Bautzer dated scores of women. The following is a short list of his more famous romantic interests.
Wendy Barrie
Mari Blanchard
Carol Bruce
Joan Caulfield
Marguerite Chapman
Rosemary Clooney
Buff Cobb*
Joan Crawford
Nancy Cuffman
Niki Schenck Dantine*
Marlene Dietrich
Ava Gardner
Greer Garson
Paulette Goddard
Rita Hayworth
Sonja Henie
Marion Jahns*
Isabel Jewell
Evelyn Keyes
Susan Kohner
Dorothy Lamour**
Carole Landis
Peggy Lee
Mary Maguire
Pamela Mason (Mrs. James Mason)
Marilyn Maxwell
Merle Oberon
Barbara Payton
Ella Raines
Jane Randolph
Ginger Rogers
Ann Sheridan
Simone Simon
Ann Sothern
Claire Trevor
Lana Turner **
Jane Wyman
Dana Wynter*
Audrey Young (Mrs. Billy Wilder)
* MARRIED
** ENGAGED