CHAPTER 2
SEX TRAFFICKING
image
The Case of Nigeria
Brute force, no matter how strongly applied, can never subdue the basic human desire for freedom.
—Dalai Lama
INTO DARKNESS
I HAVE STEPPED into darkness many times, but none so dark as Nigeria. To research slavery is to face the raw and unrestrained bestiary of man. Those beasts are most fiercely unleashed in the dens of sex slavery, and Nigeria is the most unleashed of them all. Other countries may have more victims and other networks may be more sophisticated, but Nigeria took everything I had experienced about sex trafficking and cast it into an inscrutable abyss. It took all my fortitude not to fall into the abyss myself; for once the creeping pall invades your mind, it never leaves.
I landed in Nigeria before dawn on January 2, 2010. Christmas carols played over the speaker system as I waited in the immigration queue at Lagos Murtala Mohammed International Airport. The tranquility of the music and the calm before first light belied the extremes of violence, hardship, and disarray I was about to encounter. It took years of planning before I felt I could travel to Nigeria and conduct research effectively and safely. I needed local fixers and trusted relationships deep in the field; I also needed considerable resources. Despite being one of the poorest countries in the world, Nigeria is one of the most expensive in which to conduct human rights research. The primary culprit is security costs. The moment one steps outside the airport, security is a pressing concern. The price of keeping safe within Lagos is steep enough, but once I left the capital for rural areas, those costs skyrocketed, as did the challenges of getting around and finding enough food to eat.
Lagos is a miasma that transcends description. The metropolis is built in a swampland stitched together by the longest bridge in Africa, the Third Mainland Bridge. Filth, smog, putrescence, and urban snarl exceed human tolerance in this steamy West African capital. The sky is narrow and stained, hanging wearily like mud-caked clothes. Beneath it lies one of the most violent cities in the world. Peril skulks in every shadow, preying on less vigilant souls. Roaming the streets at night is a death wish. Gangs known as “Area Boys” will mug you, abduct you for ransom, or just kill you for sport. Navigating the city by daytime is a trial by combat. In addition to unyielding traffic, Lagos is an oppressive nebula of ramshackle huts, rundown buildings, stockpiles of trash, hordes of people, and the thickest haze anywhere in the world. Yellow buses that look like they have been through war zones shuttle citizens around town, while the rich travel comfortably (when they leave their gated compounds) in stretched, bullet-proof sedans. It is a humid, dusty, heavily congested megacity that is difficult even for experienced travelers to traverse. To have a chance, one must rely on a trusted guide, and my guide in Lagos was Stanley. I arrived on a Sunday, and after a quick breakfast Stanley took me to church.
Church in Nigeria is unlike church anywhere else, and going to a Sunday service at the TREM Redeemed Evangelical Mission in Lagos was the first step toward understanding the power of spirituality to the people of Nigeria, a power that is central to the trafficking of women, girls, and boys from the country. The open-air church was draped in red and green streamers for the Christmas season. The ceremony was officiated by Bishop Mike Okonkwo, who wore a flowing blue and gold kaftan. Bishop Okonkwo officiated his service to more than four thousand people. He preached at the top of his lungs to a rapt congregation that cheered more loudly and more feverishly with each passing hour. By hour four, the energy of the gathering was electric. Bishop Okonkwo mesmerized the audience with an impassioned praise of God. His oratory was enthralling. As his sermon reached its apex, he suddenly fell to the ground and spoke in tongues. As if in mass hypnosis, the entire congregation fell to the ground as well, and everyone spoke in tongues. I cannot describe the cyclonic sensation of observing thousands of people in mass rapture, crying phrases that seemed to have no meaning. The congregation was in ecstasy. It was one of many experiences I had in Nigeria that defied comprehension. I watched intently as men, women, and children rolled on the ground with eyes transfixed on another dimension. I worried that my incongruous presence might somehow corrupt their experience, but I realized I was a nonfactor in the euphoria of the moment. It was a fathomless scene, both beautiful and alarming, a communion wreathed in wails of exaltation. At length, Bishop Okonkwo returned to himself and brought the congregation back with him. There was a mass release, followed by a calm that passed my understanding. The sermon concluded with praise for children, who are the innocent future of the nation.
After the ceremony, I was invited to meet with the bishop in his office. He was still wiping the sweat from his brow when I entered. Up close his presence was surprisingly soothing. Was this the same man who had just brought thousands of people to an unbridled frenzy? The bishop welcomed me with a gracious smile and spoke to me about his sermon. He explained that the people in his country need to feel that God loves them so they can have hope. “God’s love gives every person a foundation that can withstand any storm,” he explained.
I wanted to ask the bishop about the period of his sermon in which everyone was speaking in tongues, but I did not know how to formulate the question. I assumed he would simply say that the spirit of God entered the congregation and that they felt the ecstasy of his presence. What other explanation could there be? We spoke about various topics, then the bishop introduced me to his wife, Dr. Peace Okonwko, who would show me the church’s shelter for victims of sex trafficking.
Dr. Okonkwo gave me a gracious tour of the shelter, which housed twenty-nine survivors at the time I visited, ages eleven to nineteen. The shelter personnel were going to great lengths to heal these survivors from the brutalities they had endured. This was one of the largest and most respected survivor shelters in Nigeria, operating in conjunction with the International Organisation on Migration (IOM) and the National Agency for the Prohibition of Traffic in Persons (NAPTIP), a Nigerian government agency formed in 2003 with the mandate of combating human trafficking in the country. All but three of the victims had been trafficked abroad before being deported and sent back to Nigeria. Several had been deported more than once. A young girl named Hope told me she had been to Italy, Spain, and France and was passed from one madam to the next before she was arrested and deported. “The madams in Spain are the worst,” she said. “They beat us for fun every day.” Fifteen-year-old Osa said, “I wanted to go to Europe so I could send money to my mother. She was sick and could not work because my father beat her. I had to be with men like my father. It was very bad.”
I documented the stories of these children, one painful tale at a time. The shelter was striving to give them hope, healing, and a chance at a decent future, but there was no mistaking the brutalities they had endured. The stories they told of arduous journeys to Europe, the tortures of men and madams, and their fears of failing to repay their debts were identical to the narratives of the Nigerian sex trafficking victims I had documented in shelters across Europe several years earlier. These were the victims who first piqued my interest in traveling to Nigeria.
The first sex trafficking victims from Nigeria I met were in Italy. I describe some of these encounters in Sex Trafficking.1 From Italy, my encounters spanned Europe, and eventually Thailand and the United States. All but two of the Nigerian sex trafficking victims I met were from Edo State, all were Yoruba and lived in terror of a juju priest who had taken control of their souls during a ceremony that almost none were willing to describe. These women and girls told impossible tales of traversing the desert by foot for weeks and months before taking a raft from north Africa to Spain, only to be deported and trafficked back again. They were tormented by their madams, brutalized by the men who purchased them, and refused to cooperate with local authorities for fear that the juju priest would curse them. This curse was no small matter—an evil spirit would possess anything that had been, or one day would be, born from their womb. If that were not enough, the juju priests typically worked in conjunction with the Nigerian mafia, which threatened the worst possible punishments to the victims and their families should the girls ever try to escape or fail to repay their debts. The juju ritual also serves the purpose of erasing the girl’s identity. She is told she must forget who she is and be reborn as someone else, someone under the control of the oath. The level of control exerted by the juju ritual was beyond anything I had encountered. Chains and locked doors were nothing compared to the hold this curse had on the women of Edo State. The curse clutched their souls and did not let go. Few of the Nigerians I met were willing to speak about the ritual. One young woman who did so was named Gift.
I met Gift in Copenhagen at a Red Cross shelter for sex trafficking victims. She was from the Eshan village in Edo State. The name of her village means “place she ran to,” based on an old story that the queen of the Benin Empire fled to this area centuries ago after a quarrel with the king. Today young girls cannot flee from Eshan village fast enough, and they search desperately for safety and income in faraway lands. Gift’s father died when she was six, leaving her mother and three siblings to fend for themselves. They worked as day laborers in farming for the local landowner, but the wages were paltry, and the family could barely survive. Tribes and armed militia from the north also began raiding villages in the south and absconding with young girls, placing Gift and her sisters in considerable jeopardy. In this context, Gift was desperate to travel to Europe. This is what she told me.
I took the juju oath when I was fifteen years old. The priest made me swear to repay my debt for arranging my trip to Italy. He said I would work as a cleaning lady. A few days later, some men took me from my village to Lagos and gave me a passport and plane ticket. I flew to Milan. When I arrived, a Nigerian woman met me. She wore beautiful clothes and jewelry. She took me to an apartment and said she had purchased me and that I would work in prostitution until I paid her forty thousand euros. I told her there was a mistake, but she beat me until I cried, then she forced me to be with men. She said if I did not obey her, she would tell the priest and he would curse me. She said the men who took me to Lagos would kill my mother and sisters.
I worked in prostitution for this madam for eight months in Milan. The madam was evil. She beat us and made us do horrible things with men. One day I was arrested. I told the police what happened to me. They deported me back to Nigeria. At the airport in Lagos, the mother of my madam in Milan picked me up and told me I had not paid my debt. She made me work as her house slave in Lagos for six months while they arranged to send me back to Italy. She beat me every day and terrorized me psychologically. After six months, a man we call a “trolley” said he would take me back to Europe. He drove me and five other girls to Burkina Faso. We worked there for three months in prostitution to earn money for the rest of the trip. After Burkina Faso, two trolleys took thirty girls to Tunisia. Sometimes we traveled by car; sometimes we walked. It took more than a month.
At Tunisia we went to the coast where we took a rubber boat called a zodiac. We got lost on the way, and it took us four days to arrive in Spain. There was very little food and water on the boat, and two girls died. The trolleys threw their bodies into the sea. We landed on a beach in Spain where tourists were drinking cocktails.
After a few days, the trolleys drove us to Italy. I returned to my madam and worked three years in prostitution. I was arrested again and deported back to Lagos. The madam’s mother said I still had fifteen thousand euros debt. This time, I worked as a house slave to a family on Victoria Island for almost one year, then they sent me on a plane back to Italy. After two more years in prostitution, my madam sold me to another madam in Denmark. I thought my debt was paid, but she said I still owed five thousand euros. Some Arabic men took me on a train to Jutland, and the new madam made me work in a brothel. Men came from many countries to that brothel. After five weeks there was a raid and I was sent to prison. The authorities contacted the Danish Center Against Human Trafficking and they came with me to court. The judge told me that since I was not trafficked directly from Nigeria to Denmark, I did not qualify as a victim of human trafficking for Denmark, so I was sent back to prison for immigration violations. I was in prison eight weeks while the NGOs tried to help me. They explained to the judge that if I was deported to Nigeria I would be a house slave again and would be trafficked back to Europe for prostitution. Eventually, the court granted me asylum and I was taken to a shelter. Two days after I arrived at the shelter, I received a letter from the juju priest on his stationery. He said if I cooperated with the authorities or discussed my oath he would send someone to kill me. My younger sister, Mercy, has taken the oath with the same priest. She wants to come to Europe because the conditions in my village are bad. I begged her not to come.
I blame myself for what has happened. I had ambitions for a better life, and God has punished me. Ambition is a sin. I learned my lesson.
Gift showed me the letter that was sent to her by the high priest of Edo State. (I will refer to him as “GT.”) He is the head of the Cult of Ayelala. I read the threats he made; they were written in plain English on professional letterhead. When I looked back up at Gift, she burst into tears. “You tell me, what can I do? This man will kill me! How do I protect my sister?” I took Gift’s hands and promised her I would go to her village, meet with her family, and do everything I could to persuade her sister not to travel to Europe. I also promised myself that I was going to meet GT.
The juju oath undertaken by thousands of women and girls in Edo State before they are trafficked abroad is shrouded in mystery. Many child soldiers take the oath as well, although it is primarily administered to females before leaving Nigeria for forced prostitution abroad. One component of the oath requires that the women must never discuss the ritual, let alone try to flee or stop working before discharging their debts. These debts, which can exceed forty thousand euros, are the highest levied against sex trafficking victims anywhere in the world. A few brave survivors like Gift, and a few juju priests in Edo State, discussed the ritual with me in pieces, providing just enough detail for me to piece together most of what happens.
The ritual typically starts late at night in a juju priest’s shrine. It can last a few hours or go on for days. The priest takes some of the girl’s menstrual blood, nail clippings, and hair, and places these items in a container with her photo affixed to the outside, upside down. The priest and the girl drink alcohol and drugs to achieve an altered mental state. As they chant, the young woman must repeatedly take several oaths: she will obey her madam, never try to escape, never discuss the ritual, never cooperate with authorities abroad, and will keep working until she is told that her debt is discharged. The priest marks the girl’s body with cuts using a sharp stone or razor blade, then he smears the cuts with ash. The girl undertakes the ritual because she will not be transported abroad otherwise, and she also receives a blessing from the priest that her journeys will be safe and fruitful. A tray of sand and chicken bones is used for divination to predict the girl’s future, and a pact is made with the earth so she can be controlled or cursed by the priest whenever her feet touch the ground, no matter how far away she is. The priest also takes control of the girl’s womb, giving him the ability to curse any child that has been or ever will be born from it. The girl lives in terror of this curse and believes in its power completely. No amount of reasoning can persuade her that the curse is invalid.
Although the arrangements vary, many priests are paid by the Nigerian mafia to conduct the rituals. The mafia handles the travel documents and transportation to Europe. Madams in Europe purchase the girls from the mafia, then work them as prostitutes until they feel the debts have been repaid. The madams operate sophisticated networks across Europe to buy, sell, and exploit girls as sex slaves. Several madams I met were former slaves who had discharged their debts and “graduated” to exploiting other women, just as they had once been exploited. Many of these madams returned to Edo State to show off their material wealth, building big homes in Benin City, driving fancy cars, and wearing expensive clothes. Known locally as “Italianos,” the madams are living advertisements of the riches that await the girls of Edo State if they take the oath and travel to Europe. They tell the girls that the only barrier that stands between them and a prosperous future is breaking their oath. Never do so, and prestige, wealth, and respect will be theirs.
EDO STATE
By the time I met Gift, I had built the ties I needed to conduct research in Nigeria effectively and safely. Although I was sincere when I promised her I would go to her village to do what I could to persuade her sisters not to travel to Europe, I knew that my task was likely to be futile because her sisters probably had no reasonable alternative other than to leave. Even if I managed to persuade them on the day we met, who is to say what might happen weeks or months down the road? The pernicious realities faced by the girls in Edo State were just as responsible for their exploitation as someone like GT.
The first step in my journey to Gift’s village was to travel from Lagos to Benin City, the capital of Edo State. Traveling in Nigeria proved to be more difficult than travel in any other country I have visited. First, the environment is utterly toxic. There is a perpetual brown murk in the air from the burning of crude oil and vehicle pollution. To make matters worse, I arrived in Edo State at the time of the Harmattan winds, which carry fine sand from the Sahara desert across the entire country. As bad as the air was in Lagos, it was much filthier in Edo State, and in Delta State it was worst of all. Near Port Harcourt, the air was intolerable and the ground was covered in a toxic oil slick. Plant life was sparse, and I did not see a single bird in the sky. Hills of rubbish were everywhere, with a dead body or two lying next to them now and then. Land travel in Nigeria, even with security and a trusted driver, is unequivocally discouraged due to the certainty of being abducted for ransom or being forced to pay numerous “dashes” (bribes) at police check points along the highway. I was advised never to use plastic currency in Nigeria, or my credit card details would be stolen within minutes. Corruption runs rampant in the country, and most people reading this book will have received numerous emails from a supposed Nigerian barrister promising an inheritance of millions of dollars if the recipient’s bank details are provided.2 These emails are known locally as “419 Letters,” referencing the portion of the Nigerian penal code that addresses fraud. The same scam artists prey on their countrymen as well, often selling another person’s home or land without the owner’s permission. As a result, hand-painted signs are often placed in front of homes across rural Nigeria that read: “This home and attached land are not for sale, by order of Jesus.”
In addition to being the capital of Edo State, Benin City is the capital of the historic Benin Empire.3 Unlike most of West Africa, Benin was not a slave-dealing empire, making it all the more disheartening that the region has become one of the primary sources of human trafficking from West Africa. The southern portion of Nigeria was dominated by the Benin Empire dating back to the fifteenth century, and it is said that the current Oba (king) of Benin can trace his line of royalty back to 1170. When the British arrived in Benin City in 1897 and discovered human sacrifice, they were so appalled that they burned down the king’s palace and took control of the empire. Their next task was to civilize the “heathens” through the introduction of Christianity. Traditionally, the people of Edo State are Yoruba and follow an all-powerful God named Olorun or Olodumare (“owner of the universe”), along with well over one thousand other deities and spirits. The Yoruba tradition was mixed with Christianity upon the arrival of the missionaries, and it evolved into a unique Christian-Yoruba mix still practiced today across much of southern Nigeria. However, unlike other parts of southern Nigeria, Edo State clung more tightly to traditional beliefs, which have seen a resurgence since the chaos that ensued in Nigeria after independence in 1960. In this context, several cults to ancient deities in the Yoruba tradition have emerged. The primary one, the Cult of Ayelala, is responsible for all juju oaths taken by Nigerian girls prior to their trafficking abroad. This cult dominates the spiritual lives of the Yoruba people, and it is also the primary source of law and order in the state. Most people have little faith in the Nigerian police and justice systems.
Ayelala is a fascinating deity and her origin story reveals why she governs the juju oaths. Long ago, there were said to be two main tribes in the Yoruba lands, the Ijaw and the Ilaje. An Ilaje man fell in love with an Ijaw woman, and even though he was already married, he ran away to the Ijaw to be with the woman. This created strife between the two tribes, so it was agreed that an Ijaw slave woman would be sacrificed to atone for the sins of the adulterous Ilaje man. As the slave woman was being sacrificed, she uttered the word “Ayelala,” which means “the world is incomprehensible,” and this became her name. Before she passed away, Ayelala made a solemn vow to witness all agreements made under her name, and should they be broken she can be invoked to curse the oath breaker. Ayelala was deified, and a cult grew around her and spread across Benin. She instills fear in all believers and is the ultimate dispenser of justice and the protector of truth and morality.4 Traveling to Gift’s village meant traveling into the heart of the land of Ayelala—the land over which GT had complete control.
Gift’s village was about 100 kilometers north of Benin City. Travel by car from the city to her village was unavoidable, even if highly inadvisable. I had several drivers throughout my time in Nigeria, most of whom were very cautious and professional. Finding a driver with a reliable car in rural Nigeria, however, was quite a challenge. A car breakdown deep in a rural area was not at all desirable. I did my best to find dependable drivers and cars through word of mouth, and although the results were mixed, the driver who took me to Gift’s village turned out to be particularly helpful.
His name was Step-by-Step and he spoke pidgin English, which does not relate in any systematic way to normal English. For example, “hoy far” means “hello,” “abeg” means “please,” “chop” means “food,” “how bodi” means “how are you,” “butta my bread,” means “God has answered my prayers,” “go slow” means “traffic jam,” and “so kin so” means “two-door vehicle,” such as the one driven by Step-by-Step. I tried to memorize a few useful phrases before traveling to Edo State, but communication was still difficult without a guide who could translate pidgin English to English, and such guides were simply not available.
I set out with Step-by-Step from Benin City early in the morning for the drive to Gift’s village. As we ventured deeper into the countryside, the landscape was a contrast of brick-red earth, pale-green foliage, and chocolate-brown haze in the sky. The land seemed to wheeze and groan under the strain of its defilement. The red color of the earth in Nigeria in particular caught my eyes, as I had never before looked down at the dirt and seen any color other than brown. It was as if the land was covered in a legacy of rust-dried blood.
Because of the language barrier, Step-by-Step and I could not talk to each other, so most of our drive was spent in silence. About half way to Gift’s village, I phoned her at the shelter in Copenhagen to let her know I was almost at her home. We had stayed in contact during my journey, and she was both excited and anxious about my visit. She was very touched that I would be meeting her family, and she hoped that the voice of someone objective might be enough to persuade her sisters to pursue other options, such that they existed. However, I knew that no one short of the almighty would be able to change their minds. It was he, after all, who had left these children with no alternatives.
After I spoke with Gift, she sent word through a few people in her village who had mobile phones that I would be arriving. Gift’s village consisted of a few dozen red clay houses with sheet-metal roofs. The clay was made by mixing the red dirt with water to form a bricklike substance that was sturdier than the mud huts in most of the villages I had visited in other rural settings. Gift’s mother was named Joy, and as our car pulled up to her hut, she ran out, threw her arms around me, and erupted in tears. Like Step-by-Step, she only spoke pidgin English, so I could not understand what she was saying, but I understood her tears, her embraces, and her ardent gestures toward her children. I knew she did not want them to follow in Gift’s footsteps, but I could see why she would not want them to stay in the village either. It was a place where people could barely survive. The only water came from rain, toilets were holes in the ground covered by a plank of wood, and there was no electricity. To make matters worse, kidnappings by militias heightened the risk of remaining. Though Boko Haram had not yet ventured this far south, it was rumored that they were coordinating with local sympathizers to abduct girls and take them north where they would be sold as sex slaves.
Joy was the mother of nine children, ages thirteen to twenty-five. Most of them spoke broken English, which they learned at a nearby government school when they were able to attend. Gift was the second oldest child. One of her younger sisters, Mercy, age sixteen, had recently taken the juju oath with GT and was preparing to leave for Europe. She was taller than Gift, with a very calm and reassuring presence that belied the harshness of her surroundings. Joy’s only son, Promise, had recently been recruited to play in a junior football league in Greece, which I knew was little more than a trafficker’s ruse to lure young African boys into forced labor in drug running, street begging, and petty theft in Europe. Even though Mercy knew she would likely by forced into prostitution, she was anxious to leave her village in the hopes that she would be the exception to the rule.
Joy invited me into her hut. Near the entry I noticed a wooden pole in the ground, with a dead pigeon tied to the top, hanging upside down. This, I later learned, had been arranged by GT, to indicate that Joy’s home was cursed because Gift had broken her oath. No one in the village would step inside her home for fear that the curse would spread to them. The children’s desperation to leave became clearer.
Inside, Joy’s children huddled around me. The home consisted of two rooms, a main sitting room and one bedroom with dried grass on the ground. The main room had a phrase written with chalk on the wall: “There’s nothing on Earth more precious than a loaf of bread.” To be sure, a loaf of bread would have been a delicacy for Joy and her family; they subsisted primarily on boiled tree leaves and yams, three meals a day. Their weary aspects manifested all too clearly the toll taken by perpetual hunger. As with most of the people who lived in the village, work was difficult to come by, which meant income was minimal. During the agricultural season, there was farm work with a local landowner. The villagers were not called by the landowner every day, but when they were, Joy and her children woke at 4 AM and walked two hours to a farming area where they worked in day labor harvesting cassava and yam. They returned home around 8 PM. For their backbreaking work, they were paid the equivalent of $0.26 per day.
Joy apologized for having nothing to offer me to eat but boiled tree leaves. I told her she must not apologize; rather, I should apologize to her as all I had to offer her family were a dozen granola bars I brought for them. I handed out the granola bars, and the children tentatively ate them. Joy sat down on the ground next to me and started to cry. Mercy, whose English was relatively good, translated the conversation.“My mother says Gift is so far. We know she is in Europe, but we do not know where she is. She is so far.”
Joy asked me if Gift was okay, and I said she was safe in a shelter. “Please tell Mercy not to go to Europe,” she begged me. I looked at Mercy intently and considered my words. I wanted to come right out and tell her “Do not go!” However, once I stepped foot in Joy’s home and saw the penury and perils of their existence, I did not feel it was my place to instruct them on what they should and should not do. Still, I had to give Mercy some level of warning, which I did. I explained the mistreatment Gift had endured, just like so many other children from Edo State who had embarked on similar journeys. I could not offer a reasonable alternative, so I knew that my warnings held little meaning. If someone is standing in a fire, you can warn them all you like that if they jump out they may land in the mouth of a crocodile—they still have to jump.
I spent the rest of the day and that night with Joy and her children. Light came by shrouded moon and cooking fire for a few hours, then impenetrable darkness. There was little more I could accomplish regarding travel to Europe, so we talked about their struggles in the village and their hopes that God would one day bless them with a better future. As the hours passed, my thoughts turned to GT and my hope to learn more about him and the juju oaths. I knew Mercy had recently taken the oath, so I asked her if she could tell me more about it and the priest who administered it. Much to my surprise, she pointed to Step-by-Step and said, “He is the one who took me.”
I could not believe the coincidence, if that’s what it was. Of all the drivers who could have taken me to Gift’s village, I ended up with the man who had driven her sister Mercy to GT for her juju oath. Maybe there are not many drivers in rural Edo State, or maybe it was just dumb luck, but as it turned out, Step-by-Step had driven dozens of girls to GT through the years. Not many people know the way to GT’s shrine, but Step-by-Step knew the way well. I asked Mercy to ask him if he would take me, and they both said it was not a good idea. Step-by-Step said that GT’s shrine was far away in a rural area and that GT would be very suspicious if we just showed up. I tried to persuade Step-by-Step that it was important for me to see GT and his shrine, because I wanted to understand him and the power he held over girls like Gift and Mercy. Eventually, Mercy persuaded him by agreeing to come along with us under the guise of saying that she needed more guidance from him before leaving for Europe. She would say that I was a friend of her sister’s who had come to visit and was interested in helping more members of the family migrate to Europe. It felt like a flimsy cover story that GT was not likely to believe, but it was the only way I was going to have a chance to meet the man who had terrorized Gift and countless other Nigerian sex trafficking victims around the world.
Two days later, Step-by-Step, Mercy, and I drove to meet GT. His shrine was located a few hours drive from Mercy’s village, deep in the forested area down a remote dirt road. We did not talk much during the drive, and I could tell that both Mercy and Step-by-Step were very uneasy. When we were about a mile from GT’s shrine, Mercy began to panic. She trembled and asked to be let out of the car. “I can’t go,” she said, “I can’t go. Please leave me here. I can’t go.”
We pulled the car to the side of the dirt road, and I told Mercy I was not going to leave her on her own in the middle of the forest. She told me she would be fine and that she did not want to disrupt my research. I was very uncomfortable with the idea of leaving Mercy on her own and assured her I could always return another day, but she was adamant that we continue without her. She explained that if I tried to go back another time GT would likely be suspicious because Step-by-Step had asked permission for us to visit on that particular day. It was a difficult decision, and if anything happened to Mercy, I never would have forgiven myself. I knew I was crossing a line, but I calculated we would be back within an hour, maybe less, so I agreed to leave Mercy by the side of the dirt road. She stepped out of the car and took a seat in the shade under a tree. Before we pulled off, she told me, “Do not drink anything he gives you!”
As we continued down the path, I felt conflicted about leaving Mercy behind and contemplated going back to her. I was also quite anxious that without her I could not understand Step-by-Step and that our cover story was no longer plausible. Why on earth was I randomly, and without Mercy, showing up to visit GT? I ran through possible scenarios in my mind but could not come up with a clear answer to the dilemma. This would probably be my only chance to meet GT, but I did not want to cause harm or risk to anyone other than myself. The risks of leaving Mercy on her own in the forest for an hour were difficult to assess, as were the risks of carrying on with the meeting with GT without her. Indeed, not carrying on with the meeting with GT might also raise suspicions on his part that could put Mercy and her family at risk. Overcome by the complexity of the situation, I pushed on.
From a distance, the shrine appeared ominous and incongruous. As we got nearer, I saw a peach and green painted building with “Ayelala Spiritual Home” written on top. Outside, fenced off by a pile of mattresses, was a warrior statue, red with a white-painted face. A sign in front of the statue read, “Out of bounds for women under menses.” Step-by-Step parked the car outside the shrine. He was tense and desperate to tell me something, but we could not communicate with each other. I pointed to the door of the shrine as if to ask, “Is that the way in?” He nodded, then pointed to the camera in my hand and shook his head no. I put the camera in my pocket.
We stepped out of the car, and I took a moment to take in my surroundings. Suddenly seven children rushed at us out of nowhere, hissing and shrieking. I looked at Step-by-Step nervously, and he made a “steady on” gesture. The children swarmed and howled ferociously. Eventually they scurried off. Later a colleague told me these were “witch children” who were possessed by demons as a result of the curse unleashed by GT on their mothers for breaking their juju oaths. Cast out from their homes, GT took them to his shrine and raised them as he saw fit.
At this point, the fear that Step-by-Step, Mercy, and thousands of girls from Edo State had felt became all too real to me. I am a rational person, but—here in the middle of West Africa amid customs and powers I did not understand—even I began to wonder what kind of world I was entering. What were the rules, and what kind of forces held power here? Step-by-Step gestured to me to wait where I was as he walked into the shrine. I stood alone outside, trying to take in as much as I could. I quickly pulled out my camera and snapped a few photos of the shrine and the surroundings. The front wall of the shrine was covered in dozens of framed photographs. I moved closer and saw that each photo was of a deformed female, some with distended bellies, others with disfigured faces and limbs. These were the women GT had cursed for breaking their oath, broadcast plainly for all to see. I imagined a sixteen-year-old village girl confronted by howling witch children and seeing these images upon entry to the shrine, and I began to understand the awful power of this man.
Step-by-Step emerged from the shrine and waved me in. I waited for a moment and thought one last time about whether I should proceed. When entering dangerous venues such as a brothel with sex slaves or a carpet factory with child laborers and armed guards, I always had an exit strategy. However, here there was no escape. The moment I walked through the door into the shrine, my fate was out of my hands. I could be walking into the kind of trap I had assiduously avoided so many times before. This was, after all, a cult whose priests were rumored to perform human sacrifice and eat human body parts during their rituals. I decided to proceed.
I followed Step-by-Step into the shrine. There were more framed photos of disfigured and deformed women on the inside walls, some white ceiling fans, piles of artifacts, clothes, and trinkets scattered about, and about a dozen red wooden benches facing an altar. There were at least two hundred small mirrors hanging from the ceiling on short strings (I later learned these mirrors held demon spirits that GT could unleash on any woman who broke her oath). The altar consisted of a small wooden table with various large bottles of alcohol on it, and the numbers “2” and “1” painted white in red squares on the floor. Beneath the altar were a dozen large yams painted with blue markings, and above was a framed photo of the king of Benin. A handful of priests in red robes sat on white plastic chairs on either side of the altar. Directly behind the altar, sitting on a red sofa and wearing a light green robe, was GT. He was a broad man, intense, with a penetrating gaze. I feared him the moment I saw him. It suddenly seemed all too plausible that there and then, in the dark heart of his realm, this man might actually have the ability to curse me just as he had so many Nigerian girls. I felt his eyes slicing me like knives, and I tried to assess whether I should push forward or leave.
“Welcome,” GT said in perfect English, “I understand you are interested in our culture.”
Step-by-Step looked at me nervously.
“Yes,” I replied, “Thank you for allowing me to visit.”
GT waved me forward, “Sit here. I can describe our culture to you.”
I took a few steps forward, keeping my senses trained on my surroundings to catch any sudden movements. I took a seat on the front bench, and one of the priests in red robes entered from a side door holding an oatmeal colored beverage in a glass.
“Please have this drink,” GT said, “It is a custom for us.”
I nervously took the glass, remembering Mercy’s warning not to drink anything GT offered me.
“I’m not very thirsty,” I replied, “But thank you.”
“Please drink, it will cool you down.”
I did not want to drink the beverage, but I knew if I declined it could be construed as an insult to his hospitality. I tried to think quickly of a delicate way to avoid drinking the beverage.
“Actually, today is a day of fasting for me in my religion, so I can’t have the drink. I hope that’s okay.”
GT nodded, “Of course that’s okay.”
I later learned I had been offered a malted beverage laced with intense and sometimes incapacitating hallucinogens, which GT gave most girls prior to beginning the juju ritual.
“Where are you from?” GT asked.
“I am Indian by ancestry, but I live in the United States.”
“I have been to America many times,” GT replied, “Just last month I was in Miami.”
“What brought you to Miami?”
“I have business there.”
I spoke with GT about his travels, the many cities in the United States he had visited, and my interest in understanding the local culture. I knew GT did not believe a word of my cover story. He was probing to ascertain the real reason I was visiting him, in his shrine, far off the beaten path in the rural reaches of Edo State. He was too sophisticated not to be suspicious, and I knew it was just a matter of time before the charade was over. I had seen enough, and I was not about to pry into areas that would raise his suspicions further. I felt increasingly apprehensive about remaining in the shrine and was desperate for a way to leave.
“I must apologize for coming in the middle of the day,” I said to GT, “You look busy. Perhaps I could come back another time and we could speak more about your culture.”
“We will be having an important ritual here tomorrow night,” GT replied, “I will send a driver to bring you. You will be my guest. Where are you staying?”
I told GT the name of a village about a hundred kilometers away from the village where I was actually staying.
“Be ready at five.”
“Thank you,” I replied, “Perhaps I can leave a donation for you, as gratitude for your time.”
GT nodded. I took out about forty dollars worth of Naira and placed them on the altar. Before leaving I wanted to do one last thing because I knew I would never return to this place.
“Would it be okay if I took a picture with you?” It was a brazen question, one that may have pushed matters one step too far. After a moment GT said, “Okay.”
I stood where I was, on the opposite side of the altar in front of GT, turned around, and faced Step-by Step. I handed him my camera and motioned to him to take a photo. He shook his head no, but GT told him it was okay. I stood there, stiff as a board, and Step-by-Step took the photo. I thanked GT again and said that I looked forward to being his guest the next day. I walked out slowly, taking one last look at the deformed women, the markings in front of his altar, and the demon-prison mirrors hanging from the ceiling. After closing the main door of the shrine, I looked into Step-by-Step’s eyes and said, “Let’s go. Now!” He did not understand the words, but he knew exactly what I said.
Thankfully, Mercy was safe just where I left her. We picked her up and continued back to her village. I could tell that she was relieved to see me.
“How did it go?” she asked.
I took her hands and said, “I understand.”
A few weeks later Mercy left for Europe.
THE MADAMS
My brief encounter with GT helped me understand the nature of his power. He is the counterpoint to Bishop Okonkwo. Both men govern with intense spirituality—the bishop rouses his congregation into an ecstasy of hopeful communion with the divine, whereas GT wields the divine for a grimmer purpose. The unrestrained faith of their congregants empowers both men to prophet status; however, one is a prophet of light and the other is a prophet of darkness. They are the two faces of divine power, two outcomes of fervent spirituality. No doubt, GT sees himself as a man who brings order to a chaotic world infected with corruption and the degradation of morality and law. That is the power he exerts, which he transfers to the madams, who act as extensions of his reach. This makes the madams the crucial link in the Nigerian sex trafficking chain. They purchase and exploit the trafficked Nigerian women, wielding power through physical and psychological force and the ever-present threat of the juju curse.
There have not been many studies on the madams of Edo State to explain how they operate and how they recruit sex trafficking victims from the region. One study conducted in Benin City in 2004 found that one-third of women surveyed had been approached by a madam who offered to help them get to Europe for work.5 Roughly 97 percent of respondents knew what sex trafficking was, and 70 percent had relatives working in prostitution in Europe, most of whom had been recruited by madams.6 The madams and the system they represent seem to be well known to the women of Edo State. Given their central role in the sex trafficking chain from Nigeria, I endeavored to meet as many as I could.
Most madams in Nigeria live in Benin City or in Lagos. It was relatively easy to meet them, and most were quite willing to speak with me. The conversations I had with the madams were remarkably similar to each other, and also remarkably similar to the conversations I had with gharwalis in the brothels of India. In both cases, the women saw themselves as doing a favor for poor, illiterate girls by providing them with opportunities for a better life. The concept of “sex trafficking” had little meaning to them, and they did not perceive any fault with what they were doing. Five of the six madams I interviewed in Nigeria were former sex trafficking victims themselves (not that they saw it that way). This was the natural progression, in their eyes, of hard-working, dutiful girls who keep their oaths and repay their debts.
The most extensive conversation I had was with a madam named Love. She was thin compared to the other heavy-set madams I met, and there was even a hint of kindness in her eyes. She was intelligent, practical, and quite at ease with her vocation. She explained that she first left Edo State after taking a juju oath at the age of sixteen. She worked for four madams across Europe for five years, after which she was told that her debt had been repaid. At the tender age of twenty, she was ready for her new life.
My madam threw a party for me when my debt was finished. She told me, “Now, you can be just like me!” She gave me one thousand euros as a gift, and I started working as a madam myself. It was the happiest day of my life. I made so much money you cannot imagine. I send money to my family every month. My parents are proud of me. They built a new house in Benin City, and they sent my two sisters and my brother to school. In this country, school requires fees, so who do you think is going to pay? I paid! I tell my girls that if they work hard, they can be just like me and help their families. Most of the girls are selfish and lazy and wicked. They want money without work. They lie and they steal. If bad things happen to them, they can only blame themselves.
I pressed Love on the issue that most of the girls she was talking about were probably too young to realize what they were getting into, and that they were too vulnerable to make a real “choice” to take the oath and go to Europe.
“They are not stupid. They know exactly what they are doing,” Love retorted.
“Then why do so many try to escape?” I asked, “Why do most of them want to stop this kind of work and return home?”
“As I said, they are lazy. Once they realize they have to work to earn money, they quit. If you want a better life, you have to work for it. This is true for all people.”
“Then why do they have to take the juju oath? Why make them afraid to stop working if they wish to be lazy, as you say. Why force them through fear?”
“Do you know how expensive it is to get them to Europe? They have to repay these debts, or they will run away after they arrive. We make an investment in these girls and they must pay us back.”
“But it doesn’t cost forty thousand euros to take them to Europe.”
“We also have a right to our profit for housing them and teaching them and giving them this opportunity to be wealthy for the rest of their lives. It’s like an internship, you see. Don’t they have this in your country? Why is this so hard for you to understand?”
Love and I sparred politely for a while. For every argument I made to point out the exploitative nature of her trade, she had a perfectly reasoned response. If girls tried to escape, it is because they were lazy. If the use of a juju oath applied undue coercion on the girls to stay in prostitution, it is required because the wicked girls will otherwise flee before working off the costs of their transport. In Love’s mind, these girls were lucky to have the opportunities she afforded them. She had nine girls under her “protection” (as she put it), and she traveled back and forth between Italy and Nigeria regularly, so she could spend time with her family and recruit more girls. When she was away, other madams kept charge over her girls until she returned. There was not much that surprised me about my encounter with Love except that toward the end of our conversation she offered to arrange for me to meet several Nigerian girls in shelters who had been deported from Europe. Surely, I thought, most of them were sex trafficking survivors and would not have positive things to say about their experiences, let alone their madams.
“I know you are a good man,” she said, “I want to help you even if we do not agree. Most people only want to help those they agree with, but in Nigeria we are not like this.”
Love mentioned one shelter in Benin City and two in Lagos. I thanked her for her generosity and visited two of the shelters she mentioned in Lagos. They were home to girls whose stories were particularly devastating. They had all been trafficked for the first time between the ages of thirteen and twenty. Several of them were pregnant for the second, third, or fourth time when I met them. One of the “older” survivors I met was Sandra. She was thirty-one and had worked for several madams in Italy, France, and England. She had short hair that was gray beyond her years, and though her face was sallow, she was always smiling. Sandra was arrested in England a few years ago and courageously assisted with the prosecution of her madam. She was granted asylum, but after a few years she missed her family too much and wanted to return home. She thought by this time, it would be safe.
A few days after I came home, some men came in the night. They broke into my home, dragged me into the street, stripped my clothes, raped me, and chopped off my left arm with a meat cleaver. They said this was my punishment for breaking my oath.
Sandra was left for dead but managed to get to a hospital with the help of neighbors. She was eventually fitted with a crude plastic prosthetic in place of her left arm and has since lived in various shelters. The head of the shelter, Anne, told me that the violence against Sandra had been particularly inhuman because she is a lesbian.
“In Nigeria, it is better to be an animal than to be a homosexual,” Anne told me.
Traditional cultural beliefs across Nigeria, including in the Yoruba tradition, view same-sex preferences as dirty, unnatural, and pathological.7 Even secular law is set harshly against same-sex relations, which in the southern states are punishable by up to fourteen years in prison,8 and in certain northern states that have adopted Shari’a law the punishment may be stoning to death.
Despite the brutalities she had endured, Sandra remained remarkably cheerful about her future. She had even recently started going to school.
“I am going to study law, so I can fight for justice for women like me,” Sandra told me.
If Sandra’s story were not harrowing enough, I heard stories from two other young women at her shelter, Veera and Precious, that were even more disturbing. They had both recently been rescued from a “baby factory” in Lagos. They were eighteen and nineteen years old and had been locked inside a building in the outskirts of the city for a few years, where they were forcefully inseminated and kept imprisoned throughout their pregnancy.
“There was a nurse who fed us,” Precious explained, “And a doctor came to examine us and deliver the babies.”
Veera and Precious both delivered two babies while they were held captive. The babies were rumored to have been sold for international adoptions.
“Some of the other girls in that place said the babies might be used for sacrifice by juju priests,” Veera added.
I asked how many girls were in the baby factory with them, and they said there were over thirty. I had heard anecdotes about these factories but had considered them to be an urban myth until I met two girls who had actually been in one. News stories revealed very little in the way of corroboration, but I did come across a few instances, including a case in 2013 of seventeen girls in Imo State who were locked inside a baby factory, each impregnated by a single man. The girls gave birth to babies who were again rumored to have been sold for international adoption.9 The conditions Veera and Precious described were impossible to imagine. The notion of being forcefully impregnated and held captive like a breeding animal left me nauseated. The rumor that some of these babies were used in black magic juju rituals was beyond reckoning. Precious insisted it was true and told me about a place, called Jankara Market, where items for black magic juju rituals could be found. She told me that at the southeast corner of the market I would find dried monkey heads, animal skins, insects, frogs, and, in very secret places accessible only to insiders, human body parts, including from babies. I went to the market, to the southeast portion, and I saw all manner of creatures for sale, but nothing human.
After meeting Veera and Precious, I tried vigorously to find one of the baby factories in Lagos, but I was not successful. Every lead I explored turned up empty. The Nigerian mafia is said to operate the factories, so there are considerable risks relating to how far one can push. To my knowledge, no one knows exactly how extensive this phenomenon is in Nigeria, or in other countries across western Africa where similar rumors persist. It is one of the most abhorrent forms of sexual slavery I have ever encountered, all the more so because the result is the birth of an innocent child who is either sold off to international adoption or, if the darker rumors are true, killed in blood sacrifices.
HOW DID IT COME TO THIS?
From the severities of poverty and desperation that motivate thousands of Nigerians to take juju oaths and embark on perilous journeys with traffickers to the merciless control exerted over them by priests and madams, Nigeria represents human trafficking in the extreme. The system is unrelenting, and I could not help but wonder how the country arrived at this bleak state. In my estimation, three socioeconomic factors in Nigeria’s history hurled the country into a state of severe impoverishment and unrest, which ultimately precipitated its contemporary human trafficking crisis.10
The first factor of Nigeria’s history that informs its present state of unrest is the religious divide between Muslims in the north and Christians in the South.11 Islam arrived in West Africa around one thousand years ago, culminating in the creation of the Sokoto Caliphate in 1804, which consolidated the northern half of Nigeria under Islamic rule. At that time, the southern portion of the country was dominated by the Yoruba culture and the Benin Empire. Christianity, which was brought by the colonial powers, was also growing in influence. These religious divisions ossified, resulting in ongoing clashes and strife. The south controls the all-important oil ports, which further exacerbates tensions. Religious conflict has raged across the country for decades, leaving the poorest people of Nigeria desperate to find safety abroad, which fuels human trafficking. The raids, murders, and human trafficking activities of the Boko Haram, beginning in 2013, are the most extreme expressions of the clash of cultures between extremist Islam and the more moderate Muslims and Christians in the country.
The second factor of Nigeria’s history that influenced the current state of violence and instability in the country was the discovery of oil in the Delta region by Shell-BP in 1957. This discovery preceded Nigerian independence by three years and has precipitated several decades of military strife among those seeking control of oil territories. The strife was exacerbated by the fact that the boundaries drawn at independence forced together three highly disparate and incongruous ethnic groups—Hausa-Fulani in the north, Yoruba in the southwest, and Igbo in the southeast—and forced them under a single governance in the south, where the oil was found. As a result, the first few decades of Nigerian self-rule were mired by strife among the disparate tribes and communities of the nation for control of land and oil. Major ethnic riots in 1962 and 1964 relating to regional land divisions and accusations of rigged elections rocked the country. In 1966, a group of Igbo army officials led by Major General Johnson T. U. Aguiyi-Ironsi overthrew the elected government and assassinated Prime Minister Balewa (a Fulani) and several senior officials in the government. Ironsi named himself president and instituted martial law. The Muslim community in the north naturally viewed the coup as a Christian attempt to undermine their customs and take control of the oil resources in the south, resulting in mob violence and thousands of deaths. Military leaders in the north staged a coup against Aguiyi-Ironsi four months after his coup, assassinating him and retaking control of the country. Ethnic violence between the north, south, and east raged for several years, culminating in a declaration on May 30, 1967, by the military leader of the eastern region, Lieutenant Colonel Odemugwu Ojukwu, that his territory was to be a separate nation called the Republic of Biafra. The military government in Lagos promptly responded with a declaration of war on the Republic of Biafra. Biafra was supported by France, and Lagos received support from Great Britain and the USSR. This postcolonial proxy war left 3 million Nigerians dead. On January 12, 1971, the Biafran forces surrendered, but the country was in ruins. The Biafran war remains one of the bloodiest postindependence civil wars in postcolonial history, and its crippling effects are felt by millions of Nigerians to this day.
With some semblance of stability under military leader Yakubu Gowon, the government’s focus returned to capitalizing on the oil reserves discovered by Shell-BP prior to independence. The government forged a joint venture with BP and erected a state-owned oil concern, the Nigerian National Petroleum Company (NNPC). Nigeria joined OPEC, and the rise in oil prices in the early 1970s brought huge amounts of capital into the country, most of which was deposited in the accounts of a handful of oligarchs. Oil quickly became responsible for almost 90 percent of all government revenue, which meant that economic stability in Nigeria was highly dependent on the price of oil. The stability under Gowon did not last. There was too much oil at stake.
The third factor that contributed to Nigeria’s contemporary human trafficking crisis involved a series of coups and riots throughout the 1970s and 1980s. Angered by the imbalanced allocation of the country’s newfound oil wealth, Army Brigadier Murtala Mohammed from the north led a coup and took control of the country in 1975. The very next year, Mohammed was assassinated and replaced by a Yoruba military leader from the south. The country returned to civilian rule in 1979, but the oil bubble burst in 1981 and the country fell into massive debt, escalating inflation, and broad-scale unemployment. Riots followed, and thousands of people were killed. Those who had made their wealth during the oil boom of the 1970s took their money out of the country as quickly as they could. The 1980s were marred by one military coup after another, leaving the country in a constant state of disarray. The country’s debt skyrocketed and per capita income fell to below $300 per year. In an effort to quell the strife between north and south, the capital of the country was moved from Lagos to Abuja in 1991. Nonetheless, corruption, coups, civil unrest, and the allocation of oil income to a small wealthy elite have typified Nigeria’s political and economic realty for the last few decades. When oil prices boom, the money flows in; when prices bust, the country suffers from massive increases in debt and inflation. The most recent drop in oil prices in 2015 put severe pressure on the poorest in the country, increased ethnic violence, and pushed peasants to migrate abroad in search of income and security. All the while, violence between Muslims and Christians shows few signs of abating. The unfortunate truth is that disparate and incongruous ethnic groups were thrust together at independence, and oil was found in just one part of the country, leading to a series of devastating coups and clashes that have resulted in decades of suffering. This suffering is unquestionably more real and painful than the prospective harms most any Nigerian would face by accepting an offer from a human trafficker. In this context, millions of poor Nigerians remain eager to flee their country, and traffickers are only too happy to assist them.
ENSLAVED BODY, MIND, AND SOUL
The combination of political and economic instability, grinding poverty, social unrest, and powerful cultural forces of coercion conspire to ensnare countless women and girls from Edo State in sex slavery around the world. More than any group of sex trafficking victims I documented, these young women are enslaved body, mind, and soul. In Sex Trafficking, I provide details and metrics on the sex trafficking cases I documented around the world,13 some of which are updated in appendixes A and B of this book. The uniqueness of the journeys of the Nigerian sex trafficking victims, especially their levels of debt, merits a closer look. In total, I documented the cases of sixty-six Nigerian sex trafficking victims in full. Here are some of the summary statistics of these cases:
•    100 percent females
•    16.7 years: average age at time first trafficked
•    98 percent involved debt bondage
•    $30,528: average debt to repay
•    95 percent from Edo State
•    93 percent took a juju oath prior to being trafficked abroad
•    82 percent trafficked to Europe, 13 percent to Asia, 5 percent to the Americas
•    54 percent trafficked more than once
•    50 percent had another family member who had previously migrated abroad/been trafficked
Some of the most striking data to emerge from these cases relates to the high proportion of victims forced to repay debts (98 percent), as well as the average level of the debts ($30,528), which are five to ten times greater than the debt levels of sex trafficking victims I documented from other countries who were held in debt bondage. No doubt, the powerful spiritual hold placed on these girls by the juju oath plays a pivotal role in the coercive extraction of large amounts of money from the victims. Indeed, many Nigerian sex trafficking victims will retraffic themselves if they are deported out of fear of failing to discharge their debts. It is also worth noting that the average age of the Nigerian sex trafficking victims at the time they were first trafficked (16.7 years) is a little higher than the average of all the sex trafficking cases I documented (15.4 years), but most were still minors at the time they were first trafficked. Just slightly more than half of the victims were trafficked more than once, and half were not the first members of their family to migrate or to be trafficked abroad. Beneath these numbers, there is immeasurable torment, misery, and woe. The system of Nigerian sex trafficking assaults the totality of the human being of its victims with unyielding violence and debasement. Most disconcerting of all, very little is being done to protect the women and girls of Nigeria from the monsters who devour them—domestically or abroad.
BADAGRY
My extraordinary time in Nigeria drew to a poignant close in Badagry, a town about a two-hour drive west of Lagos. In the late fifteenth century, the Portuguese were the first Europeans to arrive on the West African coast in search of new trading routes and access to the Saharan gold trade. The most important consequence of their arrival was the commencement of the trans-Atlantic slave trade, in which Badagry played a central role. Africans were initially taken as laborers on Portuguese ships crossing the Atlantic, and they were subsequently sold into slavery on sugar plantations in the Caribbean Islands. Once Pope Leo X gave permission for slaves to be taken from Africa in 1513, the number of African slaves trafficked by European powers to the Americas grew rapidly. By the end of the sixteenth century, the Dutch, Danish, Swedish, French, and British had all arrived at the “Slave Coast” of West Africa to trade in slaves and traffic them to the Americas. Much has been written about this trade and little needs to be added here beyond the fact that during its precolonial period (1500–1800) and during several decades of British rule (1800–1960) Nigeria was a primary source of trafficked African slaves for European powers. Estimates are that around 3.5 million of the 11 million Africans trafficked into slavery across the ocean during the course of the trans-Atlantic slave trade emanated from Nigeria. Of these, approximately 550,000 passed through Badagry.
Most of the slave museums and historic buildings in Badagry are located on Marina Road, which runs parallel to the coastline. The first historic site I visited was the Vlekete Slave Market, build by the Portuguese in 1502. The market was named after a local deity, Vlekete, goddess of the sea. The original structure was destroyed in 1852, but it was subsequently rebuilt and turned into a two-story museum that chronicles the slave trade that took place at the market for 350 years. Indeed, Vlekete was one of the first and largest slave-trading markets where Europeans bartered with African slave dealers who brought slaves from the inland regions. At its peak, it was open for business seven days a week, with 150 slaves typically sold each day. Europeans inspected each slave prior to negotiating a price. Were they young, fit, and healthy or older and diseased? Once prices were agreed upon, the buyers paid in spirits, guns, silk, beads, cannons, cotton, and other commodities. The slaves they purchased were taken to holding cells, called baracoons, where they were crammed fifty or more into a 9 foot by 9 foot room, forced to defecate, urinate, sweat, sleep, and agonize on top of each other. They could spend months in these cells, waiting to be shipped to the Americas, branded with the name of the slave trader who purchased them. There were once several baracoons in Badagry, but only one of the buildings stands today: the Seriki Faremi Williams Abass Brazilian Baracoon. It is a yellow-painted building with a rusted tin roof, built in 1840. Seriki Abass was a former slave from Yorubaland who was sold as a child to a Portuguese slave trader and trafficked to Brazil. His owner taught him to read and write, and Abass learned several languages, including Portuguese. Years later his owner told him he would set him free on condition that he work for him as a slave dealer back in Africa. Abass agreed. He returned to Badagry, where he built his slave baracoon and began dealing with African slave traders to acquire slaves to sell to the Portuguese. Rusted chains, shackles, and mouth muzzles used to restrain the slaves were on display when I visited the Brazilian Baracoon. Each restraint came in smaller sizes as well, for children. Abass went on to become a very wealthy and powerful man, with 128 wives and 144 children. He died in 1919 and is buried at his Baracoon compound at Badagry, haunted no doubt from every direction by the boundless wails of despairing slaves.
When the European slave traders were ready to depart with their cargo, they took the slaves from the baracoons across a narrow lagoon to a peninsula just off the coast of Badagry. I hired a boat to take me across the lagoon to the northern edge of the peninsula, just as the slaves were ferried centuries before. From there, the slaves trudged in shackles to the southern shore, where the larger seafaring ships awaited them. I walked that same path, through the brush and the coconut trees. With each step I tried to imagine their dread. Did they have any understanding of what was happening to them? Did they try to bargain with their captors? Did they fear they would never see their family members again? Did they have any sense of where they were going and the fate that awaited them? It was a walk of miserable imaginings. I peered down at my unshackled feet and reflected on the hundreds of thousands of shackled ankles that walked these same sands centuries before. What separated my free steps from theirs other than flukes of time and birth? I could feel the searing distress of the slaves walking across these very sands, swelling with panic, frenzy, and horror. Just when I thought the terror of this walk could not get any worse, my spirits collapsed when I came upon a sign that read “Original Spot, Slaves Spiritual Attenuation Well.”
Next to the sign, I found a small, red-stone well tucked inside a hut. There was a poem hanging on a wall written in English and Yoruba. Centuries earlier, each slave would drink from the well, and recite these words:
I am leaving this land,
My spirit leave with me.
I shall not come back now,
My shackles do not break.
It is the shackles that hold the ship down.
My ancestors bear me witness,
I shall not return.
This land shall depart,
My soul do not revolt,
My spirit go along with me.
I depart to that land unknown
I shall not return.
I fell to my knees. It was too much to bear.
Slaves bound for the Americas recited this oath, that they were leaving their land and that they would never return. They prayed for their spirits to go with them, and not revolt. They were to be slaves forever, for the shackles do not break.
How was this oath any different from the juju oaths Nigerian slaves take today before departing for servitude abroad? They too leave their land and pray that their souls stay with them, remain safe, and do not revolt. They too know they will be slaves forever, for the “shackles” that ensnare them do not break.
After I read the oath at the Slaves Spiritual Attenuation Well, I understood slavery more clearly than I ever had before.
Slavery is the erasure of humanity.
I drifted off the slave path toward the coconut trees. I sat, knowing not where to go. The whispering palms held no solace. The salty smell of the ocean brought no comfort. After all my years of research, it was as if I understood slavery only for the first time—and that understanding devastated me.
I completed the slave walk to the beach at Badagry, where I was greeted by a sign that read “Point of No Return.” Here slaves passed through two pillars, like a portal, into the lowest rungs of hell. They boarded the slave ships and never returned, other than a handful like Abass. The ocean ferried them to an unknown land of torture and slavery. The beautiful blue never looked the same again.