The Beginning—the day before
My mother’s funeral is a small, sad affair, held on a sunny early summer’s day that somehow makes its lack of fanfare feel even worse. Nature is having a party, but nobody else is celebrating.
The crematorium is picturesque, its tree-lined routes shaded by pink and white cherry blossoms, the blooms so heavy and full with life that they droop and spill onto the pathways. The petals flutter and dance in the breeze, settling on the hearse as I follow in the solitary funeral car, vibrant against the somber black as I drive alone toward our destination.
I look through the car window and see life and energy and rebirth; I hear the sound of birdsong and the low-level hum of insects. I feel the soothing warmth of the sun on my skin through the glass, and I close my eyes and try to stop myself enjoying it. It seems disrespectful to enjoy anything on a day like this.
There are only five of us at the funeral, and that includes the vicar. Or the celebrant, whatever the official name is for the middle-aged lady who stands at the front, attempting to string together a coherent tribute to a woman she’s never met. Who had a life that feels too small, too narrow, to fill a whole five minutes’ worth of platitudes. She was my mum, and I loved her—but there isn’t much to say.
We all sit there, dappled by stained-glass light, in one small row. The sum total of my mother’s world: me, my aunt Rosemary and uncle Simon, and my cousin, Michael. My mother hadn’t planned this funeral—she wasn’t one of those people who made special requests about how the end of her life should be marked.
Of course, she might have done, if she hadn’t been incapacitated by a series of strokes four years earlier. After that, she was barely capable of eating a jelly on her own, never mind articulating her last wishes.
The service is blessedly short; the awkwardness over quickly. I’m struck again by the confines of my mother’s life, the controlled environment in which she failed to thrive. A stage lit entirely in shades of beige. I wish there’d been more joy, more abandon, more rule-breaking.
I cast glances at Rosemary, my mother’s sister, who sits upright and rigid throughout. If she feels any emotion at all, she doesn’t show it—not even a sniffle into a clenched tissue, or a hand held in her husband’s. Nothing to mark the fact that my mother, whom she grew up with, must have played with and laughed with during simpler times, is gone. I struggle to imagine them as children together, carefree and adventurous.
I always wanted a sister, always dreamed it would be joyous. Someone to share my triumphs and sorrows, and help me through days like this. But perhaps, I think, looking at my aunt, it wouldn’t be like that at all.
She is the very epitome of a stiff upper lip, and it’s infectious. It sets the tone, and informs the way we all behave, as we say our goodbyes to a woman who was a wife, a mother, presumably at some point a lover, an angst-ridden teenager, a little girl with gaps in her teeth. She must have had hopes and dreams and wild moments and passions and regrets—at least I hope so.
I don’t remember her being anything other than Mum—and Rosemary isn’t the type to share stories. Perhaps it’s too painful for her. Perhaps I am doing her a disservice, and beneath her calm, cold exterior is a deep well of pain, barely held together.
My pain is there too, my very own barely-held-together hell. I’ve looked after my mum for years; my life has been dominated by her routines and rituals and needs. By understanding that although her body was broken and her ability to communicate was compromised, she was still there, still inside, still my mum.
I’d be lying if I said there weren’t moments where I dreamed of freedom, of being liberated from the scheduling and the carers and the hospital appointments and the constant awareness that I could never risk a spontaneous moment of my own.
Now, of course, I have that freedom, and it’s an unwanted gift that I’d quite like to return, unopened. Right now, the gift of freedom feels overrated, especially when it comes wrapped in guilt and tied with a big shiny bow made of grief.
My mother was not young. My mother was not well. My mother was suffering. My mother, as everyone involved in her care has either implied or said out loud since her death, had probably yearned to be at peace.
Whether their view is that she’s sitting on a cloud in Heaven surrounded by celestial angels and reunited with all her loved ones (her care assistant, Elaine), or that she’s at least out of pain (our GP), or that she lives on in the Spirit Otherworld (the lady who works at the pharmacy who wears crystal pendants), the agreed wisdom—reduced to a few harsh words—is that she’s better off dead.
Maybe they’re right, who knows? None of us do, but it all adds to the whirlpool inside my head. I feel guilty that I ever wished for freedom. I feel guilty that I want her to still be alive even though she was suffering. I feel relieved that she’s gone, for her and for me, and then I feel guilty that I feel relieved. I basically feel too much, all the time, and with absolutely no consistency. I’m trapped on a deeply unpleasant roller coaster.
I keep all of this hidden, of course, for the time being. Wouldn’t want to let the team down, or give Aunt Rosemary a heart attack. It’s safely tucked away—damped down, coiled inside me, angry and eager to break free.
I won’t show my weakness in front of people. Not the vicar, or the ushers, or the funeral director, or what’s left of my family. My mother would have been mortified at the public display of emotion. She saved her tears for characters in soap operas, weeping along with their lost loves and failed marriages and lothario love rats. In the real world, until she was ill, she was always precise, tidy, and controlled.
That’s how she would have wanted this thing to be done, I think. This funeral, this farewell. With minimum fuss, no weeping and wailing and beating of chests. Quiet and dignified and quick. Like her, this also needs to be precise, tidy, and controlled.
So I hold it all in, and barely hear the words, and train my eyes to skim over the coffin that looms so large in front of us. I can’t look at that box and stay controlled, because that box contains my mother. That box proves she is really gone.
When it’s finally done, the coffin slides along its tracks and behind the magic curtain. It’s all extremely strange and surreal, like this is happening to somebody else entirely, and I am witnessing it from outside my own body.
We leave the room and stand outside together in the shade of the Victorian Gothic building, hands shielding our eyes from the rude intrusion of sunlight that contorts around corners and pierces through gaps in the guttering. We form a small, awkward huddle of social niceties all dressed in black.
As we exit, the next party arrives on the conveyor belt of death—this one is huge, a convoy of shining cars; noisy, wet crying; massive floral arrangements that spell out the word “Granddad” in carnations and lilies. The sound of Frank Sinatra singing “My Way” floats in the air as the tear-stained family make their way inside. There will be a “do” afterward, I’m sure—pork pies and Scotch eggs and a lot of drinking and crying and possibly a fight. They’ll do it their way.
Their way, of course, is not our way, and Rosemary looks at it all with distaste, as though expressing grief is unforgivably common and lower class. She flicks a stray blossom petal from the shoulder of her black jacket, and says nothing.
There is no wake for us, no reception. No tearful karaoke at a pub, where we all share war stories and precious memories and mournful laughter. We simply prepare to go our separate ways.
“At least she’s not suffering anymore,” Rosemary says.
“It’s a blessing, really,” adds Simon.
“You’re right, of course. Thank you for coming,” I reply, because that is what is expected of me. Because for the sake of my mother’s memory, I will remain precise, tidy, and controlled, at least for a few minutes more.
My aunt and uncle politely hug me, as this too is expected—it is clearly in the Bereaved Family Book of Acceptable Etiquette. It is a brief hug, keeping all physical contact to the required minimum, offered and received with an equal lack of enthusiasm. I watch them walk away to Simon’s Jag, awash with relief.
Michael stays with me. If I am being kind, I will assume this is to offer his support in my time of need. If I am not being kind, I will think it is because he will do literally anything to avoid spending more time than is absolutely necessary with his parents. There is, now that I come to think of it, no reason that it can’t be both.
We have all come to the funeral separately—me in the funeral car, Michael in his Fiat 500, his parents in their Jag—and you don’t need to be Freud to analyze that. We couldn’t be any more obviously broken, even if we wore T-shirts with the words “Dysfunctional Family” emblazoned on them.
Now, the big black cars are gone, along with the undertakers, away to cause simmering road rage elsewhere. After a brief discussion with my cousin, he offers to give me a lift home and I gratefully accept. I’m not in the mood to make casual conversation with a taxi driver. He crams his awkwardly tall frame into his tiny Fiat, and I sit next to him, thinking he looks like a giant behind the wheel of a Lilliputian car.
We’re quiet as we drive, both still infected by our family’s entrenched belief that silence is the only dignified way of communicating. You can’t cause a scene if you’re silent, or say anything embarrassing if you say nothing at all. He puts on some music, and we both smile guiltily as Katy Perry roars. It feels jarring, out of place, funny. Rosemary would hate it, which makes it even more of a naughty pleasure.
Together, me and Michael and Katy, we come home, back here, to the place where I grew up.
It’s a handsome house: detached and Edwardian, built in mellow, pale stone. It’s double-fronted with large windows and five big bedrooms. It is a house built for more people than it ever held during our time here; for more living than it ever experienced during our custodianship. For more noise than we ever made.
It sits in a quiet part of what was once a village, but after the arrival of a large estate in the 1950s expanded into being a small town, almost against its will.
The older village buildings are pretty and timbered, with a touristy black-and-white-painted pub and a quaint village hall and a higgledy-piggledy row of old cottages that are now sweet shops and craft centers.
The newer part—the part that developed after the estate—has a Wetherspoons and an Aldi and some truly ugly concrete blocks that contain betting shops and places that sell vaping equipment and unlock mobile phones. Pretty much Sodom and Gomorrah as far as my family was concerned.
Our house is firmly enclosed within the posher side of town, on a tree-lined street, near a duck pond and the post office and the primary school where I work.
Now, after I unlock the big wooden door and walk inside, I am standing in the cool air of an old building on a hot day. Around me, I see the splinters of my mother’s existence, burrowed beneath the skin of the house. I see the walker she rarely used; the recliner chair she practically lived in; the side table laden with pills and potions and her blood pressure monitor, wires curled like a slumbering snake.
I see the days and months and years and decades, embedded in the walls, in layers of wallpaper, in outdated lamps that were popular in the 1980s, in the swoosh of heavy brocade curtains that kept the glare from the TV screen as she sat and stared at the soaps she always claimed to hate while my dad was still alive.
He despised them with every ounce of his being—watching the trials and tribulations of common people with common accents was never going to appeal to him.
After he died, I thought maybe my mother would break free. That she might emerge from the confines of her oh-so-proper life and start going to raves and eating Pot Noodles in the nude or join an a capella choir.
In reality, all she did was start watching EastEnders and Coronation Street. Maybe that was rebellion enough for her. Maybe that was all she had left inside her by then.
Michael shakes his head and looks spooked. His expression resembles that of Shaggy from Scooby-Doo when they first enter a haunted mansion.
He’s been here countless times before, of course—but it does feel different now, without her. It feels old-fashioned, locked in time, as though everything simply stopped all at once. It even feels alien to me, with its musty smells and faded carpets and the echoes of ticking clocks that somehow sound judgmental, even though I’ve lived here for most of my life.
Michael disappears off into the kitchen, carrying the bag he brought with him to the funeral, hidden in his car, while I examine the remnants of a life interrupted and wonder what I’m going to do with the leftovers.
I should hire one of those house-clearing firms, I think, or put everything in a dumpster, or have a yard sale. That would scandalize the entire neighborhood: going cheap, at a bargain price, secondhand commode—one careful lady owner.
Or maybe, it occurs to me, pulling the heavy curtains back and letting the sunlight stream through, I should keep it all as it is. Then I’m completely set up for my own decline, in a few decades’ time. The recliner chair and the collection of remote controls that don’t even work but never got thrown away will be mine, all mine. My destiny awaits.
I hear clinking in the background, and then Michael emerges. He is holding aloft two tall glasses, and smiling like he’s just made a deal with the devil at an especially fertile crossroads. The glasses are full of fizzing liquid, and he’s added little brightly colored swizzle sticks decorated with cardboard flamingos. They look like the kind of drinks they’d serve in a cocktail bar in Miami.
“Pink gin!” he announces triumphantly. I raise one eyebrow, and he adds: “It’s what she would have wanted . . .”
“Really?” I ask, taking the glass from him and sniffing it suspiciously. “My very proper, teetotal mother, who thought using tea bags was a sign of a slovenly moral character, would have wanted us to drink pink gin on the day of her funeral? With added flamingos?”
“Maybe not,” he responds. “I’m sure she’d have thought that the flamingos were an especially vulgar touch. But, Jess, sweetheart, let’s face facts here—I hate to put it so bluntly, but she’s dead. You’re still alive. And you look like you need a gin, darling.”
Michael tugs his black tie loose, and undoes the top buttons of his shirt, and kicks off his smart shoes to reveal socks that have the day of the week embroidered on them. His left foot says “Wednesday,” his right foot says “Saturday,” and it’s actually a Tuesday. He’ll have done that deliberately to feel outrageous—it doesn’t take a lot in our family.
He’s only twenty-one, Michael—just about young enough to be my son, if I was a “gymslip mum,” to use a phrase I heard a lot during my own teenage years. In fact I was a gymslip mum—but not to Michael. He was the belated product of the very respectable marriage of my aunt and uncle, who I always suspected only had sex that one time. And even then, it was in the dark, almost fully clothed, with a minimum of fuss.
Despite the age difference, we’re close, my cousin and I. Certainly closer than anyone else in our supremely strange family—we’re like two survivors clinging to each other on a life raft. Except there isn’t a life raft, and we’re frantically treading water to try to keep our heads above the suffocating waves.
Michael told me when he first had sex, and told me when he decided he didn’t like it, and told me when he decided that maybe it wasn’t the sex he didn’t like, but the fact that it was with a woman.
He told me when he got his first boyfriend, and when he first had his heart broken, and when he considered telling his parents that he was never going to get married—at least not to a “nice girl”—and give them the grandchildren they were expecting.
He never did quite manage that last one, at least not so far. It’s not as simple as his parents being anti-gay—they’re just anti-everything that isn’t exactly like them.
They go on holiday to hotels only populated by affluent English people, and their social lives revolve around a golf club so dazzlingly white in its ethnic makeup that it could blind you. These are not people who are flexible in their worldview. They’re not evil—they’re just so rigid it’s as though rigor mortis has set in while they’re technically still alive.
Michael is not a caricature flaming queen—not unless he’s doing it for entertainment value. He can pass as a “norm”—his word—when he chooses to. But there is part of me that can’t help thinking that on some level, Rosemary must know.
I suspect, though, that even if Rosemary does know, she has simply decided to ignore it and hope it goes away. That he’ll come to his senses. That it’ll be a passing phase, something silly and rebellious like joining the Labor Party or listening to R&B. She’s certainly not the sort to drag an issue as sordid as sexuality into the open and prod at it, that’s for sure.
I sink down onto the sofa, and decide I will drink the pink gin. I have nothing to lose but my sobriety, which is vastly overrated. I grimace when I discover that it’s mainly gin, then feel it burn pleasantly in my throat once the chill of the ice wears off. The flamingo stares at me with one giant eye as I sip.
Michael chooses to sit in my mother’s chair. The one with the remote controls lined up on the arm like soldiers. The one she lived her last few years in, getting half shuffled, half carried from this room into her bed across the hall. He presses the button that raises the footrest, and displays his mismatched socks.
“Is EastEnders on yet?” he asks, then cackles wickedly.
“Michael, you are a very insensitive creature. I’ve just been to my mother’s funeral. I might not be ready to laugh about it right now.”
“Ah, but I think you are,” he says sagely, pointing his flamingo in my direction and waving it. “I think you said goodbye to your mother years ago. I think you know that she’s barely been alive for a long time. That in fact she comes from a long line of women who have specialized in being barely alive, even when they don’t have strokes to use as an excuse. I’m sad to see Aunt Ruth go—but I’ll be even sadder if you don’t start living your own life again.”
I refuse to be bullied by a man waving a flamingo-shaped cocktail stick, but have to acknowledge that there is some wisdom in his casual insight, in what he says about my mother, and about me.
He might, annoyingly, have a point. And it might, also annoyingly, be a point that frightens me. Makes me admit that I am also standing at a crossroads, and am worried that the devil won’t even be interested in my soul. That I’m just too dull for him. I take the sensible option, and swallow the rest of the gin.
“I need to clear some of this stuff out,” I say, looking around me at the old-lady detritus and ugly pottery ornaments and health-care aids that are no longer aidful and were never caring.
“You do!” he says enthusiastically, leaning forward. “Let’s get hammered and wash the granny right out of this place—even if she wasn’t actually a granny, this house feels like she was!”
My breath catches in a choking gulp, and I feel a vein in my forehead throb, and a fluttering inside my rib cage. I haven’t felt those things for a while, but they’re like old friends you never want to see again. The harbingers of anxiety and panic, and the close relatives of my throat closing up and a suffocating sensation of there not being enough air in all the known universe to fill my starved lungs.
My mother was a granny—but not for long. Not long enough. Michael doesn’t understand what he’s said, the response he’s accidentally triggered. He knows I have a history—that I was the black sheep of this family way before he could even baa—but he wasn’t old enough to live it with me. And he isn’t old enough now to understand the way that grief can sneak up behind you, like someone trying to catch a glimpse of your PIN at a cash machine, and cosh you over the head.
He doesn’t understand—and I hope for his sake that it’s a long time until he does.
He jumps to his feet from my mother’s chair, and announces: “I shall return with more gin. And with many bin bags.”
I nod, and smile, and feel my right eye twitch in tension while I wait for him to leave. I take a slow, deep breath in through my nose, and out through my mouth. I go through the exercises I was taught long ago, in a place with dull green paint on the walls and alarms on the doors and gentle music on speakers that made you feel like you were trapped in a horror-film waltz.
A place filled with broken people, sitting in circles on plastic chairs, sharing their fears with a man who had studied pain for years but never truly understood it. One of the places my parents took me to when the real world simply disappeared—when I was sucked under, like a foal stepping into quicksand. One of the places they never spoke of again, erasing it beneath a code of silence that I willingly acceded to.
I still don’t know why we all had to pretend it didn’t happen. That I’d never been there. That the “problem with my nerves” was something we all jointly hallucinated and needed to bury under layers of half-truths and evasions. Perhaps it was to protect me. Perhaps it was because it offended their sense of order. My mother and father are gone now. I will simply never know. Even if they were both still here, they weren’t the type to answer questions. Such curiosity would be offensive to them.
I am holding one hand to my chest when Michael returns, as though I will be able to soothe the pounding beast inside.
“You OK?” he asks, head to one side, gin in each hand, and a roll of black bags tucked under his arm.
“Fine,” I lie, getting to my feet, taking the gin, gulping it down so fast that his eyes widen. “Where should we start?”
“With a visit to AA, if you’re going to keep drinking like that,” he replies.
“I’m not,” I say firmly. “That was medicinal. This isn’t easy. I’m not easy. My mother wasn’t easy. If you want to go, then go—I can do it on my own.”
I sound aggressive, and know this is unfair. Michael has done nothing wrong, other than coexist with me at a place and time when I am stretched, my control taut and vibrating so hard I can almost hear it hum like a tuning fork.
He stares at me, perhaps noticing the twitch in my eyelid, the paleness of my cheeks, the clenched fists that are crushing my fingernails into the flesh of my palms. Perhaps simply wondering if he needs to nip to the store and buy more alcohol.
“No chance, cousin dearest,” he replies, passing me a bin bag. “I’m in this for the cheap kicks. I want to see if there are any guilty secrets hidden around the place—you know, your mother’s dildo collection, your dad’s blond hooker wigs, their Fifty Shades playroom in the attic . . .”
He’s deliberately aiming to shock me. He feels uncertain, and this is how he rolls, my cousin Michael, when he feels uncertain. He knows he can get away with it when he’s with me—he can flounce and swear and pout to his heart’s content.
When he’s with his parents, he has to play the role of the well-behaved, perfectly conventional son, studying law and planning a life and a career that they approve of. When he’s away from them, all the outrageousness he’s bottled up comes pouring out, spilling over anyone who happens to be in the vicinity like an oil slick of eye-popping rudeness. I smile to show him that I’m still me—that it’s all OK.
“I cleared out the gimp masks and sequined nipple tassels already,” I say, clutching the plastic of the bin bag so tightly I feel my fingers plunge through. “The best you can hope for in the attic is some nudie shots of yours truly. Though I was only one at the time.”
Michael holds his roll of bin bags in the air as though he’s a composer directing a symphony orchestra, and announces: “To the attic, boys and girls!”