Molly woke and couldn’t remember falling asleep. She tried to convince herself that Mr. Fen’s assault hadn’t happened, that his body weight had simply been her own heavy limbs, his whispers mere delirium induced by the fog. But the smell of him had lingered, sulfurous and sweaty, and the cloth with which she’d cleaned her leg was crumpled on the floor. The waterbreath had thinned and it was easier to breathe. She could now see Nicholas distinctly in his cot. She changed her clothes before he woke, but even her extra shift had dampened in the night and every inch of her was sticky, every part of her was fouled.
She went to Nicholas’s side, rubbed his arm, and woke him up. He looked at her and sighed but the sigh became a cough, so phlegmy that it choked him for a moment till he swallowed. He regarded her with no apparent knowledge of the night, as if she’d only just arrived to tell him it was foggy and he hadn’t spent the intervening hours in oblivion.
“Good morning,” Molly said, grateful he was sick; in health, he would have recognized the falseness of her smile.
“G’morning,” Nicholas wheezed, and gestured for a drink.
She gave him sips of wine and talked about the waterbreath, worried Mr. Fen was listening at the door. What if he could hear the muffled conversation? What if he suspected she was saying something more? Molly raised her voice, enunciating her words, speaking of the fog and of the Serpentine Current. Nicholas chewed a biscuit and appeared to pay attention, but the air in the windowless cabin remained oppressive and he dozed again, his face slightly pinker from the wine.
She took his spare clothes to dry on deck. Mr. Fen’s door was closed when she passed it and she hesitated, worried he would hear her creeping past. She thought of returning to her cabin for Nicholas’s safety but, desperate for a walk among the crew, told herself that Mr. Fen had only meant to frighten her into silence.
The waterbreath was gone, the day was clear and bright, and a rich, warm wind fluffed the sails to sunny life. The vessel raced along the waves and all the seamen were delighted, calling out and laughing, and the morning air revived her as she hung her brother’s clothes to freshen on the shrouds.
Mr. Fen appeared thirty feet away, partially concealed by the cross-hatched rigging. He looked at her intently, didn’t waver, didn’t blink. His stare was like a candle flame pausing in its flicker, turning for a moment into a sharp blade of light. Molly’s vision swam. She felt as if the fog were in her lungs again. He didn’t speak or gesture but she understood him fully: I am watching every moment. Not a word or I will kill him.
Nicholas’s death would hardly be suspicious after weeks of constant illness. She could tell the crew directly and the sailors would believe her: she was popular and Mr. Fen was generally disliked. They would flog him and confine him all the way to Floria. But Captain Veer distrusted her and might dismiss her claim. Lacking any proof, Mr. Fen could walk away.
Refusing to cry or look afraid, she turned from his unwavering stare and walked to the stern of the ship, wobbly as a lubber who had just come aboard.
“Good morning, Mrs. Smith!” said Mr. Knacker, doffing his hat. “The Cleaver’s grown wings and we are flying ’cross the Serpentine!”
“Good morning,” Molly said without her customary cheer, continuing ahead as though he were a stranger. She registered the hurt in Mr. Knacker’s falling features but she longed to be alone and couldn’t risk conversation, not with Mr. Fen assuming she’d accuse him.
The gleaming sea, luscious green with rippling sun and white-capped waves, was too alive and colorful to look upon today. Molly sat below the rail against a weatherworn barrel, found a short length of rope, and practiced a knot she had learned from one of the midshipmen. It was an octopus knot, named for its appearance and extraordinary hold, and she tied and untied it dozens of times as various members of the crew discovered her there, and greeted her, and asked whether she was well.
“Yes,” she said to each without looking up.
The wizened second mate approached her and said, “Beg pardon, Mrs. Smith, but there’s a large pod of mourningfish racing off the bow. They’re marvelous quick and sad. It’s said their great intelligence causes them to grieve.”
He invited her to watch. Molly sullenly declined, and when the second mate returned to the crew with news of her indifference, the sailors were so concerned—she could see them in a huddle, speaking lowly, glancing over—they themselves lost interest in the mourningfish and went about their work, serious and quiet.
She had been sitting alone for an hour when a shadow moved beside her. Molly recognized his boots and how they planted on the deck, but she didn’t acknowledge his presence when he loomed there above her, studying the ocean with his customary glower.
“You’ve done it wrong,” Captain Veer eventually said without looking down, as though he sensed a faulty knot just by standing in its presence.
He was right. She had been tying it incorrectly every time, but when she double-checked her loops and turns, she couldn’t spot her error. She loosened the rope and tried again, concentrating fiercely. He followed her attempt out of the corner of his eye. She failed and tried again, fumbling and annoyed, until he turned and said, “There. Pull the bight through the left.”
“Yes, of course,” Molly said, admiring the difference.
“The other way appeared to be correct,” the captain said, “but would tighten up demonically as soon as it was wet.”
She finished the knot, felt its strength, and loosened it with ease. It seemed a miracle, the way its whole complexity unraveled. She remembered how severely Jeremy used to bind her, and how completely they had caught him in their own tight snare.
Captain Veer walked away before she realized he was leaving.
Molly stood and said, “Sir.”
He stopped and turned around. The wind blew his shirt against his chest and showed his ribs, as well as a scar like a cutlass wound just below his throat. His breeches flapped. He’d grown an inch of beard during the voyage and reminded her of a pirate, dangerous but gallant.
She noticed Mr. Fen watching from afar.
“Thank you,” Molly said.
The captain answered with a bow.
“At your service, Mrs. Smith,” Captain Veer replied.
He paused as if intuiting she needed something more.
Molly took her knot and went below to sit with Nicholas.
* * *
She lay awake in her cot that night, dressed in all she owned, including her cloak and double stockings, underneath a blanket tucked tightly at her sides. She was attuned to every sound, down to the faintest creak of timbers. Shortly after two bells, she heard Mr. Fen creeping through the door and looked to Nicholas beside her, too far to reach and sleeping on his side, and hoped he wouldn’t wake until the worst of it was done. Mr. Fen stepped between them in his dull gray shift. He checked on Nicholas himself and lifted Molly’s blanket, smiling at the extra clothes she’d worn to keep him out.
“Hush,” he said.
He opened her cloak and laid himself upon her. Every inch of her contracted when he hiked up his shift, letting the blanket fall so Molly saw his plump, hairless buttocks.
“No,” Molly whispered.
“Then I’ll smother him,” he said.
He forced his hand between their bellies to the middle of her legs. Next he peeled her stocking down and rubbed against her thigh, presumably afraid of getting her with child and content to find his pleasure in a less invasive manner.
“Wait,” Molly said, taking hold of his erection.
It was softer than expected, given its rigidity, and tacky with his sweat when she gripped it in her fist. Mr. Fen did not object but repositioned himself at once, allowing her to cup her other hand around his balls.
“Move it up and down,” he said. “Nicely, up and down.”
She did as she was told until he shut his eyes and moaned. Molly worked faster. He relaxed in his distraction. She was amazed that such a motion—little effort, little grace—could render him as helpless as a child in her power.
Molly reached beneath her back, still stroking with her fist, and found the octopus knot she had hidden in the cot. It was warm. It was wet. She had tied it incorrectly. Mr. Fen didn’t notice when it looped around his scrotum.
Molly let him go, seized the dangling ends, and cinched the knot tight enough to hold a rolling cannon.
Mr. Fen constricted and he looked at her, aghast. The whiteness of his face turned furiously red and his sounds were otherworldly, like a corpse made to groan. He clapped his hands around the knot and tried to roll away. Molly felt the sway, held the cot, and stayed within it when he tumbled off and thudded to the floor.
He struck his elbow and his head and wobbled to his knees, as astonished by the mass of wet rope between his legs as by the fact that she had done it—by the fact that she had dared.
She’d expected him to flee; she panicked when he stayed.
He turned to Nicholas, enraged, to carry out his threat.
Nicholas had woken up and knelt beside his cot. He aimed the pistol from the trunk at Mr. Fen’s chest. His eyes were clear and bright, his arm an iron bar. Only a dead man risen would have bettered the effect and Mr. Fen shrank, buckling over in his fear. He didn’t move until Nicholas fully cocked the gun, and then he lurched toward the door and hobbled to his cabin for a long, hard night of wrestling with the knot.
Nicholas collapsed. In her haste to help him up, Molly tumbled from her cot. She banged her knee, got a splinter in her thumb, and crawled to reach him. Once she had him on his feet, she tried to take the pistol but he wouldn’t let it go until she’d eased him into his cot again. The effort had fatigued him and he struggled to raise his head.
“I have to tell the captain straightaway,” Molly said. “I couldn’t prove myself before, but now the knot—”
“Proves nothing”—Nicholas winced and coughed—“but that you had him at your side.”
“He knows we’re brother and sister.”
Nicholas revived. “How?”
“He guessed. I tried to lie. I didn’t tell him! But we have to tell the captain what he did. Don’t you see? He’ll follow us in Floria and ruin all our secrecy. He has to be arrested.”
“He’d be punished and released.”
Molly groaned in agitation, flopped down, and bumped her tailbone. She prodded at the sliver in her thumb. “What can we do?”
“Keep the pistol in your cot.”
“And then?”
“Let me think,” he said.
“No.” Molly stood. “I’m going to the captain.”
“Stay,” Nicholas told her. “We have time enough to answer this. Tomorrow you will see it in the clear light of day.”
* * *
Early next morning, something was amiss. Molly’s ears popped. She blew her nose and yawned to work the pressure out. The Cleaver’s rises and falls were longer, more profound, and urgent shouts and footsteps sounded overhead. She’d grown accustomed to the sea but now her stomach felt the plunges, and the air had a cold, gray smell of greasy metal.
Nicholas hadn’t moved since returning to his cot. After convincing her not to speak to Captain Veer about their trouble, he had given her the pistol, lain awake thinking, and eventually fallen asleep without another word. She’d tucked the pistol under his arm—she hadn’t trusted herself to use it—and had slept until the strange new atmosphere awoke her.
Now she had to get them food and learn the state of Mr. Fen, and so she left her brother alone and crept through the hold as subtly as she could.
The door of Mr. Fen’s cabin stood open and she paused to peek inside. Mr. Fen was gone. His book was in the hammock and his lantern hung above it, throwing just enough light to clarify the room. She entered warily and double-checked the shadows in the corners. The octopus knot lay severed on the floor, slightly bloody near the cut as if he’d nicked himself slicing through the fibers with a razor.
Molly hurried on deck where the day was scarcely brighter than the heavy dark below. The sea astonished her. The waves were vastly taller than she had expected. She’d have felt the motion more except that the Cleaver, taking longer to traverse the broader swells, rose and fell at wider intervals and seemed more controlled. In truth the sturdy ship was little better than a cork. It bobbed along, largely at the mercy of the ocean, and amazement took her breath when the bow began to crest.
They’d been sheltered from the gale by the great surrounding waves. Now the wind filled the sails and Molly felt the lurch. The humming of the rigging sounded like a choir, one of long-dead women keening for their lives. There were gray-black valleys. There were mountains spewing foam. The sky bulged low, swirling and contorting, ironclad with scraps of brighter mist whipping by. The bow began to dip and Molly tilted with the pitch. Down they went, falling smoothly, till the waves were all around them, taller than the mainmast and quieting the wind.
She heard the sailors then—she hadn’t even noticed they were with her—shouting from their stations, swearing at the clouds.
Mr. Fen was not in sight. Molly walked the deck with concentrated effort, asking everyone she passed if anyone had seen him.
“No,” they said in turn, focused on their duties.
Each of them impressed her with a warning, gravely spoken: “Get yourself below.” “Use the privy, now or never.” “Ask McGiverns for a rope and tie yourself down.”
The second mate frowned at Mr. Fen’s name, preoccupied with several men shortening the mainsail. “Hell on earth is tiddlywinks to hell upon the sea,” he said, speaking less to Molly than to his own recollections. “Never worry, Mrs. Smith,” he hastily continued. “Captain Veer will see us through. Go and ask him there afore.”
The captain stood alone, regarding sea and sky. She was relieved to see him drinking from a small cup of coffee, as confidently balanced as a man upon land. When she wobbled up beside him, his expression changed her mind. Neither angry nor afraid, he stared with resignation, like the matron who had carried her loaf of bread to face the guns.
“Morning, Mrs. Smith,” he said, dispensing with the “good.” “I suggest you take a meal and tie yourself securely into your cot.”
“Mr. Blake said the same. Is it really so dire?”
“Aye,” the captain said.
They climbed another wave, much higher than the others, and the wind flung droplets from the corners of her eyes. She waited for the quiet of the next deep trough.
“Have you seen Mr. Fen? He wasn’t in his room.”
“Ask the cook if he has gone to get his eggs,” the captain said. He drank his coffee in a gulp and turned to meet her eye. “Keep yourself below. We’re in for evil weather. I have never seen the pressure fall as quickly or as far.”
Molly’s spirit fell as swiftly. She worried for the sailors who were bound to stay on deck—friends of hers and kindly men, minnows in the storm.
“Be safe,” she said to Captain Veer.
She kissed him on the cheek. He softened like chocolate held briefly in her hand. Molly left before he spoke and saw the crew stifling laughs. It warmed her for a moment—Mr. Knacker winked hello—but then the spume smelled icy and the ship sank low and she imagined being drowned in the everlasting cold.
She collected two coils of rope from Mr. McGiverns and started below to get some food, but then a thought rippled up, causing her to stop: Mr. Fen unaccounted for and Nicholas alone. The pistol wasn’t loaded. She’d been gone too long.
She hurried back and Mr. Fen was reading in his hammock. He looked at her and smiled with malevolent success. Molly felt her stomach falling through her bladder when she left him there and rushed down the passage to her cabin. A wave struck the ship and rocked it far to starboard. Molly hit the wall and landed on the floor.
She crawled toward her brother’s cot, unable to see his face until she kneeled up beside him. Nicholas was sleeping with the pistol at his side. She laughed and kissed his hand, tied him down with half the rope, and made herself secure within her own swaying cot. The ship’s chaotic motion steadily intensified and Molly lay awake, and listened to the storm, and worriedly obsessed over Mr. Fen’s smile.
* * *
There were times she felt the ship had rolled upon its side, or underneath the water like a small wooden bubble. Lightning cracked, terrible as fractures in the hull—she couldn’t see it but she smelled it, caustic and electric—and now and then her arm hairs tingled at the tips. Waves boomed from all directions. Molly gripped the rope that held her in the cot and tried to pray, using prayers she invented on the spot. Closing her eyes made the nauseating movement more pronounced, and the unrelenting storm began to wear her out. Eventually she slept. She dreamed of swirling darkness.
When she woke and looked around, Nicholas was gone. His safety rope dangled from the cot. She fought her own wet rope; the knot was tied correctly but refused to come loose. She tried to see if Nicholas was lying on the floor; half a foot of water sloshed against the wall.
Finally the rope came free and Molly stood. The water chilled her feet, cold as winter rain, and then a wave hit the Cleaver and the ship fell aslant. Molly slipped back, grabbing at the air, and struck herself senseless on a beam of solid oak.
Later, coming to, she remembered having fallen. She could not remember getting up and climbing into her cot. She was shivering and soaked but safe beneath her blanket with the rope she had loosened re-secured around her body.
Had the storm begun to weaken? She was swaying less dramatically. Her skull ached dully and her thoughts wouldn’t stick, and looking around the room left her dizzy and depleted. There was Nicholas, however, safe within his cot again, motionless and quiet but observing her attentively.
“How?” Molly wondered, but she couldn’t form the word and went to sleep again, falling into fathomless relief.
* * *
“Mrs. Smith,” came a voice.
Someone shook her arm—Mr. Knacker at her side. He wore a cloth around his forehead, pink with rainy blood, and held a lantern up to see her.
“There you are. Up and at ’em.”
“Nicholas,” she murmured.
“Beg pardon?” Mr. Knacker asked.
She realized she had used her brother’s real name, but before she had a chance to remedy the slip, Nicholas himself answered from the corner. He was sitting on the trunk, leg crossed above his knee, more alert than she had seen him since they left Umber Harbor.
“Nicholas was her childhood friend,” he said to Mr. Knacker. “You were dreaming, my dear,” he told her with a smile.
“Jacob,” Molly said, straining at her rope.
Mr. Knacker freed the knot and helped her sit forward. Her vertigo returned and the cabin seemed to warp. Blood pounded in her temples and her stomach felt wrung, but after several slow breaths, the symptoms went away and Molly focused on her brother, comforted but dazed.
He looked like a boy freshly risen from a nap. His head was high. His eyes were warm. His face was calm and supple. Only now did Molly recognize the quiet of the cabin. Gone were the shrieking winds and urgent hollers of the crew. The ship, still ascending and descending with the waves, had a trustworthy rhythm and a balance in its rolls.
“The storm…,” she began.
“Did its worst,” said Mr. Knacker. “We were beat to pulp and splinters but the captain fought us through.”
“Your head,” she said.
“’Twas nothing but free-swinging tackle.” With the rag around the wound and his eyes so askew, he seemed to be a man long familiar with concussions. “Quite a few of us was battered, though. Mr. Darn has a bone jutting from his thigh, Mr. Shivers got his foot crushed flatter than a sheet, and poor McGiverns slipped off the mainmast and landed on his noggin. He’s been knocked out solid with a dent ever since.”
“How awful!” Molly said. Only yesterday McGiverns had provided her with rope and he had smiled at her and told her not to worry, not a jot.
“What’s more,” said Mr. Knacker, lowering the lantern, “Mr. Fen has disappeared.”
Molly gasped and looked at Nicholas. The lantern swung light over his face and made him younger, swung away and left him shadowy and old, unfamiliar.
“We’ve searched from top to bottom, stem to stern,” said Mr. Knacker. “He must have ventured up and fallen overboard. The captain’s all a fury, raging to and fro. The two of you was right to stay in your cots.” He slumped and shook his head, bulging out his eyes. “What on earth possessed him? God be with him in the deep.”
He pondered so long, Molly worried that he was addled, that the tackle had perhaps hurt him more than he believed. She refused to let him leave until he showed Nicholas his head.
“My husband studied medicine, enough to be a doctor.”
Nicholas examined him. The lump was not severe. Molly tore a strip from the bottom of her blanket to replace the sodden bandage. Mr. Knacker grew teary—from the pain or Molly’s care?—and didn’t go until he had thanked her twice and sung her praise to Nicholas, declaring her a wife to make any husband proud.
“I see that you have made your usual impression,” Nicholas said when he was gone.
“But what of Mr. Fen?”
Molly stood and crossed the room, closing up her cloak against the cold northern air.
“Perhaps he felt shame,” Nicholas suggested. “Shame for what he was and fear of being caught. It’s possible he threw himself over in despair.”
“No,” Molly said. She could almost see her breath. “He wasn’t afraid. He was smiling when I saw him.”
“When?” Nicholas asked.
“Just before the storm. He was smiling in his hammock as if he knew something wicked. I was scared he might have smothered you. What else could he have done?”
Nicholas considered this, at first as if to humor her but crystallizing, slowly, like a window growing ice. He stood abruptly. Molly’s heart jumped backward in her chest. He turned toward the trunk, opened the lid, and dumped it out, and then he sifted through the extra clothes, shaking every article.
“The money bag,” he said, and hurried out the door.
Molly followed up the passageway to Mr. Fen’s cabin, where he ransacked the travel chest and blankets in the hammock. He examined every corner, every nook and board until he finally slumped down, grimly stunned, against the wall.
“He took it,” Molly said. “Everything we had!”
“To the bottom of the sea,” Nicholas replied.
“Maybe he’s alive and hiding in the hold.”
Her brother shook his head with dreadful resignation, losing his complexion like a man spilling blood. Molly clutched the hammock for support and almost fell.
“Nicholas,” she said. “Oh, Nicholas, what have you done?”
The ship carried on, pitching forward down a wave. In the air, she could feel their destination fast approaching—the sting of autumn, even winter, in a land full of strangers.
“Nicholas,” she said, but he was distant. He was gone.