When he quoted the Jesuit, Alzina, Justus Forfex was beginning his short study of sea burial. As he was to relate in his autobiography Viaticum (‘Life has written me, not I my life’), he was shipwrecked eight times in his wanderings between 1842 and 1867. One way and another, he was able to observe burial customs from Subang Gulf through New Castile to what he whimsically dubbed ‘Cholynesia, or the Bile Islands’. He also had the opportunity, over long months’ tattered living off crabs and coconut juice on deserted atolls, to reflect on how the significance of water pervades both soul and body.
Years later, as Giusto Forbici, he passed his scholarly retirement in a gaunt, book-lined palace in Arezzo. When asked why he had chosen that particular city (he was born on the Italian coast, down south in Salerno), he replied that there was no part of Arezzo from which one could possibly see the sea. In his most notorious essay, ‘De atramento et oceanis morteque’, he writes of the relation between ink, oceans and death. For those with a little Latin, his title makes the connections less apparently strained since the word for ink, atramentum, would call to mind the adjective atratus, meaning ‘darkened’ or ‘wearing mourning’. This essay had its roots in the circumstances of Forbici’s last and most desperate shipwreck, when he was the sole survivor washed up on a coral strand in the heart of ‘Cholynesia’. Washed up with him was more than his fair share of irony: nine immense straw-covered glass carboys which he remembered having glimpsed in the ship’s hold. These, he knew, contained fresh water. His elation at this reprieve was short-lived. They turned out to be full of ink, part of a consignment destined for Dutch bureaucrats in Batavia. The ink was made of dried sepia extracted from thousands of cuttlefish, purified, mixed with lamp-black and thinned with spirits and water. It smelt of bad fish. Forbici thus found himself alone on an islet with many gallons of a substance scarcely more drinkable than the ocean surrounding him.
With immense effort he trundled the great flasks up above the high tide mark and buried them. He hoped to prevent the direct heat of the sun from evaporating the alcohol through the cork bungs and thereby stop the liquid’s fishy component from putrefying still further. For nearly three months he eked out survival by drinking small tots of rotten ink. They made him retch as well as leaving a slight hangover. He produced occasional sooty turds full of free carbon, until towards the end as he grew weak and feverish he was seized with stomach cramps accompanied by a stygian leakage. Not only was he drinking ink but seemed to be excreting it as well.
How formative is illness for the imagination! Entering what should have been his final delirium (he later wrote), he saw himself as quite conventionally encompassed on all sides by death. Yet suddenly he perceived it was a distillate of that very death – as produced by octopuses and cuttlefish – that was keeping him alive by a kind of homoeopathy. Was this proof of the eccentric Dr Hahnemann’s ‘Law of Similia’? How did these cephalopods extract their black essence from clear seawater? Since it was impossible to make an element such as carbon, did this not imply that the world’s oceans already consisted of highly dilute ink which the creatures then concentrated? Two-thirds of the planet was a fatal inkwell.
These thoughts seemed to him very clear and satisfactory as he sat under a sparse canopy of thorny macrophyllum whose mildly hallucinogenic leaves he now and then chewed. Much later, after being rescued and having recovered his wits, he remembered Varelius’s little monograph on the presence of gold in the sea. Forbici then made the leap which was to give his own essay its fame. He reasoned that if the sea acted as a body of solvent, leaching out of rocks their auriferous veins, then its clear depths must contain all the essence of land (il nocciolo della terra), down to its last molecular constituent. If the human body itself was composed only and wholly of chemicals and minerals that occurred in the Earth’s crust, then it followed that the sea must also contain all the component parts of a person. In theory, therefore, a wizard, alchemist or divine agent would be able to assemble a human being from a quantity of seawater. Nothing would be lacking but the soul; and who knew but that also might be found lurking in the invisible interstices of water?
This lively fancy was not at all understood in Arezzo and went down positively badly in Pisa, Siena and Florence. It was scarcely ten years since Darwin had published his own genealogy of the human race, and that had been impious enough in its proposal of a scurrilous ancestry that vastly pre-dated the book of Genesis. Now here came this vagabond – an Italian no less – who was just as godless but even bleaker, to suggest that the frame made in God’s image was composed of nothing but chemicals after all, regardless of its lineage. The Bishop of Lucca referred in a sermon to ‘a fashionable, Satanic materialism that … reduces the sacrament of motherhood to the level of a factory or a workshop assembling puppets’, a remark which some believe gave Carlo Collodi the germ of his fable ‘Pinocchio’, which was published a decade later in 1883.
Forbici, leathery and reclusive in his Aretine library, gave not a fig for the Bishop of Lucca. ‘I look in the mirror and see – nothing,’ he wrote exuberantly. ‘I look through the casement at the people who, from the sound of their voices, I judge are in the courtyard below but who seem today not as visible as they should be. Our bodies – what are they? Diffuse clouds of whirling atoms held together by some clotting or electric propensity. Why should this appear so miraculous? How can we ever embrace? It is our brilliant fluidity that provokes me to love whatever our poor shadows extend. We pontificate and preen, we survive childbirth and shipwreck with all the corporeality [fisicità] of a cloud. The sky-cities we saw above Pacific horizons have long since returned to the ocean, and so shall we. What is it about this process that makes one confident and affectionate? Cradles full of clouds. Coffins full of clouds. Shaving-mirrors full of clouds. Books full of clouds.’ This retired traveller then went on to meditate – at too great a length, maybe – on water. He returned to the relationship between dilution and concentration. Was it possible for un nocciolo to be dilute and still remain an essence? Can a concentration be said to exist even when dispersed among extraneous things? It is hard for today’s readers to address such questions with Forbici’s tirelessness. His staunchest admirers are obliged to admit that in his later, landlocked years, the great Justus Forfex became obsessive about water, bodies, the oceans, ink and so forth, returning to them in essay after essay. He never did manage to pull them (or himself) together into a single philosophical proposition. Instead, they flow in and out of his thoughts and writings like busy animalcula crossing a microscope slide. Cholynesia had taken its toll.
His earlier monograph on sea burial, though, showed him at his best. It is a lively volume full of arcana and jolting details, still widely consulted by anthropologists, scholars and ghouls. It lists with great attention to detail the classical or ancient practices as well as those he had personally witnessed in the southern archipelagos. And yet even this essay lacks a central thought as to what it might mean to be returned to water, as opposed to the magic benefits accruing to survivors for burying a body in the sea. ‘Returned to water’ is the significant phrase, one which might not have occurred to him then because this little book antedated his final and most traumatic shipwreck. He had not yet formulated his thesis that all bodies are by nature oceanic and that earth-burial, urn burial, cremation, etc., are merely forms of postponement. (Even fire is water.) And, of course, he was unable to end his monograph with the highly pertinent story of how he had finally been rescued from his atoll with its dwindling ink supply.
Forbici dealt with all this in his so-called ‘Parergo’, a ‘by-work’ or corollary to the rest of his writings. When Marcello Vanni came to produce the collected edition in 1907, he judiciously printed the ‘Parergo’ twice, inserting it as an appendix to Viaticum (where it forms a neat climax to his author’s adventures) and again as an addendum to the monograph on sea burial, Talassotafia. In this position it augments the list with one last strange example, while the autobiographical element gives it an immediacy which is irresistible.
Over the long weeks of isolation on the atoll he had undoubtedly entered an extreme world. There were times when all his shipwrecks and misfortunes collapsed together and he knew he had been living on the islet for centuries, slowly wading its leeward shallows in a constant quest for food. He had reached the stage where the finding of a single overlooked sea urchin became the high point of the day. Using probes of antler coral he would prise open the friable shell, trembling, so as to leave the inside undamaged. Then, having reluctantly discarded the animal’s rudimentary digestive tract (which only made him vomit ink), he greedily ran his thumbnail around the shell’s interior, scraping up a tiny mound of gonads which tasted to him like the rarest caviar. The ghost crabs which lived in burrows in the coral sand and danced in and out of the rippling wavelets at dusk were still plentiful but difficult to catch. When by guile (blocking up its bolt-holes) he did succeed in catching one, he triumphantly ate it whole, crunching up claws and carapace even as the translucent running legs scrabbled at his lower lip.
He had tried and failed to catch fish, even the tiniest fry that hung like flakes of brilliant metal about the coral outcrops. No net, no line, no hook. The scholar was reduced to dropping boulders into the shallows where the fish flickered in the hopes of stunning one. The turbulence subsided, the water cleared; nothing had changed except the new naked rock lying there with the braver fish already nosing around it. Forbici did find one place on the atoll that looked promising, a pool among the rocks on the windward side. Roughly circular and about 4 yards across, its ragged sides fell vertically for several fathoms, forming a kind of porous shaft. Over many centuries, some freak of the current must have scoured it out of the dead coral formations of which the islet was built. By lying at its lip and putting his face close to the water’s surface, he could see, beyond his own ragged castaway’s visage, a dark bottom strewn with broken coral: white chunks and lengths among which bulky parrot-fish moved lazily.
For long hours he pondered a way of trapping these succulent creatures. With some damage to his hands he managed to break off several wands of the tough little bush which had become his shelter. These he tried to weave into a trap of sorts; but no sooner had he dipped this crude, lopsided construction into the water than it began to unravel. Besides, as he realised too late in an outburst of rage, he had no cord with which to lower it, and nothing tempting with which to bait it. He gave up and went back to eating titbits of weed and mollusc he found beneath the rocks in the lagoon.
Otherwise the days passed unrecordably, and the listless view from beneath the macrophyllum repeated itself at the mesmeric pace of evolution itself. It is not difficult, even well over a century later, to be confident of what Forbici saw. On the atoll’s windward side the craggy foreground hides the water’s edge. Impelled by the long Pacific swell, occasional tufts of sea leap up among the coral rocks into the dazzled air. A marine heartbeat thuds underfoot and trapped air sighs gustily in vents and fissures. The water in the pool rises and then sinks. This is land no solider than a petrified sponge, with the sea passing continuously through its roots. Small crustacea move on the lunar surface; the isopod Ligea scurries everywhere into cracks like a littoral woodlouse. It is a fossil scene.
At night, according to Forbici, a cool breeze sprang out of nowhere. In an act of self-burial which might bring him a little warmth he would heap up the detritus of a billion dead creatures over his legs, for he was sick and shivery. He had nothing to do but lie on his back and stare at the universe. Forbici’s cosmos was entirely classical: Greek and Roman and Arab. Apart from his training as a scholar, years of voyaging had left him with a good knowledge of the heavens. The pictures he saw were familiar: an archer, a herdsman, Hercules, a plough and a lyre and Berenice’s Hair. To stop himself falling forever upwards into the radiant silverpoint overhead (for the tropical night sky sucks the soul away from its human moorings and dissolves it in oceans of eternity) he would retell himself the stories he could remember. He believed it was Tycho Brahe, the Danish astronomer and Kepler’s teacher, who had introduced Coma Berenices (which in fact was only faintly visible from Cholynesia’s latitudes). Instead of choosing a story from Scandinavian mythology, or else making some contemporary allusion, Brahe had instinctively gone back to the classics. The devoted Queen Berenice vowed that if her husband Ptolemy returned safely from war with Assyria she would cut off all her hair and present it to Venus. When Ptolemy duly returned in triumph, she remained true to her promise. Jupiter, awed by this sign of human devotion, retrieved the pledge from the temple and hung her shining tresses in tribute among the spring stars. By such means, Forbici did his best to cling to his culture, his identity, his memories. But that had been in the earlier part of his marooning.
Nights on the atoll were severing one by one the threads which still attached him to a previous life somewhere beyond the flickering horizon. To rest one ear on his gravel pillow was to hear the ocean on all sides of the atoll, rinsing and clucking and mewing. But it was also to hear it thrumming below in deep gasps like those of a labouring beast as it turns and turns a creaking water mill. These sounds filled Forbici with terror. Trapped between the starry ocean overhead and that which surrounded and undermined him, he knew himself about to be engulfed. He awoke from hectic dreams of typhoons, of tsunami-like waves big enough to sweep the atoll bare or else tear it loose like a twirling stone raft. The whole weight of the universe pressed down on him until he felt himself trodden beneath the waves, buried by immensity, sinking through ever-blackening layers, a miserable fragment of mind lost among the ocean’s roots. In still other dreams he found himself trudging across waterless orange deserts, maybe on Mars or in some Arabian wilderness, in driven search for the oasis where all yearnings would be quenched. Mirages floated up in the trembling air and flowed together until they formed a rim of palms that encircled his whole horizon. It no longer mattered in which direction he urged his stumbling feet: there was nothing but the mockery of endless recession. Here he would awake in black tears. Lying exhausted, beached on dawn’s calm and lapped by undrinkable ocean, he forced his parched mouth to repeat the tales he knew, declensions of Greek verbs, multiplication tables, the names of relatives.
It seems that one day Forbici, delirious with ink, sun and hunger, was sitting semi-comatose beneath his macrophyllum when two heavy wooden craft appeared off the atoll. Long in the water like war canoes, with outriggers and thatched cabins, they were evidently dugouts hewn from monster tree trunks. Besides blood-coloured sails, eight oarsmen apiece propelled them whose polished brown backs glistened with sweat and spray. Each craft had at its prow a striking device: one an enormous fish with gaping mouth and counterbalanced, swivelling eyes, the other a great wicker bird with streaming raffia plumes dyed red, green and yellow.
The two boats hove to within 50 yards of shore. Forbici made no move, having taken them for one more hallucination. He thought this diagnosis confirmed when the fish and the bird began uttering shrill cries, the one rolling its eyes and the other flapping its gaudy wings. He wondered if they were talking amongst themselves or interrogating the islet to see whether it was propitious to land. After a long while the creatures fell silent. Then a hinged flap fell open beneath each, and a child crawled out backwards and fell into the boat; whereupon a drum took up a deep, lugubrious pounding from the shrouded cabin.
These heavy drumbeats began with both drums in unison, slow and regular, appearing to Forbici as the thudding of his own blood in his ears. Little by little the two drummers drifted out of synchrony, becoming increasingly independent and setting up everchanging syncopations. This went on for some considerable time. At length the drummers must have reversed the process, for their rhythms gradually approached one another until the two were finally in unison once more. In his account Forbici observed that it represented a great feat of rhythmic control and musicianship as would far exceed the abilities of even the best European orchestral players. At the time, though, nothing seemed to him more miraculous than anything else because the boundary between a world dominated by ink and one of pure delirium was vague indeed.
As he watched the two strange boats run their keels up the dazzling beach, the state of his head could be described as fugal with assorted wisps of story. The men jumping into the shallows not 40 yards away could as easily have been Ulysses and his crew as archipelagic gypsies on the other side of the world. Not knowing whether he was watching events taking place inside or outside his skull, he sat where he was and made no move. At any rate the disembarking men gave no sign of having noticed the presence of a half-cracked European on the islet. They were too much taken up with handing out, from one of the curtained cabins, a life-sized statue carved in ebony. This was carried reverently and shoulder-high beyond the surf in a procession which was brought up by the two little boys (who swam the first few yards), two men carrying the fish and bird figureheads, and, last, the drummers with their turtle-shell instruments.
When the two parties were assembled on the beach, Forbici could see that everyone with the exception of the children was masked. Plain hoods of dark material were drawn over their heads, featureless but for eyeholes.
This procession now walked purposefully across the islet, passing within 20 metres of the observer as he lay beneath his bush. Nobody spoke. The drummers drummed softly, the little boys held hands. The ebony statue was borne above the party’s heads at the full stretch of glistening brown arms. They disappeared among the rocks in the direction of the coral pool. It was, as Forbici himself remarked, a measure of his weak and incurious state that he had not the slightest inclination to follow them. In a little while the sound of the distant drumbeats ceased, and all that came to his ears was the sea’s familiar stirring. Whether or not all this was a delirious fantasy, it had brought with it a peculiar melancholic charge. The sudden interruption of his long isolation – which he could easily believe had already lasted several years – had imposed a trivial human dimension on what was becoming a grandly geological scene. So far had Forbici turned into a mere component, a kind of sentient rock, that it never occurred to him to announce his presence, to caper with pathetic joy at the sight of fellow humans, or otherwise to greet his rescuers. The waves now spoke to him more familiarly than any human voice. Even when he came to write this day, he was unable to say whether the sadness that had descended so abruptly had to do with the solemnities of the ritual or his sense of being dragged away from an impending private destiny.
Those gull-like cries – were they, too, a property of the moving water that surrounded him? Such mournful screams blurred with surf! He wondered whether he had ever seen a seabird land on this atoll. He could not remember for certain. Long ago he had dreamed of turkey-like birds so tame he could catch them with his hands before roasting and devouring their succulent steaks … mere dreams of hunger based on Galapagos tales, that trusting tameness which ought to pose any human being a moral dilemma but which never seemed to. Once broken, the rules of Eden fell in tatters before the rules of self-interest or commerce. Had he not lately read of British entrepreneurs in Antarctic lands? Protestant flint-hearts so weary from clubbing penguins to death that they had taken to driving their sacrificial victims up walkways so that they fell living into the huge cauldrons in which they were rendered down for oil? Again, the far-off cries reached him and, afterwards, a great outburst of drumming.
It may be that Forbici fell into a doze at this point. He next became aware of the scuff of footsteps passing behind his bush towards the beached craft. The masked figures maintained their silence, the turtle-shell drums were mute. The ebony statue was missing, likewise the figureheads and the children. Once embarked, they pushed off. The boats were rowed a few hundred metres offshore before pausing, the one alongside the other as though in discussion. It suddenly mattered to him to know whether or not he was dreaming. He dragged himself from beneath his bush and tottered down to the coral pool on the islet’s windward side. There, invisible from the boats, he knelt and peered into the water.
When his eyes had adjusted he could see very clearly the ebony statue lying on the bottom of the shaft among the white pipes of coral. Nearby lay the two figureheads: the great wicker bird with its plumes trailing in the gentle current, the wicker fish with one eye staring fixedly up through the fathoms of pellucid water, mouth agape as though for air. The immense fish he had once thought to trap were bumping at the wicker and ebony with inquisitive snouts.
Forbici crawled back to his shade and discovered that the boats had also returned. The natives had surely not failed to notice his presence even if they had elected not to interrupt their ritual. He never did learn whether the now-unmasked men had come back to rescue him or to salvage the glass carboys, which would have represented valuable storage containers. As they approached the macrophyllum they certainly fell on the empty flasks with excited shouts before greeting this blackened scarecrow of a human with a certain matter-of-factness. Their language was not wholly opaque to him, for the archipelago’s dialects overlapped in such a way as to leave audible beneath the surface a framework common to all. He heard ‘Aa’, which he knew to be ‘man’. He heard ‘bangsa saddi’, which he interpreted as ‘other race’. They half-carried him to one of the boats and gave him musky water from a gourd. It tasted like nectar.
The ‘Parergo’ describes at some length the weeks he spent aboard a succession of boats as his wandering rescuers went about their maritime business and allowed him to regain his health. They often saw land but seldom went ashore. They did so for fresh water and, on two occasions, for wild pig. But they were clearly not at home there, venturing only fearfully into the jungle which began almost at the high-tide mark. The endless sea was where they felt most secure, and they knew its ways with respectful intimacy. Their fishing abilities were extraordinary, as was their navigation. Out of nowhere, towards dusk, identical boats would appear and moor alongside each other. Sometimes as many as twenty craft congregated in mid-ocean, a family to each, to celebrate a birthday or a wedding. For a while they formed a floating hamlet or random village. Then at dawn, or after a few days, sails would be hoisted and the houses scatter away again over the horizon.
As time passed and language became less of a problem, Forbici was less than ever inclined to return to what and where he had been. This congenial way of living, bounded and dictated by nothing but water, was a transcendent version of the sterile and terminal existence his shipwreck had recently thrust upon him. But the time came when a port was nervously approached and they stood out in the roads until he could be transhipped into a schooner. This was bound for Makassar and the unsought curiosity and attention of his own kind. What comes off these last pages of ‘Parergo’ is regret. Yet as if Forbici himself could never make his mind up, it is unclear whether this was regret at leaving his rescuers, for their having rescued him in the first place, or even for something yet larger and vaguer he had perceived but could not write. At some point in his mid-ocean stranding on the atoll, he had ceased to be a European, but neither had he become a true sea-gypsy. Maybe that was the source of regret? Maybe, too, he knew he must either lose the sea for ever or else become it for ever by diving in and omitting to surface again. Hence Arezzo, and the grumpy discourse of his later years.
Meanwhile, he learned that the ebony statue had been the body of one of their princes, a kind of sea datu, wrapped mummy-like in a single length of sharkskin flayed on the bias in the manner of a peeled orange. Once tightly bound, this skin was given many thick coats of a shellac made from boiled carrageen or similar seaweed mixed with a mucilage extracted from turtle bones and tree sap. This treatment produced the smooth, dully shining black surface he had so easily mistaken for carved wood. The care and ritual the natives had lavished on their chieftain’s body was proper to the awe in which they held the sea and their duty to return their own bodies to its dissolving embrace. To lie buried on land was unthinkable. As he understood more and more, Forbici appreciated the irony of having been cast up in a marine cemetery. Not snapped-off flutes of coral, then, but countless gypsy bones had strewn the bottom of the pool. From time to time he heard again the small, gull-like cries among the sound of the waves, and saw the fat fish sniffing around the wicker figureheads lying companionably near the mummy. Had the children known their fate even as they shrilly begged the island’s spirits for permission to land, rolling their eyes and flapping their wings? He never found out. Or if he did, he never confided it to his ‘Parergo’, with its mood of grieving for unnamed things.