Top to bottom: Fiscalini Bandaged Cheddar, Bleu Mont Bandaged Cheddar, Cabot Clothbound Cheddar

American Cheddar Smackdown

Mendocino Brewing Company Red Tail Ale

Comparing three fine Cheddars from California (Fiscalini), Wisconsin (Bleu Mont), and Vermont (Cabot Clothbound) will help you assess the domestic state of the art. For a ringer, throw in Keen’s, Quickes, or Montgomery’s Cheddar from England, widely considered that country’s best. With its balance of toasty malt and floral hops, Red Tail Ale can manage any Cheddar in its path, from mellow to tangy.