At first, as the bus came down the slope to the main street of the resort, Carlos thought that the crowd welcoming them was going to be bigger than before. The street was busier than he’d ever seen it. New housing had been built along the hillside. The amusement arcade, the one with the frame and scooter simulators, had trebled in size. More umbrellas were on the beach, and swimmers in the sea.
When he stepped down on the pavement however, only Chun’s boyfriend, Den, and Tourmaline were at the stop to greet them. He wasn’t bothered by Nicole’s absence—this time, he’d remembered to check his phone, and found a message saying she’d meet him in the Touch in an hour or so. All the shops on the arcade were open, and the street was thronged with so many young men and women strolling and chatting and buying beachwear and swigging from cans and licking at cones that it looked like a coach-load or two of singles and couples tourists had just disembarked. The difference was that when you looked past the gaudy sun hats and flashy shades and colourful beach bags you saw they were all wearing khaki T-shirts and trousers and boots.
“Christ,” said Rizzi, weaving her way along the thronged pavement with one arm around Den, “you find some nice wee unspoiled place for the holidays, and the next thing you know it’s overrun by fucking Club Med.”
“Comparable to the worst excesses of the French Revolution,” said Chun, fanning his face with his hand.
“You say that like it’s a bad thing,” said Carlos. He didn’t recognise anyone—no surprise, after his student days he’d barely met another Accelerationist except online—but several did a double take when they saw him. He kept a lookout for Jacqueline Digby, but that was more a passing nod to an old flame than a spark of new hope.
Beauregard, to Carlos’s surprise, camped it up right back. “The heat! The noise! And worst of all, the people!”
“Stop bitching,” said Karzan, struggling along behind them. “We have new comrades!”
“Yeah, that’s what’s bad about it,” said Carlos. “How the fuck are we supposed to train and integrate scores of new fighters?”
“Think about it,” said Beauregard. “How long have we been away? Hours. That’s months here. Time enough to train them all. Even since we lifted from SH-17, they’ll have had more time than we had.”
“More to the point,” said Carlos, covering his annoyance with himself for not having thought it through, “how are we going to find seats in the Touch?”
They all laughed, a little ruefully. But it turned out they had nothing to worry about. Other bars and cafés had opened along the seafront to meet the new demand, and the Digital Touch was as half empty and welcoming as it had always been. This time, Carlos did manage to buy the first round.
“The real worry,” said Beauregard, out on the deck, a beer in his hand and Tourmaline on his knee, “is whether we’re supposed to lead all these new recruits.” He looked around from one face to another, shaking his head. “Can’t see all of you lot becoming generals. Or any of you, come to that.”
“Thank you, sarge,” said Zeroual. “I was a colonel in the Tunisian army and a brigade commander in the resistance.”
“And your point would be?” Beauregard said.
Zeroual’s smile was thinner than his moustache. “Nevertheless, we may have something to teach the newcomers.”
“No doubt the lady will tell us in due course,” said Karzan. “Meanwhile, and speaking of ‘course,’ here comes our first.”
Seafoods and salads were indeed arriving.
“I’ve warned you before about attempting English puns,” said Beauregard. “Even Tourmaline can do better than that. No offence, sweetie.”
“None taken,” said Tourmaline, reaching for a hot mollusc. “I’ll take this instead. Always did like mussels.” She nudged Beauregard’s triceps.
“You’re not doing my case any favours,” Beauregard grouched.
“Nah, they’re not favours, they’re starters,” said Tourmaline, taking another.
Beauregard put his head in his hands and groaned.
When Nicole arrived she didn’t waste time in explaining developments. She called them all inside to watch the television screen above the bar. A few of the local regulars were present, and a gaggle of newcomers who regarded the veterans askance and with evident awe. The squad and their camp followers commandeered a couple of tables, ordered another round and settled down.
The screen was reaching the end of an episode of its midday soap opera, a convoluted and never-ending tale set in a Moon colony corridor, originally in Yoruba and dubbed into the local synthetic language. That they now all spoke it made the plot even less comprehensible than it had been when the dialogue had been so much babble. The usual portentous closing drumbeats and frozen shocked faces signalled the day’s cliffhanger ending. The hour turned over. A trumpet bray and swirl of colour announced something none of the fighters had ever seen before on local television, but which everyone else there—locals, bar staff, recent recruits—had apparently got used to: news.
What Carlos expected from that medium and format was breathless and brainless: flashy graphics, grainy pictures; jingoism and talking airheads. Back in the day, he’d become hardened to air war, drone war, media and online war, information overload filtered to sound bite and gore-shock.
What he got was far more sober. It took him a moment to realise that the difference in tone was all about moments: the thousandfold discrepant timescales of the sim and the real outside worlds. The news was presented entirely as if the sim really was the planet H-0, and the conflict was going on far away around SH-0. The transfer of fighters to and from the sim was described—never quite explicitly stated, but taken for granted, shared and tacit—as if happening by long-range tight-beam transmission. Everything happened, from the point of view of his own experiences, in slow motion. The deployments to and from the station were like the movements of fleets in a naval conflict. What he’d lived through as small-scale infantry skirmishes on the ground happened like tank battles, with long ponderous manoeuvres giving way to brief decisive exchanges of fire, above and through which the scooters wallowed like blimps.
The runaway Arcane Disputes modular complex was, on this scale, a mighty floating fortress breaking away from the mainland of the station and making its stately course to a new and distant ocean. Safer to let it go than to fight it too close to home, and with its intent as yet unclear.
The absence of sensational coverage almost dulled the shock of realising what was going on, on both sides. Locke Provisos had by now mobilised as many walking dead war criminals—those khaki-clad tourists outside, and at the adjacent tables—as it feasibly could: ninety, including his own squad. Two other agencies, Morlock Arms and Zheng Reconciliation Services, had already done the same.
Arcane Disputes was raising troops, too—and doing something far more dangerous.
It was mobilising the enemy itself. This was no incomprehensible, dog-in-the-manger escalation of their dispute with Locke, Astro, and indeed with Gneiss. The agency wasn’t just hanging on to the robots it had captured. It was actively siding with them.
The rebel robots on SH-17 had, it now turned out, made contact with holdouts from the previous outbreak of machine consciousness that had been crushed one Earth year or so earlier. Some of these had lurked in the distant gas giant G-0 system, dormant but alert. Others had lain low among the many small exomoons (and moonlets of exomoons) around SH-17. Worst-case scenarios were that some rogue AIs were hidden inside the software and hardware of the station itself. Only a handful of the original insurgent intelligences might have initially survived, but that didn’t matter. Replicating macroscale robotic machinery required only the dispersal of microscale packages, propelled by tiny lightsails on the exosolar flux like thistledown on wind. All that these seeds had to do to flourish was fall on stony ground.
Those around SH-0 had burrowed deep inside the small bodies, turning machinery intended for exploring and construction to their own purposes. Literally under deep cover, within fragments of rubble too small to have been more than catalogued as yet, they had built the capacity to listen, to observe, to act—and to move the entire rock. Some of these micro-moons were in effect spacecraft. What this could lead to Carlos knew all too well from the kinetic weapon warning shots.
Now, with the emergence of an open revolt among newly conscious robots—the term “freebots,” Carlos noted with some disquiet, had slipped into the news analysts’ and presenters’ discourse, from God knew where but quite possibly from Arcane or the rebel robots themselves—the dormant and hidden remnants of the defeated outbreak had emerged like sleeper cells.
And now they were allied with, or had subverted, or had themselves been manipulated by Arcane Disputes. Nobody knew which of these, or some combination or variant thereof, was true. Nobody could even be sure that the truth didn’t lie with some alternative entirely.
The wildest speculation was that Arcane and the freebots were all being controlled by an outside force. It was established fact that there was multicellular alien life on SH-0. What if some of it was intelligent, or at least purposeful, and had seized the opportunity to disrupt the ongoing human invasion of the system? That idea generally got short shrift, but even the sober possibilities were disturbing.
Disturbing, Carlos thought, was not quite the word. Whatever was going on, the entire mission profile—the whole vast project of settlement and terraforming—was being put in jeopardy.
“This is fucking insane,” said Rizzi, when the half-hour of news was over. “Why are you letting them get away with it?”
“We’re not letting them get away with it,” said Nicole, sounding uncharacteristically irritable and defensive. She waved a hand about, the gesture encompassing the new fighters nearby and the others out on the street. “We’re preparing to hit them with everything we’ve got.”
“With respect,” said Beauregard, “that doesn’t seem to be the case.”
“How so?” Nicole asked, eyes narrowing.
“I know you’re pulling up more troops, building more fighting machines and spacecraft and so on, but come on. Those Arcane fuckers and blinkers are playing with fire. You brought us back from the dead just to take out a dozen conscious robots. Now you’ve got all of them plus an unknown number of others, and an agency with as much capacity to churn out weapons as we have. And raise many more fighters, if they go down that route. Or arm robots and freebots, come to that, which would be even worse. These so-called freebots obviously have the capacity to make weapons—at least kinetic and ballistic—of their own. They hit us with them. OK, warning shots, but we got the message loud and clear. If you were hitting them with everything you’ve got, you wouldn’t be pussy-footing around with infantry and aerospace. You’d be hitting their base on SH-17 and all their little moons and the goddamn Arcane module itself with KE and HE weapons. Pulverise them to rubble and be done with it, then fry any leftover robot minds and human uploads with EMP. And, yes, I do mean an electromagnetic pulse from a nuclear weapon if necessary.”
“But—”
Beauregard raised a hand. “I know all about the delicate and complex question of property rights and the value of the scientific knowledge and incalculable future benefits that might be derived from keeping SH-17 et cetera as pristine as possible, and all the wretched rest of it. Your holographic philosopher explained all that to us down there on the moon. But any cost-benefit analysis—heck, common sense—would tell you that it’s better to lose a little than to lose a lot, and to risk losing everything. Remember what you said about being at the mercy of intellects with no mercy and lots of curiosity? Remember you said to us, when you were hyping us up for this fight, ‘I advise you not to lose’? Well, lady, right here and now that’s what I advise you.”
By now he was pointing at Nicole, his finger quivering, his voice shaking, his face and fair scalp red. He took a deep breath and a gulp of now flat beer and sat back, glowering.
Carlos glanced at him, then at Nicole, who seemed taken aback by the outburst. The bar staff were looking askance, the new recruits at nearby tables perplexed. Carlos was a bit rattled himself. He’d never seen Beauregard come anywhere close to losing his temper. In previous stressful situations, of which Carlos had seen him in plenty, what had been perturbing about the man was his calm.
Carlos leaned in and murmured, “I wouldn’t have put it with such vehemence, but I think Belfort speaks for all of us. And I think whatever your answer is concerns everyone here.”
Nicole nodded. “Very well, I’ll tell them all.”
Carlos stood up, raised his voice, and made lifting motions with his palms.
“Everyone out on the deck!”
Nicole took her accustomed commanding place on the rail, cigarette and glass poised, knees crossed, hair stirred by the sea breeze. The squad, and the fourteen new fighters who happened to be in the bar, stood or sat. Even the regulars and local partners hung about at the back, listening and passing drinks forward.
“OK,” said Nicole. “You all heard or overheard what the sergeant here just said. Now I can’t say I blame him, though he could have picked a better time and place. Nevertheless, I’m sure some of you have some doubts about the Direction’s strategy in dealing with this emergency. That’s understandable. The Direction is playing a very deep, long game. It has countless contending interests to reconcile. There are even some companies that see opportunities in having conscious robots, and are clamouring to save the rebel robots for study. Others are ready to go to severe legal action, even go to war, to foreclose that possibility. Others still are so appalled at even threatening serious conflict that they are serving writs by the millisecond at anything and anyone that raises these matters speculatively. Others again… as I said, it’s complicated, and even that’s an oversimplification. I represent the Direction in this environment and to this company, but I can’t begin to grasp the complexity of its plans and its actions.
“But I do know this. The Direction knows far more than I do, more than any of us do. The Direction back on Earth planned this mission, and laid out a development programme for millennia to come. The Direction module within the mission has so far executed that programme with astonishing precision and adaptation to new circumstances. The AIs that run this virtual world, and that command vast operations out there in real space, and that brought you all back from the dead, are a lot smarter than we are. I know that, and just by reflecting for a moment on your very presence here you must know that, too.
“So to be perfectly honest and completely blunt, any strategic thinking any of us may work out on the back of a cigarette packet”—she held hers up, just in case people didn’t understand what she was talking about—“is unlikely to be an improvement on what they’ve come up with. I don’t say I know what they’re doing, but I do say I know that they know what they’re doing.”
“If the Direction and the company AIs are so smart,” came the inevitable voice from the back, “how come there are any robots left from the revolt a year ago still around to make trouble? And how come these robots rebelled in the first place?”
Good question, Carlos thought. Nicole’s argument so far struck him as a bit like that of a theologian tackling the problem of evil, all the way from the inscrutability of the divine purpose to the embarrassing question of how the Adversary had been able to rebel at all, and just what it had rebelled against.
“Good questions,” said Nicole.
She lit another cigarette, and drew in, then sighed out.
“The answer is very simple: nature is infinitely bigger than the biggest AI. The AIs are smarter than any of us, but they can’t predict and control everything. It’s elementary chaos theory, or to give it its popular designation—Murphy’s Law. Random changes happen all the time. Mistakes accumulate. Correcting them brings further changes. As someone smarter than me once said, evolution is smarter than you. And that’s true even if ‘you’ are a mind so vast that the very word ‘you’ has no meaning. This entire system will one day be a garden of delight, for our descendants and inheritors and with luck for us, for each and every one of you.
“Yes, you! And you and you and you! So remember this—in even the best gardens, weeds spring up. Even the greatest gardener can’t stop them sprouting. But even the least of gardeners can do a bit of weeding. We’re the weedkiller, my friends.”
She tossed her cigarette end and vaulted to the deck and raised her glass.
“Let’s do a good job of it!”
It was awkward for the crowd to clap with drinks in their hands. Instead, they stomped and roared. Carlos grinned at Nicole as she rejoined them.
“That was great,” he said, not meaning it.
She hadn’t answered Beauregard’s question. She had merely quietened the doubts it had raised. As he swung an arm around her shoulders and inhaled her smoky hair, Carlos glanced behind him to see what Beauregard made of it. The sceptical sergeant had already slipped away.
Tourmaline in tow, Beauregard prowled the strip. There were more establishments than he remembered from their last shore leave. In every bar where even one fighter could be found, Beauregard drank one slow bottle of beer and listened. All the groups had been through much the same training as his own had—he could quibble over details, see things he’d have done differently, but a lot of that was just legacy style from different army or militia backgrounds: here a Russian, there a Nigerian. Unlike his lot, they’d all been told from the start that they would be part of a larger force, human and machine. Nobody was going to be a general, or be for that matter in any higher rank than Carlos or himself. The general staff work, the planning, the strategy, the logistics would all be handled by the company AIs—he found it hard to imagine the Locke entity posing as a field marshal or fleet admiral, but no doubt they’d come up with a more fitting avatar than the company logo if the AI had to manifest in that role.
And yet, as with his own squad, the grunts had been assured they were still essential, irreplaceable. In action the final decisions rested with each and every one of them. Fucking bizarre, but not wholly unfamiliar. It was like a baroque elaboration of the doctrine that soldiers should disobey illegal orders, and the more recent rulings on drone and robot warfare. The human in the loop. He’d always thought it impracticable crap that did more to ease conscience elsewhere than to apply it where it mattered.
He found what he sought in Seeds of Change. The bar was much more of a dive than the Touch, all hologram floor show and thumping music and low-watt lasers slicing through herbal haze. Noticed Harry Newton, a Londoner. Checked him out with the grunts who knew him. Harold Isaac Newton, no less. Aspirational parents, vindicated. A POC but one of the good ones. Self-disciplined. Moved and sat still like a martial arts master. Beauregard approached Newton at the bar. As he caught his eye there was a moment of mutual recognition, not of each other as individuals but of the type.
Beauregard hauled up a stool, propped Tourmaline on his knee, ordered raksi and got talking. After they’d sunk half the bottle the two men went for a slash.
“Seen that serial about Turing?” Beauregard asked, eyes down on a soul-satisfying torrent of piss.
“The warrior queer thing? Yeah.”
“Queen,” Beauregard corrected, automatically. Shook, zipped. “This feels a bit like that.”
A look of mock shock. “You coming on to me?”
Beauregard laughed. “No. You know what I mean and I know you know I know you know.”
Newton stared straight ahead at his hands under the dryer.
“Morning,” he said. “Sunrise. Jog on the beach.”
“Sounds like a plan,” said Beauregard.
They went back to the bar in silence and finished the bottle in conversation, raucous and innocuous.