Many years have passed since I first typed the four words, “Why follow a routine?” Little did I know then the controversy those four simple words would create. But here I am still, explaining again why I think routine is important. I must stress that my views have not changed one little bit from when I wrote my first book. I personally believe that the majority of babies thrive and are happier in a routine. But I certainly realize and respect that following a routine is not the best choice for all parents.
There is already so much advice out there for “baby-led parenting”; therefore, the advice I give in my books is for those parents who believe that they and their baby will be happier with more structure. I assume that one of the reasons you are reading this book is that you already have a certain level of structure in your life and that you believe you will cope with your baby better by following some sort of routine. If this is the case then I can assure you that following Contented Little Baby routines will most certainly benefit both you and your baby. They are followed successfully by hundreds of thousands of parents around the world. Follow your own instinct as a parent as to what works best for you and your baby; use the routines and advice in this book as tools to help you be the parents that you want to be.
Why the CLB Routines Are Different
During the years that I worked as a maternity nurse, I read hundreds of books on child care. I have also had the unique privilege of working personally with more than 300 families around the world. It is because of these parents and their beautiful babies that I feel I am able to share with you so much of what I have learned, which I hope will help you overcome many of the everyday challenges of parenting.
I would typically arrive at a home a few days after the birth and live with the family 24/7 for periods of 3–5 days, or sometimes several weeks to six months. While the media make much of the fact that many of my clients were rich and famous, I can assure you that most of the families I helped were not. They often had to get outside help because of health issues, family bereavement or other personal circumstances. Whether they lived in a mansion with 20 bedrooms or a walk-up apartment with only one bedroom, were a rock or movie star, struggling actor, high-profile banker or teacher, these parents all had two things in common—they wanted to ensure that their baby was happy and contented and that they could manage to meet all of their baby’s needs as well as cope with the demanding lives they led.
When I started, the leading child-care books all endorsed baby-led parenting and claimed that it was impossible to put a small baby into a routine. The implication was that if parents even attempted to do so, they could seriously damage the child’s health.
In my first book I said that, having successfully spent many years teaching parents how to put their newborns into a routine that results in a happy, thriving, contented baby, I can only assume that the authors of these books have not personally worked with enough babies to know this is possible. The fact that The Contented Little Baby Book became a runaway bestseller through personal recommendation is proof enough that the statement I made in my first edition in 1999 has been proved true.
Parents who have properly read the book, the routines and the advice I give can testify that the CLB routines really do work. Unlike old-fashioned every-four-hours feeding, they do not involve leaving a baby to yell until a feeding is due or letting him cry himself to sleep for lengthy periods. While establishing a routine is often very hard work and requires sacrifices on the part of the parents, hundreds of thousands of parents around the world will testify that it is worth it because they quickly learn how to meet the needs of their babies so that any distress is kept to a minimum.
Benefits for Your Baby
The reason that the CLB routines are different from traditional every-four-hours routines is that they are created to meet the natural sleep and feeding needs of all normal, healthy babies. They also allow for some babies needing more sleep than others and some going longer between feedings than others. The aim of the routines is not to push your baby through the night without a feeding but to ensure that structuring his eating and sleeping during the day will keep his nighttime waking at a minimum. He will wake and eat quickly before settling back to sleep. The routines also ensure that once your baby is capable of going longer between feedings, this will happen in the middle of the night, not during the day. The basis of these routines evolved over many years of observing babies in my care. Some babies would develop an eating pattern very quickly with little prompting, while others would be difficult to feed and settle for many weeks.
The following are the main observations that I made from babies who settled into a pattern quickly:
The parents had a positive approach, wanted a routine and tried to keep the first couple of weeks as calm as possible.
Handling of the baby by visitors was kept to a minimum so that the baby felt relaxed and secure in his new surroundings (which is especially important when the baby is first brought home from the hospital).
The baby always had regular sleep times in a quiet room.
The baby was kept awake for a short spell after the daytime feedings.
When he was awake and had been well fed and winded, he was then stimulated and played with for short periods.
A bedtime routine was established from day one. He would be bathed at the same time every evening, then fed and settled in a quiet room. If the baby did not settle, the parents would ensure that they kept things as quiet as possible and continued to comfort him in a dimly lit room until he did eventually settle.
Benefits for You
Listening to their baby crying is stressful for parents, particularly if the crying goes on for any length of time despite all their attempts to calm him. By following the CLB routines, you will soon learn the signs of hunger, tiredness, boredom and many other reasons why young babies get upset. The fact that you are able to understand his needs and meet them quickly and confidently will leave both you and your baby calm and reassured and avoid unnecessary crying. The common situation of fretful baby and anxious parents is avoided.
The other big plus for parents following my routines is that they have free time in the evening to relax and enjoy each other’s company. This is not usually possible for parents who follow baby-led parenting, as any attachment parenting Web site will show the early evening is a time when these babies are often particularly fretful and require endless rocking and patting to try to keep them calm.
Other Approaches
The routines and advice in this book evolved over many years. During my time as a maternity nurse, I tried and tested various ways of establishing breast-feeding and healthy sleep habits. Before I further expand on why I believe my methods are so successful, I will briefly discuss the other methods I have had experience with over the years, which I hope will give you an insight into why I believe that the CLB routines can be of great benefit to today’s readers.
Strict Every-Four-Hours-Feeding Routine
This routine evolved when hospital birth took over from home delivery many decades ago, and women would stay in the maternity unit for up to 10–14 days. Their babies were brought to them from the nursery every four hours and given a strict 10–15 minutes on each breast before being returned to the nursery. Although such routines are more associated with our grandmothers’ generation, there are still parents nowadays who believe that babies can be slotted into them. During my early years of working as a maternity nurse, I did work with some families that adopted these routines and, for some babies they did succeed, particularly if they were formula-fed.
However, I did find that trying to establish breast-feeding with a strict every-four-hours schedule, in which feedings were limited to a strict 10–15 minutes on each breast, did not work for most babies. The mother, believing that the reason her baby was not managing to stick to the schedule was because she was not producing enough milk, would be pressured early on to introduce top-up feedings of formula in order to get the baby to nurse at the right times according to the routines. I would be a multimillionaire if I had a dollar for every grandmother who said to me, “My milk dried up the minute I left the hospital.” The reality was that, due to rigid routines and restricted timing of feedings, the mother’s milk had started to dry up long before she left the hospital. The trend for bottle-feeding became well established in the 1950s and 1960s, with many mothers not even attempting to breast-feed. This trend continued well into the 1970s. Then, as research started to unearth more and more information regarding the health benefits of breast-feeding, the trend started to swing back again. Mothers were told not to restrict feedings and to allow their babies to nurse for as long as was needed to satisfy their hunger.
The CLB routines are not about strict four-hour-feeding schedules. It might be many weeks before an every-four-hours pattern can emerge, and I urge you not to be pressured into it, however keen you are to establish a routine. The main reasons every-four-hours feeding can fail:
Six feedings a day in the early days are usually not enough to stimulate a good milk supply.
Babies need to nurse little and often in the early days; restricting him to six feedings a day may lead to his being short of his daily intake.
Babies between one week and six weeks old usually need at least 30 minutes to reach the hind milk.
Hind milk is at least three times higher in fat content than fore milk and is essential for satisfying your baby’s hunger.
Demand Feeding
Although I did look after some babies that were put on a strict every-four-hours-feeding routine from birth, much of my experience in the early days of my career was with babies who were being fed on demand.
The advice given then is the same nowadays. Mothers are encouraged to let their babies take the lead, allowing them to nurse as often and for as long as they want. This method, like the every-four-hours method of feeding, did succeed for some babies, but it did not work for a huge number that I was asked to help. Very early in my experience, it became obvious that, quite simply, many newborn babies do not demand to be fed. This is particularly true of low-birth-weight babies and twins.
That is my main objection to demand feeding. If you had had the experience of sitting by the bedside of a baby only days old, fighting for his life because he has become seriously dehydrated through not being fed enough, you would probably feel the same way. Dehydration is a very serious problem among newborn babies and one that many new parents are now aware.
The production of breast milk works on a supply-and-demand basis, so babies who are allowed to sleep for long periods between feedings are not put to the breast often enough in a 24-hour period to signal the breasts to make enough milk. Mothers are lulled into a false sense of security that they have a baby who is easy and sleeps well.
In fact, what they have is a very sleepy baby who normally, 2–3 weeks down the line, will start waking more often and demanding more milk than the mother is producing. A pattern quickly emerges of the baby having to feed every couple of hours, day and night, in order to meet his daily nutritional needs.
The current advice is that this pattern is normal and that the baby will sort itself out, but mothers are not told that with some babies it may take months! Sometimes a pattern does emerge in which the baby will go longer between feedings. But often the baby is eating so much in the night that when he does wake for feedings during the day, they tend to be short and small. This leads to a vicious circle of the baby needing to feed more in the night to satisfy his daily needs. The mother then becomes exhausted. This exhaustion can often lead to some or all of the following problems:
Exhaustion and stress reduce the mother’s milk supply, increasing the baby’s need to nurse little and often.
Babies who continue to need to nurse 10–12 times a day after the first week often become so exhausted from lack of quality sleep that they become even more tired and feed for shorter and shorter periods.
Exhaustion can lead to the mother getting sick.
Being too tired to concentrate properly can lead to positioning the baby incorrectly on the breast. Poor positioning is the main reason for painful and often cracked and bleeding nipples, which again reduces how well the baby feeds at the breast.
A sleepy baby left too long between feedings in the early days reduces the mother’s chances of building up a good milk supply.
Another reason I am so opposed to the term demand feeding is that it is often taken too literally. If the baby is fed every time he cries, mothers tend not to look for other reasons as to why the baby may be crying—overstimulation or overtiredness, for example.
Of course, all babies must be fed if they are genuinely hungry; no baby should have to cry to be fed or should be kept on a strict timetable if he is genuinely hungry. But in my experience, and if research on sleeping problems is anything to go by, a huge number of demand-fed babies do not automatically fall into a healthy sleeping pattern months down the line. Many continue to wake and feed little and often long after they are capable of going a longer spell in the night. Another problem is that babies who continue to feed little and often invariably end up being fed to sleep. This creates a whole other set of sleeping problems, in which they have learned the wrong sleep associations and cannot get to sleep without being nursed.
Whether you are the parent of a newborn baby or of an older baby, I urge you not even to attempt to start the routines until you have read and understood Chapters Three, Milk Feeding in the First Year, and Four, Understanding Your Baby’s Sleep, on feeding and sleeping in the first year. Because CLB routines are not like the old-fashioned every-four-hours routines, it is not just a case of trying to fit your baby’s feeding and sleeping into the times I suggest. The CLB routines change ten times during the first year. The times given for feeding and sleeping in each set of the routines are approximate guidelines for your baby’s age, not rigid rules. You need to understand the principles behind the routines so that you can make necessary adjustments to ensure that your baby’s individual needs are being met.
Your Questions Answered
Q | I am six months pregnant, and like many new mothers-to-be, I am concerned about how I am going to cope with the sleepless nights. My prenatal class stresses the importance of demand feeding, that new babies should be fed when they need it and that I should not attempt a routine in the early days. I am concerned that if I try to follow your routines, I may be denying my baby food when he is hungry. |
Q | Do I really have to wake my newborn baby up to feed him? He wants to sleep all the time and I am tempted to leave him. |
Q | Several friends and relations have said that it is cruel to wake a sleeping baby and that he will wake when he is ready to nurse. I am a very organized person and feel that following a routine would be best for both my baby and me, but I am frightened that I could do some sort of psychological or physical damage to my baby by waking him. |
Q | The current advice is that parents should have their baby in the same room with them for all sleep periods during the first six months. I am concerned that my baby will not sleep well in our living room for naps and in the evening and that it will be difficult to get him used to sleeping in his nursery when he does reach six months. How easy is it to establish your routines while also adhering to the new guidelines? |
A | The majority of parents with whom I have worked have had their baby sleep with them in their room at night. The latest advice is that your baby should be put down for all his sleeping in the room you are in until he is six months old. This means that it will take more time to get him used to his nursery. However, getting your baby used to his own room sooner rather than later can help you avoid disrupting and unsettling him when he reaches six months. You can make the nursery a peaceful haven for him by using it for diaper changing, feeding and winding down or quiet playtime. In terms of settling your baby to sleep in another room, try to keep things as calm and quiet as possible for him to help distinguish between “awake” time and time for sleeping. It is unlikely that you will have a crib in two places in your home; therefore, a bassinet with a proper, firm mattress would be an acceptable option. Follow the same guidelines for settling your baby in the bassinet as those given for settling him in a crib: place him in the bassinet with his feet at the bottom, and firmly tuck in any sheets and blankets. Putting the hood up during sleep times will help keep out the light and help your baby sleep better. Last, remember that these recommendations are only for the first six months; after that you can start to settle your baby in his own room for naps and nighttime sleep. (See Chapter Thirteen, Months Six to Nine, for advice on how to make the transition easier for him.) |
Q | Is it true that you say babies should not be cuddled? I keep reading that babies need lots of physical affection and attention in order for them to feel secure. |
Q | While I would like a routine when my baby is born, I do not want to let him cry for long spells. |
Q | I have read that on your routines a baby should not be fed in the middle of the night once she reaches 12 weeks. Surely all babies are different and a baby should not be forced to go without food if she is hungry? |
Q | I read a message from a mother in an online parenting chat room that she is very lonely and depressed following your routines as it leaves her no time to get out and do anything else. |
Q | In your routines you tell mothers when to eat and drink. This strictness puts me off. |
Q | Why are your routines so rigid? Surely half an hour here or there won’t make much difference? |
Q | I have been trying to follow your routines for four weeks but my baby is not anywhere close to fitting in with them. I feel like a failure and wonder if I should just give up and let her nurse and sleep whenever she wants. |
Q | Why are you so strict about avoiding eye contact at the late feeding? I feel very cruel depriving my baby of cuddles and this close contact. |
Q | Your routines are so strict. When can I enjoy my baby without worrying about what he should be doing next? |
Q | I have a toddler as well as a new baby to care for, and I cannot seem to get your routines to work around both of them. |