He’s a child who clearly had some kind of accident—or worse, perhaps, a tumor—and is now forced to wear an eye patch. It’s kind of hard to laugh at the hilarious banter between Joe and the gang when this dark cloud of tragedy hangs over the whole thing.
Plus, there’s that mentally ill kid who insists on wearing his turtleneck over his mouth.
CREEPIOSITY INDEX: 7.27
No wonder someone poked his eye out.