Better Read Than Dead:
A Revised Opinion

My attendance at grammar school coincided rather unappealingly with the height of the cold war. This resulted in my spending a portion of each day sitting cross-legged, head in lap, either alone under my desk or, more sociably, against the wall in the corridor. When not so occupied I could be found sitting in class reading avidly about the horrors of life under Communism. I was not a slow child, but I believed passionately that Communists were a race of horned men who divided their time equally between the burning of Nancy Drew books and the devising of a plan of nuclear attack that would land the largest and most lethal bomb squarely upon the third-grade class of Thomas Jefferson School in Morristown, New Jersey. This was a belief widely held among my classmates and it was reinforced daily by teachers and those parents who were of the Republican persuasion.

Among the many devices used to keep this belief alive was a detailed chart that appeared yearly in our social studies book. This chart pointed out the severe economic hardships of Communist life. The reading aloud of the chart was accompanied by a running commentary from the teacher and went something like this:

“This chart shows how long a man must work in Russia in order to purchase the following goods. We then compare this to the length of time it takes a man in the United States to earn enough money to purchase the same goods.”

 
RUSSIA U.S.A.
 
A PAIR OF SHOES—38 HOURS A PAIR OF SHOES—2 HOURS
  
“And they only have brown oxfords in Russia, so that nobody ever gets to wear shoes without straps even for dress-up. Also they have never even heard of Capezios, and if they did, no one would be allowed to wear them because they all have to work on farms whenever they are not busy making atom bombs.” “And we have all kinds of shoes, even Pappagallos.”
  
A LOAF OF BREAD—2½ HOURS A LOAF OF BREAD—5 MINUTES
  
“They do not have peanut butter in Russia, or Marshmallow Fluff, and their bread has a lot of crust on it, which they force all the children to eat.” “We have cinnamon raisin bread and english muffins and we can put whatever we like on it because we have democracy.”
  
A POUND OF NAILS—6 HOURS A POUND OF NAILS—8 MINUTES
  
“And they need a lot of nails in Russia because everyone has to work very hard all the time building things—even mothers.” “Even though we don’t need that many nails because we have Scotch tape and staples.”
  
A STATION WAGON—9 YEARS A STATION WAGON—4 MONTHS
  
“If they were even permitted to own them, which they are not, so everyone has to walk everywhere even though they are very tired from building so many things like atom bombs.” “And we have so many varieties to choose from—some painted to look like wood on the sides and some that are two different colors. We also have lots of other cars, such as convertible sports cars.”
  
A PAIR OF OVERALLS—11 HOURS A PAIR OF OVERALLS—1 HOUR
  
“And everyone has to wear overalls all the time and they’re all the same color so nobody gets to wear straight skirts even if they’re in high school.” “But since we can choose what we want to wear in a democracy, mostly farmers wear overalls and they like to wear them.”
  
A DOZEN EGGS—7 HOURS A DOZEN EGGS—9 MINUTES
  
“But they hardly ever get to eat them because eggs are a luxury in Russia and there are no luxuries under Communism.” “We have lots of eggs here and that is why we can have eggnog, egg salad, even Easter eggs, except for the Jewish children in the class, who I’m sure have something just as nice on their holiday, which is called Hanukkah.”
  
A TELEVISION SET—2 YEARS A TELEVISION SET—2 WEEKS
  
“But they don’t have them. That’s right, they do not have TV in Russia because they know that if the people in Russia were allowed to watch Leave It to Beaver they would all want to move to the United States, and probably most of them would want to come to Morristown.” “And many people have two television sets and some people like Dougie Bershey have color TV so that he can tell everyone in class what color everything was on Walt Disney.”

All of this was duly noted by both myself and my classmates, and the vast majority of us were rather right-wing all through grammar school. Upon reaching adolescence, however, a number of us rebelled and I must admit to distinctly leftist leanings during my teen years. Little by little, though, I have been coming around to my former way of thinking and, while I am not all that enamored of our local form of government, I have reacquired a marked distaste for Theirs.

My political position is based largely on my aversion to large groups, and if there’s one thing I know about Communism it’s that large groups are definitely in the picture. I do not work well with others and I do not wish to learn to do so. I do not even dance well with others if there are too many of them, and I have no doubt but that Communist discothèques are hideously overcrowded. “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs” is not a decision I care to leave to politicians, for I do not believe that an ability to remark humorously on the passing scene would carry much weight with one’s comrades or that one could convince them of the need for a really reliable answering service. The common good is not my cup of tea—it is the uncommon good in which I am interested, and I do not deceive myself that such statements are much admired by the members of farming collectives. Communists all seem to wear small caps, a look I consider better suited to tubes of toothpaste than to people. We number, of course, among us our own cap wearers, but I assure you they are easily avoided. It is my understanding that Communism requires of its adherents that they arise early and participate in a strenuous round of calisthenics. To someone who wishes that cigarettes came already lit the thought of such exertion at any hour when decent people are just nodding off is thoroughly abhorrent. I have been further advised that in the Communist world an aptitude for speaking or writing in an amusing fashion doesn’t count for spit. I therefore have every intention of doing my best to keep the Iron Curtain from being drawn across Fifty-seventh Street. It is to this end that I have prepared a little chart of my own for the edification of my fellow New Yorkers.

The following chart compares the amount of time it takes a Communist to earn enough to purchase the following goods against the amount of time it takes a New Yorker to do the same.

 
COMMUNIST NEW YORKER
 
A CO-OP APARTMENT IN THE EAST SEVENTIES ON THE PARK—4,000 YEARS. And even then you have to share it with the rest of the collective. There is not a co-op in the city with that many bathrooms. A CO-OP APARTMENT IN THE EAST SEVENTIES ON THE PARK—No time at all if you were lucky in the parent department. If you have not been so blessed it could take as long as twenty years, but at least you’d have your own bathroom.
  
A SUBSCRIPTION TO The New Yorker—3 WEEKS. And even then it is doubtful that you’d understand the cartoons. A SUBSCRIPTION TO The New Yorker—1 HOUR, maybe less, because in a democracy one frequently receives such things as gifts.
  
A FIRST-CLASS AIRPLANE TICKET to PARIS—6 MONTHS—Paris, Comrade? Not so fast. A FIRST-CLASS AIRPLANE TICKET to PARIS—varies widely, but any smart girl can acquire such a ticket with ease if she plays her cards right.
  
A FERNANDO SANCHEZ NIGHTGOWN—3 MONTHS. With the cap? Very attractive. A FERNANDO SANCHEZ NIGHTGOWN—1 WEEK, less if you know someone in the business, and need I point out that your chances of being so connected are far greater in a democracy such as ours than they are in Peking.
  
DINNER AT A FINE RESTAURANT—2 YEARS to earn the money; 27 years for the collective to decide on a restaurant. DINNER AT A FINE RESTAURANT—No problem if one has chosen one’s friends wisely.