The Mystery in the Old Attic

“What?” Violet seemed very reluctant to leave her book, but looked up when Jessie came toward her.

“A diary.” Jessie was already flipping through the pages. Though they were yellow with age, they did not fall apart when Jessie touched them. Violet bent over the book, as excited as Jessie. The handwriting belonged to a young girl who wrote in script. Some of the words were crossed out or smudged from the fountain pen, which made the diary hard to read.

Brockton, Michigan

8 November 1900

This diary was a present from Father for my twelfth birthday. I am going to write in it every week.

“Oh, she’s just my age,” said Jessie. She could not believe that a girl who had sat in this library, perhaps in the very chair Violet had just been sitting in, was writing in her diary almost one hundred years ago.

Today, Father gave me a lovely tea party. All my dolls came, including Samantha, who is very old. I dressed her in a long pink dress with a lace collar.

Betsy and Ann, my best friends from school, came to the party, too. So did Mother, who felt well enough to come downstairs. That made the party extra special.

We ate cream cakes and gingerbread and drank real tea with lemon in it. Because it was my birthday, Mother gave us permission to use Grandmother’s special blue-and-white china.

“I wonder if that’s the china we used at lunchtime,” said Jessie. “Emily can tell us so much about this house.”

Violet nodded as she wrapped her arms around her shoulders. “I can’t believe you found this. Let’s show the others.”

When Grandfather saw the diary, he held it in his hands and just stared at it. “You know, Emily is the daughter of the couple whose portraits are in the dining room.”

“Oh, no, not of the woman who died,” Violet said.

Grandfather nodded.

Soon all five Aldens were seated around the kitchen table listening while Jessie read the diary aloud.

17 November 1900

Mother is still very weak, so weak there are days she does not leave her bed. I visit her when I come home from school. We still laugh and talk, but I can tell she is very tired. She has been teaching me to write sonnets and riddles. Mother loves poetry. Today we wrote a riddle together about a clock. Here it is:

I run around in circles, yet my path is always straight.

I can be quiet or noisy; sometimes I am late.

Of size and shape, I have many. I come in circles or squares.

And some, seeing me sit so calmly, think I have no cares.

If I run slower or faster, things do not work as smoothly.

So I try to be on time not to upset things unduly.

Can you guess what I am?

“Wow,” said Benny. “I wouldn’t be able to guess that was a clock.”

“She does give us lots of clues, though,” Jessie said. “Like here when she’s talking about being late, running slower or faster, and being on time.” Jessie pointed out the words to Benny as she talked.

Benny nodded. “Oh, now I understand.”

Jessie continued reading:

24 November 1900

I can tell Father is very worried about Mother. He has been ever since she fell from her horse last month. The doctor now comes to the house to visit her almost every other day.

There wasn’t another entry until December 15:

I have not been able to write in my diary in a long time. Mother died on December first.

“How sad,” said Jessie.

“She was awfully young to lose her mother,” said Grandfather. The children nodded.

21 December 1900

Mother left me her diamond engagement ring, and many other things like her linens and lace. Father says the ring is very valuable, and I should keep it in a safe place. It is a beautiful ring with a pearl and a diamond on a high setting. Here is a picture of it:

3 January 1901

I have put the ring in a little box with some of Mother’s lace handkerchiefs. I have hidden it in a special place that meant a lot to Mother and me, and I have not told anyone where it is, not even Father.

“I wish she would tell her diary where it is,” said Benny.

“Maybe she does,” said Jessie as she turned the page.

“The ring may no longer be in the house,” said Grandfather. “No doubt Emily took it with her when she grew up and moved away.”

“Here is a long entry about a sleigh ride Emily took with Betsy and Ann,” said Jessie.

“I want to hear more about the ring,” said Benny.

“Oh, I found something,” said Jessie. “Here Emily says she’s practicing her riddle writing. And she’s written a riddle about where the ring is hidden.”

“Oh, Jessie, please read it!” Benny was so impatient, he wiggled in his chair.

Jessie cleared her throat. “A riddle by Emily Rebecca Taylor,” she began:

My ring lies near the waiter who brings me up my tea.

As I hear his creaking sounds,

I hope my ring will not be found — by anyone but me.

When Jessie finished, the others looked at one another. “What does she mean?” asked Benny. “It doesn’t make any sense.”

“We need to think about it,” said Henry. “Maybe there are more clues in the diary.” He bent over the little book while Jessie flipped the pages. There were more entries about Emily’s mother, her family, her friends, her riding lessons, and her parties, but no other clue about the ring.

“Skip to the end,” Benny suggested.

Jessie nodded. “Oh, here’s something,” she said.

19 September 1906

Tomorrow I will be leaving to go study in England. How I will miss Father and this house where I have so many memories of Mother! I do hope Father will not be too lonely, but he travels so much with his work.

I am taking many of Mother’s dresses with me to England. Most of her clothes fit me now, but I have decided not to take the ring. It is too valuable and I do not want to risk losing it overseas. I am leaving it in this house, where it will always be safe in its hiding place.

“Is that it?” asked Benny. “That’s the last page?”

Jessie nodded and held out the book to show Benny.

“That’s means the ring might still be here — right in this house. Maybe even in the library.” Benny got up and looked around the room, wondering where there might be a good hiding place.

Jessie closed the diary. “Grandfather, do you know if Emily ever came back to this house?” she asked.

Grandfather did not answer right away. “I don’t believe so,” he finally said.

“That means the ring could very well still be in this house,” said Jessie.

Benny hopped up and down. “I knew it. I knew it!” he exclaimed. “We should start looking right now.”

The others laughed. “Benny, it’s been here all these years. It’s not likely to disappear overnight,” Henry pointed out.

“Oh, Benny, look out the window,” said Violet. “It’s snowing.”