Included here are session-by-session outlines for delivering the eight-session EET protocol, and all scripts, handouts, and worksheets in single-page format, for copying. Note that all handouts and worksheets are also available for download at http://www.newharbinger.com/34039.
The session overview for group therapy is as follows:
Session 1 is dedicated to introducing group members to EET. It’s also designed to help clients develop a sense of what’s possible by learning how to have a new relationship with emotions. Clients also learn what emotions are, how they work, and how they are experienced. In addition, Session 1 sets the tone for treatment, establishing guidelines about the structure for the session, participation expectations, and between-session skills practice.
Overview
Procedures
If you are using pretreatment measures, administer them at the very beginning of group. (A list of recommended measures is provided in chapter 10, and full versions are available in Appendix A.)
When working within a group format, there are several dynamics you’ll want to be prepared to address. First, take some time in the beginning of treatment to create comfort and rapport with the group. You can do this by articulating the intention to create a safe space.
Take a few minutes to introduce yourself to the group, and allow enough time for each person to introduce him- or herself. Depending on the context and the group, you may ask clients to share something about their relationship with their emotions, ranging from what their most difficult emotion is to what brings them to treatment. As an icebreaker, you might ask group members to share their least favorite emotion. This will help establish some connection among group members and to normalize the common struggle with emotions that has brought each client to treatment.
Review guidelines for disclosure as well as confidentiality. While you cannot legally enforce confidentiality among participants, you’ll want to ask them to keep what is shared private so that the group will be a safe space to engage in the treatment. In addition, you can remind your clients that while at times they will be asked to share or to give feedback, it is up to them whether to disclose anything personal. Participation in the group is intended to focus on learning EET skills, which does not depend on disclosing personal or specific details.
Using the What You Can Expect from Emotion Efficacy Therapy handout, review EET treatment and outline the session structure for the group:
You’ll want to emphasize that EET treatment involves regular skills practice between and outside of group sessions, and that the effectiveness of treatment will depend, in part, on how willing clients are to practice the skills on their own.
Using the handouts What You Can Expect from Emotion Efficacy Therapy and What is Emotion Efficacy?, introduce clients to the concept of emotion efficacy and to the skills they will be learning.
Using the handouts Emotion Awareness and Anatomy of an Emotion, introduce clients to what emotions are, how they work, and what they’re made of. (See chapter 2 for further detail on how to introduce this.)
Using the Emotion Watching Worksheet, have group members identify a situation that evokes strong emotion, and have them name the four parts of the emotion that go with it. Refer them to the Feelings Word List handout for help identifying the feeling label that goes with the emotion.
Explain the importance of skills practice outside of session. Then introduce them to the Skills Practice Record. Emphasize that emotion efficacy is like a muscle that needs to be exercised to build up. Skills practice between sessions will allow clients to become more efficient and effective at using the skills. It will also give them a chance to figure out where they need help troubleshooting.
Use the Session 1 Skills Practice handout to review the skills practice for the week and to give clients a reminder of what they should practice.
What You Can Expect from Emotion Efficacy Therapy
EET will help you learn skills so you can be more powerful in how you respond to your emotions:
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion efficacy is how well you can—and believe you can—respond to emotions, including intense emotions, effectively. This might mean responding by doing nothing, doing something that reflects what you care about in the moment, or practicing skills that decrease the emotion to keep from making the situation more difficult.
This treatment is based on the idea that pain is an inescapable part of being human, as are the emotions that go with it. And while we cannot avoid pain or difficult emotions, the good news is that we can reduce suffering and increase our quality of life by how we understand and respond to our emotional experience. Another way of saying this is that, while we can’t escape painful emotions, we can choose how we respond to them. That’s what emotion efficacy is all about.
The skills you’ll learn from emotion efficacy therapy (EET) will help increase your emotion efficacy through the following five components:
We’ll be talking about these skills in every session, and by the end of treatment you’ll know about and have experience using each of them.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
What Are Emotions?
What are emotions, really? Most simply, emotions are signals that help you respond to what your brain thinks is happening. Here’s how they work: the brain responds to internal and external cues (events or observations from our environment). Then the brain produces biochemical messengers, which we experience as emotions. These emotions motivate us to make choices. For example, the emotion we know as anxiety helps us choose to avoid danger. Anger helps us choose to fight when we feel threatened. Sadness helps us choose to withdraw when we need to process a loss or failure.
From birth, our amazing brains are evolutionarily wired to protect us from harm—to help us survive. That means any time your brain is sensing a threat to your well-being, it will do everything it can to send you emotional messages to motivate you to protect yourself. You may have heard about this process referred to as “flight, fight, or freeze,” all of which are common responses to intense emotions.
However, while our emotional wiring has been adaptive for the survival of the human race over time, the survival wiring doesn’t always serve us when it gets activated in a non-survival situation. Over time, your brain develops a “negativity bias,” whereby it constantly scans your environment for anything negative that could be interpreted as a threat so it can protect you. The downside of this protective negativity bias is that you can end up in a state of constant anxiety, or you can be easily triggered—whether or not there is an actual threat.
Author and psychotherapist Tara Brach explains how the negativity bias impacts us: “The emotion of fear often works overtime. Even when there is no immediate threat, our body may remain tight and on guard, our mind narrowed to focus on what might go wrong. When this happens, fear is no longer functioning to secure our survival. We are caught in the trance of fear and our moment-to-moment experience becomes bound in reactivity. We spend our time and energy defending our life rather than living it fully” (2003, p. 168).
EET can help you learn how to respond to non-survival emotions using skills that will help you respond effectively.
Why Do Some People Struggle with Emotions?
You’ve probably noticed that some people tend to be more emotionally reactive than others. We are all unique human beings, and how we experience emotions also depends on the wiring in our brains. While we are all born wired for survival, some of us are born with a tendency toward heightened emotional sensitivity. Others develop this tendency as a result of difficult experiences that leave them more emotionally reactive to certain cues.
If you are someone who has heightened sensitivity, you may have an increased vulnerability to stress. Even more, the heightened sensitivity to certain cues can become so ingrained and the emotional reactions so automatic that you may forget you have choices when you get triggered. Unfortunately, this emotional reactivity can negatively affect your well-being, quality of life, relationships, personal goals, and long-term health.
For this treatment, we will focus on how you can respond to distressing emotions and increase your emotion efficacy. You will learn how to stop being controlled by your emotions, how to respond in ways that reflect your values, and how to create more of what you want in your life.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
There are four components that make up your experience of an emotion:
Let’s consider one example: If something great happens, you may have the thought, “There is so much to look forward to!” The feeling may be excitement. You may notice sensations of looseness and energy in your body. You may experience the urge to engage with people and/or dance around.
Two more examples: When you feel sad, you may have the thought, “I will always be alone.” You may sense tightness in your stomach and a lack of energy in your body. You may have the urge to withdraw from people. If someone threatens you, you may feel angry, you may think, “How dare he say that?!” You may notice the sensation of increased heart rate and energy. You may have the urge to attack the person.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Observing the Four Components of Emotion
Use this worksheet to record the four components of emotion you experience from specific triggers.
Triggers |
Thoughts |
Feelings |
Sensations |
Urges |
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Session 1 Skills Practice
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a relaxation skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction strategy. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Emotional triggers: Record any events or emotions that are distressing during this week.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Session 2 is the most content-heavy of all the sessions. Group members add the key component of mindful acceptance to emotion awareness, which is used in every exposure-based skills training both within and outside of session for the duration of treatment. The types and consequences of emotion avoidance are also highlighted to increase motivation for trying new behaviors. Finally, clients begin working with emotion exposure and learning how to do their own exposure-based skills practice both in session and between sessions.
Materials
Overview
Procedures
Using the Skills Practice Record, ask group members to share how their skills practice went since the last session, providing validation and an opportunity for troubleshooting. If necessary, briefly review the concept of emotion efficacy and the four parts of emotion.
Using the Mindful Acceptance | Observe + Accept handout, introduce clients to the idea of observing and accepting their emotions.
Using the Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance, lead your clients through mindful acceptance practice. Be sure to leave time for feedback both as an opportunity for troubleshooting and to consolidate learning.
Remind group members that each session will begin with mindful acceptance practice. Tell them that, as part of their homework for the remainder of treatment, they should practice this for at least ten minutes a day and record it on their Skills Practice Record.
Use the Consequences of Emotion Avoidance handout to introduce your clients to the different kinds of avoidance, as well as how emotion avoidance negatively impacts their lives. Then have them assess the pros and cons using the Emotion Avoidance Consequences Worksheet.
Introduce clients to emotion surfing, emphasizing what happens to emotion when we try to avoid the emotion versus accepting it and “riding the wave.” Set up the exposure and lead clients through an emotion surfing exercise practicing mindful acceptance using the following script.
Be sure to leave time for feedback both as an opportunity for troubleshooting, and to consolidate learning.
Mindful Acceptance | Observe + Accept
Mindful acceptance is derived from the practice of mindfulness, which has been shown to reduce psychological stress and improve well-being in numerous studies. The practice of mindful acceptance is essential for emotion efficacy because it will help you better tolerate difficult emotions, recover more quickly, and respond in ways that enrich your life moment to moment.
Mindful acceptance will help you practice observing and accepting emotions instead of reacting to them, avoiding them, or trying to control them. It doesn’t mean you have to “like” your emotions; it simply means that you don’t resist what you are experiencing.
One helpful metaphor is to think of yourself as the atmosphere and your emotions as the weather. The atmosphere is constant, while the weather is ever-changing. In mindful acceptance, you simply observe and accept changing weather, without reacting, while you as the observer remain constant.
There are many benefits to using mindful acceptance when you are emotionally triggered:
Mindful acceptance is practiced by learning to observe and accept the four parts of emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. Following is a simple description for practicing mindful acceptance you can use as you do your skills practice outside of session. Try to practice for at least 10 minutes a day when you are resting or when you get emotionally triggered.
Scan your body for sensations with the intention of observing and accepting them instead of reacting to them. Just notice all the details of the sensations: size, shape, temperature, tension, and movement. See if you can soften to the sensation and make space for it, without trying to change it…just allowing it to be exactly as it is.
Try to identify the feeling that goes with the emotion. Name it and allow it to be exactly as it is, without judging it.
Clear your mind, and then wait and watch for each thought as it arises; let the thought go without getting involved in it. Come back to the present moment and wait for the next thought to show up. When a thought arises, you might say to yourself, “There’s a thought,” and then just let it go. If you find yourself struggling to let the thought go, you might just acknowledge it as a “sticky thought,” and then let it go.
The more you practice these mindful acceptance skills, the bigger your emotion efficacy muscle will grow. It will get easier and easier to observe and accept your emotions instead of acting on them. Practicing mindful acceptance will also prepare you to use the other skills you will learn in EET.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation…just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations, feelings, or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Consequences of Emotion Avoidance
There are at least five types of emotion avoidance that researchers believe are at the root of many emotion problems.
Why not just keep on avoiding? Because the consequences of emotion avoidance are usually worse than the experience of what we try to avoid.
By allowing yourself to experience fears—and difficult thoughts, feelings, sensations, and urges—you can learn to decrease your suffering.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion |
Pros of Avoiding |
Cons of Avoiding |
Cons of Experiencing |
Pros of Experiencing |
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Script for Guided Emotion Surfing
After the provoking scene is “shut off,” a typical emotion surfing exercise might look like this:
What do you notice in your body right now? Can you describe the sensations? [Client responds.]
What are the feelings that go with that? [Client responds.]
If there are thoughts, can you just watch them and let them go? Any time a thought shows up, just say so. Any thoughts now? [Client responds.] See if you can just let go of any thoughts that arise.
Where are you on the wave? [Client responds.] SUDS? [Client responds.]
Any urges? Does the emotion make you want to do something? [Client responds.] Notice how you can just observe the urge. You don’t have to act on it.
What’s happening in your body right now? [Client responds.]
Can you label your feelings? [Client responds.] See if you can just allow the feelings without reacting to them.
Remember to watch and let go of any thoughts. Are thoughts showing up? [Client responds.]
Urges? Something the emotion wants you to do? [Client responds.] See what it’s like to just notice the urge without acting on it.
Where are you on the wave? SUDS? [Client responds.]
What are you experiencing in your body right now? [Client responds.] Can you make room for that and just allow that sensation?
Your feelings? [Client responds.] Can you just allow that feeling? Can you let it be there without trying to control or stop it?
Watch the thoughts and let them go. [Client responds.]
Urges? [Client responds.]
Check the wave. Where are you? [Client responds.] SUDS? [Client responds.]
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Using the Introduction to Exposure handout, orient clients to exposure and how it will be used to enhance skills training. If you have a group where multiple members have a history of severe trauma, you may consider adopting guidelines to prevent clients from triggering each other. For example, you may want to ask that no details of the situations they choose for imaginal exposure be shared during feedback. Rather, they can just share the course of their emotion wave and SUDS level at the beginning, middle, and end of exposure practice.
Setting up exposure in a group setting requires some extra time and attunement. Some people—such as those with high anxiety, a severe trauma history, or panic disorder—may need to set their target SUDS levels lower in the beginning, while others can target the recommended 5 to 6 range.
You’ll easily identify clients struggling with imaginal exposure during the group practice. After having clients close their eyes and locate themselves in the triggering scene, ask them to raise their hands when they get to their SUDs level. This will allow you to know when to proceed to the next phase of exposure. Often, the clients who struggle to become activated will not raise their hand, and you’ll want to check in with them during the exposure feedback or after session. They can still practice exposure in the group, but the research shows the best outcomes occur when clients’ SUDS are elevated, so you’ll want to work with clients to find a way to do skills practice in an activated state.
Following is a script and the Introduction to Exposure handout you can use to help clients figure out how to find the right “stretch” with exposure.
Therapist: So we’ve talked about how it’s important to practice skills in the same emotional state as you’ll be in outside of group. It’s important to choose situations that you know can activate you emotionally, but they shouldn’t be so upsetting that you can’t recover after the exercise.
Client A: Yeah… I’m afraid if I choose the wrong scene I’ll get totally overwhelmed.
Therapist: Right, so I’m going to give you some suggestions about how to choose a situation that works for you. Has anyone heard of the SUDS? It’s an acronym for a fancy scale you can use to rate how upset you are. It stands for the subjective units of distress scale: S-U-D-S [draws a continuum on the white board with 0 on the far left, 5 in the middle, and 10 on the far right].
Therapist: Basically, if you were in no distress you would rate your SUDS as a 0; if you are in the most distress you can imagine you would rate yourself at 10. For our exposure exercises, you want to try to pick scenes to work with that will activate you somewhere between a 5 or 6 SUDS.
Client B: So how do we predict that?
Therapist: Great question. It can take some practice to get good at predicting. Everyone is different, and some people can get activated at a high SUDS level very quickly, and others may have a hard time getting activated at all. The best way to figure it out is to start with something that’s not too distressing when you think about it, but immediately activates emotion. In others words, you don’t want to pick something that will leave you feeling too exposed or inside out. Does that make sense?
Client C: So like if I think about the fight I just had with my partner, and I immediately start to feel tense?
Therapist: Exactly. And do you have some idea about how upsetting it might make you to revisit that scene?
Client C: Well, it’s not horrible or anything…not like the car accident I had last year…that would be like a 10 on the SUDS!
Therapist: Right. So where do you predict your SUDS might be if you use the fight with your partner?
Client C: Probably around a 6. I was pretty upset and have been for the last few days.
Therapist: That sounds like a good scene to work with. It’s likely you’ll have a sense of what you can handle. The important thing is that you want to stretch yourself enough to get the benefit of the exposure. If you’re not very activated, you won’t experience the shift in distress tolerance that exposure can provide.
Therapist: [To Client A] Do you feel like you can find a scene to work with that’s in the 5 to 6 SUDS range?
Client A: I’m not sure… I understand what you’re saying, but sometimes I can’t predict how I’m going to feel. I can go straight to panic and down the rabbit hole.
Therapist: I’m glad you brought that up. It may help you to start by choosing a scene you don’t predict is too activating. If it ends up being too low—under a 5—you can always switch it for the next practice.
Client A: Okay. But what if I end up getting really upset during the exercise and start to panic?
Therapist: Any time you start to sense you may be getting too distressed to recover, you can just come out of the exercise, open your eyes, and ground yourself by counting your breaths or focusing on feeling your feet on the floor. If you still feel too distressed, you can leave the room.
Client A: Well, that might be embarrassing.
Therapist: It sounds like you’re concerned about drawing attention to yourself?
Client A: Yeah, and I don’t want to mess it up for the rest of the group.
Therapist: I appreciate that. But it’s really important that you know how to take care of yourself during the treatment. If you need to come out of the exposure or leave the room, please do that. Everyone here is on his or her own path, and each person has different challenges with their emotions.
Client A: I get it. I’ll try.
Therapist: Great. After each exposure, we will have time to check in and share feedback. If you still feel distressed after the exposure and feedback time, I’d like you to check in with me once the session has concluded. Does that work for everyone? Any questions?
While it might seem daunting to conduct an exposure-based treatment in a group setting with clients struggling with emotions, using exposure in a group format, as compared to individual, showed no treatment difference (Barrera, Mott, Hofstein, & Teng, 2013). In fact, there are many benefits from doing EET in a group format. Having multiple treatment participants normalizes the struggle with emotions, allows the group members to learn from each other’s challenges, and can provide a supportive context for treatment.
In this treatment we’ll be doing some skills practice we’ll call “exposure exercises.” The exercises are intended to help you “expose” yourself to the experience of difficult emotions so you can learn how to recover from distress as well as learn new ways of responding that enrich your life. Research shows that when you face distress instead of avoiding it, you can not only increase your tolerance of the distress but also recover more quickly.
Here’s how it works. First pick a situation or scene that is distressing to you. For example, try to recall the last time you got upset, and see if you can feel yourself getting activated when you think about it. Then, assess whether it is activating enough to use for your exposure using the following SUDS tool.
The SUDS Rating
The SUDS rating stands for subjective units of distress scale. In plain terms, this just means how much distress you experience when you think about the situation on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being no distress and 10 being the most distress you can imagine. For each situation, you want to predict how upset you might become if you expose yourself fully to the emotion of the situation. Ideally, your distress will be in the 5 to 7 range. If your distress is too low, the exercise is unlikely to be effective, and if it’s too high, you may become distracted and unable to stay engaged.
If at any point in the exposure exercise you begin to feel too distressed to stay with it, you should let the therapist know and stop the exercise. You are in the driver’s seat. Once you have done a few exposures, you may want to try to use situations that you predict will take you higher, to an 8 or 9.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Use the following handout (available in downloadable format at http://www.newharbinger.com/34039) to review the skills practice for the week and to give clients a reminder of what they should practice.
Session 2 Skills Practice
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a relaxation skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose to practice radical acceptance. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction task or activity. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Emotional triggers: Record any events or emotions that are distressing during this week.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Once you’re emotionally activated, take note of your SUDS level and then begin to practice emotion surfing following the sequence below:
Keep going until the distress improves or the emotion shifts. Record your SUDS level when finished.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Values Clarification Worksheet
Review the list below and circle your top 10 values.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Session 3 begins the first of two sessions focused on values-based action (VBA). Group members will learn the key skill for choosing alternatives to emotion-driven behaviors: locating the moment of choice. In addition, they begin to clarify values in each of their life domains and to identify how they can express these values when they are emotionally triggered. Finally, clients begin working with VBA using imaginal exposure both in session and between sessions.
Materials
Overview
Procedures
For the first ten minutes of session, lead group members through mindful acceptance practice using the Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance. Ask clients to provide feedback about their experience as an opportunity for learning and troubleshooting.
Briefly review Session 2 skills and ask clients to share feedback about their weekly practice using their Skills Practice Record.
Using the Moment of Choice handout, introduce clients to the moment of choice. Emphasize that finding this “pause” is critical for being able to make choices that are effective and that will help them create lives that reflect their values.
Give clients the sample Values Domain Worksheet, as well as the blank Values Domains Worksheet, and ask them to complete it using their Values Clarification Worksheet from Session 2.
Lead a whiteboard exercise using client examples. First, list a core value. Second, identify a recent situation when a client was emotionally triggered. Third, identify the values-based action he or she could have chosen to reflect the core value. Do at least two to three examples to reinforce how VBA works and to prepare clients for the group exercise, Monsters on the Bus.
Next, have clients complete the Benefits of Values-Based Action worksheet. Then solicit feedback.
Following is a guide to helping your clients practice using VBA with imaginal exposure. Be sure to explain that this is the way they will practice VBA using imaginal exposure outside of session during the week. You may also encourage clients to try to use VBA in vivo when any triggers arise.
While still visualizing the triggering event, have the clients observe any action urges that arise. Is there a desire to be verbally aggressive, to withdraw, to stonewall, to be defensive? Have the clients describe such urges and notice that the urges don’t have to become action. This is the moment of choice, and it’s important for the clients to stay with it for several minutes: observing the emotional pain, accepting and allowing the pain to be there without avoidance, and choosing not to act on emotion-driven urges.
Use the following handout to review the skills practice for the week and to give clients a reminder of what they should practice.
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation…just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Moment of Choice
As humans, we don’t have control over whether or not we have emotions. Emotions will arise naturally in response to what’s happening inside us and around us. But we can control how we respond to our emotions, and that’s where we find true emotion efficacy.
This concept was illuminated by neurologist and psychiatrist Victor Frankl as follows:
How effectively we respond to difficult emotions depends on being able to locate this “moment of choice.” This moment is the time when you realize that you’re emotionally triggered, and you realize you have the power to choose how to respond. You might think of it as a “sacred pause” when you can either react, avoid, or try to control it—or you can choose a response that is life enriching.
In EET, you’ll learn a variety of skills you can choose to use in your moment of choice to help you respond to your emotions in a way that brings you close to what you want to create in the moment.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Values Domains Worksheet
1. Intimate relationships Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
2. Parenting Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
3. Education/learning Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
4. Friends/social life Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
5. Physical self-care/health Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
6. Family of origin Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
I = Importance A = Action: How much action did you take in the last seven days toward your value?
7. Spirituality Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
8. Community life/citizenship Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
9. Recreation Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
10. Work/career Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
11. Value: I = A =
Values-Based Action:
Values-Based Action:
I = Importance A = Action: How much action did you take in the last seven days toward your value?
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Values Domain Worksheet
(Client Sample)
1. Intimate relationships Value: Caring I = 2 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
Express concern, interest re: difficulty getting organized
2. Parenting Value: Supportive I = 2 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
Talk with gentleness/love when they didn’t listen or are sassy
3. Education/learning Value: Learn how to write I = 1 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
Enroll in community college class
4. Friends/social life Value: Listen I = 1 A = 2
Ask about what’s going on, be interested. Don’t interrupt or judge.
5. Physical self-care/health Value: Healthy stamina I = 1 A = 1
Values-Based Action:
Cardio exercise 3x week
6. Family of origin Value: I = 0 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
7. Spirituality Value: I = 0 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
8. Community life/citizenship Value: Volunteering I = 1 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
Help at children’s school
9. Recreation Value: I = 0 A = 0
Values-Based Action:
10. Work/career Value: Support co-workers I = 2 A = 2
Values-Based Action:
Ask how their projects are going
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Benefits of Values-Based Action Worksheet
Now that you’ve identified your values—and you understand that the moment of choice presents an opportunity to make a helpful decision about how to respond in an emotion-filled situation—let’s explore possible reactions. Answer the following questions about your values, your intentions, and your actions around your values.
How does values-based action affect my relationships with friends and family?
How does values-based action affect my relationship with my spouse or partner, or my living situation?
How does values-based action affect my relationships when I am emotionally triggered?
How does values-based action affect my work or school?
How does values-based action affect my financial situation?
How does values-based action affect my health?
How does values-based action affect my long-term goals?
How does values-based action affect my safety and security?
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a relaxation skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose to practice radical acceptance. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction task or activity. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Emotional triggers: Record any events or emotions that are distressing during this week.
Session 4 is the second of two sessions focused on values-based action. Using a group experiential exposure, Monsters on the Bus, clients drill down further on the experience of accepting difficult emotions and tolerating their distress in order to choose values-based action. The consequences of choosing to avoid painful emotions are highlighted to increase willingness and motivation for clients to choose VBAs in the moment of choice. Group members continue working with VBA using imaginal exposure as well as in vivo.
Materials
Overview
Procedures
For the first ten minutes of session, lead group members through mindful acceptance practice using the guided script. Ask clients to provide feedback about their experience as an opportunity for learning and troubleshooting.
Briefly review Session 3 skills and ask group members to share feedback about their weekly practice using their Skills Practice Record.
First, ask a group member to volunteer for the exercise; the client will be working with values-based action and the barriers that show up when trying to choose VBA.
Next, ask the volunteer to choose a situation from one of his or her life domains that is distressing. Then have the volunteer identify what value he or she would like to express in the situation. Make sure that the value is rated as very important to ensure the likelihood that group members will be motivated to try a new behavior.
Ask the volunteer to identify the values-based action that could be enacted to move in the direction of his or her value in that particular domain, and help the volunteer be very specific about how the VBA would be enacted in the situation.
Ask the volunteer what emotional barriers come up when he or she visualizes enacting a VBA. Make a list of all the barriers—thoughts, feelings, sensations, and urges—writing each one on its own piece of paper. These pieces of paper will represent the “monsters” for the exercise. If you have time and are so inclined, you can even draw a picture of the monster for each emotional barrier.
Instruct the volunteer to stand up at one end of the room. Place a sheet of paper with the VBA written on it at the other end, so that it’s visible to the volunteer. Place the pieces of paper with the emotional components, which serve as the “monsters,” in any order in a row between the volunteer and the VBA.
Tell the volunteer that you will be going on the journey as his or her guide toward the VBA. Explain that the volunteer will be driving a bus in the direction of his or her VBA, and along the way he or she will encounter “monsters”—the barriers to reaching his or her VBA. Let the volunteer know that, while you are guiding him or her, he or she is in complete control of what he or she chooses to do along the way.
Ask for more volunteers from the group to act as the barriers, or “monsters.” Explain to them that, when you cue them, they should come and stand in front of the volunteer driving the bus and say their line. For example, if the barrier identified was the thought “I will never be good enough,” have a volunteer say that. Or if the barrier is a feeling of anxiety, have another volunteer say, “You’re feeling anxious.” If the barrier is a sensation, have an additional volunteer say what it is, for example, “tingling in the fingers” or “hot flashes.”
Take the first volunteer—now the bus driver—on the journey, and when he or she encounters a monster, ask the bus driver how he or she can get past the monster. The rule is that the monster will not let the bus by, and the only choices are: veer off the path and onto the road to emotion avoidance, or let the monster on the bus and keep driving.
At each barrier, or monster, ask the driver if he or she wants to stay on the path to his or her VBA or veer off and onto the road to emotion avoidance. At least once, if the driver doesn’t choose it, suggest to the client that he or she might take the path to emotion avoidance to see what it’s like.
When the driver does choose the path to emotion avoidance, guide the driver to the side and ask him or her to take a moment to experience the pros and cons of emotion avoidance. If the client is able to recognize the consequences of avoiding, he or she will choose to get back on the values-based path.
Once the client has successfully made it to his or her value, take a moment to review how being able to choose values-based action means being clear on what it is for that situation, and then being willing to experience all the uncomfortable emotions while moving in a valued direction.
For a more detailed therapist-client dialogue, refer to the Therapist-Client Dialogue Example: Monsters on the Bus, in chapter 6.
If you have time, repeat the Monsters on the Bus exercise a second or third time, trying to involve each group member in either the bus driver or monster roles. After each experiential, ask if group members learned anything about their relationship with their emotions from the exercise.
For the session exposure practice, repeat imaginal exposure + VBA using the following guide:
While still visualizing the triggering event, have the clients observe any action urges that arise. Is there a desire to be verbally aggressive, to withdraw, to stonewall, to be defensive? Have the clients describe such urges and notice that the urges don’t have to become action. This is the moment of choice, and it’s important for the clients to stay with it for several minutes: observing the emotional pain, accepting and allowing the pain to be there without avoidance, and choosing not to act on emotion-driven urges.
Your clients have now had two sessions on values-based action and may be ready to practice in vivo. Invite them to think of a situation that is going to present itself in the week ahead. Ask them to consider practicing mindful acceptance and then choosing a VBA when they get triggered.
Remind clients that they have the Exposure with Values-Based Action handout to help them practice this skill again between sessions.
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation… just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a relaxation skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction task or activity. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Emotional triggers: Record any events or emotions that are distressing during this week.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Session 5 introduces the last EET component, mindful coping. Unlike mindful acceptance and values-based action, mindful coping is only used when clients have tried to observe and accept painful emotions (mindful acceptance), and/or have attempted to choose a values-based action, but are too overwhelmed to execute them effectively. Instead, mindful coping skills are intended to facilitate a decrease in emotion activation. In this session, clients learn how to use relaxation and self-soothing to downregulate emotion. These mindful coping skills are practiced using emotion exposure in session, with time for feedback and troubleshooting.
Materials
Overview
Procedures
For the first ten minutes of session, lead group members through mindful acceptance practice using the guided script. Ask clients to provide feedback about their experience as an opportunity for learning and troubleshooting.
Briefly review Session 4 skills and ask clients to share feedback about their weekly practice using their Skills Practice Record.
Mindful coping skills are used in combination with mindful acceptance and only when necessary—when clients are unable to choose a VBA or recover through the practice of mindful acceptance alone. Emphasize to clients that the goal of EET is to help them be more powerful when facing and tolerating difficult emotions and still move in the direction of their values; mindful coping skills are used only in crisis situations to help regulate their emotions when they are flooded, so they can recover enough to choose a VBA.
Relaxation and self-soothing skills work by using somatic stimulation and intention to decrease emotional activation. By learning how to intentionally let go of tension, and/or create pleasurable sensations in the body, clients learn to use relaxation and self-soothing to downshift emotion.
Lead your clients through emotion exposure by selecting one of the relaxation skills on the Mindful Coping Through Relaxation handout, and then follow the step-by-step guide below. Be sure to leave at least ten minutes for feedback and troubleshooting after the exposure.
Next, lead your group through emotion exposure by selecting one of the self-soothing skills on the Mindful Coping Through Self-Soothing handout and then following the step-by-step guide below. Be sure to leave at least ten minutes for feedback and troubleshooting after the exposure.
Your clients have now had their first session combining mindful acceptance and mindful coping skills. While they can still practice mindful acceptance with values-based action, invite them to try using relaxation and self-soothing skills—even if they don’t feel flooded—to help them begin to internalize how to use mindful coping. This way, when they are too triggered to choose VBA, they will have had practice in an activated state.
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation…just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Mindful Coping Through Relaxation
When a powerful emotion has been triggered and you are suddenly facing your moment of choice, a mindful coping skill can help downregulate your emotions before you decide on a values-based action. Practice these relaxation techniques daily so that you can rely on them in your moment of choice.
Diaphragmatic Breathing
Place one hand on your abdomen, just above the belt line, and the other on your chest.
Take a slow, deep breath into the abdomen. The hand on the abdomen should move but not the hand on the chest.
If you are having difficulty pushing the breath into your abdomen (and the hand on your chest is moving), you can do one of two things:
Practice 15 diaphragmatic breaths three times a day.
Relaxation Without Tension
Choose a cue word. Identify a word or phrase that you associate with relaxation. This could be a color (golden light, sea blue), a place that calms you (Tuolumne, Shenandoah), a command (“relax now”), or a spiritual mantra (om, peace on earth, I let go). This cue word will become associated with, and soon trigger, deep relaxation.
Observe a muscle group (see next paragraph) and notice any tension. Take a deep, diaphragmatic breath. At the top of the breath, say to yourself the cue word. Now, as you exhale, relax away any tension in the target muscle group. Do this process twice with each muscle group, in any order.
The five muscle groups you will relax are:
Practice this skill three times a day.
Use the same cue word you established with Relaxation Without Tension.
Take a deep, diaphragmatic breath. At the top of the breath, say to yourself the cue word. Now, as you exhale, relax away any tension throughout your body at once. Let your body slump forward slightly as you exhale and release all tension.
Take 15 cue-controlled breaths three times a day to practice this new skill.
Five-Senses Exercise
For 30 seconds, focus on every sound you can hear: voices, traffic noise, machinery noise such as the hum of an air conditioner, sounds of movement, sounds your body makes. Try to keep your attention fully on these sounds. If your mind wanders, gently bring it back to focusing on what you hear.
For 30 seconds focus on what you can smell: fragrances, odors, scents from your own body or the environment. Try to keep attention on what you smell; return to this focus when your mind wanders.
For 30 seconds focus on your sense of touch, including temperature and texture, noticing the pressure where your body touches the floor or chair. Return to your sense of touch when your mind wanders.
For 30 seconds focus on visual sensations, observing color and shapes, and noticing the objects in your environment. When you get distracted, bring your attention back to what you see.
For 30 seconds focus on your sense of taste. What residual tastes do you notice in your mouth—bitter, sweet, sour, salty? Are there more-subtle tastes? If you get distracted, bring your attention back to taste.
Practice this exercise twice daily as a way to focus attention away from negative thoughts and onto present-moment experience.
Mindful Coping Through Self-Soothing
This worksheet will help you identify some ways to soothe yourself using each of your five senses.
Sense of Smell
Using your sense of smell can activate specific thoughts, memories, or sensations that can be calming. If you identify smells that make you feel good in advance, you will be prepared to use them when triggered. Following are some examples, and feel free to add your own ideas:
Sense of Sight
Sight is an important sense for humans in that a large portion of our brain is devoted to what we see. What we look at can have powerful effects on our emotions, for better or for worse. If you identify images that make you feel good in advance, you will be prepared to use them when upset. Following are some examples, and a place for you to add your own ideas:
Sense of Hearing
Certain sounds can be very soothing. For example, everyone has his or her own tastes or preferences in music. By identifying in advance songs or sounds you know are soothing for you, you will be prepared to use them to help calm down. Following are some examples, and a place for you to add your own ideas:
Sense of Taste
Our tongues have distinct regions on them that use taste buds to differentiate flavors and tastes of food. These sensations can also trigger memories and feelings. By identifying tastes you know are soothing for you in advance, you will be prepared to use them to deal with upsets. Following are some examples, and a place for you to add your own ideas:
Sense of Touch
Our skin is the largest organ in the body, and it’s completely covered with nerves that carry sensations to our brain. This makes skin a powerful emotional messenger. By identifying tactile sensations you know are soothing for you in advance, you will be prepared to use them to quiet your emotions. Following are some examples, and a place for you to add your own ideas:
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a relaxation skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose to practice radical acceptance. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction task or activity. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Emotional triggers: Record any events or emotions that are distressing during this week.
Session 6 continues with mindful coping skills, to be used only when clients have tried to observe and accept painful emotions (mindful acceptance), and/or have attempted to choose a values-based action, but are too overwhelmed to execute them effectively. While the skills in Session 5 are focused on using sensations to downregulate emotion, Session 6 skills focus on using cognition to decrease emotional activation through coping thoughts and radical acceptance. These mindful coping skills are practiced using emotion exposure in session, with time for feedback and troubleshooting.
Materials
Overview
Procedures
For the first ten minutes of session, lead group members through mindful acceptance practice using the guided script. Ask clients to provide feedback about their experience as an opportunity for learning and troubleshooting.
Briefly review Session 5 skills and ask clients to share feedback about their weekly practice using their Skills Practice Record.
Use the Client Coping Thoughts handout to introduce your clients to coping thoughts. Tell them how coping thoughts can be helpful in the moment of choice. Then use the worksheets to let clients create their own coping thoughts as alternatives to automatic thoughts.
Lead your clients through emotion exposure with a coping thought using the following step-by-step guide. Be sure to leave at least ten minutes for feedback and troubleshooting after the exposure.
Use the following handout to introduce your clients to radical acceptance and how it can be helpful in the moment of choice. Then have clients complete the worksheet to help them use radical acceptance with a specific situation or reality they are resisting and that is emotionally triggering for them.
Lead your clients through emotion exposure with radical acceptance using the following step-by-step guide. Be sure to leave at least ten minutes for feedback and troubleshooting after the exposure.
Your clients’ focus this week should be on practicing mindful acceptance with coping thoughts and radical acceptance. Again, they can still practice mindful acceptance with values-based action, but invite them to try using coping thoughts and radical acceptance—even if they don’t feel flooded—to help them begin to internalize how to use mindful coping.
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation…just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Client Coping Thoughts
Coping thoughts can be used when you are facing a difficult emotion. They may be especially helpful after you’ve practiced observing and accepting the difficult emotion, and you’re still struggling with specific ruminations, or a repetitive automatic thought is fueling your emotion wave.
You now know that your emotions will follow whatever you pay attention to. If you’re triggered, you’re likely to have negative automatic thoughts. One way to tolerate the distress and shift your emotion is to replace the negative automatic thought with a coping thought. The key with a coping thought is that you believe it to be true and realistic. If you don’t believe the thought, it’s unlikely to be effective.
Following are some examples of coping thoughts:
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Replacing Automatic Thoughts with Coping Thoughts
Use this worksheet to record specific triggers, the automatic thoughts that go with them, and alternative coping thoughts with which you can replace them.
Trigger |
Automatic Thought |
Coping Thought |
1. |
1. |
1. |
2. |
2. |
2. |
3. |
3. |
3. |
4. |
4. |
4. |
5. |
5. |
5. |
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
(Client Sample)
Trigger |
Automatic Thought |
Coping Thought |
1. Turning in a project to my boss. |
1. My work isn’t as good as it should be. |
1. I’m doing my best, which is all I can do. |
2. Being at a party with people I don’t know. |
2. If I don’t say the right thing at this party, people are going to think I’m a loser. |
2. I can have this thought without acting on it. |
3. My wife comes home and goes straight to the bedroom. |
3. My wife doesn’t love me anymore. |
3. My defectiveness schema is talking, but I’m not listening. |
4. Anytime… … |
4. Something’s wrong with me. |
4. I have strengths and weaknesses, just like everybody else. |
5. My boss doesn’t talk to me at the office-wide lunch. |
5. My boss doesn’t like me. |
5. It’s not my job to be liked. It’s my job to do my job. |
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
The Art of Radical Acceptance
What It Is
Part of successfully navigating intense emotions is knowing when it’s time to try to improve your situation and when it’s time to accept it. Radical acceptance is another mindful coping skill that allows you to accept “what is” and stop suffering from rejecting the reality in front of you. We have a choice in every moment: to reject the reality of what is or to accept it. The choice we make will determine whether we continue to suffer or create space for something else to exist.
Our natural response to distressing emotions is to fight against the reality that we think caused them. In doing this, we can make ourselves and others miserable. Choosing radical acceptance—to accept “what is”—is a huge shift for most people. It feels like the opposite of what your emotions urge you to do when you encounter pain.
What It’s Not
Radical acceptance does not mean you like or condone what happened. It just means that you accept the reality that it happened. In other words, some situations in life are simply unjust or unfair. In other situations, you may share responsibility for what happened. Either way, just because you accept that it happened doesn’t mean you’re condoning it.
The more you practice radical acceptance, the easier it will become to stop resisting what you cannot change.
Following are a few examples of radical acceptance:
Radical acceptance requires a willingness to look at things differently. Sometimes our disappointments and moments of frustration were preventable. We can also practice radical acceptance by accepting what we might have done differently, and taking responsibility for how we didn’t. For example, could you have prevented being late to an appointment, forgetting to do work assignments, or behaving in a way that was less than stellar? Moreover, could you have prevented lying to hurt someone or allowing yourself to be motivated by hate? Many times we have culpability in “what is.” Accepting that is key to practicing radical acceptance.
While the outcomes of these situations may have serious consequences, they can also be opportunities for growth if you can view them as moments of learning. Often people who struggle with intense emotions believe that life is something that “happens” to them, instead of recognizing their own power in creating their experience.
The good news is that if we have responsibility in the things happening, we also have the power to make different choices—choices that can alleviate suffering and bring us closer to living the life we want in accordance with our values.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Think of a situation you have no control over, but about which you struggle to accept. Then answer the following questions:
Describe briefly the distressing situation:
What past events led to the situation?
What role, if any, did you play in creating the situation?
What roles, if any, did others play in the situation?
What do you have control of in this situation?
What do you not have control of in this situation?
What was your response to this situation?
How did your response affect your own thoughts and feelings?
How did your response affect the thoughts and feelings of others?
How could you have changed your response to this situation so that it led to less suffering for yourself and others?
How could the situation have occurred differently if you had chosen to radically accept the situation?
How to Practice Radical Acceptance
Once you’ve identified the situation and have a clear understanding of it, you can use these steps to practice radical acceptance during imaginal exposure or when you get upset.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose to practice radical acceptance. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction task or activity. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Session 7 completes mindful coping skills with the final skills: distraction and time-out. Distraction focuses on shifting attention of present-moment awareness away from the distressing stimulus or emotion to something that has more positive affect to downregulate emotion. Distraction is practiced using imaginal exposure in session, as well as in vivo, with time for feedback and troubleshooting.
Materials
Overview
For the first ten minutes of session, lead clients through mindful acceptance practice using the guided script. Ask clients to provide feedback about their experience as an opportunity for learning and troubleshooting.
Briefly review Session 6 skills and ask clients to share feedback about their weekly practice using their Skills Practice Record.
Use the following handouts to introduce clients to the mindful coping skills of distraction and time-out.
Lead your clients through emotion exposure with distraction using the following step-by-step guide. Be sure to leave at least ten minutes for feedback and troubleshooting after the exposure.
The Personalized Emotion Efficacy Plan is intended to help clients review and consolidate what they’ve learned. Having a plan written down will assist with this, giving them something to refer to after treatment has ended to practice and to prevent relapse. Encourage clients to take time to think about what has worked for them and what they want to continue to work on, as well as any questions they have about skills that were more difficult for them.
Clients will practice mindful acceptance with distraction. As with previous weeks, invite them to try using distraction—even if they don’t feel flooded—to help them begin to internalize how to use mindful coping.
Clients will also review all the EET skills they’ve learned and complete the Personalized Emotion Efficacy Plan worksheet, which you’ll review in Session 8.
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation…just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Before You Act, Distract
Emotions mirror what we pay attention to. If we pay attention to people, things, or situations that anger or upset us, our feelings will reflect that. And the intensity of those emotions can make it hard to act on our values. If we switch attention to something else, our feelings will reflect the new experience we’ve chosen. We have the power to shift how we feel by shifting our attention. There are several benefits from using distraction:
Avoiding Avoidance
Sometimes it’s hard to tell if you’re using mindful coping to avoid your emotions or to move in the direction of your values. If you’re not sure, you can ask yourself this basic question: “Am I using this skill to move toward my values or to avoid my emotion?” Using distraction after you observe and accept your emotional experience can be a life-improving, values-consistent choice in situations when you’re getting overwhelmed and need to “downshift” an emotion wave.
Mindful Coping with Distraction
Follow these steps for mindful distraction:
Remember, if you experience a strong, painful emotion in the course of daily life, you can do one of two things: You can stay with the feeling, noticing the moment of choice, and responding with a values-based action. Or, if the pain is pushing you hard toward emotion-driven behavior and you can’t muster a values-based response, you can mindfully choose distraction (or any of the other mindful coping skills).
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Distraction Strategies
The following handout will help you identify mindful coping ideas to distract yourself when you have already tried to use mindful acceptance and/or values-based action and are still feeling triggered.
Pay Attention to Someone Else
One effective way to shift your attention when you are emotionally triggered is to place your attention on someone else. Following are some examples of how you might do this, as well as a space for your own ideas:
Pay Attention to Something Else
Our brains are amazing thinking machines. They produce millions of thoughts every day. Our emotions follow what we think about, and you can intentionally shift your thoughts when you’re triggered to decrease your emotional activation. Following are some examples of how you might do this, as well as a space for your own ideas:
Be Productive
Many people don’t schedule time to take care of themselves or their living environments. Doing tasks and chores can be an effective way to shift your attention away from your distress. Following are some examples, and a place for you to add your own ideas:
Do a Pleasurable Activity
Alternatives to Self-Destructive Behaviors
Some people who struggle with overwhelming emotions use self-destructive behaviors to temporarily relieve their distress. Instead of continuing to hurt yourself, consider using some tools to help shift your emotions rather than acting on them. Following are some examples, and a place for you to add your own ideas:
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Take a Time-Out
Sometimes when you get emotionally triggered, the best thing you can do is leave, or take a “time-out.” If you find yourself in an extremely distressing situation with someone or something, and, after trying to practice mindful acceptance or enact a values-based action, you’re still very upset, it’s often best to distance yourself and shift your attention away from the trigger to a more positive present-moment experience.
Try to remember that if you’re already overwhelmed by your emotions, it will be more difficult to resolve your problem in a healthy way. If you stay in the situation, you may make it worse than it is already. If you can put some distance between you and the situation, and give yourself time to calm your emotions, you can better think about what to do next.
It may be helpful to rehearse doing this, or to write a short script ahead of time, so that you’ll know exactly how you want to excuse yourself from the situation. If you don’t feel you have time to excuse yourself, sometimes just walking away is the best you can do to keep from making a difficult situation worse.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Emotion Efficacy Therapy Skills
You now have a whole new set of skills to use to help you make choices that are effective and consistent with your values when you get triggered. Use the following list to review the EET skills you’ve learned and to complete the Personalized Emotion Efficacy Plan worksheet.
Mindful Acceptance
Mindful Coping
Values-Based Action
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Personalized Emotion Efficacy Plan
Use this list of EET skills to remember what works for you when you get emotionally triggered. In addition, there is space for you to write down what else you have learned or want to remember about your relationship with your emotions.
Mindful Acceptance Skills (O + A)
When I am triggered, I can practice the following mindful acceptance skills:
Values-Based Action (O + A + Choose Values-Based Action)
When I’ve practiced mindful acceptance (observe + accept) and want to choose to move toward my values, I can choose the following values-based actions:
Situation VBA
Situation VBA
Situation VBA
Situation VBA
Situation VBA
Mindful Coping (O + A + Choose Mindful Coping)
When I have practiced mindful acceptance and/or have tried to use values-based action and still feel at risk of acting on destructive urges, I can choose the following skills:
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Session 7 Skills Practice
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Skills Practice Record
Emotion Efficacy Therapy
Directions: Place a check mark next to the skill you practice each day. Record any triggers at the bottom. Bring this record to your next session.
Day 1 |
Day 2 |
Day 3 |
Day 4 |
Day 5 |
Day 6 |
Day 7 |
|
Observe the four parts of an emotion: sensations, feelings, thoughts, and urges. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and surf your emotion wave, with SUDS. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a values-based action. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a relaxation skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a self-soothing skill. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a coping thought. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose to practice radical acceptance. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a distraction task or activity. |
|||||||
Observe, accept, and choose a time-out. |
Emotional triggers: Record any events or emotions that are distressing during this week.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016
Session 8 attempts to pull together and consolidate everything clients have learned during EET treatment. The session begins with a review of the Personalized Emotion Efficacy Plans with ample time for feedback and troubleshooting. Clients will get to choose from their skills to do a final exposure using either emotion or imaginal exposure and an EET skill of their choice. Next, group members will rate their emotion efficacy and share how they think they can continue to increase it. Finally, clients receive validation for participating in treatment, especially for their willingness to learn and try new behaviors. Outcome measures would ideally be administered before clients leave session.
Materials
Overview
Procedures
For the first ten minutes of session, lead clients through mindful acceptance practice using the guided script. Ask clients to provide feedback about their experience as an opportunity for learning and troubleshooting.
Briefly review Session 7 skills and ask clients to share feedback about their weekly practice using their Skills Practice record.
Using the completed PEEPs, ask each client to share what he or she recorded. Solicit any questions they have about the skills. Emphasize that treatment is only eight weeks and that skills that are more difficult will become easier the more they are practiced.
Lead your clients through a final exposure using a situation and skill of their choosing. Be sure to leave at least fifteen minutes for feedback.
Now that treatment is coming to an end, you’ll want to ask clients to informally rate their emotion efficacy when they began treatment and now, at the end. You can use the Emotion Efficacy Scale as a brief measure pretreatment and posttreatment. Or, you can conduct an informal assessment by asking them to rate their emotion efficacy using a scale from 0 to 10, with 1 being no emotion efficacy, 5 being able to use skills about 50 percent of the time, and 10 being able to use skills every time they are emotionally triggered to choose a VBA. You might also ask group members what they think will help them increase their emotion efficacy.
As noted in chapter 1, changing behavior is difficult when people have been hardwired for survival, have a negativity bias, and—since these clients are seeking treatment for emotion problems—are usually highly reactive. Validate clients for being willing and flexible enough to try new behaviors and make choices that will often feel unnatural when they are first used. Remind them that they can continue to improve their emotion efficacy through practice, especially in an emotionally activated state.
This is also a time to speak to any specific challenges that were shared and overcome in the group, how the group may have supported each of its members, and what they were able to learn from each other.
If you are using posttreatment measures, administer them at the end of this session. A list of recommended questionnaires is provided in chapter 10, and full versions are available in Appendix A: Outcome Measures.
Script for Guided Mindful Acceptance
For the next ten minutes I’m going to lead you through a mindful acceptance practice exercise. You will practice observing and accepting your emotional experience in the present moment. Practicing mindful acceptance in a neutral state will build your emotion efficacy muscle and make it easier for you to use this skill when you are triggered.
First, just sit comfortably, and either close your eyes or relax your gaze and pick a spot to focus on in front of you.
Now, take a few minutes to notice any sensations in your body. Scan your body until you find a sensation and rest your attention on it. See if you can let it be just as it is and get curious about it. Notice its size and shape; whether it’s moving or staying the same; if there’s any temperature or tension to it. See if you can soften to it, or even lean into the sensation…
Now, see if you can identify a feeling label that goes with the sensation…just name it and allow it to be as it is without judgment or reacting to it.
Next, we’ll spend a few minutes just noticing and watching our thoughts. Our brains produce different kinds of thoughts all the time, and the key is not to get involved with them. Instead, as each thought arises, you can simply say, “There’s a thought,” and then let the thought go. Then, just return to the present moment, and wait for the next thought to arise. For the next few minutes, notice your thoughts until I say stop…
Okay, now stop. Next, see if there’s an urge that goes with your sensations or thoughts. It could be an urge to do something or not do something. Try to just sit with the urge. Notice what it’s like not to act on the urge, to just surf it.
[Allow the client to sit with the urge for 30 seconds. Then repeat the sequence one more time.]
Before you come out of this exercise, take a few deep breaths and slowly open your eyes as you bring your attention back to the room.
Emotion Efficacy Therapy (EET) © 2016