| P | plays Pontius Pilate and Satan (was Pontius the Fish Gutter in Part One) |
| J | plays Jesus; P’s brother (was John the Fisherman in Part One) |
| MARY 1 | plays the Virgin Mary (was Mary 1 in Part One) |
| MARY 2 | plays Mary Magdalen; Mary 1’s sister (was Mary 2 in Part One) |
| VA PSYCHIATRIST | also plays ensemble roles (was Visiting Friar in Part One) |
| VIOLET | Mary 1’s child, three years old when we first meet her (was Village Idiot in Part One) |
| CARPENTER 1 | also plays ensemble roles (was Carpenter 1 in Part One) |
| CARPENTER 2 | also plays ensemble roles (was Carpenter 2 in Part One) |
| DIRECTOR | (was Director in Parts One and Two) |
| YOUNG DIRECTOR | (was Machinist in Part One) |
| PRESIDENT REAGAN | also plays Queen Elizabeth and Hitler |