Matthew James Taylor, my one and only brother, was my hero every day of my life when I was a little girl. He was the big brother of dreams, the one who all my friends adored and wished they could be around, no matter what stage of life I was at.
As a child I’d hear him sing in his bedroom, everything from Elvis Presley to Oasis, and I’d watch him in awe when he took the lead in school concerts, drama groups and anything that allowed him to take centre stage. Other boys were mad into following football and chasing women, but Matthew had one dream and one dream only and that was to sing.
At first my father tried to push him into sports of all sorts, thinking he wasn’t manly enough if he didn’t play rugby or cheer on the reds or blues or whoever was the popular soccer team of the day. But Matthew was always to be found in his bedroom with a guitar strumming along to the Top Ten hits, or in the music room that used to be our garage but was soon filled with second-hand keyboards, drums and everything under the sun that Matthew could gather to build his own idea of a ‘man shed’.
In many ways he was an isolated boy growing up, because in rural Ireland it was only cool to have alternative interests as long as you could still score points and goals when it came to Gaelic games and show some rough and tumble.
But Matthew wasn’t that type at all. He was quiet and gentle and the only time he’d raise his voice was when he was hitting the high notes of a Guns N’ Roses song.
‘He’s a deep boy,’ my mother used to say, as if in apology. ‘He thinks too much. Maybe his passion for music will be his saviour one day.’
And so, it became his thing.
I, on the other hand, could have stood on my head and done a jig to try and impress, but even if I could I’d never be seen to be talented like Matthew was. Emily often joked she was the invisible middle child, while at least I got some attention being the youngest, but Matthew was always the one to watch – the one who was destined to be different – and everyone came to adore him for it.
Now, to see him put down his tools as such, to have abandoned his university degree in architecture (which was a back-up plan he never thought he’d need anyhow), and to be working in the village corner shop back at home as he battled with the demons in his head was a bitter pill to swallow.
I follow the stone walls into Loughisland, a drive I could do with my eyes closed, and my heart swells when I see the familiar faces making their way up and down the little street where I will always call home.
It’s a quiet-looking place to the naked eye, but behind the scenes it’s a bustling little village, where the tiny primary school is the heart of the community and where everyone lives and breathes for football matches on a Sunday after Mass. I loved growing up here – a world away from Dublin and the city life that caught my stride since I left here almost ten years ago.
I park the car on the side of the street and walk towards Sullivan’s corner shop, which even in December has a huge ice cream cone outside advertising its famous 99s that everyone who passes through will stop for. The shop is attached to a pub of the same name where you’ll also find the local undertaker, should you ever need to plan a funeral when you’re doing your grocery shopping. Well, you never know, do you?
Across the street is the chapel with its adjoining cemetery, and I notice some very entrepreneurial thinker has opened a new florist’s alongside, meaning that every event or occasion, be it a christening, a wedding or a funeral, is well catered for. A tall, somewhat overpowering evergreen tree is decorated with bulbs of green, red and blue and a string of clear lights hang to tell us that it’s the season to be jolly.
I was christened in that very chapel on a sunny Saturday in April many years ago. I made my First Holy Communion there in a white dress handed down from Emily when I was seven, and it was the first place I heard a choir singing ‘Ave Maria’, which made me fall in love with live music when I was barely tall enough to see over the pews. We sang carols every year beneath a tree in the exact same place, which would then be replaced when spring came with pots of daffodils and snowdrops, then bursts of colour in summer that always made us proud of the locals who made such an effort to make the place so pretty.
The snow has thawed a little now, but a bitter winter breeze catches my breath, forcing me to tighten my scarf and quicken my step towards the shop front of Sullivan’s. I get there and stop, despite the sharp weather, to watch Matthew through the window serving a friendly local. A wave of sadness overcomes me from deep inside.
This is my hero, my big brother. How did he ever come to this?
His eyes light up when he sees me through the window before a familiar-sounding chime above the door marks my entrance. The shop smells of my childhood – of warmth, boiled sweets, newspapers and ice cream in wafers – and I rush across to give him a hug which he receives shyly. He is thinner than he used to be and his hair, which once upon a time sported every colour of the rainbow, is pale brown, lank and light. He is thirty-two years old now but he looks at least ten years older in his navy apron, worn-out jeans and with his tired, drained face.
‘You got my message then?’ he asks, his eyes wide in anticipation. ‘I probably wasn’t making much sense, but I hope you understood my rambling?’
His eyes crinkle as he smiles, which tells me he may have some good news. It’s far from what I was expecting. I didn’t listen to the voicemail he left me last night, but I can’t bring myself to tell him so. I just couldn’t do it. I was too afraid he may have found out about me and Tom and I wanted to speak to him in person, hence my unannounced visit.
‘Oh, did you leave me a voicemail?’ I bluff. ‘Sorry, I’m so bad at picking up messages.’
‘Some things never change,’ he says, wiping his hands on his apron. ‘I just said I wanted to meet up with you in the next day or two, so looks like we’re on the same wavelength, after all. I’ve something to tell you.’
I know by his face that it’s good news, which is a huge relief. Something to tell me? What on earth could it be?
‘I did see a missed call,’ I confess, feeling guilty now, ‘but decided on a visit home instead. I miss my big brother.’
Never one for big affection, he rolls his eyes and goes back in behind the overcrowded counter as another customer approaches. It’s the type of shop that used to feature in every Irish town or village but has died out over the years, replaced instead by heartless chain-stores that don’t reflect the soul of a community like this one does. Here, you can buy everything from a loaf of bread to your morning paper, but you’ll also find hardware, a pub and you can choose a coffin out the back if you need one.
‘I’ve a few things to tell you, one biggie and the other is a really cool idea for Mam and Dad, if you and Emily are up for it,’ he says as he punches numbers into an old-fashioned till, without acknowledging any further that I’ve no idea what he’s talking about. ‘I think it would be something different and would give Mam a lift this Christmas.’
‘Of course,’ I say with as much enthusiasm as I can muster. ‘We can talk more when you’ve finished your shift.’
I’m a little bit worried but only because this all seems too good to be true. Matthew wanted me to come here to share some big news, and to plan a Christmas surprise for our parents. It’s like the old Matthew is back, the one who used to be so bright and full of ideas and excitement.
He glances through the hatch behind him that looks into the bar where, as always, there is horse racing flashing on a TV high up in the background.
‘I can finish up here now,’ he tells me. ‘Look, do you want to pop next door and I’ll buy you a drink? Mrs Sullivan can mind this place too when I need a break. We have that sort of arrangement.’
‘Cool,’ I say to him. ‘I’ll let you get finished up.’
I make my way out onto the blustery street again, my head lost in wonder and steeped in time as it always is when I come back here.
Mrs Sullivan knows the score, I think to myself, realizing that Matthew’s ‘job’ at the shop is more for his benefit than theirs, of course. It’s a baby step back into society for him and a subtle level of responsibility that gives him a reason to keep going.
Four years of this have passed, though. We’d all hoped he’d have got better a whole lot sooner, but depression knows no boundaries and the black dog inside him doesn’t seem to want to move on just yet. Well, not until now perhaps, as he shows this light glimmer of excitement for the first time in a long, long while.
Mrs Sullivan, or Angela Martin as I know her as she was only a few years older than me at school, is the third Mrs Sullivan to run this place for as far back as I remember. She greets me shyly, a bit nervous as most people are around us city types who left Loughisland for wider shores, but she soon relaxes when we start chatting like I’ve never been away at all.
‘He’s doing so well,’ she tells me, wiping her hands on a brown and white tea towel. Nothing in here has changed a bit. The old chocolate-coloured stools at the bar are the same with their black metal legs that I used to have to climb up to reach my seat when Daddy and I would slip in here on a Saturday afternoon for a sneaky bet on the horses. I’d be fed Tayto Cheese & Onion crisps and bribed with a glass of Fanta while he chugged down a quick pint of the black stuff and prayed that his luck would come in.
‘I think working here can only be good for him,’ I say to Angela. ‘We’re worried sick for him, to be honest, but thanks to you and your family for giving him this chance.’
‘You know he wants to start a folk club?’ she says, as if she’s telling me she’s won the lottery. ‘Now, that’s a good sign! He’s showing an interest in music again at long last. Your mother is thrilled!’
We keep our voices down as the open hatch that adjoins the bar to the shop means noise can travel, but we don’t get to chat any further as just then Matthew makes his way in and joins me.
‘Have you ordered?’ he asks. ‘Have what you like, it’s my treat.’
He seems so chirpy and excited, which now all makes sense. The folk club here in the village, the job in the shop and whatever this Christmas surprise for Mam is. I dread the thought of bursting his bubble when I get round to mentioning Tom, but maybe, who knows, it could be good timing if he’s other more positive things on his mind.
‘I’ll have a gin and tonic,’ I say to Angela. ‘What are you having, Matthew?’
‘The usual,’ he says to Angela. ‘And don’t be expecting any fancy berries or glasses like goldfish bowls in here, Charlotte. A gin and tonic is a gin and tonic in Loughisland, not a bowl of mixed fruit.’
He laughs at his own joke and Angela pretends to be offended.
‘The original and the best,’ I say to them both and soon we are clinking our glasses together in true Christmas spirit. ‘So, what is it you want to tell me? It’s good news, I take it?’
Matthew sits up straight on the stool. ‘I thought, well it just came to me yesterday before I rang you …’
His appearance may be changing each time I see him but somewhere in there is still my big brother, still the one we all looked up to.
‘I was thinking,’ he continues. ‘Wouldn’t it be a great idea if we were to take Mam and Dad on a summer holiday next year, just the five of us? Well, Kevin too, I suppose, as he’s family now,’ says Matthew. ‘It’s their thirty-fifth wedding anniversary this year and I think after all the crap we’ve been through over the past while, it might be something to look forward to? As a family?’
I almost choke on my drink in delight. ‘I love it!’ I tell him.
‘You really think so?’
He’s showing so much hope for the first time in ages. He’s making plans. He’s excited about something once and for all. I lean across and hug him.
‘That’s the best idea ever!’ I say to him, and I really mean it. ‘Let’s get onto Emily and Kevin and we’ll surprise Mam and Dad with all the detail on Christmas Day. Is that what you’re thinking?’
‘Exactly,’ he agrees. ‘You know, Charlotte, I remember when I was just a nipper how Mam used to stand at the kitchen sink and say that if she ever came into money, she’d love to take us all to see the pyramids in Egypt. Now I know it will take a lot of money, but if we booked it for, say, August, it would give us all eight months to save the fare and some spending money. Does that sound OK?’
He has thought it all through and it’s breaking my heart in two.
‘That sounds absolutely spot on, Matthew! Oh, look at you! You’re looking so much brighter,’ I tell him. ‘How are you feeling? Are you coping any better these days? You definitely look like you are.’
He stares at his pint for a second and then breaks into a smile.
‘Well, the truth is I’m feeling stronger, yes. I’ve met someone, Charlotte,’ he reveals to me, circling his finger on the top of the glass, and his face instantly brightens. ‘Would you believe that I’ve managed to find another music type, just like me, who was visiting relatives here in the back of beyond? We started as friends, and it’s still early days, but it’s given me a whole new lease of life. We’re thinking of starting up a folk club here in the pub once a month. Don’t laugh, I know I’m a rocker at heart, but I’m excited. At long last I’m excited about something.’
I lift my drink and clink my glass against his with tears in my eyes.
‘Well, blow me down, big brother!’ I say to him. ‘That’s the best news in the world! Does she sing or what? Tell me more about her. This is just fantastic! Do Mam and Dad know yet?’
He looks away shyly. I’ve often imagined Matthew’s wedding day, him making a heartfelt speech, maybe singing to his bride at some part of the ceremony and my father speaking of his son and new wife, saying how much he is looking forward to welcoming her into the family. If this is really happening for him at last, I’m over the moon.
‘I told them last night,’ he whispers. ‘I wanted to tell you first, but in person, so I just had to tell them over dinner last night.’
I’m taken aback at that. ‘You wanted to tell me first? Why?’
‘I suppose you’ve always been the one I’ve felt closest to,’ he says. ‘The one I trusted the most. I know I may have pissed you off sometimes by looking out for you a little too much, but you’ve always been special to me, Charlotte.’
Ah … I feel my opportunity arise.
‘Sometimes a little bit too much,’ I say with a light laugh. I remember I’ve the car outside and decide to leave it there and walk the mile or so to our parents’ house so I can have another drink. That’s the effect Loughisland has on me. ‘Can I get another G and T please, Angela?’
Angela looks flustered as a new couple enter the bar and I can see the shop has a few customers too. Matthew really should be working and I’m relieved when he offers to get the drinks while she attends the adjoining shop. When he sits back down, I fear the moment to tell him about Tom may have passed.
‘So, before I get into all the gory detail about my love life, what about you, little sis?’ he asks me when we get back to our conversation. ‘I know you’re busy being teacher of the year but is there anyone special in your life right now?’
Yes! It’s all happening so organically so I decide to grasp the opportunity. I can quiz him further on his mysterious new lover in a while, but this is my big moment to tell him about Tom.
I take a deep breath. I’ve practised this the whole way from Dublin to Loughisland and now it’s time for the big reveal.
‘I’ve met someone too, yes,’ I tell him softly. ‘And, just like you, it’s early days, but I’m feeling it, you know? I think when you know, you know.’
He brightens instantly. ‘That’s so true, sis. So, who is he? A work colleague, I bet! I always thought you’d end up surprising us all by falling for Mr Sensible who teaches Year Fives and wears corduroy trousers and—’
Oh no, no, no. I am so not going down this road for a second.
‘You mean you hoped I would,’ I interrupt him, unable to disguise the jag in my voice. ‘Oh Matthew, I’ve no interest in Mr Sensible with corduroy whatever, you must know that? I could never go there, in fact I’d run in the opposite direction from anyone remotely beige. Please cut me some slack for goodness’ sake.’
He looks offended now but I’m not sorry. I didn’t question or judge his type of woman when he just told me he’d found a kindred spirit so why should I let him do the same to me?
‘What I mean is, I hope you’ve met someone who matches your intelligence,’ he quickly covers up. ‘Someone good enough for you, who will be good to you, someone who isn’t like—’
‘Someone who isn’t like Tom Farley, you mean?’ I interrupt him and he actually jumps.
‘What?’
‘Is that what you’re getting at?’ I ask him, still nipped by the very idea of me falling for Mr Sensible. ‘You’d love me to be with anyone on this earth as long as it isn’t a womanizing rock wannabe like Tom Farley who maybe is my type after all?!’
‘Where is this coming from?’ he asks me, as if someone has just punched him in the stomach. ‘Why are you talking about him?’
This is not going as I’d rehearsed it at all, but I can’t hold back. I’m losing it. I’ve lost my way, and everything goes into some strange sort of slow motion as the name Tom Farley seems to catch the back of my brother’s throat.
His mouth twists a little and he grabs his beer and takes a long, thirst-filled drink then slams it down just a bit too hard for my liking. Here we go …
‘What on earth do you have against him?’ I ask him, wanting to know once and for all the truth behind the stupid row that changed their whole future. That changed my future perhaps, too.
‘Why the hell are you bringing him up all of a sudden?’ Matthew asks me. He looks ashen now as opposed to the bright happy chappy I just witnessed. ‘We weren’t even talking about Tom Farley! You know I’ve a history with him that I can’t discuss. My doctor told me never to indulge in conversation with him or about him. Do you know why?’
‘No?’ I say, afraid now of what is to come.
‘You really have no idea?’ he says to me, looking at me now as if I’m telling lies. I shake my head.
‘I don’t, Matthew,’ I tell him. ‘I mean, I know that he asked for my number and you turned on him and—’
Matthew’s voice is shaking when he responds. I really seem to have hit a nerve more than I ever could have expected to.
‘Are you trying to upset me?’ he asks, his face crumpling now. ‘Is that what you came here for? Are you bringing him up just to test me or tease me? Why are you talking about Tom Farley, Charlotte? I’ve left all that behind. I’m trying to move on!’
I realize that I’m shaking now too as he raises his voice. It’s not like him. It’s so not like him and it’s frightening me. He downs the remainder of his pint, leaving me dizzy with where I’m going now with this conversation, and calls for a vodka and Coke from Angela who looks like she’d rather be anywhere than near us right now. She pours him a drink and sets me up with another gin and tonic and I feel like I’m going to need it.
‘Look, I just need to be honest with you. I met him a few days ago, OK?’ I say to Matthew.
I can’t stop now. I have to finish what I came here to tell him.
‘I just bumped into him on a night out really unexpectedly and we spent some time together catching up. He is so, so sorry for whatever happened between the two of you, and the whole breaking up of the band that meant so much to you all, but we’ve all moved on like you said, Matthew. Can’t you forgive him? It’s not good for you to hold onto so much anger.’
Matthew drums his fingers on the bar. He shakes his head really slowly.
‘It’s you and him again, isn’t it?’ he says to me, closing his eyes in disbelief. ‘I don’t believe this! That’s what you came here to tell me, isn’t it? Isn’t it?’
I’m afraid to go any further now. I want to change my mind and tell him no, of course it isn’t, but then I remember Tom and his kindness, his way of knowing me, of how he makes me feel, of how we were pushed apart when we were meant to be together, of the second chance we have and of how I drove all this way to make sure that nothing and no one would ever come between us again.
‘We want to give it a try,’ I whisper to Matthew. ‘Is it really that bad for you if we do?’
I reach out to touch him, but he pushes my hand away.
‘Charlotte, please!’ he says defiantly, and then downs his vodka and Coke in two gulps.
‘Are you denying me being with the one person I want to be with over a stupid band?’ I ask him. ‘Are you really going to hold onto this forever? Why don’t you want me to be with him?’
He inhales and I fear what is coming next. There is more to this story, I just know it.
‘He will only ever be trouble, Charlotte! You’re making a big mistake, believe me, but hey, maybe I’m wrong? Maybe you two will live happily ever after,’ he spits at me and gets up from the stool. ‘But I very much doubt it.’
He walks away, leaving me puce-faced in front of Angela who is finding it hard not to look in our direction.
And at that he is gone.
My head is spinning with what just happened. I just don’t understand. What on earth could spark such a reaction? Why is he so angry at Tom, so bitter and mad that he can’t even stand the mention of his name? I look at Angela in utter confusion and embarrassment that she witnessed such an uproar, but she looks away until I say a quick goodbye to her, deciding to go after him and demand some answers. This time she does meet my eye, but her look is now one of pity, like I’m the last to know on this sorry occasion. I jump from the bar stool to follow my brother out onto the street where I’m met with a furious blizzard of fresh snow.
‘Matthew! Matthew, where are you going? Wait for me, please!’
I’m blinded by the wind, the snow and the haze of alcohol that’s pumping through my veins and blurring my already confused state of mind.
‘Matthew!’
I reach into my pocket to find my car keys, knowing that even out here in the middle of nowhere it’s too risky to drive. My head is racing, my heart is thumping, and I know there’s no way I could get behind the wheel to follow him, wherever he has disappeared to. I’ve had almost three drinks in a very short space of time and my emotions are running high. I can’t drive, I just can’t.
But I don’t know what else to do. The snow is thick and heavy now, and then I see him. I can just about see Matthew getting into his car across the street.
‘Matthew, no!’ I shout into the roaring wind. ‘You can’t drive in this weather! You’ve had too much to drink! Matthew, please don’t!’
But he can’t hear me of course, so I try to cross the street to get to him and a car slams on the brakes, the driver shouts obscenities at me and I take a step back onto the safety of the pavement, cursing myself for being so careless in my despair. I can’t see him any more. He’s in the car. Oh no, he’s in the car!
‘Matthew, please!’ I call out into nowhere. ‘Don’t do this, I’m begging you! It’s too dangerous!’
I hear the windscreen wipers scream and I too scream out in frustration. The engine roars and I roar too, but it’s too late. He is gone.