Jim Allyn: The Master of Negwegon
Dan Bevacqua: The Human Variable
Gerri Brightwell: Williamsville
Jeffery Deaver: The Incident of 10 November
Brendan Dubois: The Man from Away
Peter Ferry: Ike, Sharon, and Me
Charles John Harper: Lovers and Thieves
Craig Johnson: Land of the Blind
William Kent Krueger: The Painted Smile
Joyce Carol Oates: The Woman in the Window
Steven Popkes: The Sweet Warm Earth
William Soldan: All Things Come Around
Peter Straub: The Process Is a Process All Its Own
Other Distinguished Mystery Stories of 2016