Index

a priori: judgments, 144; method, 62–70, 97; Descartes, 81–82

Abbé Gratry: 107

Abbot, Francis Ellingwood: 191–92, 232–33

Abbott, Thomas Kingsmill: 253, 269

Abduction: 12, 147, 167, 240, 287–88, in perception, 183; validity of, 182. See also hypothesis, explanation

Abelard: 46, 97, 105

Absolute, the: 45, 233

Achilles and the tortoise: 126, 276, 280

actual: 91, 257, 273

Adams, Henry: 3

adequate idea, defined: 102

agapasm: 76

agapastic epistemology: 76. See also social epistemology

agape: 130

al-Sufi, Abd al-Rahman: 6

analogy: 139, 261; argument from, 224

analytic: mathematical demonstrations, 138, 147; vs synthetic, 138, 142, 146, 182

Anselm of Canterbury: 150, 165, 205

ápagogè: 287

Appleton, William H.: 7, 10, 13, 21, 192

Appuleius: 46

Aquinas, St. Thomas: 205

Archimedes: 230

argument: 132, 224, 242, 259, 289; classification of, 16, 129, 168, 266, 269; demonstrative vs probable, 113; force of, 207, 244; from design, 149; a sign, 259, 263, 266–67. See also inference

Aristotle: 46, 53, 57, 97, 203, 270; apagoge, 287; logic, 44, 124, 253, 266; Organon, 234; science, 200

associationalism: 217, 236

atomic theory: 282

Aubrey, John: 47

authority: method of, 59–61, 68ff, 97, 175; vs a priori method, 66; Descartes, 81–82

Bacon, Francis: 47, 66, 109, 129, 177, 200, 203; four idols, 45; induction, 234

Bacon, Roger: 46, 77

Bain, Alexander: 189, 232; definition of belief, 76

balancing reasons: 136–37

Baldwin, James Mark: his dictionary, 40, 193

Barbara: 172–73, 181; all reasoning reducible to, 168

Bayes, Rev. Thomas: 222, 237; Bayes-Laplace doctrine: 222

belief: 87, 135, 250; a habit, 58, 72; a rule for action, ix, 73, 86; true vs false, 96

Bentham, Jeremy: 201, 203, 214, 218

Berkeley, George: 8, 74, 78, 104, 188, 216; pragmatism, 193, 233; theory of calculus, 237; on vision, 160, 258

Bernoulli, Daniel: 178, 183

best explanation, inference to: 182

Boler, John F.: 232

Boltzmann, Ludwig: 183

Boole, George: 35, 222, 237, 147. See also logic

Bowen, Francis: 102

Boyle’s law: 177–78, 183; a hypothetical inference, 179

Bryant, William Cullen: 105

Bulwer-Lytton, Edward: 261, 270

Bunsen, Robert: 235

buried secrets: 99f

Burks, Arthur: 18

Butler, Benjamin Franklin: 189, 232

Cambridge Scientific Club: 234

Campos, Daniel G.: 182

can be’s: 273

Canavarro, Marie de Souza: 31, 41

Cantor, Moritz: 22

Carrington, Hereward: 123, 130

Carus, Alwin C.: viii

Carus, André: 36

Carus, Paul: 2, 15, 19–35, 37–42, 76, 271–72, 287

Cattell, James McKeen: 3

causation: 65, 92, 104, 159; and the law, 189

Cayley, Arthur: 195, 234

Chambers, Robert: 164

chance-world, contradictory idea: 154

chance, absolute: 237, 277; doctrine or calculus of: 11, 17, 112, 207, 222, 226, 247, 272; logarithm of, 135; real, 287; rules for that calculation of, 118–21

Chance, Love, and Logic: 35

chemistry: classificatory science, 109, 181; inspiration for logicians, 21; Peirce’s early exposure to, 5, 75

Cicero, Marcus Tullius: 218

Clausius, Rudolf: 49, 75, 183, 203, 234

clear idea: defined, 80, 102

clearness: of apprehension, 81, 83, 108; vs distinctness, 81, 83, 102; first grade, 80, 102, 274, 286; maxim of, 193; pragma(tis)tic, 26, 271, 285; second grade, 96, 102, 273–74, 286; sensuous vs logical, 102, 286; third grade, 85, 90; three grades of 10, 79, 101, 193, 273

Cleveland, Grover: 225, 237

Coast Survey. See U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey

Cohen, Morris: 35, 42

Coleridge, Samuel Taylor: 200

Collected Papers (Hartshorne & Weiss): 18–19; its rendition of Illustrations, 35, 42, 44

Collected Papers (of 1893): 15

Comte, Auguste: 105, 208–11, 215; positive philosophy, 187, 235

conceptualism: 219–20, 147. See also probability

concrete reasonableness: 166. See also frog, decapitated

Congreve, Richard: 235

connotation vs denotation: 267

consciousness: 17, 240–41, 251; stream of, 103

continuity: 109–11, 129, 259; of consciousness, 86; law of, 82, 221; Mill, 221; principle of, 90

contradiction, principle of: 273

contributory negligence, law of: 189

Cook, Catherine: 40

Copernicus, Nicolas: 47, 234

copyright: of Illustrations, 20, 26–28, 33, 35, 39–40

cosmic weather: 187

Cournot, Antoine Augustine: 202, 208, 211, 234

Couturat, Louis: his Logic, 28

Crease, Robert: 4, 36

criminals, punishment of: 190

critic, logical: 250, 252, 255, 266, 269

Curtis, Matoon Monroe: 18

Dalton, John: 282

Darwin, Charles: 48, 49, 187

Davidson, George: 14

De Morgan, Augustus: x, 153, 165; on probability, 133, 137, 147

de Waal, Cornelis: 36, 233, 288

de Waal, Kelly: viii

deduction: 11–12, 107, 146, 167, 170, 181, 279; Kant: 283; probable, 172; relation with analytic and synthetic reasoning, 138, 145–46, 169–73; typified by Barbara, 168. See also reasoning

Delledalle, Gérard: 14–15, 37

demonstration: 56–57; vs belief, 225; mathematical, 138, 147

Dendy, Helen: 254, 270

Denotation. See connotation

Descartes, René: 76, 97, 102, 150, 165; method of doubt, 62f, 81–83; a nominalist, 82; proofs of God’s existence, 63; reason, 74

Deschanel, A. Privat: 104

design argument: 149–50

desire: 197

despotism, method of: 61. See also authority, method of

destiny: 98; truth, 164

determinants, theory of: 201

determinism: 277

dialectic, Hegel’s conception of: 64 dialectic, method of: 62, 64. See also a priori method

diamond, pragmatic definition of: 103. See also hardness

dicent: 289

Dickens, Charles: 189, 258

disposition: 257, 276

disputation, medieval: 46, 56, 97, 218

distinct idea, defined: 81, 102

“Dmesis”: 232

Don Quixote: 72

doubt-belief theory: 8, 17, 52, 53–55, 85

doubt: 72–73, 117; Cartesian, 77; definite vs indefinite, 54; an emotion, 75; as (feigned) hesitancy, 73, 86; vs ignorance, 54, 75; living, 56; real, 77

Duns Scotus, John: 188, 203–4, 218; definition of reality, 104f, 206

Durandus of St. Pourçain: 218, 236

dynamics: instinctive understanding of, 213; Mach on, 21

Eck, Johann Maier von: 219, 236

economy of research: 249

Eliot, T.S.: 1

Ellesmere Island: 6

Ellis, Robert Leslie: 234

Emerson, Ralph Waldo: 268

energy: potential vs kinetic: 215

Euclid: 57, 106, 175, 247

Everett, J.D.: 104

evolution, theory of: 48, 187; Lamarckian, 237; natural selection, 51; Spencerian, 231; Weismannian, 237

excluded middle, principle of: 220, 257, 273

exclusions, method of: 200

existence: 81, 91, 100–101, 113, 152, 236, 257–58; of a dream, 96; God’s, 63, 150, 155, 165; incognizable, 162; Napoleon’s, 180; struggle for, 49; vs reality, 45, 233, 257; truth, 115

existential graphs. See graphs

experience: 47; collateral, 289

experiential method of settling opinion: 96

fallibilism, 76

Faraday, Michael: 282

Fay, Melusina: 103. See also Melusina

Fechner’s law: 136, 147, 252

Ferretti, Giovanni Mastai: 76. See also Pius Nonus

fiction: 96; its utility in science, 111. See also reality

Fisch, Max H.: viii, 13

Fiske, John: 191, 232

Fizeau, method of: 98

flatus vocis: 205

force: 104, 160–61, 178–79; pragmatic maxim applied to: 92–95

Foucault, method of: 98

Franklin, Christine. See Ladd-Franklin, Christine

free will vs determinism: 92

freedom: method of, 59. See also tenacity, method of

frog, decapitated: 16–17

Galileo Galilei: 47, 69, 282

Galton, Sir Francis: 111, 129, 241, 269

Gamblers Fallacy: 130, 223

Gases, theory of: 48, 75, 178–79, 183

Gauss, Karl: 129

Gay, John: 217, 236

Gefühl theory: in logic, 254

general(s): 91, 220; objective truth, 191; real, 215–17, 272

generality: 73–74; contrasted with vagueness, 236

geometry: non-Euclidean, 195

Gerbert d’Aurillac: 195, 206, 233

God: 90, 149–50, 163; existence of, 63, 150, 155, 165; manufactured by men, 221; His perfections, 18; Kant on, 63; reality of, 77, 165. See also design argument

Goethe, Johann Wolfgang: 22

grace: 47

grammar: speculative, 269; universal, 266, 269

Grand Logic, 37. See How to Reason

graphs: existential, 29, 30, 272, 274, 286

Gratry, Joseph: 107, 145, 148

gravity: 92; research, 5–6

Gray, Asa: 187, 231

Gray, Thomas: 105, 273, 284

Greely expedition: 6

Green, Nicholas St. John: 76, 189–91, 232

guiding principle: 51–52, 113, 132

Haack, Susan: 183

habit: 87, 276; a would be, 125, 127–28, 216; relation to meaning, 88; virtual, 197–98. See also would be’s

Hamilton, William: 187

Hamiltonianism: Wright’s, 188

hardness: 220; example of, 91; nominalism, 10, 103–4. See also pragmatic maxim

Harman, Gilbert: 182

Harriott, Thomas: 202, 234

Harris, Stephanie: vii

Harris, William Torrey: 130, 279, 287

Hartley, David: 236

Hartshorne, Charles: 36

Harvard Lectures: of 1865, 287; of 1903, 18, 38, 287

Harvard Observatory: 6

Harvey, William: 47

heat: 49, 176, 215; Bacon’s discussion of, 203; mechanical theory of, 178–79

hedonism: 49

Hegel, Georg: 77, 130; and the a priori method, 64, 69

Hegeler, Edward Charles: 15, 19, 27

Heim, Karl: 258

Heinze, Max: 37

Herz, Heinrich: 215

Hobbes, Thomas: 82, 216

Hodges, Wilfrid: 181

Hole, Charles: 165

Holmes, Oliver Wendell: 192, 232–33

Hoosac tunnel: 6

Houser, Nathan: vii

How to Reason: 2, 16–18, 36, 38, 41, 55, 77, 234

Huggins, Mary and William: 105, 235

Hulswit, Menno: 104

humanism: x, 218–19

Hume, David: 63, 236

hypothesis: 12, 177, 240, 248; Comte on, 210; vs induction, 174, 176, 179–81, 279; an inference, 279–80, 287; instinct, 283; Riemann on, 226, 237; rules for, 175; synthetic, 170, 179; validity of, 282. See also abduction; plausibility; Retroduction

Icon: 261–62, 284, 289

ideas: self-reality of, 100

ignorance: compared with doubt, 54, 75

il lume naturale: 47, 69

Illustrations: series title, 12

Index: 261–62, 284, 289

Individualism: 217

induction: 146, 156; vs hypothesis, 174, 176, 179–81, 279; of characters, 173, 182; crude, 281; defined, 280; irreducible to Barbara, 169; justification of, 11, 157, 281; principle of, 145; quantitative, 280; synthetic, 169–70, 179; true, 245

inference: conceived semeiotically, 251, 259; defined, 248

inquiry: 10, 55, 72–73, 186, 245; communal aspect of, 15; defined, 55; laboratory, 75, sole end of, 55–56, 58. See also doubt

inquiry, four methods of. See a priori; authority; tenacity; science

instinct: vs reason, 53, 57, 83, 213–14

International Geodetic Association: 14

International Scientific Series: 12

interpretant: 262, 266–67, 288; dynamical, 285, 289; final, 285, 289; immediate, 289; initial, 285

introspection: knowledge by, 258

James, William: 20, 38, 40, 45, 274, 288; Metaphysical Club, 7, 8, 192, 233; on pragmatism, ix–x, 2, 18, 36–37, 79, 103, 193, 233; specious vs knife-edge present, 78

Jastrow, Joseph: 244, 269

Jesus: a pragmatist: 90, 185, 235

Jevons, William Stanley: 221

Johns Hopkins University: 14, 36

Joshua: 166

Jourdain, Philippe: 33, 41

Kant, Immanuel: 124, 221, 288; a priori method, 63–64; deduction, 283; first Critique, 188, 200, 211; Ich denke, 259; limits of human understanding, 288; logic, 253–54, 269–70; nebular hypothesis, 166; Peirce’s first reading of, 232; subsistenz, 215, 236; synthetic a priori, 144–45; things in themselves, 9; transcendental, 38; would be, 283

Kantism: Peirce’s, 188. See also Kant

Kehler, James H.: 286

Kelvin. See Thomson, William

Kent, Beverly: 39, 183

Kent, Charles N.: 76

Kepler, Johannes: 64; foolish remark on, 74; orbit of Mars, 47–48, 282

Kinematics: 104

Kirchheiss, Johannes: xxiii

Kirchhoff, Gustav: 104–5, 235

Klein, Felix: 195, 234, 280, 288

Koehn, Donald R.: 36

Ladd-Franklin, Christine: 7, 14, 36

Lamarck, Jean-Baptiste: 237

Lambert, Johann Heinrich: 64

Laplace, Pierre-Simon: 34, 237; on God, 165; nebular hypothesis, 166; on probability, 108, 222, 274, 279

Lavoisier, Antoine: 48, 109

law: 109, 147, 183, 256; of contiguity, 236; of continuity, 82, 221; of Contributory Negligence, 189; of demand and supply, 65; of (the distribution of) error, 11, 129; of mechanics, 151, 162, 179; of motion, 69, 95; of nature, 103, 150, 152, 166, 177, 192, 203, 216–21; of perception, 67; psychological, 59; and reality, 67; statistical, 75; of sensibility, 136; subsist, 67; of three stages, 209; vs uniformity, 216–17. See also Boyle, Fechner

Lawrence Scientific School, 5

leading principle. See guiding principle

legisign: 289

Leibniz, Gottfried: 63, 82, 187, 221; adequate ideas 102–3; linear equations, 201

Leo 13: 60

Leonardo: 193, 233

Lieb, Irwin: 289

Liebig, Justus: 5, 36; method of chemical analysis, 74

likelihood: 281. See verisimilitude

Lipton, Peter: 182

Lissajoux: curves of, 98

Liszka, James: 288

Lobatchewski, Nikolai: 195–96, 234

Locke, John, 78, 102; substratum, 8; probability, 112–13, 130

logarithm: 147

logic book of 1872–73: 9, 16

logic: algebra of, 22; art of reasoning, 44, 256; Boolean, 34; as semeiotic, 239, 268; division of, 266; indispensible requirements of, 117; mathematical, 17; non-psychologistic, 242; normative science, 186; quantitative, 17; of relatives, ix–x, 17, 128, 130; rooted in the social principle, 116–18, 122; scientific, 101; transcendental, 16, 38. See also critic; grammar; Methodeutic

logical extension and comprehension: doctrine of, 182

logical machines: 50

Lord Byron: 77

Lowell Lectures of 1866: 165, 179, 183

Lowell, Lawrence: 288

Lully, Raymond: 82

Mach, Ernst: 47; treatment of dynamics, 21

Madden, Edward H.: 231

Malthus, Thomas Robert: 48, 49

Marquand, Alan: 4

Marshall, Alfred: 202, 234

Martínez, Alberto A.: 104

mathematics: 53; a definition, 133, 146; a demonstrative science, 57; an experiential science, 194

Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution: 183

Maxwell, James Clerk: 49, 75, 183

may be’s: 282

Mayorga, Rosa M.: 232

McDermott, John J.: 38, 103

McKerrow, Raymie E.: 36

meaning: 79, 84; criticism of Berkeley, 8; relation to habit, 88; relation to sensible effects, 89; of a sign, 263; of thought, 87, 89. See also pragmatic maxim

measurement: nature of, 102

mechanics: 163, 179; analytic, 95; Hertz’s, 236; Mach’s 39. See also law

Melusina: 84, 103. See also Fay, Melusina

Mendeléef’s Table: 75

Metaphysical Club: 2, 76, 186–92; Peirce’s paper written for, 7–9, 19, 192

metaphysics: 101; Mill’s, 202; under the spell of religion, 265

Methodeutic: 21, 252, 266, 269; a practical science, 256

Mill, James: 201, 203, 214, 218, 236

Mill, John Stuart: 1, 11, 37, 75, 211–21; Examination of Hamilton, 188; four methods, 175; induction, 34, 157–59, 165; influence on Chauncey Wright, 187; Kepler, 282; Logic, 201, 211, 222, 235–36, 274, 284, 165; probability, 108. See also nominalism

Milton, John: 197

Minute Logic: 37

Misak, Cheryl: 183

Monist: 15, 19

Musick, Thomas Hubbart: 104

Napoleon Bonaparte: 165, 171, 174–75, 179–80, 182

nature, uniformity of: 149; ground for hypothesis, 174; ground for induction, 157–59, 165. See also law

nebular hypothesis: 166

“Neglected Argument”: 165

Neoplatonism: 105, 203

Neopragmatists: 91

Newcomb, Simon: 222, 237

Newton, Isaac: 187, 237; law of universal gravitation, 165, 183, 257

nominalism: 10, 63, 75, 203, 217–21, 284; blind to the spiritual side of science, 210; extreme, 82; laws of nature, 192; Mill’s, 75, 188, 202–3, 204, 216, 273, 284; principal error in Illustrations, 26, 79, 105, 271–73; vs realism, 26, 97, 186, 203–5, 215–19, 224–25, 271–72. See also conceptualism; hardness; Ockham realism

Norton, Charles Elliot: 189, 232

Numa Pompilius: 60

number: 274, axiomatization of, 286; conception of, 109, 274; and continuity, 111; relative, 118–20, 139, 169

object: dynamical, 289; immediate, 284, 288; mediate, 289; Real, 284; of a sign 260–62, 266–67, 288

obstinacy, method of: 59, 175. See also tenacity, method of

Ockham, William of: 203–4, 215, 217–18, 237

Oleksy, Mateusz W.: 232

ontology: 101

Open Court (the magazine): 15

Open Court Collection: xii, 37

Open Court Publishing Company: 15; London office, 33

opinion: 100; vs fact, 53; destined or fated, 98, 101; public, 62, 66; and reality, 105, 113, 146, 220, 257; settlement of, 10, 55–71, 96–98; sole end of inquiry, 56, 58, 98

Ostwald, Wilhelm: 258

Pacio, Giulio: 287

Palladino, Eusapia: 123, 130

papal infallibility: doctrine of, 76

Papini, Giovanni: 233

Parmenides: 113, 130

Pearson, Karl: 216; a nominalist, 221; Peirce’s review of his Grammar of Science, 21, 34, 39, 40, 286

Peirce, Benjamin: 4, 5; nebular hypothesis, 166

Peirce, Charles Henry: 5

Peirce, Charles Sanders: life, 4–6; obituary, 35, 41

Peirce, Herbert: 77

Peirce, James Mills: 10

Peirce, Juliette: 4, 22, 31

Peirce, Sarah Mills: 10, 13, 37

Peirce, Zina. See Fay, Melusina

Pendulum research: 6

percept: 183

perception: 257–58; instinctive abduction, 183

perceptual judgment: 183

Pérès, Jean-Baptiste: 182

Perry, Thomas Sergeant: 7, 8

persecution, method of, 61. See also authority, method of

Petrus Aureolus: 218, 236

Photometric Researches: 6, 286

Pius Nonus: 60

Plato: 64

plausibility: 123–24, 275. See also probability

pleasure: 65

Poincaré, Henri: 221

Pope Sylvester II: 233

Pope, Alexander: 61

Popular Science Monthly: 3

Popular Science: 3

Port-Royal logicians: 80

positive evidence: 283

positivism: 204, 208–9

practical/practice: related to pragmatism, 3, 8–9, 51, 53, 69, 75–76, 89–90, 100, 203, 243, 250; certainty, 124–25; logic, 174; religion, 208; Retroduction, 182, 249; science, 200, 220, 256

practicalism, 9

Pragmatic maxim: 8–9, 78, 103, 166; applied to editing, 3; applied to the concept of hardness, 10, 78, 91; Peirce’s misunderstanding of, 193; third grade of clearness, 90. See also James, William

pragmaticism: 2, 18, 22, 74, 79; relation to pragmatism, 39, 103, 193

pragmatism: 192; habit of conduct, 288; nominalist interpretation of, 79; origin of the term, 9, 45, 193

prayer test (Tyndal’s): 166

Prezzolini, Guiseppe: 233

Principles of Philosophy: 38

probability: 131, calculus of, 222; vs chance, 134; conceptualistic view, 133, 136–42, 146; defined, 113, 122–23, 129, 277, 286; doctrine or theory of, 49, 111; inapplicable to a single case, 114–15, 122; indeterminacy of, 107; inverse, 147; meaning of, 112; mathematical, 207, 275; materialistic view, 35, 133; pragmatic maxim applied to, 92; relative number, 118, 122; subjective view, 35; theory of, 30. See also likelihood; plausibility; verisimilitude

Proclus: 106

Ptolemy: 6, 106

public opinion, method of: 66. See also a priori method

Pyrrhonism: 204

qualisign: 289

quality: conception of, 52; of the sign, 289. See also hardness

Quest for a Method: 15f, 37

Quetelet, Lambert Adolphe: 111, 129, 139, 147

Rankine, William: 203, 234

real/reality: 45, 104, 115, 146, 233, 257–58; contrasted with fiction, 96, 113, 205, 257–58; etymology of, 104–5, 205; hypothesis of, 67–68; Law, 221; vs permanence, 215; pragmatic maxim applied to, 95–101. See also actual; existence; universals; would be’s

realism: 10, 26; Abbot’s, 192, 192; vs nominalism, 26, 186, 203, 205, 219–20, 272; scholastic, 188, 191, 232, 284, 288. See also conceptualism; nominalism

reason: first rule of, 182

reasonableness. See concrete reasonableness

reasoner vs reasonee: 277

reasoning: aim of, 186, 256; art of, 44, 194, 206, 252, 256; Berkeley’s 258; dialogic, 241; elementary kinds of, 12, 167, 279; genera of, 252; good vs bad, 50, 53, 69; instinct for, 213–14; mathematical, 226–27; necessary, 254, 279; through sampling, 243–45, 251; two sciences of, 240; self-control, 186; semeiotic, 266. See also deduction; hypothesis; induction; logic; security

Reid, Thomas: 216

relative numbers. See number

religion: 60, 150, 164, 166, 265, 284; Comte, 208–11, 235; decayed, 62; practical, 208; reconciliation with science, 15, 60, 166; and science, 150, 163; secular, 235; skepticism, 57. See also transubstantiation

Retroduction: 12, 180, 182, 240, 287; an inference, 279–80; practical vs scientific, 249–51. See also abduction; authority, method of; hypothesis; tenacity, method of

rheme: 289

rhetoric, speculative: 269

Richelieu (play): 261, 270

Riemann, Bernhard: 226

Riemann’s surfaces: 202

Roberts, Don: 286

Robin, Richard: his catalogue, 38

Robinson, Lydia: 40

Robson, John M.: 165

Roscellin of Compiègne: 205

Rosenthal, Sandra B.: 183

Rousseau, Jean-Jacques: 49, 208

Rowell, George P.: 76

Royce, Josiah: 45, 233

rule, case, result: 168–70

Russell, Bertrand: on pragmatism, ix

Russell, Francis C.: 18, 20–35, 38–42, 233, 235, 272; evaluation of the Illustrations, 34

Ryan, Frank X.: 231

Sacksteder, M.A.: 39

sampling, reasoning through. See reasoning

Schelling, Friedrich Wilhelm: 216

Schiller, F.C.S.: 2, 18, 79, 193, 233; his humanism, x

Schröder, Ernst: ix

Science: 3

science: classification of, 39, 181, 183–84, 269, (Comte’s, 208–9); defined, 200; history of, 4, 12, 76, 124; of logic, 9, 12 (see also logic); logic of, 48; method of, 65–69, 71, 98, 101; Peirce’s activities in, 4–6; treated quantitatively, 107–9; vs religion, 163–64. See also mathematics; religion

Scientific Metaphysics: 38

Scientific Monthly: 3

scientific reasoning, rules of: 101. See also reasoning

Scotus Erigena: 96, 105, 130

Search for a Method: 16

security: 51, 57, 102; ideal of logic, 250; of reasoning, 254

Seguin, Léo: 14; French anarchist, 14

self-control: 57, 77, 198; required in good reasoning, 186

self, dialogic: 241–42; reality of, 101

semeiotic: 239, 260, 263, 288

semiotics. See semeiotic

sentimentalism: 49

Shakespeare, William: 288

signs: 236, 284; argument, 251, 259–60, 266–67; classification of, 284, 288–89; definition of, 266, 284–85, 288; doctrine of, 13, 16; grammar of, 266, 269; nature of, 73–74, 260–63

Sigwart, Christoph: 270; on logic, 254–57; a nominalist, 257

Sigwart, Heinrich: 254, 270

sinsign: 289

skepticism: 57, 81; absolute, 204

Small, Robert: 74

Smith, Irving Cranford: 35, 42

social epistemology: 43

Socrates: 96–97

Sonnenfeld, Albert: 182

space: 160

Spencer, Herbert: 187, 231

Spinoza, Baruch: 188, 232

St. Paul: 118

statistical conception of laws: 75

Staubermann, Klaus: 36

Stewart, Dugald: 216

Stöckhardt, Julius Adolph: 5, 36

Stoics: 200, 203, 279

Story, William Edward: 129

stream of consciousness: 103

subsistence, 215, 236

sufficient reason, principle of: 82

Swedenborg, Emanuel: 166

syllogism: 11, 34, 124, 168–72, 200, 211, 259; an argument, 289; in dispute, 46; forms (moods) of, 145, 167, 253, 269; and induction, 221. See also Barbara

Sylvester, James Joseph: 11

Symbol: 251, 261–62, 284, 289

synechism: 168

synthetic: vs analytic, 138, 142, 170, 182; hypothesis, 170; induction, 169; a priori, 107, 131, 144, 146

tenacity, method of: 58–59, 61, 67, 68–70, 96. See also obstinacy, method of

terminology, ethics of: 104, 267

Theophrastus: 124

thermodynamics: 203, 256

thirdness: operative in nature, 130

Thomson, William (1st Baron Kelvin): 203, 234

thought: dialogical, 259; distinguished from perception, 258; sensual vs habitual, 181; sole function of, 88

Tillotson, John: 151, 153, 165

time, 160; reality of: 100

transubstantiation: 47, 89

Trivium, the: 46

truth: 51, 55, 71, 81, 115, 200, 240, 259, 264; of a conditional proposition, 194; end of inquiry, 67, 98; of generals, 191; meaning of, 98; pragmatic notion of, 249–50; public notion, 67; relation to belief, 43; religious side of, 210. See also science, method of

Tully. See Cicero

Turrisi, Patricia Ann: 38

Tychism: 103, 237, 287

Tycho Brahe: 6, 47

Tyler, Samuel: 76f

Tyndall, John: 166

U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey: 5, 6

Überweg, Friedrich: 11, 37

Ulugh Beg: 6

uniformity of nature: 11, 149, 152; ground of induction, 157–8, 165; and hypothesis, 174; law of, 221

universals: 205; defined, 219–20; doctrine of, 202

Unterschiedsschwelle: 244, 269

Vacherot, Étienne: 150, 163–65

vagueness: 236

Vailati, Giovanni: 193, 233

validity of reasoning: 50, 113; Sigwart on, 256

van ’t Hoff, Jacobus Henricus: 109, 129

Venn, John: 114, 130, 131, 147

verifiability: Comte on, 209

verisimilitude: 123–24, 275. See also probability

virtual: meaning of, 197

Watts, Isaac: 102

Weber, Ernst Heinrich: 269

Weierstrass, Karl: 247

weight: pragmatic maxim applied to, 92

Weiss, Paul, 36

Weissmann, August: 224, 237

Welby, Lady Victoria: 288–89

Whately, Richard: 5, 36, 130, 221

Wheeler, William A.: 156, 165

Whewell, William: 200–1, 208, 211, 234, 251

Whitehead, Alfred North: 36

will be’s: 273

would be’s: 125, 128, 268, 273, 280; and nominalism, 284

Wright, Chauncey: 37, 75, 187–89, 231

Writings of Charles S. Peirce: its rendition of Illustrations, 35

Wundt, Wilhelm: 103

Wyman, Jeffries: 187, 231

Youmans, Edward L.: 3, 12, 21, 25–26; criticism of “Fixation,” 14, 106; Spencerianism, 21

Zeno of Elea: 126

Zöllner’s astrophotometer: 6, 36