absolute rule 105
absolutism 234
acquisition 95
action, separation from thought 66
Agamemnon 47
Agis IV, King 103
Alaric, king of the Visigoths 155
Alcidamas 51
Alexander the Great 84, 99–103, 138, 144
Alexandria 103
al-Farabi 190
Anonymous Iamblichi, the 51
Antigone (Sophocles) 48–50, 122, 143
Antipater 102
Antiphon 51
Arianism 160
Aristotle 2, 19; account of Solonian reforms 32; advice to Alexander the Great 99–100; background 83–4; characteristics of Athenian democracy 36; civic principles 162; and class relations 195, 214; on Cleon 52; comparison with Plato 82–3, 84–6, 87, 91–3, 97; definition of democracy 38–9; definition of human associations 93; definition of the polis 93–4; on despotic rule 100–1; on equality 90, 92, 213–14; on governance 99–100; historical context of political theory 88–9; ideal polis 91–3, 197, 205–6; on inequality 89–92, 94–5; Islam and 191; and justice 90, 210–11, 213–14; and knowledge 85–6; medieval political theory and 192–3, 196–8, 203, 210–11; and morality 85–7; on the oikos 95; opposition to democracy 82; parts and conditions of the polis 77; politics of 87–93; and property 91, 95–6; and the public-private dichotomy 122–3; and the sciences 187; on slavery 15, 94–5, 100, 131, 132; theory of nature 97–8; Thomas Aquinas and 204–6, 207–8; and virtue 86–7, 214; and vulgarity 86–7
Athens 17; aristocratic disaffection 33–4, 51–2; aristocratic withdrawal from politics 66–7; assembly 37–8, 58–9; characteristics of democracy 36–42; Cicero and 142–3; civic freedom 41; Cleisthenes’s reforms 34–6, 89; comparison with Rome 115, 121; concept of freedom 30–1; culture of democracy 46–50; debate about social arrangements 44; elections 37; empire 41–2; law 36; the Lyceum 84; Macedonian hegemony 84; moral decadence 52–3; oligarchic revolutions 52, 56, 65, 143; Plato’s attack on 19; political relations 20; the rise of democracy 30–6; slavery 38; Solonian reforms 32–3, 89; and the Sophists 51; strength of ruling elements 69; unwritten law 143; women 38. See also Greeks
Augustine of Hippo, St 2, 131n, 145, 154–63, 184, 205
Augustus Caesar 116
autonomia 104
beatitudo 207
blood rivalries 47
Bodin, Jean 186n, 231, 232, 234
Boniface VIII, Pope 181, 201, 202, 215
Brown, Peter 160
Caesaropapism 146
Callicles 51
Calvinism 155
Cambridge History of Medieval Political Thought 200–1, 233
Cambridge School, the 7–11, 12, 16
capitalism 13, 24, 2, 41, 1255, 234
Carthaginians, the 18
Catiline 133
Charles Martel 178
China 2, 18, 102, 118, 137, 182
Christianity 23, 24, 120–1; Augustinian doctrine 154–63; civic principles 163; comparison with Islam 190–1; departure from ancient political traditions 162–3; divine and civil law 209–10; division between secular and spiritual power 177–82; doctrine of original sin 160–1; dualism 147, 150–1, 158, 188–9, 192, 210; Eastern 156, 161; emergence of Roman 144–7; and equality 148–51, 236; and feudal governance 177–86; the filioque controversy 161, 179; heresy 155, 159–60; and inequality 162–3; Neo-Platonist 151; and obedience 158–62, 163, 188; Pauline 145, 148–52, 178; the Pelagian heresy 160; and philosophy 187–9; and predestination 155–6; and property 147–8; Roman mission 156–7; schism 161, 179; and sexuality 161n; and sin 152, 153, 157, 158–61; and slavery 150; spheres of authority 151–2, 158; and Stoicism 147–8, 150–1; transformation into imperial religion 161n; universalism 145, 148–51; Western 156. See also Church, the
Church, the: authority of 215–16, 217; and conciliar theory 217–18; corruption of 221–2; Dominicans 185, 210; Franciscans 184–5; governmental power 179–82; and heresy 159–60; Marsilius of Padua attack on 219–23, 224; mendicant orders 184–6, 210; organization 152–4; poverty 184–6; property 181–6, 215–16; rise of 24; wealth 181, 184; William of Ockham’s challenge to 229–30. See also Christianity
Cicero, Marcus Tullius 19, 117; and Athenian democracy 142–3; background 132–4; characterization of the state 140–2, 157; conception of natural law 143–4; on constitutions 142; and the decline of the Republic 138–9; on equality 142–4, 236; influences on 127; on justice 135, 140–2; justification for Roman imperialism 131–2; on moral equality 135–6; on natural equality 137–8; and Plato 133, 141–4; and political inequality 136–7; political principles 134–5; on property 139–40; on the redistribution of property 129–30; on the role of the state 23; on slavery 131–2; Stoicism of 132, 136, 136–7; and wealth 134; works 134–5
Circumellions 155
citizens and citizenship: division between ruler and ruled 100; equality 137–8; in Greek democracy 17; Marsilius of Padua on 220–1; medieval political theory and 193–4, 196; and property 91; Roman 121, 124, 126–7, 144, 163, 194, 236; Solonian reforms 32–3; tensions within 20–1
City of God, The (Augustine) 131n, 154–63
civic community 18–19, 30, 162, 163, 197, 199–200, 210–11, 220–2, 236
civic humanism 10
civic sphere: disappearance of 171–2; medieval political theory and 193–6
class relations 19, 21–3, 40–1, 69–72, 78–9, 88–92, 122, 133, 194–6, 214
Cleisthenes 34–6, 52, 78, 89, 194
Cleon 52
Clytemnestra 47
Code of Justinian 104
Cold War, the 4
Coleridge, Samuel Taylor 82
commercial society, emergence of 9–10
common good, the 212
commonalities of experience 14
commonwealth, definition of 231
Confucian philosophy 2
Constantine, Emperor 146, 149, 156, 221– 2
Constantinople 145
constitutions: Cicero on 142; classification of 20; mixed 19–20, 125, 142, 144, 212–13; Plato on 77–9
context: Cambridge School interpretation of 8–11, 16; historical 12, 13–15, 16, 83, 88–9
corporatism 217–18, 218–25, 220–1, 223–5, 225–6, 227–32
cosmic cycle, the 76
cosmopolitanism 101–3, 104, 107, 144, 148, 150
Crates 108
Critias 51
Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage 153–4
De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate (On the Unity of the Catholic Church) (Cyprian) 153–4
De Officiis (On Duties) (Cicero) 129–30, 135, 136
De Rerum Natura (On the Nature of Things) (Lucretius) 106, 139
Decisive Treatise (Ibn Rushd) 189–90
Defensor Pacis (Marsilius) 193, 199, 201, 219–25
Demetrios of Phaleron 84
democracy: Aristotle’s definition 38–9; Aristotle’s opposition to 82; Athenian culture of 46–50; characteristics of Athenian 36–42; Cicero and 142–3; and class relations 40–1; criticisms of Athenian 39; Greek 17–21; mass 5n; opposition to 52–3; origins of 17–21; and philosophy 50–5; Plato and 21, 38, 39, 62, 64–5, 77–8, 81, 82; and poverty 39; rise of 30–6; Solonian reforms 32–3; the Sophists and 50–5; and techn 63–4
Democritus 51
destiny 47
Dionysius I 66
Dionysius II 66
discourses, diversity of 13
dominium 23, 124–5, 147, 148, 168, 181, 182–3, 185–6, 209–10, 215, 228
donation of Constantine 222
dualism 147, 150–1, 158, 188–9, 192, 210
economic relations, feudal 167–8, 173
England 25, 174–7, 186, 198, 202, 203, 225–32, 234–5
Epictetus 107
Epicurus 106
equality 28, 36, 39, 51, 53–4, 66–7, 99, 109, 129, 235–6; Aristotle on 90, 92, 213–14; Christianity and 148–51, 236; Cicero on 135–8, 142–4, 236; and justice 69; and the polis 95, 96, 122–3
feudalism: and Christianity 177–86; competing claims of authority 170–1; definitions 167–8; disappearance of civic sphere 171–2;economic relations 167–8, 173; English 174–7; Germanic influences 167; governance 177–86, 205–6, 209; legal relations 210–14; levies 168; lordship 167–8, 195, 197; nature of 165–77; obligations 171–2; origins of 164–5; peasants 167–8, 172–4, 195; and political theory 192–200; property and 24n, 168–9, 181–6; public–private dichotomy 183; rise of 23–4; social relations 172–4, 194–6; transition from 25, 234–5; urban elites 172; variations 25
Finley, M.I. 15n
Foundations of Modern Political Thought, The (Skinner) 7
France 175, 176n, 186, 198, 202, 202–3, 203, 214–18, 231, 234
Francis, St 184
Franks, the 170
fraternity 99
freedom 28–30, 41, 123, 171–2, 212, 228, 231–2, 236
God: authority of 149; dominium 186; relation to 145, 153; Thomas Aquinas and 208–10
goodness 206
Gorgias of Leontini 51
governance: feudal 177–86, 205–6, 209; types of 99–100
Gracchi brothers 114, 116, 129
Great Britain, emergence of commercial society 9–10
Greeks: changing conception of justice 44–6; characteristics of democracy 36–42; concept of freedom 28–30; concept of ownership 124; democracy 17–21; equality 28; evolution of political theory 42–6; Macedonian hegemony 83; origins of political theory 17–21; property 31–2; public–private dichotomy 122–3; the rise of democracy 30–6; rise of the polis 30–1; slavery 19, 29, 38; tradition of political thought 1–2; women 38. See also Athens
Hegel, Georg 2
hektemorage 32n
Hermes 60
heroic ideals 2
Hindus 2
Hippias of Elis 51
historical background: and the Cambridge School 8–11; importance of 3–4
historical materialism 12
historical rupture 165
History of the Peloponnesian War (Thucydides) 42
Hobbes, Thomas 2, 10, 12, 135, 196, 236
Holy Roman Empire 170, 172, 199, 222–3, 224, 234
homonoia 112
household ties 31
human association, Aristotle’s definition 93
human nature 3, 43, 50, 53–4, 60, 63, 86, 105, 109, 136, 236
humanism 233
humanistic principle, the 21
Ideas 69
imperium 23, 124–5, 147, 148, 168, 182–3
In Defence of Flaccus (Cicero) 142
In Defence of Sestius (Cicero) 139
India 2
individualism: Epicureanism and 106–7; Stoicism 107; William of Ockham on 227–32
inequality 66–7, 213–14, 235–6; Aristotle on 89–92, 94–5; Christianity and 162–3; Cicero on 136–7; natural 53–5, 59; Plato on 59, 69–72, 137–8; Romans 123; Stoicism 112–13, 130–1. See also political inequality
isegoria 39
Islamic fundamentalism 191
Italy 25, 172, 198–200, 202, 203, 218–25, 234
John XXII, Pope 185–6, 201, 201–2, 219, 226
Julian the Apostate, Emperor 158
justice: Aristotle and 90, 210–11, 213–14; changing Greek conception of 44–6; Cicero on 135, 140–2; conflicting conceptions of 47; and equality 69; medieval political theory and 210–14; natural 141; Plato on 11, 46, 67–70; Roman 128; and the Socratic method 56–7; Solonian reforms 33
kingship 104–5, 170–1, 195, 211, 215
knowledge: absolute 57; Aristotle’s theory of 85–6; Plato’s theory of 64, 74, 84; requirements for 59; Stoicism and 108; universalism and 63; and virtue 61–2
labour: control of 18, 70; division of 63–4, 70, 72, 136; and freedom 29–30; and political rights 40–1
law: Cicero on 141; divine and civil 209–10; English 174–6; equality of 36; Islamic 189–91; and kingship 104–5; Marsilius of Padua on 220–3, 225; and nature 53–5; Plato on 77–9, 104–5; and religion 187–92; Roman 23, 120–7, 148, 168, 176, 182–3, 184,196; Solonian reforms 33; Sophocles on 49; and Stoicism 129; Thomas Aquinas and 208–10. See also natural law
Laws (Plato) 19, 71, 73, 75, 78–9, 92
legislators, Marsilius of Padua on 220–3
libertas 28
living law 104
Locke, John 2, 10, 12, 13, 135, 236
logos 108–10, 112–13, 147–8, 149
Ludwig of Bavaria 201, 201–2, 218, 223, 226
Lycophron 51
Lycurgus 66
Machiavelli, Niccolo 2, 10, 234
Macpherson, C.B. 6
Magna Carta 175
Manichaeism 154
Marathon, Battle of 37
Marc Anthony 134
Marcus Aurelius, Emperor 107
Marsilius of Padua 193, 199, 201–2, 203–4, 218–25, 230
Marx, Karl 96
Miletus 111
Mill, John Stuart 2
Minoans, the 17
mixed constitution, the 19–20, 125, 142, 144, 212–3
modernity 5n
monarchies 169, 174–5, 176, 196, 211, 213, 216–17
moral principles 21
mos maiorum 139
natural law 109, 126, 135, 137, 141, 143–4, 192, 208–10, 210–14, 229
Netherlands 25
Nicholas of Cusa 234n
Nocturnal Council, the 79
nomos 36, 49, 53–5, 66, 77, 104, 104–5
Odyssey, The (Homer) 45
oikos, the 31, 67, 93–4, 95, 122–3
On Duties (De Officiis) (Cicero) 23
On Royal and Papal Power (John of Paris) 214–15
Oresteia, The (Aeschylus) 46–7, 48
ownership 124, 184, 185–6, 216, 229
Pagels, Elaine 161n
pain, avoidance of 106
Panaetius 107, 113, 127–8, 130, 131, 132
Pandora 48
Parmenides 81
Paul of Tarsus, St 145, 148–51, 153, 161n
peasants 21–2, 29, 40, 154–5; feudal 167–8, 172–4, 195; Roman 115, 117, 119; Solonian reforms 32
Pergamum 103
Persians (Aeschylus) 49
philia 49
Philip IV, King of France 201, 202, 215
Philo of Larissa 133
philosophy 43, 50–5, 57, 58, 64, 79, 79–82, 82–3, 103–4, 187–92
Phonecians, the 18
Plato 2, 48; attack on Athens 19; background 65, 83; Cicero and 133, 141–4; civic principles 162; and class inequality 137–8; class structure 78–9; communism 73; comparison of works 75; comparison with Aristotle 82–3, 84–6, 87, 91–3, 97; on constitutions 77–9; on the decline of the polis 72–3; on democracy 77–8; educational programme 74; and eleutheria 29; epistemology 59; on the Good 74; and Heraclitus 110–11, 112; higher reality 84–5; ideology 80–2; and inequality 59, 69–72; interpreting 79–82; Islam and 191; on justice 11, 46, 67–70; and knowledge 64, 74, 84; on law 77–9, 104–5; Laws 19, 71, 73, 75, 78–9, 92; opposition to democracy 21, 38, 39, 62, 64–5, 81, 82; philosophical goal 66–7, 70–1, 81; and property 73, 93; and Protagoras 57–64, 65, 73; qualities of the ruling class 71; and reason 81; and social conditions 72–4; social division of labour 64; and Socrates 55; and the Sophists 51, 53, 54, 59, 64–5; on the soul 69–72; and stability 112; on statesmanship 75–7; in Syracuse 66; and techn 63–4; universalism 62–3; and virtue 62, 72, 73–4, 84–5
Platonic Academy, Sicily 66, 79, 84
pleasure 106
Plutarch 99
polis, the: Aristotle’s classification of 87–8; Aristotle’s definition 93–4; Aristotle’s ideal 91–3, 197, 205–6; decline of 104; development of 17–18; and equality 95, 96, 122–3; and freedom 30, 123; historical context of Aristotle’s theory of 88–9; parts and conditions of 77; Plato and 67, 72–3; purpose 60; reflection of natural hierarchy 97; rise of the 30–1
political organization 1n
political power, source of 34–5
political theory and thought: the canon 25–7; canonical scarcity 234; canonical thinkers 2, 6, 235; central question 2–3, 6–7; Chinese tradition 2; definition 1, 42–3; division of 4; epochal shifts 233–6; evolution of 42–6; Greek tradition 1–2; Hindu tradition 2; in history 21–5; history of 4–11; medieval 192–200, 200–4, 233–4; origins 17–21; politics of 14–15; social history of 11–16; Straussian 5n; tools of 11
Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke, The (Macpherson) 6n
Politics (Aristotle) 91–2, 93–8, 99–100, 191, 196–8, 205–6, 211
Politics and Vision (Wolin) 4
polity, the 91
Posidonius 107, 113, 127, 130, 132
possessive market society 6
Prodicus of Ceos 51
production 18, 19, 21–2, 40–1, 95
Prometheus Bound (Aeschylus) 47–8, 50
property: absolute 124n; Aristotle and 91, 95–6; autonomy of 21; Christianity and 147–8; Church 181–6; Cicero on 139–40; conditional 167; development of 19–21; English law 175–6, 186, 203; feudal 24n, 168–9, 181–6; in Greece 31–2; John of Paris on 215–18; ownership 124, 184, 185–6, 216, 229; Plato and 73, 93; redistribution of 129–30; rights 183–6; and the rise of capitalism 13; Romans and 116–19, 120–7, 168–9, 182–3, 184; Roman Stoic philosophy 127–32; and the state 23–4, 139–40, 215–16, 235; Stoic threat to 129; Thomas Aquinas and 210; William of Ockham on 228–9
Protagoras 2, 48, 51, 55, 57–64, 65, 73, 141–2, 163
psyche 57
public–private dichotomy 23, 122–6, 140, 147–8, 169, 183
Publius Servius Rullus 133
punishment 60
rationalism 82
relevance 14
religion: and philosophy 187–92; and the state 146–7
Renaissance 199n
representation 203
Republic (Cicero) 131–2, 136, 139, 141
Republic (Plato): Aristotle’s criticism of 93; attack on democracy 62; on the decline of the polis 72–3; Ibn Rushd’s commentary on 191; as the ideal 75; on inequality 69–72; interpreting 79–82; on justice 11, 46, 67–70; and property 73; and social conditions 72–4; social division of labour 64; on the soul 69–72; state model 19; on virtue 72, 73–4
Republic (Zeno) 108
resistance theories (France) 217
revenge 47
Reynolds, Susan 166n
Romanization 102
Rome and the Romans 18–19; administration 118; army 115, 118; Christian mission 156–7; Christianization of 146, 158; citizens 121, 124, 126–7, 144, 163, 194, 236; comparison with Athens 115, 121; concept of ownership 124; concept of the state 125–6; emergence of Christianity 144–7; Empire 116–19, 124, 127, 144, 145–6, 169; expansion 115–16; fall of the Empire 118–19, 153, 174; Germanic influences 167; the Gracchan reforms 129; imperialism 131–2, 144; and inequality 123; and justice 128; land ownership 115–16, 117–19, 129–30; law 23, 120–7, 148, 168, 176, 182–3, 184, 196; medieval political theory and 193–4; municipal system 117–18; oligarchy 116–17, 117; patronage 121–2; peasantry 115, 117, 119; population 116; property relations 116–19, 120–7, 168–9, 184; public–private dichotomy 23, 122–6; the Republic 114–17, 118, 123–4, 128–31, 132–3, 134, 138–9; Romanization 102; sack of 155; the Senate 114, 125; slavery 126–7; social order mirrored in Church organization 152–3; state lands 115–16; Stoic philosophy 127–32, 147–8, 151; wealth 116
Rousseau, Jean Jacques 2
Salamis, Battle of 37
Samos 106
Saxonhouse, Arlene 15n
Scepticism 154
Scipio Africanus the Younger 128
Scipionic circle, the 128
secular power, spiritual power and 177–82
Septuagint, the 148
Seventh Epistle (Plato) 65
sexuality 161n
Sicily 66
sin 152, 153, 157, 158–61, 206–7, 228
Skinner, Quentin 7–9, 10 slavery 19, 29, 38; Aristotle and 15, 94–5, 100, 131, 132; and Christianity 150; Cicero on 131–2; natural 15; in Rome 126–7; Stoicism and 109, 112–13, 130–1; Thomas Aquinas and 209–10
Smith, Sir Thomas 231
social context 12–13; Cambridge School interpretation of 8–11
Socrates 2, 54, 55–8, 59, 61–2, 65
Sophists, the 50–5, 59, 61, 64–5
Sophocles 46, 48, 48–50, 122, 143
sovereignty: absolute 186; and citizenship 194; and consent 196; corporate 221; parcellized 23–4, 88, 119, 166–7, 168, 171, 173, 177, 182, 202–3; popular 35–6, 195; shared 212
Sparta 17, 19, 34, 35, 48, 52, 103, 113–14, 129
speech, equality of 39
Sphairos of Borysthenes 113
spiritual power, and secular power 177–82
stability 112
state, the: Augustine on 154, 157; authority of 215–18; Cicero’s characterization of 140–2, 157; control of labour 18; and equality 92; fragmentation 169–72; Hellenistic concept of 104; independence of 21; Marsilius of Padua on 220; moral purpose of 141–2; offices of 18; and production 18, 22; and property 23–4, 139–40, 215–16, 235; purpose 60; and religion 146–7; Roman concept of 125–6; Skinner and 8; Western tradition of 21
Statesman, The (Plato) 62, 75–8, 91–2, 162
Stoicism: and Christianity 147–8, 150–1; Cicero and 132, 136, 136–7; concerns 105, 107; and equality 109; foundation and phases of 107; and inequality 112–13, 130–1; and justice 141; and law 129; logos 108–10, 112–13; the Middle Stoa 130–1; philosophy 109–13; political implications of 108–14; Roman variants 127–32, 147–8, 151; shift away from politics 106; and slavery 109, 112–13, 130–1; Zeno’s Republic 108
Summa Theologica (Thomas Aquinas) 206
Suppliant Woman, The (Euripides) 28, 39, 46
Syracuse 66
telos 95, 96, 97, 205–6, 207–8
Tertullian 153
Theaetetus (Plato) 63
Theophrastus 84
thesmos 36
Thomas Aquinas, St 2, 185, 189, 196, 197, 198, 201–2, 203–4; and Aristotle 204–6, 207–8; and constitutions 212–13; on equality 213–14; God and 208–10; John of Paris and 214–15; law and 208–10; and legal relations 211–14; property and 210; slavery and 209–10
Thrasymachus 51
Thucydides 37, 42, 44, 52, 54, 122
truth 81
tyrannical rule, Thomas Aquinas and 212
unitary jurisdiction, Marsilius of Padua’s call for 220–4
United States of America 15n
Universal Forms 85
universalism 62–3, 79–80, 82, 145, 148–51
unmoved mover, the 208
vassalage 166n
virtue 57, 58–9, 60–3, 72, 73–4, 84–5, 86–7, 112, 208, 214
Webb, Eugene 161n
Wickham, Chris 169n
William of Moerbeke 196–8, 211
William of Ockham 201–2, 203–4, 218–19, 225–32
wisdom 66
Wolin, Sheldon 4
Wood, Neal 11n
writing 17
Xenophon 55