I cook a feast on Thanksgiving, with the keyword being feast. Every year, without fail, I make way more food than I (and my guests) could ever eat. I can’t help it. I also stuff myself to the point of total discomfort trying to eat it all. (Maybe I’ll learn my lesson next year!)
Although Thanksgiving is about gratitude, it’s also the biggest food holiday of the year. Thanksgiving is practically synonymous with turkey, leaving open the question: what do vegetarians and plant eaters . . . eat?
Thanksgiving is the one holiday my beloved Herbies get a little stressed over (I start getting frantic e-mails about the big day in July!) and I get why. I, too, was scratching my head my first Thanksgiving as a vegetarian (I simply ate all the sides). I’ve since created my own lavish menu, and as the years have passed, I’ve come to love my family’s plant-based Thanksgivings even more. Not only is our Thanksgiving about family and gratitude, it’s about compassion and health, too.
Even better, our dinner plates have transformed into works of art, with so many different textures and brilliant colors. Beige is out! Vibrant is in!
Interestingly, my parents had their first plant-based Thanksgiving at my house, when they were still omnivores. I was up against more than sixty-five years of tradition, and endless teasing about going to the neighbor’s house to sneak some turkey, but both of my parents were pleasantly surprised by their experience.
“I don’t feel that we missed any of the traditional meal,” my mom said. “It had all the flavors and taste of a traditional meal but it was healthy and fresh and vegan.”
After going for seconds, my dad remarked, “I had no idea you could have everything we’d always had, just healthy and vegan. . . . It was a really good replica. I don’t feel like I missed anything. It was really good!”
I find that the more years I’m plant-based, the more I move away from “traditional” replicas and into more edgy, “plant-proud” dishes like Stuffed Acorn Squash (p. 24). On the other hand, there’s a certain comfort and enjoyment in familiarity, especially when you’re serving others, so I always keep one or two traditional dishes in the mix, such as mashed potatoes or stuffing for sides and pumpkin pie for dessert.
On the next page you’ll find my basic, crowd-pleasing menu for Thanksgiving. It features a celebratory centerpiece (the Thanksgiving Loaf) with all the sides and trimmings you expect and love! No bird? No problem!
APPETIZER
Butternut Soup (p. 12)
MAIN DISH
Thanksgiving Loaf (p. 15)
SIDES
mashed potatoes (p. 18)
Everyday Mushroom Gravy (p. 16)
Thanksgiving Gravy (p. 16)
Skillet Green Bean Casserole (p. 19)
Cornbread (p. 19)
Traditional Stuffing (p. 20)
Cranberry Sauce (p. 23)
Sweet Potato Casserole (p. 23)
DESSERT
Pumpkin Pie (p. 24)
Pumpkin Cheesecake (p. 26)
MENU FOR ONE OR TWO
Here’s a special menu for those times when you’re invited to a Thanksgiving potluck or celebration with omnivores and need to make your own plant-based Thanksgiving meal—or when it’s an intimate Thanksgiving with just you and another.
Stuffed Acorn Squash (p. 24)
steamed vegetables or mashed potatoes and gravy (p. 18)
Mini Pumpkin Pies (p. 27)
For your side dish, steam some green beans or broccoli. Alternatively or in addition, whip up a small portion of mashed potatoes (see “Mashed Potatoes a Dozen Ways,” p. 18) with Thanksgiving Gravy (p. 16) or Everyday Mushroom Gravy (p. 16).
SERVES 2-4 | GF | SF | MA | P |
I can’t help myself. I have to include a butternut soup in every cookbook I write. This recipe is my new favorite, and it’s a little edgy for Thanksgiving. If you want to go a bit more traditional, skip the chilies and lime, and add cinnamon (or pumpkin pie spice) to taste with a light drizzle of maple syrup. Or if you don’t want a sweet, pumpkin-pie-tasting soup, add mild curry powder to taste—yes! Just three ingredients! Ka-pow!
1 butternut squash
2–4 c vegetable broth
1 4-oz can green chilies
1–2 limes
Per serving (serving 2): 133 calories, 0.2g fat, 34g carbohydrates, 4.3g fiber, 7.8g sugars, 2.2g protein
SERVES 4 | GF | SF* | MA | PA | P |
I’ve never had Tofurkey, and while my family has become pretty adventurous over the years, no amount of persuasion is going to get them to eat tofu shaped into a turkey mold. (Just sayin’.) If you want a centerpiece to your meal that doesn’t pretend to be turkey, this Thanksgiving Loaf is where it’s at. While this loaf doesn’t taste anything like meatloaf (or turkey), it captures all the Thanksgiving flavors that we know and love.
1 15-oz can white beans, drained and rinsed
1 c mashed potatoes (p. 18)
1 carrot
1 parsnip (optional)
2 celery stalks
1 small onion
2½ tbsp poultry seasoning (not powdered)
½ tsp rubbed sage (not powdered)
2–3 tbsp nutritional yeast
2–3 tbsp yellow miso*
¾ c instant oats (uncooked)
CHEF’S NOTES:
Per serving (¼ loaf): 259 calories, 2.5g fat, 48g carbohydrates, 11.5g fiber, 3.9g sugars, 13g protein
MAKES 1 CUP | Q | GF* | SF* | PA |
This recipe from Everyday Happy Herbivore is, hands down, the fan-favorite gravy. Because this is also the gravy my parents serve at their Thanksgiving, I’m including it here as an alternative to the Thanksgiving Gravy.
1 c water
2 tbsp low-sodium soy sauce*
2 tbsp nutritional yeast, divided
¼ tsp onion powder
¼ tsp garlic powder
¼ tsp ground ginger
8 oz white or brown mushrooms, sliced
Italian seasoning as needed
½ c nondairy milk
2 tbsp cornstarch
a couple of dashes of ground nutmeg
(optional) (see note)
CHEF’S NOTE:
For a smoky-flavored gravy, substitute smoked paprika for the nutmeg, adding more to taste.
Per serving (¼ c): 60 calories, 1.4g fat, 8.9g carbohydrates, 1.4g fiber, 1.2g sugars, 5.6g protein
MAKES 1 CUP | Q | GF* | SF* | PA |
I designed this gravy specifically for Thanksgiving when I wrote my first cookbook, The Happy Herbivore Cookbook. It captures all the Thanksgiving flavors you know and love while complementing basic sides like green beans, mashed potatoes, or grains.
¼ c nutritional yeast
¼ c white whole-wheat flour*
1 c nondairy milk
1 small onion, diced
8 oz white mushrooms, thinly sliced
2 tbsp low-sodium soy sauce*
1 tsp rubbed sage (not powdered)
Per serving (¼ c): 70 calories, 1g fat, 10.9g carbohydrates, 2.6g fiber, 3.3g sugars, 6.1g protein
No one really needs a recipe for mashed potatoes (you just mash up some potatoes!), but since mashed potatoes are, quite possibly, my favorite food, I’ve learned a number of different ways to make them.
Before I was plant-based, I made mashed potatoes with milk, as most people do, so when I went plant-based, I started making my mashed potatoes with soy milk (or almond milk) and happily discovered it worked just as well.
If I’m not going to drown my mashed potatoes in gravy, I find that generous amounts of garlic powder and onion powder (the finely granulated kind, not the coarse mince or powdery-floury kinds), makes them plenty flavorful, without adding butter or a vegan butter substitute like margarine. (I add salt and black pepper, too, of course!)
I also (and trust me on this one!) love adding Dijon mustard to plain mashed potatoes. In fact, anytime I’m serving Portobello Steaks (p. 86) or asparagus, I make my Dijon mashed potatoes. (A little goes a long way, so add Dijon to taste and omit other spices.)
Another option is adding nutritional yeast, which makes the potatoes a bit cheesy. My latest discovery, however, is vegetable broth. I ran out of both soy and almond milk on Thanksgiving last year and, not wanting to forgo serving mashed potatoes to my in-laws, I used vegetable broth and found it makes for an incredible mashed potato. (Broth and nutritional yeast are even more amazing coupled together! My No-Chicken Broth [p. 168] or the powder base really kicks it up notch!)
I shared my broth discovery on Happy Herbivore’s Facebook page and learned of yet another delicious trick from my fans: use the cooking water from boiling the potatoes! The starchy cooking water makes mashed potatoes even creamier.
If you’re looking for a less starchy mashed potato experience, use cauliflower. Or find a middle ground and use both cauliflower and potatoes. I often oven-roast garlic and cauliflower (place on a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper and bake at 375°F for 20–25 minutes, flipping halfway), and then slip that into my mashed potatoes for a more “rustic” mashed potato.
You can also add beans! Try whipping a can of white beans into your mashed potatoes, with (or without) a little fresh rosemary. A pinch or two of lemon zest and/or a little bit of lemon juice makes this version perfect for a spring meal.
Speaking of spring, for Passover specifically, mix prepared white horseradish into plain mashed potatoes to taste and garnish with fresh chives.
Cooked parsnips are another great addition to mashed potatoes (double veggie points!) and if you slip in some cooked cabbage or kale, you have colcannon, a traditional Irish dish.
For mashed sweet potatoes, use soy or almond milk, plus cinnamon (or pumpkin pie spice) to taste. Or make Sweet Potato Casserole (p. 23).
Potatoes not to use: waxy potatoes, such as Yukon Gold potatoes, especially if you plan to use an electric beater—you’ll end up with glue! My go-to choice is the little red-skin potatoes (they’re a touch sweet!) or Idaho or russet potatoes, though if you want a smooth mashed potato consistency, steam the latter instead of boiling them.
SERVES 2 | Q | GF | SF | MA | P |
I didn’t grow up eating green bean casserole, but I remember it being advertised on television. This ultimately led me to asking my mom to make it every year, which then led her to say, “Why? You don’t like mushrooms. Or onions. Or creamy things, Lindsay!” (I happen to love all those foods now and this casserole, too!)
1 c vegetable broth, divided
1 onion, diced
2 garlic cloves, minced
1 c mushrooms, thinly sliced
½ lb green beans, trimmed
1 tbsp poultry seasoning (granulated, not
powdered) (see note)
1 tbsp Dijon mustard
½ tsp dried thyme
½ tsp rubbed sage (not powdered)
dash of nutmeg
½ c nondairy milk
2 tbsp nutritional yeast
1 tbsp cornstarch
toasted bread crumbs (optional)
fried onions (optional)
CHEF’S NOTE:
In a pinch, you can use Italian seasoning instead of poultry seasoning.
Per serving: 145 calories, 2g fat, 26.9g carbohydrates, 8.5g fiber, 5.1g sugars, 9.2g protein
VARIATION
Asparagus Casserole: Replace green beans with asparagus for a tasty alternative!
SERVES 9 | Q | GF* | SF | MA | P |
You may recognize this cornbread recipe from my previous cookbooks. It’s a favorite and for good reason: you need only a handful of pantry staples to make it happen, and it’s foolproof. You can also get a little fancy pants by adding corn (fire-roasted is my favorite), sliced jalapeño, or diced bell pepper in the batter or sprinkled on top.
1 c yellow cornmeal
1 c white whole-wheat flour*
1 tbsp baking powder
1 c nondairy milk
¼ c unsweetened applesauce
¼ c pure maple syrup or agave nectar (see note)
2 tbsp raw sugar (optional)
Your choice of add-ins (optional)
CHEF’S NOTES:
Per serving: 131 calories, 1g fat, 28.7g carbohydrates, 1.6g fiber, 6g sugars, 2.6g protein
SERVES 8 | Q | SF | PA |
I created this recipe for the two men in my life who live and die for stuffing at Thanksgiving. (I’m talking to you, Dad and hubby!)
6 slices of whole-wheat bread
1 c vegetable broth, divided
1 medium onion, chopped
4 celery stalks, sliced or diced
2–3 tbsp Italian seasoning
Per serving: 70 calories, 1.7g fat, 10.8g carbohydrates, 1.7g fiber, 2.2g sugars, 2.9g protein
MAKES 2 CUPS | GF | SF | MA | P |
We always had cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving when I was growing up, but it was the gelatin, tubular-looking kind that came from a can. Years later, after I was married and cooking my very first Thanksgiving dinner, I picked up a bag of cranberries. The bag said to boil the cranberries with water and add sugar. I looked at my husband and said, “That’s it? That’s all you do? Why do people buy it in a can?” Indeed, a real head-scratcher.
12 oz fresh cranberries
sweetener (see note)
1 orange (optional)
CHEF’S NOTE:
You can use agave nectar, maple syrup, or stevia as your sweetener. When using agave nectar or maple syrup, I tend to add 2 tbsp at the end of cooking, then another 1–2 tbsp to taste once it’s chilled. (That’s the beauty of those liquid sweeteners; they combine right in—even if it’s a cold food—unlike sugar, which only dissolves into hot contents.) If you’re using stevia, add it to taste, a very light sprinkle at a time, once the sauce has thoroughly chilled.
Per serving (¼ c, without sweetener): 20 calories, 0.1g fat, 5.2g carbohydrates, 2g fiber, 1.7g sugars, 0.2g protein
SERVES 4–6 | GF | SF | MA | P |
Sweet potato casserole has been around all my life (it is a favorite of my parents’) but I didn’t try it until a few years ago. While most recipes call for lots of sugar, I use carrots to make mine naturally sweet (double veggie points!).
5–6 carrots, chopped
4 sweet potatoes, cooked and skinned
cinnamon or pumpkin pie spice, to taste
2 tbsp cornstarch
FOR THE CASSEROLE TOPPINGS:
brown sugar
cornflakes
vegan marshmallows
pecans
Per serving (serving 6, with 5 carrots, no toppings): 90 calories, 0.2g fat, 20.9g carbohydrates, 4.1g fiber, 7.3g sugars, 2g protein
SERVES 2 | GF | SF | MA | P |
This recipe from Happy Herbivore Abroad works as an easy, fuss-free (but delicious) meal on Thanksgiving for solo diners or couples!
1 acorn squash
½ c quinoa
1¼ c vegetable broth
¼ tsp mild curry powder
about tsp ground cinnamon
¼ c raisins
1 c spinach, finely chopped
Per serving: 302 calories, 2.8g fat, 65.8g carbohydrates, 7.2g fiber, 11.4g sugars, 8.4g protein
SERVES 9 | GF* | SF* | MA | P |
This pie is incredible. It’s totally crustless but still firms up like the real deal so you can cut individual slices without it falling apart. It’s like a little Thanksgiving tofu miracle.
½ c silken tofu* (see note)
1½ c nondairy milk
2 tbsp cornstarch
1 tsp vanilla extract
2 c canned pure pumpkin
½ c whole-wheat pastry flour* (see note)
2 tsp baking powder
½ c brown sugar
¼ tsp fine salt
3 tsp pumpkin pie spice
CHEF’S NOTES:
Per serving: 77 calories, 0.6g fat, 16.4g carbohydrates, 1.9g fiber, 10.8g sugars, 2.5g protein
SERVES 9 | MA | P |
If you’re looking for a pumpkin pie that even the pickiest relative will devour, this is it. Since this recipe calls for vegan cream cheese and a graham cracker crust, it isn’t as wholesome as my other recipes, but I’m okay with making a few nutritional compromises on big holidays.
1 15-oz can pure pumpkin
1 8-oz container vegan cream cheese
c light brown sugar
1–2 tbsp pumpkin pie spice
1 tsp vanilla extract
2 tbsp cornstarch
1 graham cracker pie crust (see note)
6 oz plain soy yogurt or vegan whipped cream (optional)
ground nutmeg or cinnamon for dusting
CHEF’S NOTES:
Per serving: 156 calories, 4.6g fat, 27.3 carbohydrates, 1.6g fiber, 16.2g sugars, 1.8g protein
A GRACIOUS TOUCH
Set name displays by each place setting with the person’s name plus a short note why you’re thankful for them (let them know they’re appreciated!) or why you’re thankful in general. To display it nicely, roll up the note and then tie a ribbon around it and leave it on the person’s plate. I like finding creative ways to make the day about Thanksgiving—giving thanks—instead of “Turkey Day.”
SERVES 2 | Q | GF | SF | MA | P |
This recipe makes two individual servings of pumpkin pie, which, without a crust, is a bit more like pudding or a custard—but still delicious! It’s also a great way to use up leftover sweet potato or pumpkin puree. Serve as a snack, treat, or even breakfast. You can also serve these mini pies at dinner parties—just glam it up with garnishes!
c nondairy milk (see note)
2 tsp cornstarch
½ c canned pure pumpkin or mashed sweet potato
2–3 tbsp brown sugar
½ tsp pumpkin pie spice
CHEF’S NOTES:
Per serving: 72 calories, 0.6g fat, 16.7 carbohydrates, 2g fiber, 10.8g sugars, 0.9g protein