BRODICK COULDN’T BELIEVE HE WAS THE VOICE OF REASON. He was usually the hot-tempered one. But not today.

Today his duty was clear: to keep Colm from doing anything reckless, and that was no easy task. It had taken a great deal of talking for Brodick to convince him not to storm into the abbey and tear it apart room by room in order to find out what had happened to his brother.

Colm had been resistant, but managed to control his anger on the ride to the abbey. Then he saw Liam leaning against the abbey gate, and he began to burn with fury.

“Good God,” Brodick whispered when he saw Liam. He took a breath, remembered he had to be the rational one, and added, “He’s alive.”

Colm didn’t respond. He could only watch Liam’s faltering attempts to walk for one agonizing minute before he swung down from his mount and headed to fetch him. With one blow to his jaw, Liam teetered and collapsed across his brother’s waiting shoulder.

Once Colm had situated his brother on the back of a horse, he motioned for two riders to flank his sides and sent them ahead.

“Someone knows what happened to my brother, Brodick. Whoever brought him to the abbey had to have witnessed something. There’s no way in hell that Liam got up and walked away from that field. He had to be carried. Look at him, Brodick.” The MacHugh nodded to the abbey and added, “Liam didn’t get there on his own. He had help.”

“He could have been left at the gate.”

“Or he could have been taken inside. If someone in the abbey knows what happened, I’ll find him, and I’ll make him tell me what he knows, no matter how much force I have to use.”

Brodick motioned to the tents set up outside the walls. “With all of these people around, you need to use your head. You can’t just force your way inside the abbey. It’s sacred, for God’s sake. You can’t even carry your sword or any other weapon with you when you walk through those gates.”

Colm didn’t appreciate being told what he could and could not do. He glanced at Brodick. “Since when do you pay attention to rules? Marriage has made you weak.”

“My wife would not be married to a weak man.”

Colm swung up on his horse, grabbed the reins, and started back up the hill.

“Perhaps she’s turned you into a weakling because she’s weak. Most women are.”

The insult amused Brodick. “You have met my wife, haven’t you?”

Colm shrugged. “Aye, we’ve met.” There was a hint of a smile in his voice when he added, “She’s a strong woman. A rarity, that.”

“That’s right, she is strong, and trying to antagonize me won’t work. I’m not going to help you wage war on a group of old men.”

“I have no intention of waging war on the priests. I’m simply going to find out what happened.”

“Before you do anything, perhaps you should talk to your brother.”

“That’s where I’m headed.”

“You probably shouldn’t have hit him so hard. How long do you think it will take him to wake up?”

“Some water on his face will bring him around.”

As the column of riders slowly made their way down the other side of the hill, Colm said, “Did you see what was done to him?”

“I saw,” Brodick answered quietly.

It would be a long time before Colm would be able to let go of the memory of his brother trying to walk toward him. It appeared that almost every inch of skin on his brother’s back and legs had been torn or ripped off of him.

No, he would not soon forget that godawful sight.

“Your men should take Liam to Kevin Drummond’s cottage. His wife has a way with healing.”

“Nay, they’re taking him home. He’ll get the care he needs there. I want you to understand, after I’ve questioned him, I’m going into the abbey.”

“I know,” he replied. “I’m going with you.”

“No, you’re not. I’m already in your debt. Those bastards would have buried Liam if you and your men hadn’t shown up when you did. I never would have gotten to him in time.”

“The dead one near the hole with the arrow in his chest…that wasn’t done by one of ours,” Brodick reminded him.

“I still owe you a tremendous debt.”

Brodick smiled. “Aye, you do.”

They caught up with the others. Dylan, Brodick’s first in command, trailed behind MacHugh’s soldiers. He heard Brodick’s shrill whistle and stopped the procession.

There were a dozen from the MacHugh clan and almost as many Buchanans surrounding Liam.

Since they were so close to Duncan’s Bluffs, they decided to let Liam rest for a few minutes before continuing on. Colm’s brother was still groggy from the blow he took to the jaw. He refused assistance as he dismounted and nearly fell to his knees. Everyone saw that the bottoms of his feet were caked with blood, but no one rushed forward to help him. They waited for him to straighten himself and follow Colm to the flat rocks overlooking the valley.

Liam tried not to wince with each slow and painful step. When he finally reached the bluff, he dropped to the ground and leaned his shoulder against a smooth rock.

Colm’s greeting to his brother was blunt. “Who did this to you?” He stepped in front of Liam and folded his arms across his chest as he waited for him to answer.

“If I knew who did this, I would have killed them by now,” Liam answered.

It was an empty boast, and both of them knew it. His brother wasn’t in any condition to kill anyone. His face was so gray, Colm thought he might pass out again. But Liam’s pride was at issue, and for that reason Colm went along with his arrogant claim.

“Aye, you would have,” he agreed. “Tell me what happened.”

“I don’t remember much,” he said. “I was leaving Monroe’s holding, heading for home across the flats, but I stayed to the east by the water. I know I was still on Monroe’s land. Yes, I’m sure I was. Something struck me on the side of my head, and I think maybe I was hit again in the back. The blows stunned me, and when I came to my senses, my hands and feet were bound. There was a hood over my head.”

He closed his eyes for a moment, trying to reclaim his memory. “There were at least four of them. I came to for a while, but I had to let them think I was still unconscious. I heard them talking before I passed out again. I’m certain there were four distinct voices…no, wait.” He sighed then, his frustration mounting. “There could have been more.”

He rubbed the back of his neck and closed his eyes again.

“Did any of them speak directly to you?” Braeden, Colm’s first in command, asked as he and some of the others circled.

“No, I don’t think so.” Liam’s voice grew hoarse and more difficult to understand with each answer he gave. “Why can’t I remember? It’s damned irritating.”

To Colm, it was obvious why Liam’s memory was so spotty. He’d taken several blows to the head.

“You said you heard them talking. What were they saying?” Brodick asked.

“That they hoped to kill as many MacHughs as they could.”

“If there were only four or so captors, how could they possibly kill seasoned MacHugh warriors?” Brodick asked.

Braeden handed Liam his leather water pouch. Liam took a long drink, nodded his appreciation to the commander, and then answered. “There were men hiding in the woods, waiting to attack. They’d been told to get as many MacHughs as they could. The more they killed, the higher the reward.”

He took another swallow before continuing. “Another one of them worried that there really weren’t troops waiting in the woods to help them, and they would be all alone to face Colm’s wrath. He wanted to kill me and be done with it, but the one in charge kept telling him they had to wait.”

“Wait for what?” Colm asked.

“I don’t know.”

“Did you hear any of their names?” Brodick asked.

“If I did, I don’t remember.”

Colm continued to question his brother, hoping for some clue as to who was behind this atrocity, but Liam wasn’t much help.

“Do you remember being taken to the abbey?” he asked.

“No, but I remember waking up there. I was in a little room. Two priests were with me. One was a healer, and the other wore his stole and prayed over me. I think he thought I was dying.”

“Who were these priests?” Braeden asked.

“Father Franklin was the healer. I asked him how I’d gotten there, and he said he didn’t know.”

“Did you believe him?” Colm asked.

“Yes, I did, after he explained. He told me that Father Gelroy came to him and asked him for his help. Gelroy was the priest praying over me,” he added.

“And Father Franklin wasn’t curious to know how you’d gotten there?” Brodick asked.

“Aye, he was curious. He asked me how I’d been injured, and I told him I couldn’t remember. I heard him ask Gelroy the same question, and Gelroy told him it was best if he didn’t know the details.”

“What about this priest Gelroy? What did he tell you?”

“He said he was outside unloading a wagon of grain when he happened to look up, and there I was.”

“There you were? That’s it? No one was with you?” Colm asked.

“I asked Gelroy that very question, and he couldn’t give me an exact answer. When I asked him to explain what he meant, he said that he couldn’t say yes and he couldn’t say no.”

“He speaks in riddles,” Colm snapped.

Liam tried to stand. Bracing his hand against the rock, he made it to his knees before falling back. Cursing his weakness, he rested another moment before trying again.

“This priest Gelroy will not speak in riddles to me,” Colm said. “He will tell me what I wish to know.”

“Colm, you need to understand. Gelroy sought to protect me. He was concerned that whoever had injured me might come inside the abbey—”

“To kill you.” Brodick nodded as he finished Liam’s thought.

“Yes,” he said. “Gelroy believed that the demons, as he called the men who attacked me, would not respect sanctuary. He and Franklin agreed to keep my presence secret as a safety measure until you arrived, Colm, but there was a problem. The two of them could not stand guard over me day and night without raising suspicion, and neither would be very effective against an intruder.”

“And how was this problem solved?” Colm asked.

“Gelroy enlisted the help of a few good men he knew to protect me while I slept. He explained to me that he wanted men who understood the ways of fighting.”

“Priests would have no such training,” Braeden interjected.

“No, they wouldn’t,” Colm agreed.

He stopped pacing in front of his brother. “Who did this priest find to watch over you?”

“He asked soldiers who were there for Laird Monroe’s wedding.”

“What clan were these men from?” Brodick asked.

Before Liam could answer, Colm asked, “Were these men Highlanders?”

“No, they were not, but Gelroy trusted them completely.”

“Then they had to be Highlanders,” Brodick reasoned.

All of the warriors listening to the conversation immediately nodded their agreement. Only Highlanders were to be trusted, and even then with caution.

“I’m telling you they were not Highlanders. I don’t know where they came from, but Gelroy must have known them well to trust them.”

Colm knew he had to hurry with his questions, for he wanted to get as much information as he could from his weary brother before exhaustion caught up with him. Liam was already drowsy. He could barely keep his eyes open, and he was having trouble concentrating.

“How many were there?” he asked.

“How many what?” Liam asked wearily.

Colm held his patience. “Soldiers, Liam. How many soldiers watched over you?”

“Four. There were always two either inside the room with me or just outside my door.”

Brodick glanced at Colm when he asked, “And these men carried weapons?”

Liam actually smiled. “No, they did not.”

“The question amuses you?” Brodick asked, trying to understand Liam’s reaction.

“Aye, it does. When you see these men, you will understand why. But I will assure you of this, Laird Buchanan. They do not need weapons.”

“They are invincible? Is that what you suggest?” Braeden asked as though the notion of such praise of an outsider’s strength should be taken as a personal affront to his own might.

“No man is invincible,” Colm snapped. “What did these soldiers tell you, Liam? Did they explain how you came to the abbey?”

“No. They talked to one another, but they wouldn’t talk to me.”

Both Colm and Brodick waited for Liam to explain further. When he didn’t, Brodick asked, “Why wouldn’t they talk to you?”

“I don’t think they understood me,” he said finally. “And I certainly didn’t understand them. They spoke a language I’ve never heard before.”

Colm was becoming even more frustrated. “Gelroy must have understood them.”

“I’m not sure he did. I never heard him speak to them.”

“Then how did he—” Colm stopped. It was pointless to continue questioning his brother. Liam needed rest, and Colm hoped that when his brother grew stronger, he would be able to remember more about the men who had taken him captive.

Besides, he reasoned, Gelroy would tell him what he wanted to know.

He removed his sword and sheath and handed both to Braeden. “Take Liam home,” he ordered.

He went to his horse to get his bow and arrows and gave those to Braeden as well. “And send the Buchanans home.” With a glance at Brodick, he added, “All the Buchanans.”

Before Colm could argue, Brodick swung up onto his mount and said, “I am going back to the abbey with you.”

Braeden nodded. “Do you want any of us to go inside the abbey with you?”

“I do not.” Colm’s voice was unyielding.

Braeden was used to his laird’s gruff ways. “Then may I suggest that half of our men take Liam home, and I and the others will wait outside the gates with your weapons, Laird.”

Brodick’s commander stepped forward to stand beside Braeden. “And since my Laird Buchanan is going with you, I suggest that I also wait with our laird’s weapons outside the gates. The other Buchanan soldiers will see Liam safely home.”

Brodick agreed. “It would be to our advantage to take our swords should we have the good fortune to run into the men who tortured your brother.”

“I prefer to use my hands,” Colm said.

“Even if others have swords?”

Colm gave him a hard look. “What do you think?”

Brodick shook his head. “I think you’re just itching to kill someone, aren’t you?”

“I am going to kill whoever did this to my brother,” Colm answered.

This wasn’t a hope or a promise. It was a solemn vow.