Two Sides to Every Story

LAUREN SPENCER

Amina’s observations about the neighborhood we share made me think about the nature of finding oneself through our own perspective from one generation to the next. She and I share a neighborhood, but with a few blocks and a couple of well-placed decades in between.

The first time off the A train at 190th Street in my new neighborhood gave me a sense of up and down. For one, I’d never realized Manhattan had so many hills—I was used to the flat, gridded plains below 125th Street—and rolling down a steep incline to my apartment made me realize how city developers had left this bit alone. I was also experiencing the vertigo of being out of a decade-long marriage and realizing that glorious freedom could mix with hard loss. My new building also reflected a tale of two worlds. On the west side was a sheer stone cliff topped by Fort Tryon Park, where a now-fancy restaurant sat. I couldn’t actually afford to go to that restaurant, but it made me happy to know it was there.

When I exited the building out the east side, I was on Broadway, where salsa music vibrated the pavement. There was a health-food store that had been there, according to the lady behind the counter, for two decades. There was a tax place next to a bodega where a card table sat and men played dominoes. I was home. Not because I knew anything about dominoes, but because I felt community. No one knew me, but everyone still smiled. For the years I lived in that apartment, I grew to understand how to live in different sides of a situation, whether it was outside my window or inside my heart. I could get dressed up and climb the hill for a pricey dinner or slip on my flip-flops and cross Broadway for a batida; could plan my future as solo or make a date with a new possibility.

Recently I took a walk up in my old neighborhood, having moved a bit south a few years ago. A beer bar had replaced the tax place. The bodega was boarded and a sign teased a new restaurant coming soon. But the health-food store was still there and a card table of domino players was outside. A lot had happened in the seven years since I’d lived there but the core remained the same and I realized how the stories that form us are available in the streets we walk through every day.