CHAPTER 36

Somebody’s shooting! Let’s go! Quick!” Ethan ducked low and ran toward the house with his rifle pointing at the front door. The stark terrain offered no cover. Footsteps thundered behind him as a dozen people followed. For a moment, it felt like his old army days, only now he was the officer leading the charge into battle. Cyrus pounded past him on the lane.

“Mr. Fennel! Wait!”

“My daughter’s in there!”

Fennel tore forward. Ethan was surprised the older man had such speed. Movement at the window distracted him, but someone behind him fired and broke the windowpane.

Cyrus slammed into the door and shoved on it, but it didn’t open. He put his shoulder to it and rammed it again. The door flew open. Cyrus and Kenton stood face-to-face for an instant. Kenton raised his gun and fired. Cyrus let off a round as he staggered off the step. More shots came from within. Ethan leaped aside and flattened himself against the log wall beside the door.

Hiram and Doc Kincaid, with half a dozen other men behind them, stopped ten yards from the house and peppered it with bullets. Farther back, a cluster of women approached.

Hiram walked steadily forward, aiming his rifle at the front of the ranch house. They must be crazy, attacking like this. Didn’t the British lose the whole country because they fought in the open and refused to skulk behind trees like Indians?

A few shots came from inside the house, but most of the gunfire came from his contingent. He looked around uneasily. What had happened to that cowpoke near the wagon? No one seemed to be crouched behind it now.

As the door opened and Cyrus went down, Hiram’s hat flew off. He whirled toward the barn, his Sharps at his shoulder. Above them, through the cloud of gun smoke hovering over them, he saw a figure in the door of the hayloft. A heavyset man with a beard stood above the posse, taking aim at those below.

Hiram hated to use his rifle to harm another human being. He also hated to reveal his well-concealed shooting ability. But unless he acted quickly, one of his friends would likely be killed. They were sitting ducks for the sniper. He hesitated only an instant before he pulled the trigger. The man in the hayloft dropped his rifle. It fell to the ground below. He staggered back and disappeared into the dark loft.

Ethan held up his hands to stop the townsmen’s shooting. Doc drew a bead and fired once more before he noticed the signal. The noise subsided. Cyrus lay still on the dirt at the bottom of the steps.

From a distance, Josiah Runnels shouted, “They’re jumping out the back!” Several shots followed.

“Go ahead, Sheriff,” Hiram called. “I’ll cover the door.”

Cautiously, Ethan took a quick peek around the doorjamb. Kenton Smith lay on his back just inside the door. Another man had crumpled beneath the window. Ethan couldn’t see anyone else, but a thick haze of smoke obscured the room.

“Doc, tend to Cyrus.” Ethan dove into the house, leading with his Colt. Eerie quiet buzzed around him.

From the doorway behind him, Hiram called, “All clear?”

“Reckon so.” Ethan continued to scan the dim room.

“Art Tinen winged one of them that ran out the back door, and Doc says he hit one in here. The rest ran to their horses and got away clean.”

Ethan jerked his head toward the man lying beneath the window. “That’d be Doc’s target, I guess.”

Hiram stepped over to the inert form and stooped to pick up the fallen man’s weapon. “That’s the fella I got into it with at Bitsy’s.”

“Yup. Eli Button.” Ethan lifted his hat and wiped the sweat from his brow with his sleeve. “Where’s Isabel? Did they take her?”

“Nobody’s seen her. She wasn’t with them when they ran.”

Ethan stared at him. “That’s crazy. We saw her an hour ago. She was in here with them.”

“Maybe she’s still in here.”

Ethan looked around again. “Miss Fennel?”

No answer. The house appeared to have only one large room with a loft over part of it. He crossed to another door and opened it. The lean-to held a woodpile and a few tools. “All right, get a couple of people in here to search the loft. She could be tied up in a corner. You don’t suppose she got away from them and ran?”

“Don’t see how she could have,” Hiram said. “We had the place surrounded.”

Ethan called again, “Miss Fennel?” He stepped out into the lean-to. No one cowered behind the woodpile. Josiah, Augie, and several of the shooting club members had fanned out over the barnyard and corral. Ethan called to Augie, “Miss Fennel’s not in here. Search that barn and the bunkhouse.” He walked back through the house, stepped over Smith’s body, and went out the front door.

Doc Kincaid and Bitsy knelt beside Cyrus, while Rose stood by, knotting her handkerchief. Ethan walked over to them.

“How is he, Doc?”

Kincaid glanced up at him. “I’m losing him.”

Ethan grimaced. They were lucky no one else had been killed, the way things had erupted.

Augie came out of the barn and crossed the yard. “Funniest thing, Sheriff. I found a rifle lying on the ground in front of the barn, and up in the hayloft there’s a dead cowpoke shot in the heart.”

Ethan eyed the front of the barn. “Somebody must have shot him through that door to the loft.”

“That’s what I figure,” Augie said. “Don’t know who did it, though. Oh, and Art Tinen says he got a shot at that Sterling fella when he grabbed a horse out of the corral. Thinks he may have nicked him, but he got through our lines.”

Ethan scratched the back of his neck. The sun beat down on them. “Go in and help Hiram tear this house apart. Isabel’s got to be here someplace. We saw her less than an hour ago.”

Kincaid sat back on his heels and looked soberly at Ethan. “He’s gone, Sheriff.”

Ethan let his shoulders sag. He’d handled everything wrong today. He should have let Cyrus scramble for the money and borrow what he could from Libby and the other business owners.

Josiah came tearing around the corner of the house. “Doc, there’s a wounded man out back.”

“One of Kenton’s men?” Ethan asked.

“Yup. Looks like he fell off his horse and the others left him.”

Dr. Kincaid stood and reached for his bag. “There’s nothing more I can do here.” He followed Josiah.

Ethan met Hiram’s gaze and sank back against the wall. “Don’t know what else we could have done when they started shooting in here.”

Hiram’s brow furrowed. He looked down at Kenton’s body and over at Button. “That was an odd thing. All our people were holding back. Who started the shooting?”

Ethan shook his head slowly. “I thought some of our people got too close. Around back, you know? Where we couldn’t see them.”

Hiram shook his head. “Augie said they heard shooting here before they moved in. According to him, it sounded like the first shots were inside the house. The fellows around back thought you’d started something out front.”

Ethan closed his eyes. Had he moved in too fast? Was it his fault that lives had been lost?

Lord, how could I have been so wrong? Now we’ve lost Cyrus and Isabel both. Those no-accounts must have gotten her out of here—don’t ask me how. Show me what to do now, Lord, ‘cause I’m not much good on my own.

No shots had sounded for a good ten minutes. Isabel had stopped shaking and had almost stopped noticing the stench of the privy. Maybe it was safe to go out now. She reached for the rusty steel hook that held the outhouse door shut and pushed it out of the staple. Slowly she opened the door an inch and peered out.

Dr. Kincaid and Josiah Runnels were walking across the overgrown barnyard behind the ranch house. She opened the door farther, and the hinges creaked.

The men swung toward her, Josiah, bringing his gun around to point at her. The doctor’s face changed from surprise to concern, and he hurried toward her.

“Miss Fennel? Is that you?”

She opened the door wider. “Yes. Is it safe to come out now?”

“Yes ma’am.” He offered his hand as she stepped down from the little shack.

“Thank you.” She stumbled a little, and he steadied her.

Josiah had lowered his gun but still stared at her. “Should I tell the folks you’re all right, miss?”

Isabel managed a shaky smile. Josiah had been one of her students not so long ago. “Yes, please. I’m fine.”

He turned without another word and ran toward the ranch house.

Isabel looked up into Dr. Kincaid’s somber blue eyes. “Is my father all right? I heard a lot of shooting.”

The doctor glanced uneasily back toward the house. “Ma’am, there was a big dustup, and …” He hesitated, and she studied his face. “I’m afraid the news is not good.”

“Papa’s been shot?”

“Yes.”

“Then why aren’t you with him? Is it serious?” The regret in his eyes told her more than she wanted to know. “Oh no. He’s not—Tell me, Doctor. Is my father dead?”

Before he could speak, Josiah’s whoop reached them. “She’s found! Sheriff, Miss Fennel’s found!”

Kincaid’s quiet words sliced through her heart. “I’m afraid so, ma’am. I’m so very sorry.”

Isabel reached for him, her head swimming. She clutched at his neat black vest as her knees buckled.