If there’s a clean body of water around, I want to be naked in it. Unfortunately, growing up in Northern Ohio, the term “clean” had to be taken with a grain of rust.
Nevertheless, Lakeshore Park was a regular summer destination. Lake Erie wasn’t as bad in the 90s as it had been when its tributaries caught fire thirty years prior. In fact, the water seemed incapable of conducting chemical fires at all anymore.
The summer of ‘99 was also the summer I came swinging out of the closet. I had graduated out of my dreadfully conservative high school and immediately made my way to the big city. The Big City, in this case, being Cleveland. I joined the LGBT Center and started going to their weekly teenage meet-up groups. The group was mostly boys in ill-fitting pleather pants and a few girls weighed down with rainbow jewelry. But being a queer kid among others for the first time, it all felt like magic.
One auspicious evening we drove to meet some other queer kids at the park: two girls and one boy. Both girls caught my eye. One was a small white girl with short blond hair, a little rough around the edges, and with the same rural Ohio accent shared by all my cousins. She had a butch, working class scrappiness that was both familiar and hot. She introduced herself as Jo and her friend as Tania.
Tania was a tall, athletic black girl. Her head was shaved, her lips were pillowy, and her skin was dark. I blushed in the face of her beauty. Tania barely spoke, but when she smiled at me, I fell hard.
When our two groups came together, we engaged in the familiar but awkward moment of claiming our crushes. This ritual happened with silent glances, smiles, and subtle attempts to stand near each other. Tania and I claimed each other. Jo also claimed me, but soon realized that I only had eyes for Tania.
The sun was beginning to set over the lake when Jo suggested we go swimming. Some of us tittered the usual “We don’t have swimsuits” line. Jo walked to the rocky shore and stripped off her t-shirt and Dickies, revealing a sports bra and boxer briefs. “This works, don’t it?” she shouted.
Tania and I shared a glance. I wondered if I was ready to show my nearly-naked body to my new crush before I’d even kissed her. She smiled and shrugged. Then she stripped.
I would like to think I was charmed brazen, but only barely. Enough to follow, if not to strip completely. I unsnapped my cowboy shirt and dropped my denim shorts to my ankles. I waded across the rocks and into the water in my bra and panties.
One of the boys, Daryl, followed after me; he was getting a perm next week, he said, so he may as well enjoy the water while he could.
The four of us clumped and giggled, waving at our friends on the shore. Tania spied a group of people past the rocks, wading off the sandy beach.
“Wanna make friends?” she asked me, her grin an impossibly-alluring combination of shy and crafty.
Swimming was always where I felt free. I was disarmed. I followed her. Tania did the backstroke, her wide smile pointed skyward. Jo followed. Daryl stayed back. “Uh, guys…?” he said, before his voice faded into our raucous splashing.
I didn’t look at the people in the distance, too transfixed with Tania’s strong shoulders as she swam. I was one stroke behind her, my fingertips almost reaching her ankle. I timed it so that I would almost touch her with each stroke.
She paused ahead of us to tread water and watch. Jo and I followed suit. The people stood in a semicircle in the water, twenty yards from us, everyone wearing matching t-shirts. I watched, unsure of what was happening.
Jo’s eyebrows jumped with the realization. “Baptists!” she hissed.
“What?” I asked.
“Shit!” Tania said. She fled, swimming away as if she spied a shark fin.
Halfway back to our friends on the rocks, we started laughing. Then leaping. Then splashing.
“Baptists!” we shouted. “Three naked dykes just crashed a baptism!”
Our friends on the shore laughed and looked at the semicircle of people now paused in mid-dunk, staring at our weird hair and naked splashing bodies.
Tania and I made a date for the following week. Tania’s school friends, a lesbian couple who had been together since freshman year, picked us up in an Astro van with burgundy velour interior. Though they were only seventeen, their relationship seemed cozy and sweet. They seemed decades older when they glanced at us with knowing eyes and jabbed each other in the ribs as Tania grasped my hand. On the way to the movie theater, on the bench seat in the back of the van, Tania and I kissed. Her lips were beyond anything I’d ever felt before, so full and soft. Her lips were like a velvet overstuffed sofa. I wanted to curl up on them and nap. I didn’t know that this was what kissing girls could be like. I wanted to kiss her for the rest of the night, just to make up for lost time.
We went to the CedarLee cinema to see But I’m a Cheerleader. The boy working the register chided us for missing the first ten minutes, which he said was the best part. We made out the whole time anyway.
After the movie we went to Subway for dinner. We were the only customers. Tania cuddled against me, but I scooted away with a furtive glance to the door. I think I was afraid of being bashed or—more likely for lesbians—harassed and followed.
But the woman behind the counter—a black, middle aged woman in a green visor and apron—smiled sweetly at us. She stole glances over the sneeze guard as Tania curled into my shoulder and leaned up for a kiss. The only bashers were in my own head.
At college I showed all my dorm mates
pictures of
Tania, and they cooed. I swelled with pride at the beauty
of the woman who let me hold her, as
though by merely choosing me, she had assigned me a greater
worth.
Tania visited me my sophomore year and we had sex for the first time, our leggy bodies awkwardly navigating my single bed.
When I put my finger inside her, I was shocked at how hot—temperature-wise—she was. It was like putting my finger inside a freshly baked peach. Though I obviously knew what a vulva—my vulva—felt like, experiencing a different person’s body, with its unique odor, taste, and feel, made sex a terrifying, thrilling experience.
Tania liked listening to music as she fell asleep, so she put on The Marshall Mathers LP. She drifted off easily as I listened, horrified, to “Stan,” the popular track about a stalker who murders his girlfriend. Neat. I couldn’t sleep for hours, the quiet flow of lyrics teasing my consciousness awake over and over again.
It was my first small sign that this relationship was doomed.
Our romance continued on and off for another year after that. She would visit me at college and I would visit her over the summers.
The last time she visited, she seemed different. Her shyness led to insecurity. Her outward beauty was invisible to her.
She often mentioned how smart I was and how pretty, always with a pitiable tone in her voice. She stayed silent around my college friends, later telling me that she was stupid and had nothing to add to the conversation. I tried to bolster her confidence, to tell her I thought she was sharp and smart and—jesus, she could go to any college she wanted. She was the one in the private girl’s school, with the athletic departments lining up to claim her as their own. She was the one who made my heart stop whenever she smiled.
When I told her how gorgeous she was, she wouldn’t blush and bat it away like she used to. Instead, she cast her eyes downward and shook her head, as though I was foolishly placating her.
One night during one of Tania’s visits, some friends gathered in a circle to smoke weed before heading out to campus parties. The marijuana, which Tania smoked copiously, only led her further into her own head.
“I don’t want to go out,” she said. “Stay in bed. We’ll blaze and watch dumb movies.”
I tried bargaining with her, but she didn’t want to go out, meet anyone, feel ashamed of herself. I left her at my house alone and returned at 3 a.m. to find her watching whatever was on network TV at that hour.
Purple smoke billowed from the TV room. “It’s 4:20 somewhere,” she said. Her sullenness cut the last thread that held me to her.
I went to bed and she joined me later. We slept without touching. The next day she went back to Cleveland, and that was it.
A few months later, she sent me a letter—neat all-capital ballpoint pen on pink stationary. It was a letter I only understood years later when I found it again. She said she liked me and just wanted to kick it every once in a while. She didn’t want to put any yokes on me.
The problem was—and still is—I didn’t do attraction half-way. I’m either all-in or not interested. And the surest way to douse whatever flame I have is to deny that you’re worth it.
I believed Tania when she said she liked me and wanted to keep things casual but fun. I also believed her when she said she wasn’t beautiful, or smart, or worthy of my affections. Or at least I believed that she believed it, and that was enough for me.