For the longest time, I thought Waverly was somehow better than me. Smart and strong and perfect—this superhuman creature I’d never be. Now I think that maybe she’s just different.
It never seemed weird before, running so long the skin peels off your feet, but that’s pretty grim when you actually think about it. Concerning. Like maybe I’m not the only one who doesn’t know where to put my feelings.
School is okay. I don’t go to see Trunch every day, but I go. It’s just nice—having a place where everything shuts up for a while. Better than the dugout in November, at least.
She doesn’t talk much, mostly sits and listens while I ramble at my shoes. The best times are when she has a lot of paperwork, because then she just lets me hang out in the corner and I don’t have to talk either.
On Friday, I sit with my chair tipped back and my feet on the radiator. “My brother’s coming over for dinner.”
“Are you looking forward to that?”
I don’t know what to say.
All semester, all I wanted was for him to share this. Now that he’s finally going to, I want to start smashing things. No one talks about the way he’s spent the last four months pretending our parents don’t exist. They just keep going through the motions and fucking each other up and acting like it doesn’t matter. Justin has never once tried to be part of it, and now suddenly he gets to just show up and everyone acts so grateful, like he’s the good son?
When I tried to talk to Annie about it, she just shrugged. “It’s dinner. It’s not a big deal.”
“So that means we have to just act like everything’s so great and perfect? Oh, wait, I remember—whenever things get stupid around here, you get to leave!”
We were in the kitchen. I was getting myself breakfast while she put away the dishes, and she slammed the cupboard so hard the glasses rattled. “Leave? Do you think, if things were different, that I wouldn’t be halfway across the fucking continent right now? But this is the situation, Marshall. This is it. We might as well get used to it.”
Then she went back to sorting forks and I stared into the cupboard, trying to decide between shredded wheat and cornflakes like there was even an answer.
No matter how hard I try, I can’t figure out how to make myself be like her. She rolls her eyes or tells them all to knock it off, then goes on with her life like nothing happened. And I don’t want to be like Justin, hard and disgusted and over it. All I want is for things to actually get better.
Trunch always says the same thing. Your family is your family, but they’re not your responsibility.
That’s easier to agree with than it is to believe, though.
By the time I get outside, it’s starting to drizzle. Ollie’s waiting for me by the bus stop, smoking and staring at the sky. “I was starting to think maybe you ditched me,” he says, stubbing out the cigarette and dropping it in his shirt pocket.
He hasn’t mentioned it, but since I started quitting he tries not to do it in front of me, like he doesn’t want to make it any harder.
I shove my hands in my coat. Autumn’s party flyer is still there, crumpled up with the shocking-green peer counselor form from Trunch’s office.
The sky is so low and wet it’s almost on top of us. Ollie trudges along next to me with his coat collar up and his head down. We’re almost across the parking lot when I stop.
“What?” he says, squinting at me through the misty drizzle.
I don’t say anything, just offer him the form.
He looks at me like I’ve just handed him a loaded gun or a hedgehog. Like I have lost my mind. “What the fuck is this?”
The form is crumpled and kind of linty, and maybe I don’t know how to be like Justin, but I know how to actually look at people. I know my best friend, even if the person he is isn’t the one he wants to be.
No matter what, Ollie’s always just been there for me, as much as I would let him. He cares so much about what’s fair and right. He thinks the feelings of little freshman girls are maybe actually important, and if Maribeth fucking Whitman can do it, then the office ladies should be falling all over themselves for someone like him.
“Just read it,” I say, and leave out the part about him being basically the best person I have ever met.
He’s watching me. Not the usual bored stare, but very careful, like I might be making fun of him. “Are you serious right now? You are not serious.”
I shrug and throw my arm over his shoulders, lean into him, pull him close. “It’s who you are anyway. They just made a job for it.”
For Justin’s stupid special dinner, my mom makes fried chicken because it’s his favorite. The scene in the kitchen is bad. All the raw, oozing joints and the shaking, browning, spattering.
She talks to herself the whole time, reading recipes aloud, hoping that the roads are good, that they won’t ice over. Outside, it’s raining.
It’s familiar and awful eating with Justin. He takes over the table like he never left, all elbows and arms, and everyone else just acts so bright and happy, like he never spent the last four months avoiding us. Like we should be so grateful that he’s sitting here now.
“What’s new at the shop?” my dad says while my mom hands out plates. He sounds way too interested in oil changes, and that’s how I know it’s not a real question. “Seems like you’ve been pretty busy.”
My mom just smiles weakly and scoops more corn onto my plate while I think about what it means to be in someone’s arms.
In someone’s arms.
Before Waverly, I never thought about it much. There was only ever my tongue in someone’s mouth. Only my leg hooked over, my hand sliding under. In someone’s arms, there is you. You’re there in the shelter of them—safe, inside. Everything else…is not.
“I’m just saying,” my dad says in a voice that implies he is not just saying anything. “Maybe you should see about cutting back your hours, if it’s so demanding.”
Justin stares at him across the table. Then he leans forward and slams his hands down on his placemat. “You want to turn this into some passive-aggressive bullshit? Great! I’m not your problem anymore, and how I fucking live my life is none of your business.”
“Says the freeloading slacker.”
They’re both red in the face, both edging toward explosion, and Justin has always been the loud one, the angry one. Now, though, he keeps both hands flat on the table and closes his eyes like he might be counting.
My dad is building up to something, getting good and mean. “Isn’t this shit exactly like you! Acting like you’re so goddamn busy, or maybe just too good to waste your time on us. Not so wonderful when you were flunking out of trade school. Not when you were asking me to drop four thousand dollars on some HVAC certificate that never materialized.”
The shot is so cheap that I feel it in my gut. We all know school has never been easy for Justin, not even when we were little. And still, maybe he would have picked something to get good at if our dad wasn’t always up his ass about picking something.
“I don’t have to sit here for this,” Justin says. His voice is flat, horribly even.
I’m so sure that in a second, we’ll be treated to the version I know. The Justin who’s always been a junior copy of our dad. He’s going to get nasty, get cruel or sarcastic. He’s going to break something.
Instead, without saying anything, he shoves back his chair. He looks from me to Annie—this hard, complicated look, like we’re somehow the ones letting him down. Then he walks out of the kitchen and out of the house.
We hear his car start up, go screeching down the driveway, and then it gets quiet. Out the window, it’s still raining.
I sit and wait for everyone to sigh in relief, like now we can stop playing this ugly Leave It to Beaver game and go back to our stupid, screwed-up lives. I’ll finish the creamed corn, put my plate in the sink, go over to Autumn’s and get numb. Or maybe not—maybe I’ll just skip it. I’ll stop by Ollie’s instead, and we’ll drive around and listen to the radio and be really careful not to talk about why I never let him come over anymore.
Annie will lock herself in her room, or meet some friends for study group. We’ll escape into the little secret hideouts that we made, and leave the two of them to cry and shout and fuck each other up some more.
I sit with my head down and wait for someone to act like anything at all has happened. The problem, though, is that they can’t. That would make it real. We’d have to admit that all the chaos and the noise is just this thing we do. We need it, because if no one’s yelling or crying, then there’s nothing left to hold on to.
We all sit there, busy with our forks, like it’s not sickening to eat this way. I shove a gooey lump of scalloped potatoes around on my plate, whisper “Razor blade.”
My dad is going in for another dinner roll, but he freezes midreach. “Something on your mind, Marshall?”
“No,” I say, trying to look as blank as he does.
Waverly, wrapped around me like she could shield me with her body.
At the other end of the table, my mom is concentrating on her salad. Her eyes are red and shiny the way they get, but she’s acting like everything is totally, stupidly fine.
My dad’s still watching like he can see through me, peel back the layers between me and him and start digging around in my bones. He looks so disgusted and I can already tell we’re going to do the thing—that thing where he tells me I’m pathetic. That at least Justin stands up for himself or knows how to act like a man.
“Then you’d better adjust your attitude, because right now, it looks like you’ve got something you want to say.”
I know he’s baiting me, still jonesing for the explosion that never happened. The only thing that can shut him up now is a fight.
“Please.” There’s a knot in my throat, but my voice isn’t shaking. “Please just stop.”
“Excuse me?”
I put down my fork and look up. “Stop acting like we’re the ones doing this to you. Stop pretending you ever once acted like you could stand to be in the same room with any of us, or like Annie somehow owes it to the goddamn family to put her life on hold. That’s not what this is.”
He stares hard at me, but doesn’t answer. He might be all about the sneering and the shouting, but when it comes to saying how he really feels, my dad would always rather say nothing.
“No one has a problem here but you,” I say. “We’re just trying to get through this, the same as you. So quit acting like we’re some kind of huge pain in your ass, because we’re not the ones making your life shitty.”
I feel dizzy, almost. Out of breath, even though I haven’t moved from the table. My blood has turned to acid, flooding my body. At the same time, I can hardly feel my hands.
He’s staring back at me, brutal and cold, and under that, hurt.
“You don’t deserve this,” I say. “It sucks, and it’s not fair. But we don’t deserve it either.”
For a second I think he might hit me, even though he hasn’t even spanked me since I was a little kid. His face is red. His hands are clenched in fists.
“So just stop,” I say, and this time I don’t say please.
My mom puts her head down on her arms and starts to cry like someone just died, but I don’t move.
Suddenly, I have a horrible feeling that I’m saying the thing everyone’s secretly been thinking. That me and Annie and my mom, and even Justin, became We five or ten years ago, maybe from the beginning, and on the other side, there’s just him and no one else.
“Give me the car keys,” I say to Annie without looking at her.
My mom looks up, wet-faced. “Where are you going?”
I shake my head, still looking at my dad. “Away.”
I don’t say that I’m sorry for this, or tell him that I hate it, that I don’t even want to be saying it—there’s really no way to make peace now. He’s the one who set the terms.
It’s him or us, and now that I’m actually honest, I realize I’ve known that for years. He hasn’t left any of us a choice.