I Shared My Favorite Sex Toys with My Boyfriend, and Now He Loves Them, Too

I keep a well-stocked supply of sex toys, because a girl never knows what’s going to come in handy. When I met my boyfriend, Jared, he audaciously suggested that I might not need them anymore. While I love his cock, I assured him that the toys would only add to our fun. He was slightly skeptical, so I said, “Let me prove it to you.”

I made him sit in a chair, stripped down, and laid out my toys next to me on the bed. I tried to forget that he was there at first and just focused on getting off. I went through my usual ritual, running through a roster of fantasies as I touched my pussy, getting myself nice and juicy. Then I turned on a small vibrator, a round bullet that I use to warm myself up. With my legs spread wide, I ran the buzzing bullet along my lips and began rocking lightly against the mattress. As I got more aroused, that tiny vibe ceased to be enough. I needed more stimulation, so I plugged in my most intense vibrator, the one that looks like a serious machine.

The minute that toy began vibrating against my clit, I was lost. Sensations suffused my body as I absorbed all the energy that was bearing down on my tiny, hard little bundle of nerve endings.

Having Jared watch me made the moment that much more exciting. I pressed the toy to me harder, keeping it humming against my flesh even as the intensity threatened to be too much. I wanted to come, but I wanted to build up to the moment before orgasm to give Jared the full experience. I had a feeling that if I peaked too soon, he’d be jerking off himself, so I held off, tossing aside that toy and reaching for some warming liquid, my favorite kind of lube. It heats to the touch, and it’s extra slippery—not that I really needed that aspect of it, as wet as I was. However, I wanted to make sure my cunt was as slick as could be before I brought out what I think of as my monster cock—a massive black dildo that I often have to work to fit inside me, but once I do, look out!

I was already well on my way to climax, and for once, the fat silicone cock fit easily inside my lubed-up slit. I relaxed and visualized the toy invading my hole, and soon I’d pushed it all the way inside me. This dildo is my favorite because of its large size, and I’ve grown to really love what it does to me. As I get more aroused, I can take more and more of it, and it always feels like a victory when my pussy manages to accommodate the whole thing.

I peeked at my man and saw that Jared was wide-eyed with amazement. He had one hand stroking his cock through his pants as he stared at what I was doing. I lifted my head a little and licked my lips as I slid the dildo in and out, savoring every inch of the toy as it plundered my cunt. I watched as the cock disappeared inside me, then emerged glistening with my juices. I rammed the toy back into me with a few hard thrusts, making myself come in a rapid-fire series of spasms. When I was done, I set the dildo aside and sat up, slightly out of breath, and looked at Jared. His pants were open, and he was pumping his cock.

“I guess you thought that was pretty hot, after all,” I said with a sly smile. I patted the bed next to me, and Jared quickly got naked and joined me. I was so used to playing with my sex toys alone that having my aroused boyfriend next to me was quite a treat. He took my hand and placed it on his dick. Feeling his pulsing, warm cock in my hands got me excited all over again. I rolled him onto his back and began kissing his chest before zeroing in on his nipples. Jared’s nubs are even more sensitive than mine. When I climbed on top of him, rubbing my slick pussy against his hard cock while I swirled my tongue against his nipples, I felt his dick jerk with excitement beneath me.

Jared growled, pretending to bite my lip. “Baby, I had no idea watching you with those toys would be like that. You got so into it, and I wanted to join you and drill that dildo right into your pussy,” he said, his fingers dipping down to stroke my slick entrance as he got ready to fuck me. While he slid his thick fingers in and out of my pussy, I wiggled against his hand and my tongue continued to torment his nipples. “I want you, Mindy,” he said, groaning, as I nipped at his buds with my teeth.

“Well, you can certainly have me if it means you’re going to fuck me with your big, hard cock,” I said, knowing how much he likes hearing me talk dirty. “But… there’s a catch,” I said teasingly. He looked at me, his face slack, as if he’d do absolutely anything I asked. “I want you to take this little vibrator,” I continued, pressing the small pink toy into his hand, “and hold it against my clit while your cock is inside me.”

Whereas before I was sure he’d have objected, now Jared practically snatched the vibe out of my hand and turned it on. A buzzing sound filled the air, and I just couldn’t wait to have his dick inside me. I pounced on him, holding his cock with my hand as I pushed my pussy down onto him, moving slowly to savor the process of his cock entering me. Once I had his full length inside me, I gave him a go-ahead look and he brought the small pink toy to my clit. Immediately, the vibrations thrummed through my sex, making me tingle. I pitched forward, grabbing Jared’s shoulder as he smiled at me, clearly relishing the power he held between his fingers.

He began working the toy in circles, the fluttering pink plastic stroking my clit in such rapid succession that my swollen nub was being constantly stimulated. When he started thrusting his hips upward at the same time, sending his cockhead rubbing against my center, I shivered with joy. This was better than any solo experience, because I got the mechanical, fast-moving sensation of the vibrator along with Jared’s very real cock pumping away. I looked deep into his eyes, working my hips in a circle as he pressed the vibe tighter against me. Soon the vibrator was wedged between our bodies as I lay down on top of Jared. My breasts were smashed against his chest, and I kissed his cheek as I got lost in the delicious rumblings teasing my pussy.

When I was ready to come, I sat back up, bouncing on his erection as he rocked against me. Both of us were rapidly approaching orgasm. “Right there, yes!” I cried out as he moved the vibrator slightly. My orgasm followed moments later, and Jared moved the vibrator aside so he could fully embrace me. He hugged me tightly as he thrust his hips upward for a few final slams of his cock into my pussy and then shot his come deep into my core. We were both breathless but excited when we recovered. It was like a whole new world of sensual possibilities now awaited us, all right there in my toy drawer.

—Ms. Mindy L., Phoenix, Arizona