A striking phenomenon occurs in the geostrophic flow of a
homogeneous fluid. It can only be observed in a laboratory because stratification effects cannot be avoided in natural flows. Consider then a laboratory experiment in which a tank of fluid is steadily rotated at a high angular speed Ω and a solid body is moved slowly along the bottom of the tank. The purpose of making Ω large and the movement of the solid body slow is to make the Coriolis acceleration much larger than the advective acceleration terms, which must be made negligible for geostrophic equilibrium. Away from the frictional effects of boundaries, the balance is geostrophic in the horizontal and hydrostatic in the vertical. Setting
f = 2Ω in
(13.11) and
(13.12) produces:
It is useful to define an Ekman number, E, as the ratio of viscous to Coriolis accelerations:
Under the circumstances already described here, both Ro and E are small.
Elimination of
p from
(13.16) and
(13.17) by cross-differentiation leads to:
which can be combined with the continuity
equation (4.10) to reach:
Thus, the fluid velocity cannot vary in the direction of Ω. In other words, steady slow motions in a rotating, homogeneous, inviscid fluid are two-dimensional. This is the
Taylor-Proudman theorem, first derived by Proudman in 1916 and demonstrated experimentally by Taylor soon afterward.
In Taylor’s experiment, a tank was made to rotate as a solid body, and a small cylinder was slowly dragged along the bottom of the tank (
Figure 13.5). Dye was introduced from point A above the cylinder and directly ahead of it. In a non-rotating fluid the water would pass over the top of the moving cylinder. In the rotating experiment, however, the dye divides at a point S, as if it had been blocked by a vertical extension of the cylinder, and flows around this
imaginary cylinder, called the
Taylor column. Dye released from a point B within the Taylor column remained there and moved with the cylinder. The conclusion was that the flow outside the upward extension of the cylinder is the same as if the cylinder extended across the entire water depth and that a column of water directly above the cylinder moves with it. The motion is two dimensional, although the solid body does not extend across the entire water depth. Taylor did a second experiment, in which he dragged a solid body
parallel to the axis of rotation. In accordance with
∂w/∂z = 0, he observed that a column of fluid is pushed ahead. The lateral velocity components
u and
v were zero. In both of these experiments, there are shear layers at the edge of the Taylor column.
In summary, Taylor’s experiment established the following striking fact for steady inviscid motion of a homogeneous fluid in a strongly rotating system: bodies moving either parallel or perpendicular to the axis of rotation carry along with their motion a so-called Taylor column of fluid, oriented parallel to the axis of rotation. The phenomenon is analogous to the horizontal
blocking caused by a solid body (say a mountain) in a strongly stratified system, shown in
Figure 8.30.
Example 13.4
Continent-scale weather maps commonly report the 500 mb height, Z, the vertical distance from sea level to the point in the atmosphere where the pressure p = 50 kPa (mb = milli-bar; 1 mb = 100 Pa). Typical values for Z lie between 4.5 and 6 km where the geostrophic balance dominates wind patterns in the mid-latitudes, especially in winter. In this height range, how are the horizontal wind components u and v related to Z?
Solution
The 500 mb height function, z = Z(x,y), is defined by p(x,y,Z) = 500 mb = const. Partial differentiation of this equation with respect to x produces:
0=∂p∂x+∂p∂z∂Z∂x=∂p∂x−ρ0g∂Z∂x,or∂p∂x=ρ0g∂Z∂x.
where (1.14) with ρ = ρ0 has been used to eliminate ∂p/∂z. Similarly, partial differentiation with respect to y leads to:
Substituting these results for
∂p/
∂x and
∂p/
∂y into
(13.11) and
(13.12) produces:
−fv=−1ρ0(ρ0g∂Z∂x)=−g∂Z∂xandfu=−1ρ0(ρ0g∂Z∂y)=−g∂Z∂y,or:(u,v)=(−gf∂Z∂y,gf∂Z∂x)
Thus, –
gZ/
f can also serve as a stream function for geostropic flow. Weather maps of
Z (such as
Figure 13.28) simultaneously show regions of high and low pressure (
Z increases with increasing surface pressure) and the mid-troposphere horizontal winds that steer weather systems.