Contents

Preface    xv

Introduction: A Primer on Islam    3

CHAPTER 1
The Past, Sacred and Profane

1. The Quran on Creation    8

2. Adam and the Angels    10

3. The Primordial Ka‘ba    11

4. The Covenant with Abraham    13

5. Abraham and Ishmael in the Holy Land    16

6. Abraham the Builder    17

7. The Beginning of the Pilgimage Ritual     20

8. The Prophet Moses    22

9. The Wisdom of Solomon    24

10. The Muslims’ Jesus    27

11. A Muslim Account of Pentecost     34

12. Mecca in the Era of Ignorance    35

13. The Religion of Mecca    37

14. Pre-Islamic Monotheism     39

15. The Hanifs     40

CHAPTER 2
The Life and Work of the Prophet

1. Muhammad’s Descent from Adam    44

2. The Birth of the Prophet    44

3. The Scriptural Prediction of the Coming of the Prophet of Islam    46

4. Marriage with Khadija    49

5. Muhammad’s Call and First Revelation     50

6. Sadness, Doubt, Consolation    53

7. The Conversion of Ali    54

8. The Earliest Public Preaching of Islam     55

9. The Opposition of the Quraysh    59

10. Persecution and Migration to Abyssinia    61

11. The Boycott    63

12. Muhammad’s Night Journey    64

13. Losses, Personal and Political     67

14. An Invitation from Yathrib    68

15. A Turn to Armed Resistance    70

16. The Hijra or Migration to Medina (622 C.E.)    71

17. The Constitution of Medina     74

18. Jewish Opposition    75

19. Fighting in the Sacred Month    76

20. The Battle at the Badr Wells    77

21. The Fate of the Banu Qaynuqa‘    78

22. From Badr to the Battle of the Trench    79

23. The Banu Qurayza    83

24. The Arrangement at Hudaybiyya     85

25. The Pilgrimage Fulfilled    88

26. “The Truth Has Come and Falsehood Has Passed Away”    89

27. Consolidation of Gains    90

28. The Submission of the Idolators     91

29. A Primer on Islam    92

30. The Farewell Pilgrimage    94

31. Muhammad’s Illness and Death (June 632 C.E.)    95

32. The Beginning of the Muslim Era     97

CHAPTER 3
The Community of Muslims

1. The Peoples of the Book    99

2. The Errors of the Jews    100

3. The Jews Warned by Their Own Prophets    102

4. The Error of the Christians     103

5. The Muslim Community    104

6. An Arabic Quran    106

7. “Catholic” Islam: Staying Close to the Tradition     109

8. A Shi‘ite View of the Community     112

9. Wrong Belief and Unbelief     113

10. The Caliphate     117

11. Caliph and Imam     120

12. The Ruler, Chosen by the People or Designated by God?    122

13. Ali, the First Imam     124

14. The Pool of Khum     127

15. The Martyrdom of Husayn     128

16. The “People of the House”     131

17. The Shi‘ite Succession     133

18. Awaiting the Hidden Imam     135

19. “Twelvers” and “Seveners” among the Shi‘ites     140

20. A Juridical Portrait of the Sunni Caliph     142

21. The Powers of the Caliph-Imam     144

22. The Delegation of the Royal Power: The Sultanate     147

23. The Religious Powers of the Caliph     148

24. The Five Pillars of Islam     150

25. Moral Islam     152

26. Alms and Charity     153

27. The Sixth Pillar: War in the Path of God     154

28. “There Is No Compulsion in Religion”     156

CHAPTER 4
The Word of God and Its Understanding

1. A Muslim History of Prophecy     158

2. Did the Jews and Christians Tamper with Scripture?     161

3. The Divine Origin of the Quran     165

4. Muhammad’s Ascension into Heaven     168

5. The Night of Destiny     169

6. The Heavenly Book     170

7. The Quran: Created or Uncreated?     172

8. “Bring a Sura Like It”     173

9. The Earliest Sura     175

10. The Heart of the Quran: The “Throne Verse”     176

11. The “Satanic Verses”     177

12. The Revelation and Its Copy     178

13. Uthman’s Recension of the Quran     179

14. Who Put Together the Suras?     181

15. The Seven “Readings” of the Quran    181

16. Textual Corruptions? The Shi‘ite View    183

17. The Proofs of Prophecy    185

18. Muhammad, the Seal of the Prophets     185

19. Muhammad among the Prophets    187

20. Avicenna on the Prophethood of Muhammad    189

21. The Clear and the Ambiguous in the Quran    191

22. How the Muslim Should Read the Quran     194

23. Quranic Exegesis    195

24. Where Did the Muslim Commentators Get Their Information?    197

25. The Outer and Inner Meanings of the Quran     198

26. Ghazali on the Sciences of Revelation    201

27. Allegorical Interpretation as a Resolution of Apparent Contradictions    203

28. Dull Masses and Minds Tied Down to Sensibles    205

29. The Pleasures of Paradise     207

CHAPTER 5
The Quran, the Prophet, and the Law

1. On the Usefulness of Tradition    213

2. Scripture, Tradition, and the Law in Islam    214

3. The Word of God Is One: The Inspiration of the Prophetic Traditions     220

4. Their Transmission    220

5. Tendentious and Sectarian Traditions    221

6. The Criticism of Traditions    222

7. The Categories of Traditions    224

8. The Companions of the Prophet     224

9. Contradictory Traditions    225

10. The Canonical Collections    226

11. The Derivation of God’s Commands    227

12. On Consensus    229

13. Personal Initiative in the Law    231

14. Legal Knowledge and Legal Obligations     236

15. The Collective Obligation    237

16. The Evolution of Islamic Jurisprudence    239

17. The Classical Schools     240

18. The End of the Age of the Fathers     242

19. Abrogation in Islamic Law    243

20. The Case of the Woman Taken in Adultery    246

21. Crimes and Their Penalties in the Quran     248

22. Divorce in Islamic Law    249

23. Controversial Questions    251

24. “O Believers, Fasting Is Enjoined on You”     252

CHAPTER 6
The Worship of God

1. How Paganism and Idol Worship Came to Mecca    258

2. Islam and the Graven Image     260

3. The Muslims’ Prayer    263

4. Prophetic Traditions on Prayer    265

5. The Direction of Prayer    268

6. The Prophet Builds His Mosque    270

7. The Institution of the Call to Prayer    271

8. On the Manner and Intent of Prayer     272

9. The Friday Service    274

10. The Two Liturgical Festival Days    276

11. A Muslim Holy Day: The Tenth of Muharram    277

12. The Pilgrimage of Islam    279

13. Muhammad’s Farewell Pilgrimage     280

14. Islamicizing the Hajj    285

15. The Twelfth-Century Haram    289

16. Ghazali on the Proper Performance of the Hajj    294

17. The Prophet’s Mosque and Tomb at Medina     298

18. A Visit to Medina     302

CHAPTER 7
Saints and Mystics

1. This World and the Next: The Islamic Preaching    307

2. The Historical Origins of the Sufi Movement     310

3. Conversions and Affirmations    312

4. Two Sufi Autobiographies: Ibn Abi al-Khayr and al-Ghazali    315

5. “No Monasticism in Islam”    321

6. Monks and Sufis     322

7. Sufi Communities     325

8. Convent Life in Islam     328

9. The Lamp in the Niche     330

10. What Is the Mystic Way?     332

11. Junayd on Oneness of and with God     335

12. Self-Obliteration     337

13. Oneness with God Is Not Identity with God     338

14. The Life and Death of a Mystic: Al-Hallaj     339

15. “I Am the Truth”     341

16. Ecstatic Utterances     342

17. The Face in the Mirror     343

18. Al-Jili and the Perfect Man     349

19. Ibn Khaldun: An Evaluation of the Sufi Tradition     351

20. Sufis and Shi‘ites     353

CHAPTER 8
Islamic Theology

1. The Origins of Theology in Islam    358

2. The Intrusion of Philosophy into Dialectical Theology     361

3. The Limited Role of Dialectical Theology     363

4. The Fundamentalist Position: “Without Howing” versus Dialectical Theology    365

5. Ash‘ari on the Charge of Heretical Innovation     367

6. Rationalist Theology     368

7. Farabi on God’s Providence     369

8. Ghazali on Theology and Muslim Belief     370

9. The Truth of Philosophy     371

10. Rationalist Ethics and Revealed Morality     372

11. Ibn Rushd: The Law Commands the Study of Philosophy     374

12. The Mystic’s Gnosis and the Theologian’s Science     377

13. The Illumination of the Intellect     382

14. The Life after Death     388

15. The Second Coming: The Muslim Tradition     389

16. “A Man from My Family”     391

17. The Preaching of God’s Final Judgment     392

18. The End Defined     401

19. The Torments of the Grave     403

20. The Incoherence of the Philosophers on the Afterlife     405

21. An End to Hell?     409

22. The Vision of God     411

Sources Cited    413

Index    417