Chapter 6
The Climate and Culture of your Organisation
28. What to do if the structure of your organisation is causing you stress
Discussing organisation design, The WallStreetJournal of 26 October 2009 reported the following:
We’ve all been there. You want to get something done at work that seems so simple. And yet it ends up being so ... hard. Too many layers, too many rules, too many cooks, too many everything. What’s even more frustrating is that those at the top often aren’t even aware of the frustrations. After all, they don’t have to deal with them. In fact, they often put those complexities there in the first place. So they remain blissfully ignorant of the problems they’ve created. Until, that is, it’s too late. Until the [organisation] is toppling under the weight of its own inefficiencies.
Do you ever get stressed because this happens to you in your organisation? Your ideas have to be approved by your boss, who has to get the approval of their boss, who has to get the approval of a committee, and so on! So you stop coming up with ideas. It may be that the design of the organisation is causing you problems and therefore stress.
Organisation design can be thought of as the formal structure of an organisation. To find out about your company’s organisational design, look at the organisational chart. The organisation should be structured in such a way that it provides excellent customer service, increased profitability, has minimal operating costs, operates at maximum efficiency with minimum cycle time, and has committed and engaged employees. When you examine your organisation’s design do these points apply?
How do you know if organisational design is causing problems at work?
A poor organisational design, apart from causing you stress, can result in numerous problems including:
What can you about it?
Tell your boss about the benefits of good organisational design. It’s best to mention this casually or in passing. You could say that good organisational design improves communications, productivity and innovation - an organisation where people can work effectively. On the other hand, although a company has great employees and leaders, a poor organisational design can mean it does not perform well.
If the current organisational design is causing you too many problems and you can’t get it changed, you may have to deal with the status quo. For instance, if your organisation is multi-layered and decisions are hard to come by, and you can see no way you can personally improve the decision-making process, you need to find personal strategies for coping. These personal strategies are mentioned throughout this book, but here are a few that you might use: develop a network of people, learn new skills that will help you if you want to leave your present job, be optimistic about life, do exercise and make sure you have interests outside work.
29. How to increase your commitment to the organisation
How strong is your commitment to the organisation you work for? Do you accept the organisation’s goals and values? Are you willing to expend a lot of effort for the organisation? Do you want to stay in your current job? These are some of the factors that will help determine if you are committed to the organisation. If you’re committed and you have adequate job experience, it has been shown that you will perform better and make any stress that you may have work for you. The reverse occurs if you have a lower level of commitment and weaker job experience, and your stress can make your performance poorer.
Maybe you’re a school teacher; your commitment (and intention of leaving) depends on your belief that you are competent, the amount of stress that the job gives you and the environment in which you have to work. This may be true of other jobs as well (it’s also been found in blue-collar roles). One study found that if you suffer from stress you feel less emotionally committed to the organisation and if you have yet more stress to deal with, your sense of belonging is reduced (although you might still stay in the job). Stress, in other words, affects your commitment to the organisation you work for.
To find out if you are committed to your organisation, take this test, scoring each as follows.
For the two items marked with a * deduct your score from 8 to get a new score. Add up your final scores. If you scored 35 to 49, you are committed to the organisation - the higher the score the more committed you are. If you scored 7 to 21 you are not committed to the organisation - the lower the score the less committed you are.
How does it happen?
How do you know if your commitment to the organisation is causing you stress?
What can you do about it?
30. How to change the organisational culture
Is the organisation in which you work supportive and open? This is a major aspect of the organisational culture. Organisational culture is like the ‘personality’ of an organisation. It affects the way we think, the way we speak to others in the organisation, what we tell others about the organisation and our attitude towards it, the atmosphere found there and so on. It’s the way employees usually behave at work. Organisational culture determines how buildings are used, the furniture in them, the clothes employees wear, the symbols found in the organisation, etc. Organisational culture is determined by the people at the top and by the employees.
It has been said that the culture of an organisation is the single most important factor accounting for success or failure. Organisational culture, when it’s healthy, produces good performance from employees and keeps stress levels lower. When organisational culture is bad, employees get frustrated and stressed. Which kind of organisational culture do you work in?
The existence of competition in an organisation, due to, for instance, downsizing and budget cuts, develops stress in the form of job insecurity, work overload, difficulties in obtaining promotion, competition within and between groups, and an under-utilisation of staff skills.
Here are some of the items you might consider in order to determine if the organisation’s culture is causing you stress:
How does it happen?
How do you know if the organisational culture is affecting you?
What can you do about it?
If your organisation is taken over by or merged with another whose culture is quite different, ask your boss if you can:
31. Office politics and how to cope with it
Office politics is quite normal - it is basic human nature operating in the workplace. If you’re working with other people, as you’re likely to, then you will encounter office politics. It comes from competition among employees for things such as money and promotions. It also is based upon the personalities of some people.
Office politics is more than just disliking some people at work. It refers to the use and acquisition of power outside of the employee’s job requirements. The outcomes the employee is pursuing by the use of office politics, or the means by which the outcomes are sought, or both, would not be approved by the organisation. Office politics can cause stress for colleagues and can result in conflict within the organisation. A recent survey of almost 500 managers found that conflict in the workplace had increased, and 44 per cent of them believed office politics was the main cause of this increase.
Maybe you are stressed because a colleague is using office politics to advance themselves; looking at dealers in the London money market, it was found that more than 45 per cent felt coping with office politics was a stressful work-related item. Many managers who play at office politics cause their staff stress. It has been said that office politics determines promotions, transfers, supplies, equipment, who is in charge of what and how managers liaise with each other. One psychologist said if you have more than one employee, you’ve got office politics - it will determine who gets a pay increase or a better job. Another management researcher noted that if you try to ignore office politics, then you’re a fool. The research further highlighted that underperforming organisations are more likely to experience an increase in political behaviour as well as viewing such behaviour as a source of conflict.
How does it happen?
What can you do about it?
If you’re an employee, use techniques that will help you when in competition with colleagues:
If you’re an employer or manager:
Whatever your position in the organisation:
Sometimes you will have to protect yourself from others. You might select one or more of the following defensive but negative behaviours (which you might later come to regret because you are associated with them):
These are unprofessional and may not enhance your integrity.
32. How to deal with favouritism in the workplace
It won’t be a surprise to you. Nepotism, cronyism and favouritism occur in many organisations, and are used to give preferential treatment to relatives and friends in employment. One study showed that nepotism, cronyism and favouritism created job stress within the workplace, and nepotism was found to be the biggest factor in creating job stress.
Favouritism happens when the manager, boss or leader displays preferential treatment towards those workers with whom they are connected in some way. This negatively affects other employees and possibly the overall performance of the organisation. It can be completely demotivating to staff. Favouritism in the workplace means that someone - or a group - is treated better than others and the reason is not necessarily related to superior work performance. The person who is favoured might be promoted faster than others, get more for doing the same job, be granted more freedom than others, etc.
As the result of favouritism, your boss might: ? Spend more time with the chosen employee.
One study in the USA found that nearly 40 per cent of employees felt there was favouritism within their department.
What can you do about it?
For employees:
Talk to the human resources department in your organisation or to a manager you can trust. Make it clear what you are worried about, and give them any relevant information about the occurrences of favouritism. Ask human resources or the manager what you should do while your claim is being checked. At the same time, ensure you are performing to the best of your ability so the favouritism you claim is not mistaken for the other colleague simply performing better than you.
For employers, to ensure there is no favouritism in the organisation:
Don’t get caught up
Don’t get caught up in forming a grudge against your colleagues. The ‘favourite’ may be unaware of preferential treatment; reserve your judgement and energy for the company’s investigation into your claim.
33. How to make sure there is no discrimination in your workplace
Do you feel you have been discriminated against at work because you’re a member of a minority group? Does it cause you stress every day you go to work? Everyday discrimination is defined as the subtle acts that are experienced by members of a group (racial, religious, national) on a daily basis. Does this fit in with how you feel?
Discrimination can cause stress. In the UK it has been shown that black African-Caribbean respondents reported higher work stress than either Bangladeshi or white respondents, and that racial discrimination among black African-Caribbean female respondents resulted in greater perceived work stress and higher levels of psychological distress.
The UK government has said ‘it’s unlawful for an employer to discriminate against you because of your race. You are protected against racial discrimination at all stages of employment’ and ‘the Equality Act 2010 makes it unlawful for an employer to discriminate against you because of race. Race includes colour, nationality, and ethnic or national origins. Under the Act, it doesn’t matter if the discrimination is on purpose or not. What counts is whether (as a result of an employer’s actions) you are treated less favourably than someone else because of race. The Equality Act 2010 protects all racial groups, regardless of their race, colour, nationality, or national or ethnic origins. The laws against racial discrimination at work cover every part of employment. This includes recruitment, terms and conditions, pay and benefits, status, training, promotion and transfer opportunities, right through to redundancy and dismissal’. You can’t be discriminated against because of your:
That’s the UK law.
You might be suffering from one or more of the four major types of racial discrimination - direct discrimination (where, for example, race is an effective cause for less favourable treatment); indirect discrimination (rules or policies are imposed on everyone but which particularly disadvantage members of a particular group if that cannot be justified); harassment (participating in, allowing or encouraging unwanted behaviour that offends someone or creates a hostile atmosphere, for instance, making racist jokes at work); or victimisation (treating someone badly because they have complained or supported someone bringing a complaint about discrimination).
What you can do if you suspect you’ve been discriminated against
The UK government suggests that if it’s another employee who is the source of the problem you should talk to your immediate boss and explain your concerns. If it’s your boss who is discriminating against you, you should talk to their boss or to the company’s human resources department. If your employer won’t help, then you may need to make a complaint using your employer’s grievance procedure.
Don’t forget your trade union official may be able to help you, and make sure you know the current law concerning racial discrimination before you make a complaint.
Maybe you feel you have been subject to sexual discrimination. You believe you are doing the same work as a colleague and getting paid less, or are being discriminated against in some other way because of your sex. The UK government is quite clear about this:
Under the Equality Act 2010 it’s unlawful for an employer to discriminate against you because of your sex. Sex discrimination law covers almost all workers (men and women) and all types of organisations in the UK. It covers recruitment, employment terms and conditions, pay and benefits, training, promotion and transfer opportunities, redundancy and dismissal. If you believe that you are being paid less than a colleague who’s doing the same job, then you can refer to the rules about equal terms and equal pay. Where men and women, working for the same employer, are doing one of the following they are entitled to the same terms in their employment contract: the same or similar work, work rated as equivalent in a job evaluation study by the employer, and work of equal value.
What you can do if you think you are being discriminated against because of your sex
You can talk or write to your employer, and if they won’t help you may be able to take your case to an employment tribunal. You can also contact ACAS (the Advisory, Conciliation & Arbitration Service) and your trade union. Again, make sure you know the current law about sexual discrimination.
There are other forms of discrimination in the workplace, and they may be subject to different laws: age discrimination, disability discrimination, and religious or belief discrimination. Whatever the discrimination, they can all cause you stress.
34. How to deal with violence at work
Don’t be surprised if you have witnessed or experienced violence at work. A recent report showed that across the EU an average of 5 per cent of employees reported being the subject of physical violence - from a colleague. The figure was even worse in the UK, at around 9 per cent. Both being a victim of physical assault and simply seeing violence at work can result in trauma. The fear of workplace violence can result in anxiety and a desire to leave the organisation.
If you’re a taxi driver, you know all about violence at work. The murder rate associated with occupations in the USA, measured per 100,000 workers, is the highest for taxi drivers - who are four times more likely to be murdered at work than police officers or other law enforcement workers. In the West Midlands in the UK, recorded crime statistics in 2010 showed a fivefold increase of violent attacks on taxi drivers since 2000, and that feedback from taxi driver and operator associations shows the West Midlands figures are far from being an isolated trend.
Hopefully you’re not a taxi driver but you may have witnessed or experienced violence at your place of work. It seems those jobs that are subject to violence have certain features in common: employees encounter members of the public, they handle cash, staff work alone or in small numbers, employees work early in the morning or late at night, and the premises they work in are relatively unsecured and tend to be located in depressed areas. The major factors that can result in violence in the workplace are as dealing with the public, denying someone a service, making decisions that affect other people, having to supervise and discipline others, working in a job that involves the security of premises, having to work with valuable items, working at night or at weekends, working alone, doing a job that involves alcohol, being a care worker and going into other people’s homes. So if you are working in a job that contains more of these factors you have a greater chance of encountering violence at work. For instance, as well as taxi drivers, it has been suggested that psychiatric nurses encounter more workplace violence than other nurses. Psychiatric nurses work in a job that attracts many of these factors and this also applies to ‘ordinary’ nurses.
What you can do about eliminating the prospect of violence at work
For employers, the possibility of violence at work can be reduced by:
For employees, violence at work can cause pain, suffering and even disability or death. Physical attacks are obviously dangerous, but serious or persistent verbal abuse or threats can also damage employees’ health through anxiety or stress. What can you do if you witness or are the victim of violence at work?
If violence at work does occur then the victim or witness may suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Post-traumatic stress disorder is a psychiatric disorder that can occur following the experience or witnessing of life-threatening events, such as military combat, natural disasters, terrorist incidents, serious accidents or violent personal assaults. The symptoms of PTSD can include reliving the experience through nightmares and flashbacks, difficulty sleeping, and feeling detached or estranged, and these symptoms can be severe enough and last long enough to significantly impair the individual’s daily life.
How can PTSD be treated? Treatment for PTSD comes in a variety of forms of psychotherapy and drug therapy. There is no definitive treatment, and no cure, but some treatments appear to be quite promising, especially cognitive behavioural therapy, group therapy and exposure therapy, in which the patient repeatedly relives the frightening experience under controlled conditions to help them work through the trauma. Anyone who suspects they are suffering from PTSD should consult a medical professional.
35. How to cope with political correctness in the workplace
Are you unsure about political correctness? Do you worry you might say the wrong thing to a colleague? Are you afraid to criticise one of your employees because you’re afraid you’ll be accused of discrimination? Do you fear offending someone and losing your job, or getting yourself or your employer sued?
Well, one of the authors of this book understands exactly what you are going through. Some time ago he had to examine a dissertation written by a student at a different university. It was a poor piece of work that he was asked to review, and the author of the dissertation was given some advice on its failings and how they should be corrected so that a resubmission would obtain a pass mark. On receiving the poor score, the student threatened to take the examiner to a tribunal and to sue his university. The basis of the student’s case was that the examiner was biased against the student because he was from a minority ethnic group. The examiner was completely oblivious to the origins of the student. The case was quietly dropped, and the student resubmitted the dissertation and was awarded a pass. For a short period of time, the examiner was very concerned about the potential of the case.
What is meant by political correctness? Political correctness (PC) describes language, ideas, policies and behaviour that reduce any social and institutional offence in occupational, gender, racial, cultural, sexual orientation, religion, beliefs or ideologies, disability and age- related environments. On the other hand, many people see PC as having the potential to be something more invidious:
You’ll have to judge for yourself which version of PC is acceptable to you.
How to be politically correct
The main thing you have to do is to learn about other people and cultures. If you do that you can then:
36. How you can get the organisation to be more committed to you
Do you have the feeling that the organisation you work for is not on your side and does not support you? Meanwhile, you give your best and are committed to the organisation. If so, it’s not surprising that you get stressed. If you believe you don’t get the support from the organisation that you need, this can cause you to have lots of psychological problems and your performance may drop off. You may also think of leaving the company. Numerous investigations have shown that employees believe their organisation has a general positive or negative orientation towards them. This orientation is both to their contributions and their welfare.
Complete this short questionnaire (developed by the University of Delaware) to determine if you think your organisation is committed to you. Listed below are some statements that represent possible opinions you may have about working in your organisation. Indicate the degree of your agreement or disagreement with each statement by giving each a score as follows:
Those statements marked (R) are reverse-scored. This means you subtract your original score from 8. Now add all your scores.
If you scored between 8 and 16, you feel you are not receiving the support and commitment you require from the organisation.
If you scored 17-40, you are getting some support and commitment from the organisation.
If you scored 41-56, you feel you are receiving the support and commitment you require from the organisation.
If you believe you are not getting the commitment you need, the above statements will help to show where the problems lie. You can then ask your boss to remedy the failings. For instance, if you scored very low (after you have reverse-scored your original score) on statement 3, you can find out what happens to your complaints, who is not replying to you and why. You can then attempt to have the system for handling complaints changed.
What can you do about it?
If you want to increase your organisation’s commitment to you, you need to appreciate the qualities the organisation looks for in its employees. These include punctuality, honesty, an ability to handle pressure, dependability, efficiency and creativity, as well as doing a good job. You should ensure that you meet all of these requirements.