and volunteer to avoid loneliness and isolation.
  9. I’ll start or continue music training.[248]
  10. Today, I’ll start a daily habit of new learning.