The First Doctor, William Hartnell

‘An Unearthly Child’: The Doctor doesn’t get a look in. He’s horrible. 7/10

‘10,000 BC’: Stone Age nonsense. 4/10

‘The Daleks’: They should have called the show Ian. 3/10

‘The Edge of Destruction’: It wasn’t boring. 2/10

‘Marco Polo’: It’s a shame it’s missing. 6/10

‘The Keys of Marinus’: The acting was dreadful. 4/10

‘The Aztecs’: Pretty good. 7/10

‘The Sensorites’: If that’s the worst you can throw at me we’ll be fine. 5/10

‘The Reign of Terror’: If I want to see a revolution, I can turn on the news. 4/10

‘Planet of Giants’: I like it when the story is self-contained. 7/10

‘The Dalek Invasion of Earth’: I’m really torn over this one. 7/10

‘The Rescue’: The plot was practically non-existent. 3/10

‘The Romans’: Definitely the best one so far. 8/10

‘The Web Planet’: I would have given it a 0 if it weren’t for the Spanish episode. 1/10

‘The Crusade’: It was very well made and it didn’t outstay its welcome. 7/10

‘The Space Museum’: It was too ahead of its time. 6/10

‘The Chase’: I’m getting a bit bored of the Daleks. 5/10

‘The Time Meddler’: It’s the most enjoyable story so far. 9/10

‘Galaxy 4’: Not very good. 2/10

‘Mission to the Unknown’: It reminded me of Babylon 5. 6/10

‘The Myth Makers’: The fans should spend more time looking for this one. 8/10

‘The Daleks’ Master Plan’: Some of it was rubbish and some of it was good. 5/10

‘The Massacre’: A confusing story with a really stupid twist. 2/10

‘The Ark’: The Monoids let it down; they were too silly for words. 5/10

‘The Celestial Toymaker’: Complete shite. 0/10

‘The Gunfighters’: We could watch it again! 8/10

‘The Savages’: For a recon, it was surprisingly engaging. 7/10

‘The War Machines’: It didn’t really feel like Doctor Who. 6/10

‘The Smugglers’: I’ll have forgotten it by next week. 5/10

‘The Tenth Planet’: Is that it? 3/10

The Second Doctor, Patrick Troughton

The Third Doctor, Jon Pertwee

The Fourth Doctor, Tom Baker

‘Robot’: The story was pants. 5/10

‘The Ark in Space’: Tom Baker was brilliant. 7/10

‘The Sontaran Experiment’: Too short. 5/10

‘Genesis of the Daleks’: Excellent. 9/10

‘Revenge of the Cybermen’: A load of old rubbish. 3/10

‘Terror of the Zygons’: It had a lot going for it. 7/10

‘Planet of Evil’: The guy who played the commander was hopeless. 5/10

‘Pyramids of Mars’: I’d like less gobbledegook and more drama. 7/10

‘The Android Invasion’: It fell apart at the end. 5/10

‘The Brain of Morbius’: Some of the dialogue was priceless. 8/10

‘The Seeds of Doom’: It can’t get any better than that. 10/10

‘The Masque of Mandragora’: Very accessible. 9/10

‘The Hand of Fear’: Good, very good, good, shit, really shit, then excellent. 6/10

‘The Deadly Assassin’: The first three episodes were perfect. 8/10

‘The Face of Evil’: Something was missing … 4/10

‘The Robots of Death’: It didn’t make any sense. 5/10

‘The Talons of Weng-Chiang’: I’ll knock some marks off for the casual racism. 8/10

‘Horror of Fang Rock’: I really enjoyed that. 9/10

‘The Invisible Enemy’: A terrible mess. 4/10

‘Image of the Fendahl’: I’ve forgotten it already. 2/10

‘The Sun Makers’: The script was very witty. 6/10

‘Underworld’: Am I allowed to give negative scores? 1/10

‘The Invasion of Time’: Oh dear. 0/10

‘The Ribos Operation’: It’s not perfect, but it’s pretty close. 9/10

‘The Pirate Planet’: An imaginative mess. 6/10

‘The Stones of Blood’: I really enjoyed that. 8/10

‘The Androids of Tara’: I don’t think there was a bad performance. 9/10

‘The Power of Kroll’: If K9 had been in it I might have given it an eight. 7/10

‘The Armageddon Factor’: They had months to get that right … 4/10

‘Destiny of the Daleks’: I hated that. 2/10

‘City of Death’: That was faultless. 10/10

‘The Creature from the Pit’: Killed by a giant cock and balls … 2/10

‘Nightmare of Eden’: The premise was great and it kept me guessing. 7/10

‘The Horns of Nimon’: I think they all need a good lie down. 5/10

‘The Leisure Hive’: Too much style and not enough substance. 6/10

‘Meglos’: Well, that was shit. 2/10

‘Full Circle’: I like Adric. So there. 7/10

‘State of Decay’: I loved the set design. 7/10

‘Warriors Gate’: I didn’t understand it, but I don’t care. 8/10

‘The Keeper of Traken’: Tedious. 3/10

‘Logopolis’: Disappointing. 4/10

The Fifth Doctor, Peter Davison

The Sixth Doctor, Colin Baker

The Seventh Doctor, Sylvester McCoy

The Eighth Doctor, Paul McGann