Chapter 11. Music, Sound Effects, and Narration

If you’re lucky, you may someday get the chance to watch a movie whose soundtrack isn’t yet finished. Maybe you’ll be scanning TV channels and stumble across a special about how movies are made, or you’ll see a tribute to a film composer, or you’ll rent a movie that includes a “making of” documentary. These shows sometimes include a couple of minutes of the finished movie as it looked before the music and sound effects were added.

At that moment, your understanding of the film medium will take an enormous leap forward. “Jeez,” you’ll say, “without music and sound effects, this $100 million Hollywood film has no more emotional impact than…my home movies!”

And you’d be right. It’s true that the visual component of a film is the most, well, visible. Movie stars and directors become household names, but not the sound editors, composers, foley (sound effects) artists, and others who devote their careers to the audio experience of film.

But without music, sound effects (called SFX for short), and sound editing, even the best Hollywood movie will leave you cold and unimpressed.

iMovie’s more powerful than it’s ever been at editing your movie’s audio. You can use traditional methods to make simple volume changes, like the classic rubber-band tool (Volume Adjustments), or advanced techniques that reduce background noise (Reduce Background Noise). This chapter explains everything iMovie has to offer in audio editing.

Three Kinds of Audio

You’ll work with three kinds of audio in iMovie: clip audio, background music, and connected audio.

Background Music

A lot of iMovie owners like to add music to their movies. It’s a fun way to augment otherwise mundane shots, and can evoke the feeling of the moment. (Think of an end-of-year slideshow set to “Gangnam Style,” or whatever song was big that year.)

To make editing music easier, iMovie can set it as background music, a solid block of audio that sits “under” the clips in your project, playing through everything, no matter how you shuffle the clips around. You can even line up a playlist of several songs; iMovie plays them consecutively, with a nice crossfade in between.

Connected Audio

Background music remains steadily in place no matter how you rearrange your footage, but some audio should move with your video. When you add a connected audio clip, you attach an audio file to a specific spot in your video. You’d use connected audio for things like sound effects, to trigger a laugh track, for example, or the roar of applause. As you rearrange your clips during the editing process, the connected audio goes along for the ride.

This section covers all the ways you can adjust the volume in your movie.

If “rubber-banding” makes you think of office supplies instead of volume levels, then meet an iMovie tool that’s super useful. (Audio editors call volume adjustments “rubber-banding” because the line you grab to adjust the fade-in and fade-out points in an audio track seems to stretch as you fine-tune those points.)

The height of the rubber band determines the volume of your clip. The higher the line, the louder the clip. The band’s starting position, about a third of the way down from the top, is the standard 100% volume. If you drag the line higher or lower, iMovie displays a floating bubble that shows you the new volume level (Figure 11-2).

If all you could do was change the height of the line for the entire clip, there wouldn’t be much point to the tool. (After all, you can change the volume of a clip in the Adjustments pane.) The beauty of it comes when you stretch it up or down on just part of your clip. You can, for example, soften the background music when Grandma Alice tells her story. Alternatively, you can increase the volume when a soft-spoken interviewee appears onscreen.

To make these adjustments, first select the part of a clip you want to affect. To do that, click the clip and hold down the mouse button until a vertical yellow line appears. Then drag your mouse—as you drag, the yellow line expands into a box that selects the underlying clip fragment (Figure 11-2, middle). Drag the rubber band within that selected area to adjust the volume. You can see the rubber band move up and down as you drag.

Once you deselect the clip fragment by clicking anywhere else in the storyboard, you can see the “stretched” parts of the rubber band, where iMovie fades the volume in or out to reach the fragment’s setting.

To change the length of the fade—that is, to make it gradual or abrupt—grab the little yellow diamonds on either end of the adjustment and drag them horizontally (Figure 11-2, bottom). Dragging them outward makes the volume change more gradually. Dragging them inward makes the volume change more suddenly, which you might do, for example, to make a song pop back in really loudly.

Finally, you can add your own yellow diamonds—iMovie calls them keyframes—by Option-clicking the volume-level line. You can drag these added keyframes the same way you do the iMovie-generated diamonds, and to the same effect—fading the volume in or out.

To delete a keyframe, right-click it and then select Delete Keyframe, or select the keyframe and then choose Edit→Delete Keyframes, or press Shift-Option-Delete.

Anytime you hear competing audio tracks in a movie, the editor has probably dropped the volume in one track so you could hear the sound in the other. (You’ve seen this when actors in a music montage stop for a moment to have a brief discussion. The music dips down so you can understand the dialogue.) This is called ducking, where you “duck,” or drop the volume in, one audio track to make room for the audio in another.

Ducking is a convenient way to make sure your audience hears your audio, regardless of where the rubber band is—that’s because ducking makes the volume adjustments for you. It really all comes down to a checkbox and a slider.

To make sure that one of your audio tracks is always heard, do the following:

  1. Select the clip whose audio you want to change.

    You might want to adjust the clip’s native audio, or the volume of an audio track you added to the clip, such as a background track or a connected audio clip (all explained on Three Kinds of Audio).

  2. In the Viewer toolbar, click the Adjust button, followed by the Volume button (the speaker icon).

    iMovie displays the volume adjustment tools, where you can change the clip’s audio in multiple ways (Figure 11-3).

  3. Turn on the “Lower volume of other clips” checkbox and then adjust the slider to your liking.

    The lower you move the slider, the quieter other audio clips become. You can skim and play your project to make sure you’ve got the right setting.

To undo the ducking on a track, turn off the “Lower volume of other clips” checkbox.

If you drag a piece of music to the very bottom of your storyboard—where you see a clip silhouette with a musical note in it—the clip turns into long green waveform (Figure 11-4). That’s your clue that you just added a piece of what Apple calls background music. (Make sure you drag the song all the way to the bottom of the storyboard and not immediately under the video clip—that would make it a connected audio clip, as explained on Three Kinds of Audio.)

Understanding what, exactly, Apple means by this term—and figuring out how it differs from connected audio—isn’t especially easy. This much, though, is clear:

Putting your background music in its own track makes sense because the music is usually ancillary to the story you’re telling (unless you’re editing a video to music, as described on Edit to the Beat). Adding the song as a background track puts it conveniently out of your way, impervious to whatever video edits you make.

Before getting into the details of how background music works, you need to add a song to your project. iMovie gives you three ways to do that: via iTunes, Garage-Band, and the Finder.

When you have a project open, iMovie displays a list of media sources in the Content Library in the bottom-left corner of the window. One of the options is your iTunes library, where you can tap into your entire iTunes song list, without actually having to open iTunes itself, a real convenience.

When you click iTunes in the Content Library. iMovie replaces the Event browser with a music browser (Figure 11-5) that displays your song list and a waveform representing the currently selected tune. A dropdown menu lets you sort your music by stock iTunes listings (My Top Rated, Recently Played, and so on) or by playlist.

If you can’t find the song you want, use the search field in the top-right corner of the music browser. As you type, iMovie narrows your choices. You can search song titles, album titles, and artist names all at once. (Typing “fun” would show the results for the band Fun., the album “Funeral” by Arcade Fire, and the song “Girls Just Want to Have Fun.”)

The Finder

If you have a music file that’s on your hard drive but not in iTunes or GarageBand, you can always just drag it into the iMovie storyboard from the Finder. You don’t get the benefit of a handy music browser, but once you add the file to your project, it behaves just like any iTunes or GarageBand song.

Once you have a song in the storyboard, you’re not stuck with it. In fact, the awesome editing-by-reference trick that iMovie does with video (The Concept of iMovie Projects) works on music, too.

To trim a song, move your mouse over the beginning or end of the clip. When you do, iMovie changes your cursor from an arrow to two arrows with a line between them. Drag to trim or extend that part of the song.

That approach isn’t nearly as versatile as the Clip Trimmer, which you can use to fine-tune your track edit, as explained in the sidebar here.

Move a Song

By default, iMovie starts your song at the beginning of your project, but you can drag it to whatever starting point you want.

Change the Volume of a Song

You change the volume of background music the same way you change the volume of any other clip. Use one of the methods described on Volume Adjustments.

If you’ve ever made a music video, you know how easy it is to pull your hair out trying to match a transition with a beat in the background. To make sure you don’t go bald, iMovie offers a subtle but very powerful tool called a marker.

Markers are specially designed indicators you add to your movie that correspond to particular moments. You can use markers for all sorts of editing strategies, like noting when you want a title to appear or a clip to end. You can also use markers to tap out beats in a song. Then, as you add video clips to your project, you can easily match the clips’ length and cuts to the beat of the music. The markers even work with adjustments you make using the Precision Editor (The Precision Editor)—those edits will also snap to line up with the beats you mark.

The truth is, markers are one of the coolest iMovie features that no one talks about. But what markers lack in recognition, they make up for in power. They’ll save you huge swaths of time editing a movie to the beat of a song.

Editing to the beat is a three-phase process. Before you dive in, make sure you have snapping enabled by heading to View→Snapping (you’ll see a checkmark if you have Snapping turned on).

You can mark beats in your song a couple of ways. As you skim through the song, you can hear and spot (using the song’s waveform) places where the beat would make a well-timed cut. As you line up your playhead on that spot, choose Mark→Add Marker (or press the letter M key on your keyboard).

In addition to tagging beats, mark any spot you want to get special attention as you edit, like a big musical swell or key bit in the lyrics.

The markers show up as tiny blue tags resting on top of your song (Figure 11-8).

Alternatively, you might find it a lot simpler to just hit the letter M key as your song plays. That way, you can have all your markers in place by just going through the song.

Play the audio track from the beginning. As it plays, tap the M key on every beat where you want the video to cut to a new shot. (It’s OK to boogie in your chair; no one is watching.)

Once you tap out the whole song, take a moment to review your markers and fix mistakes. Beat markers are draggable, even after you place them. You can remove a marker by dragging it off the top of the clip, or by right-clicking it and selecting Delete from the shortcut menu. There’s no way to get rid of all the markers at once, however. If you want to start over, delete the entire song from your project. Then add the song back into your project and begin again.

Don’t group your markers too closely together unless you’re trying to get a very fast-paced effect. If the video cuts happen too quickly, your viewers won’t be able to absorb them.

Once you’re happy with the beat placements, it’s time to start adding video clips.

What if you added beat markers after you added your footage? Or what if your video doesn’t display the exact image you want on the beat? That’s where the Precision Editor can help.

With your song at the bottom of the project window and all its beat markers in place, double-click any empty space between two video clips to launch the Precision Editor. The Precision Editor covers the basic operation of the editor, but you should know that it offers some handy extras when you work with beat markers (Figure 11-10).

To line up a transition with a beat, drag the gray transition bubble around. Each time it approaches a beat marker in the song, the bubble snaps to the marker.

Here’s a rundown of how you could use beat markers in the Precision Editor:

Connected Audio

Background music works when you want a song to play behind whatever is onscreen, but sometimes you want to marry an audio file to a particular moment in your video. You might, for example, want a laugh track to start right after your actor tells a joke.

That’s where connected audio comes in. It lets you pin audio to video. (It’s analogous to connected video clips, explained on Reverse a Clip’s Playback Direction.) If you move the video clip, the audio track goes with it. This gets super handy when you shuffle clips around or change your project timing with added transitions (see A Long Discussion of Transition Lengths for transitions and project timing).

Sound Effects

This is a great time to introduce iMovie sound effects, since you’ll almost always use them as connected audio. With a project open, you’ll see the Content Library in the bottom-right corner of the iMovie window. One of the sources listed is Sound Effects.

When you click it, iMovie opens the music browser you saw for iTunes, now full of premade sound effects (Figure 11-11). There are hundreds to choose from, so use the search box and/or the drop-down menu to narrow things down.

If anyone ever belittles iMovie for being underpowered, point out an iMovie feature that isn’t even available in many more expensive video-editing programs: the ability to record narration while you watch your movie play back. If your Mac has a microphone, you can easily create any of these effects:

To create a voiceover (a narration), follow these steps:

  1. Choose WindowRecord Voiceover, or press the letter-V key.

    The Viewer displays iMovie’s voiceover tools (Figure 11-13).

  2. Click the Voiceover Options button to choose a sound source.

    Your Mac’s microphone takes one of two forms: built-in or external. The built-in mic, a tiny hole in the facade of the iMac, eMac, or MacBook, couldn’t be more convenient. It’s always with you, and always turned on.

    If your Mac doesn’t have a built-in microphone, you can plug in an external USB microphone or a standard microphone with an adapter (like the iMic from Griffin Technology [www.griffintechnology.com]).

    The Input Source menu lists all the audio sources the Mac knows about—Built-in Microphone, Built-in Input (meaning the audio-input jack on the back or side), USB Microphone, or whatever you’ve connected.

  3. Set the input level.

    That is, move close to the microphone and practice your spiel. If the green sound meter inside the little microphone (Figure 11-13) is too low (say, just a couple of bars), your narration isn’t loud enough. On playback, it’ll probably get drowned out by the other audio track.

    If the meter turns bright red, you’re too loud, and the recording will have an unpleasant, “overdriven” distortion.

    To change the recording volume, drag the Volume slider left or right. (You can learn tricks for boosting the volume of audio tracks later in this chapter, but it’s much better to get the level right the first time.)

  4. Turn the Mute Project checkbox on or off.

    The question you’re answering here is this: Do you want to hear the audio from your movie playing back while you record? Usually, the answer is “Yes” (so you want to turn off this checkbox), because you don’t want to talk over the on-camera conversation, and you can time your own utterances to perfection. The problem is, your microphone hears the movie playback coming out of your Mac’s speakers and records it anyway, or even triggers squealing feedback.

    Therefore, turn off the Mute Project checkbox only if you’re wearing headphones to monitor playback.

  5. Find the spot in your video where you want to start narrating.

    You can use all the usual techniques to navigate your clips: skim (point without clicking), press the space bar to play the movie, and so on.

  6. When you find the right spot, click the microphone button (Figure 11-13).

    A big, orange 3-2-1 countdown timer appears in the Viewer, accompanied by attention-getting countdown beeps. You even see preroll—the Viewer shows the 3 seconds of video that lead up to the point you clicked. All of this is intended to help you get ready to speak at the spot you selected.

  7. Once the numbers in the Viewer disappear, start talking. Press the space bar (or click the glowing red microphone button) to stop.

    A new connected audio clip appears below your filmstrip, bearing the label “VO-1:” and your project name, as shown in Figure 11-13. (VO stands for “voiceover.”) As you speak, the audio stripe starts off a burning red and then cools into the standard audio green as you continue narrating. After you finish recording, point to a spot just before the beginning of the new recording, and then press the space bar to listen to your voiceover.

  8. Close the Narration window (press the letter V key).

If the narration wasn’t everything you hoped for, it’s easy enough to record another take. Just hit ⌘-Z (Undo) or highlight the green voiceover stripe, and then press Delete. Then repeat this process.

You can record as many overlapping narration takes as you like. The green stripes just pile up, and they behave exactly like the sound-effects stripes described on Connected Audio. That is, you can do the following:

  • Delete a stripe by clicking it and then pressing the Delete key.

  • Shorten a stripe by dragging its endpoints (or by double-clicking the stripe, and then using the Clip Trimmer, as described on Use the Clip Trimmer).

  • Move a stripe by dragging it to a new spot, using the middle of it as the handle.

  • Change the volume using the tricks explained on Volume Adjustments.

iMovie is perfectly capable of letting you add just the audio portion of a piece of video footage to your storyboard. The recorded audio shows up as an independent, connected audio clip. Its green flag indicates that it’s locked to wherever in the storyboard you dropped it. Figure 11-14 shows the process.

Adding just a clip’s audio to your project unleashes all kinds of useful new tricks that are impossible to achieve any other way:

It’s important to note that iMovie never removes the audio from the original video clip. You’ll never be placed into the frantic situation of wishing that you’d never done the extraction at all, unable to sync the audio and video together again (which sometimes happens in “more powerful” video-editing programs).

Instead, iMovie places a copy of the audio in the storyboard. The original video clip retains its original audio. As a result, you can extract audio from the same clip over and over again, if you like. iMovie simply spins out another copy of the audio each time.

When you transition between video clips, the audio needs to transition, too. With video transitions, you get to choose how they look because you choose from any of iMovie’s many transitions (Adjust Automatic Transitions).

In the case of audio, iMovie always crossfades between clips for the duration of the transition. That means a 2-second transition will cause a 2-second audio crossfade between clips.

If you don’t want this, you can always use the Precision Editor to change when the audio changes between clips, as explained on The Precision Editor.

Audio Effects and Enhancements

If all iMovie could do in the audio department is make volume changes and add some music, it would be good enough. But who wants good enough? Apple makes iMovie even more formidable, audio-wise, by adding a slew of effects and enhancements.

iMovie’s audio effects are really cool and a ton of fun to play with. Want your dad to sound like a mouse? Piece of cake. Want your baby to sound like a robot? Easy-peasy. Want to be able to sing like T-Pain, the rapper who made autotuning famous? You get the idea.

The Audio Effects Catalog

Although you’ve got the adorable little stick figures doing interpretive performances of each effect (Figure 11-15), you might still like a rundown of each effect and what it accomplishes:

Traditionally, an equalizer is a set of sliders that lets you increase or reduce the low, medium, and high tones in an audio track. They’ve been around for years, but most people don’t ever use them.

That’s because most people don’t need them. Usually they show up only in music-playback software like iTunes. If you have decent speakers and the song was recorded professionally, there’s little point in messing around with audio levels. The balancing work has been done for you.

Your camera’s audio, on the other hand, hasn’t been professionally adjusted. As a result, you might find that the bass guitar at the concert you’re (legally) recording sticks out like a sore thumb. That’s where the equalizer comes in handy. You can reduce the low-end sounds to make everything balance out.

iMovie doesn’t want to bother you with sliders, but it still helps you improve a clip’s sound the way an equalizer can. Figure 11-16 shows you the iMovie equalizer menu. You get to it by clicking Adjust, and then the bar graph icon, a.k.a. the “Noise reduction and equalizer” button.

If you’re not sure which Equalizer menu option to choose, try one. If you choose Bass Reduce, for example, the lower-tone sounds in your clip drop away. You can preview the result by clicking a spot in your audio and then pressing the space bar. Change your equalizer setting at any time; iMovie makes the change instantly, with no rendering.

File this feature under “Amazing power turned on with a mere checkbox.” Among iMovie’s many cool tricks, this is one of the coolest. All of us suffer from the problem this feature fixes.

Other than shaky video (Video Stabilization), the surest sign of amateur video is bad audio. Most people pay so much attention to what they’re filming that they tune out the sound they’re recording. So without your even noticing it, your camera’s microphone can pick up the hum of fluorescent lights, the drone of a clothes dryer, or even the whir of its own zoom lens. Professionals know all this, and that’s why they’re famous for shouting, “Quiet on the set!” They know that you can point a camera lens right where you want it, but microphones aren’t so discriminating.

As you’re out and about filming, unless you’ve brought professional audio equipment like a boom mike and a mixing board, you’re using the microphone in your camera. Unfortunately, built-in mics have a reputation for being undiscerning. That is, they generously record any and every sound that hits them. That’s no big deal if you’re recording an interview in a quiet room, but it really stinks if the air conditioner in the room kicks in. The drone in the background makes the whole clip sound like amateur hour.

So if you’re at the beach and just got a great little shot of your 4-year-old singing “Bob the Builder” over his sand castle, you want to hear the singing and not the wind or waves. Here’s where iMovie steps in to save the day. It magically scrubs your audio, removing sounds like waves, fan noise, traffic, and other messiness.

To use this feature, select the audio clip and then click the Adjust button. Choose the “Noise reduction and equalizer” tool (the bar graph) shown in Figure 11-17, and then turn on the checkbox labeled “Reduce background noise.”

Your clip immediately sounds cleaner. If it’s not clean enough (or if it’s too clean to sound real for the surroundings), then move the slider left or right to change the amount of noise reduction.

Let’s say you make a few audio adjustments to a clip: upped the volume, ducked other tracks, and added an effect. Now you want to do the same to a lot of other clips. Luckily for you, iMovie saves you the many clicks it would take to repeat the process. You can copy and paste the audio adjustments in one clip to a bunch of others.

Select the clip you’ve adjusted and choose Edit→Copy (⌘-C). Then select the clip(s) you want to adjust and choose Edit→Paste Adjustments. In the menu that appears, you can choose Volume (Option-⌘-A) or Audio Effect (Option-⌘-O). The first pastes all the volume adjustments, including rubber-band changes, auto enhance, and ducking, and the second pastes whatever audio effect you applied to the copied clip.

Because you can select multiple clips at once (Select by Dragging), you can make all these audio changes in one fell swoop.

Editing Audio in GarageBand

What if you really want to dig into your movie’s audio? iMovie’s audio tools are great and all, but they could leave you wanting. What you need is an audio-editing program. Perhaps one like the application that Apple offers for free in the App Store!

That would be GarageBand, the music composition program that’s part of iLife. It offers all kinds of audio-specific tools not found in iMovie, the most prominent being the composition tools you can use to create your own movie scores.

Fortunately, you can export your movie to GarageBand to edit the soundtrack with its much more powerful tools. Don’t read any further, however, until you absorb these two warnings:

GarageBand is a music composition program containing dozens of powerful tools. It lets you combine multiple audio tracks, giving you fine control over each track’s sound effects, volume, and even stereo panning.

But if you’re like most people, you’ve never even set foot in GarageBand. (Apple says GarageBand is the second least-used iLife program.) Here’s a crash course:

  1. Export your movie from iMovie.

    Use one of the file export options explained in Chapter 15.

  2. Open GarageBand.

    GarageBand’s icon looks like an electric guitar; it’s in your Applications folder. If this is your first time in GarageBand, a welcome screen greets you with a list of choices. If you have worked in GarageBand, it opens the last project you worked on.

  3. Create a new project.

    Choose File→New and then select Empty Project from the window that appears (Figure 11-18).

    iMovie asks you what kind of audio track you want to start with. Choose Software Instrument and then click Create.

  4. Add your movie from the Finder.

    Find your movie in the Finder, and then drag it into the big, empty part of the GarageBand window. (At this point, GarageBand opens a preview window showing your movie. You can close this by clicking the X in the top-left corner.)

    GarageBand creates its own thumbnails to represent your movie.

  5. Edit your movie’s audio track.

    Once GarageBand imports your movie, you’ll see an audio track directly under the video track. This is the audio from your exported movie. It contains all your movie’s audio, merged into one track. Now that it’s in GarageBand, you can manipulate the audio in a multitude of ways. At the left edge of the window, under your movie, tiny icons let you mute, isolate, lock, and pan the audio (shift the stereo sound right or left). You can also make the volume rise and fall at particular points, as shown in Figure 11-19.

  6. Add audio tracks.

    Add additional tracks, if you like, by choosing Track→New Track (Option-⌘-N), or by clicking the + button in the toolbar. You might use these new tracks to create a custom score (read on). In GarageBand, you can create as many parallel audio tracks as you like, although a huge number slows your Mac to a crawl.

    You can also drag songs from the Media Browser (View→Show Media Browser) right into a blank area of the GarageBand window. GarageBand automatically creates a new track and places the song in it.

  7. Export your movie.

    Once you finish editing the audio, send the movie out into the world by choosing File→Movie→“Export Audio to Movie.” Save the file to your computer, and now it’s ready to use for whatever you had in mind.

Because GarageBand is a music program, its greatest strength is its ability to help you create a custom score for your movie. You can actually record or compose music crafted to run in perfect harmony with your video, turning you into a regular John Williams. (Actual musical ability may vary.) GarageBand shows the movie in the timeline, frame by frame, so you know exactly where to add a cymbal crash or a guitar riff.

Here’s a super-condensed review of the different tools for scoring:

When you finish the soundtrack, export the results using the instructions given previously. With enough practice, you might eventually wind up on Steven Spielberg’s speed dial.