‘I was telling Olga about the tournament and all that trouble with the Mapp-Flints,’ Georgie said over dinner that night.
‘Yes, I had a letter from the bridge authorities this morning,’ Lucia informed him. ‘Based on the report of the directors they are asking the opinion of the Chairman of the Tilling Bridge Club as to whether the Mapp-Flints should be banned from all competitions and, if so, for how many years. I haven’t decided what to reply yet.’
‘But there isn’t a Tilling Bridge Club, is there? I mean, not yet anyway,’ Georgie pointed out. ‘And even if there is, it certainly doesn’t have a Chairman.’
‘I think that’s a bit of a grey area, isn’t it, dear?’ said she innocently. ‘After all, the club must have been in existence in order to hold the tournament as an affiliated event, so the fact that we hadn’t got around to holding its first meeting doesn’t really matter, surely?’
‘But even if you’re right about that, if the club has never held a meeting, then it can’t have appointed a Chairman, can it?’
He finished his soufflé and sipped his Chablis with the air of a King’s Counsel having just argued a particularly strong point in front of the Court of Appeal.
‘Au contraire, caro mio,’ Lucia said. ‘The constitution of the club, which is there on my desk, clearly stipulates that the club was formed before the tournament took place and that I am to be its interim Chairman. So all I have to do is convene a meeting to adopt the constitution with retrospective effect, which I am confident will be done.’
Georgie sat aghast.
‘But you can’t do that,’ he protested weakly. ‘Really, Lucia, it’s a blatant subversion of the democratic process. You should know better, having been a town councillor for so long, yes and Mayor too.’
‘Oh, Georgie,’ Lucia said sadly. ‘How little you understand about politics.’
She rang for Foljambe and Grosvenor, who cleared away the soufflé plates and then served the lamb chops.
‘I have been thinking about it very carefully,’ she went on after they had left the room. ‘I think I will give the Mapp-Flints a choice. One option would be for them to be members of the club ab initio as it were, in which case they will of course be subject to the disciplinary jurisdiction of the parent body to which we are affiliated, and would have been at the time of the tournament.’
‘And what would that mean?’ Georgie asked.
‘It would mean that I would have to reply to this letter, apologising for the conduct of two of our members, agreeing with the directors’ recommendations, and suggesting a three-year suspension. Dear me, I suppose that might have to apply to attending the club as well. I hadn’t thought of that.’
‘But that would be awful,’ Georgie said. ‘If everyone in Tilling is going to play at the club, then it’s unlikely people will carry on with their bridge teas, in which case the Mapp-Flints wouldn’t have anybody at all to play with.’
Lucia gave one of her little noises, which this time seemed to signify agreement, regret and sympathy all in one.
‘That’s why I will suggest they adopt the second alternative,’ she said.
‘Which is what?’
‘That they withdraw their application to join the club, in which case I can reply saying that they were outsiders playing as visitors, not a member of any affiliated club, and therefore outside the jurisdiction of any disciplinary proceedings.’
‘Well, that sounds a lot better,’ Georgie observed with relief. ‘Then they can just apply later to join the club when all the brouhaha has died down?’
‘After a suitable interval has elapsed,’ Lucia said judiciously. ‘The constitution does give the Chairman the right to reject membership applications without assigning any reason, so I suppose it would be for me to indicate to them when I thought enough water had flowed under the bridge, so to speak.’
‘And when would that be?’ Georgie asked.
‘Well,’ she replied rather coyly, ‘I rather thought three years would be about right, don’t you think?’
‘Oh, Lucia,’ he sighed. ‘Aren’t we all getting a bit too old for this?’
‘What do you mean, Georgie?’ she said frostily. ‘Surely you’re not losing your stomach for the fight?’
‘No, not at all. It’s just that I was rather hoping that things might settle down a bit now that all the business with the fête is over, and that we might extend the olive branch, so to speak.’
‘Pish!’ Lucia riposted. ‘If you offer Elizabeth Mapp-Flint an olive branch, first she’ll hit you over the head with it and then she’ll claim that you stole it from her garden in the first place.’
‘I know,’ Georgie said ruefully, admitting defeat, ‘and probably also that it’s a Mapp family heirloom of incalculable value.’
‘Indeed,’ Lucia agreed, ‘so let’s have no more of this defeatist talk, Georgie. We finally have that woman exactly where we want her, ready for the coup de grâce. She has behaved very badly, and in public too, and all that piled on top of the business with the fête and the coach means that everybody will completely support them effectively being ostracised.’
‘Oh, I don’t think ostracised is the right word, is it?’ Georgie objected. ‘After all, people will still talk to them and invite them to dinner and everything, won’t they?’
‘Possibly, if they have the gall to come into town, that is. No, you mark my words, Georgie, total victory is in sight – and if you really want to see the last of Elizabeth’s scheming, then total victory is the only thing that will stop her.’
‘I suppose it’s like that conference at Casablanca, isn’t it?’ Georgie proffered. ‘When Roosevelt said we would only accept unconditional surrender.’
‘Mr Churchill was there too, Georgie,’ Lucia reminded him. ‘I’m sure unconditional surrender was all his idea in the first place.’
‘Yes, I expect it was,’ he concurred.
‘Oh, by the way,’ he added, finishing his lamb chop, ‘I meant to say that I don’t think you were quite correct with your “uno piccolo codettino” after the fête.’
‘Really, Georgie?’ she enquired coldly. ‘In which particular, pray?’
‘Well, in just about all of them actually. In the first place, coda is feminine, so surely it would be una piccola codetta.’
‘Masculine, I think you’ll find.’
‘What, and ending in an “a”? Feminine surely.’
‘One of the exceptions, I think you’ll find. I’m sure there’s a line in Dante somewhere which demonstrates it,’ she said rather vaguely. ‘I really must look it up in the morning.’
‘Then there’s the diminutive,’ Georgie pointed out. ‘If you say codetta, or codettino if you must, then you don’t need piccola or piccolo now, do you? That’s tautologous – you know, saying the same thing twice.’
‘Yes, thank you, Georgie. I do know what tautologous means.’
‘Well, I’m just saying we should be careful,’ Georgie said in mollifying tones. ‘You know how we’ve sometimes been caught out in the past, and we have to remember that Mr Wyse speaks quite good Italian, as does Olga.’
‘Mr Wyse did not correct me, caro mio.’
‘No, but I saw him wince slightly,’ Georgie said, ‘and then look as though he wished he hadn’t.’
‘Perhaps I shall ask his opinion on the matter the next time I see him,’ Lucia said archly. ‘I could feign ignorance.’
‘But that wouldn’t sit very well with our famed prowess in Italian, would it?’ Georgie pointed out. ‘Think what Mapp might make of that. Why, suppose she brought a fluent Italian speaker to one of your tea parties?’
Lucia briefly considered the possibility and then smiled and shook her head decisively.
‘Non dispiace, Georgie. She’s not bright enough to think of anything like that.’
The next morning Lucia rang Grebe and explained to Elizabeth Mapp-Flint the predicament in which she found herself as Chairman of the bridge club. Apologetically, she offered the two options which she saw as being available to the Mapp-Flints.
Unsurprisingly, Elizabeth Mapp-Flint raised exactly the same juristic objections which Georgie had advanced, and equally unsurprisingly received the same responses. Sounds of barely concealed outrage then ensued.
‘You don’t have a parrot, do you, Elizabeth?’ Lucia enquired.
A spluttering reply was construed by her as a negative.
‘I was just wondering where that sound came from,’ she observed innocently.
‘What sound?’ Mapp managed to utter.
‘A sort of squawking, very much like a parrot in fact. But then if you don’t have one, it can’t have been. Curious, though, I could have sworn it was a parrot.’
There was a long silence.
‘Are you still there, dear?’ Lucia asked at length.
Surprisingly, when Mapp’s reply came it was in a curiously calm voice.
‘Yes, thank you, dear.’
‘Well, what do you wish me to do, Elizabeth? I’m sure you appreciate that the matter is a delicate one. The Tilling Bridge Club is newly formed, and is a tender flower. We don’t want any whiff of scandal or controversy to nip it in the bud, as it might be, do we?’
‘The Tilling Bridge Club is not yet formed,’ Mapp said evenly.
‘Soon will be,’ Lucia replied, ‘and with retrospective effect. The constitution makes that clear.’
‘The club will not be formed,’ said Mapp with the authority of one who had spent quite as many years sitting on committees as had Lucia, ‘until the members meet and adopt the constitution. And you may find, dear worship, that some of those present might wish to propose some teeny weeny amendments.’
‘Really, Elizabeth? I don’t think so. Such as what, exactly?’
‘Such as the automatic adoption of a certain person as Chairman, dear. Some might feel that Mr Wyse, for example, might be a more appropriate candidate, particularly as you are so busy with other matters.’
‘Dear Mr Wyse,’ Lucia said dreamily.
‘And then of course there’s the Chairman’s powers to reject membership applications. Hardly very common, is it, dear one?’
‘Really, dear? Didn’t you have something similar in WITCH? Such a shame you had to resign, of course.’
There was another interval in which heavy breathing could clearly be heard.
‘So, which is it to be?’ Lucia asked. ‘What am I to reply to these wretched people? It is unfortunate they took such a stern view of your conduct, Elizabeth. We’re going to have directors at our club sessions too, by the way.’
‘Such an unnecessary formality, Benjy and I thought. Just interrupting and spoiling people’s enjoyment. I should think again if I were you. I can’t see it being a popular innovation. Anyhow, I didn’t know anyone in Tilling was qualified.’
‘Not at the moment, no,’ Lucia said, ‘but Georgie and I have volunteered. We’re going away on a director’s course quite soon.’
There was another pause as this news was digested.
‘Elizabeth dear,’ she said gently. ‘I really must press you for an answer.’
‘I think, dear, that we would rather wait for the inaugural meeting of the club,’ Mapp said smoothly. ‘Once that is over we will see who emerges as Chairman and exactly what their powers may be. I am sure you can see, worship, that it would be premature for us to commit ourselves before then, or indeed for you to reply. If you did, you might have to write again later saying that you did not have authority to say what you did, and that could all be very awkward for the club, couldn’t it? Such a tender flower should not risk being nipped in the bud by any sort of controversy.’
‘I’m surprised, Elizabeth,’ Lucia responded with one last throw of the dice, ‘that you should view the prospect of a three-year ban with such equanimity.’
‘Three years does sound rather extreme, don’t you think, dear? Three months sounds rather more realistic. We would of course appeal in any case. The directors were clearly hopelessly biased against us. I didn’t see them rebuking anyone else all day.’
‘On the contrary, dear,’ Lucia replied. ‘Three years sounds quite lenient to me. I think there’s a serious possibility it could be five, particularly if you start casting aspersions about the directors.’
More heavy breathing and then again a curious calmness on Mapp’s part.
‘So sweet of you to have our best interests so very much at heart, but it sounds as though we must await events. By the way, we are looking forward to your tea party tomorrow.’
‘Oh, yes,’ said Lucia absently, ‘and you’re bringing your house guest aren’t you?’
‘Indeed we are. Such a charming young man. We were introduced to him through a mutual friend in London. He’s down here on a walking holiday studying birds.’
‘And what does he do, this charming young man?’ Lucia asked with what might almost have passed for genuine interest.
‘I’m really not sure,’ Mapp said vaguely. ‘I believe it’s something in the City. A bank or something. Well, until tomorrow then, worship. Au reservoir.’